20 ms·
Linux Foundation starts AgStack, an open-source agtech initiative
- sigmaprimus 6y agoThis is great news, hopefully with enough heavy hitters backing this project it will succeed. I'm not a big fan of improving pesticide application techniques (one of the examples given in the article) as at the end of the day it is still pumping poison no matter how efficient but if it means less chemicals leeching into our food and environment, I suppose it's better than doing nothing. LifeTrac is an interesting Open Source project that might benifit from this foundational type of support. When it comes to agriculture, there is already a very large grass roots, open community of farmers and growers. Eg. Market gardeners, Seed sharers, Homesteaders even Hay farmers. I believe this group is primed to turn into a powerful societal movement but does require financial support to compete against the corporate giants that at present literally dominate the AG field(s).
- nerdponx 6y agoHopefully we get some Open Hardware too.
- protomyth 6y agoThis is great news, hopefully with enough heavy hitters backing this project it will succeed. I don't see any real agriculture heavy hitters (e.g. Cargill, ADM).
- sigmaprimus 6y agoBayer? Aka Monsanto? How about JD Tractors and the whole right to repair? But yeah it would be awesome if Cargil got onboard. They are into everything, I used to run multi purpose cables for Flir trafficon cameras that was made by a Cargil company. (FLIR could be a huge supporter too for that matter)
- protomyth 6y agoBayer is big, but they are not Cargill and the big farm chain companies. Cargill is into everything. You don't really work for Cargill, you work for a division that can operate totally differently than the rest of the company.
- mastazi 6y agoUnfortunately the article doesn't contain any link to the AgStack Foundation itself, so here it is: https://agstack.org/ https://agstack.org/
- teruakohatu 6y agoHaving read that still don't know what the project really is. A venue for people and corporates to discuss open agtech and a source of funding for open agtech software?
- mastazi 6y agoI think that it's just the same mechanism as the Linux Foundation itself, but specific for the AgTech sector. My basic understanding is that on one side you have companies who want to sponsor open source tech they depend on, and on the other side you have open source developement teams who would like to be supported; the Foundation facilitates interaction between these 2 sides.
- windthrown 6y agoThis was listed on the Project page: "The AgStack Foundation will not engage in building software applications but will instead focus on the software infrastructure (tools, frameworks, and models) that will be needed to build, manage and run applications by the members and users"
- AlphaSite 6y agoI think it’s basically the CNCF for AgTech
- tomhoward 6y agoSomething like this is so sorely needed. I've been doing some work in ag-tech for the past few years (having previously worked in ISP/telco, general SME web/mobile development, then consumer travel tech). The tools available to farmers/growers for what should be quite basic things - i.e., web-connected weather stations and monitoring systems for soil moisture, frost alarms and irrigation control are terrible. The industry is full of small players who take a look and think "I know how to build stuff with [Arduino/Raspberry Pi/Zigbee etc], I can build an ag-tech monitoring/control product easily". So everyone builds a hardware product from scratch, then as a quick afterthought, a web app with an SQL database and Highcharts to show data graphs. You have an MVP within a few months, then a few paying customers in your local community, then suddenly your customers start asking for features you'd never thought of, like sensor inputs you didn't know existed, or combined displays of different kinds of data you'd never considered anyone would want, or needing it to be faster (SQL turns out to be really slow for this kind of data) or more reliable (bugfixing is hard when your devices are hundreds of miles away and connected via weak 3G/4G data links), and you realise your hardware and software architecture doesn't support any of this, and you'd have to completely start over to actually deliver something that customers really need, but you're out of money and energy. The result is a lot of farmers/growers dissatisfied/frustrated at never being able to get the monitoring systems they need (some of them having tried 3+ different vendors), and a lot of new companies trying to build new solutions and going bust. I've been thinking there needs to be some widely accepted open standards in the industry for hardware and software platforms, so solutions providers can avoid trying to re-invent everything and instead focus on integration of tried-and-true building blocks. If this initiative brings that about, it would be a big win for everyone in the industry.
- bshipp 6y agoYou appear to have had the exact same experience as I have. I work in the fresh vegetable side of things and the tools that are available are completely closed source and locked in. Even silly things like humidity controls and whatnot. there's so much potential for the ag sector to benefit from all these open data sources and systems.
- 6y ago
- BJBBB 6y agoOf interest to me because I have been doing agricultural process monitoring and production control systems for about 30 years. And most of my clients' systems are at least semi-custom and re-invent wheels for no other purpose other than to do it their way; that is, silos (pun not intended). But where NDAs and IP agreements allow, I have attempted to standardize some architectures. But was disappointing to see the way the LF is organizing this - no representation from the ag industry's heavy hitters and no specific and attainable goals. Should this be done by an Operating Systems organization? Other than centralized control and logistical systems, ag engineering is not the realm of microprocessors and operating systems, and code monkeys. Ag engineering is a world of hardware, micro-controllers, FSMs, and scheduler stacks. But then, if not the LF, whom has the organization to do this?
- is_true 6y agoThis should be done by the Food and Agriculture Organization that belongs to the UN. But well, you can't ask much to the United Bureaucrats Organization
- rektide 6y agoLF is basically a deployable organizational model, typically taken advantage of by someone with an existing project or projects they want to release & collaborate on. there are blockchain, mainframe, embedded os projects, countless more, under LF. worth noting that Linux Foundation began as a merger of between Open Source Development Labs (who worked to push Linux adoption in enterprise) and the Free Standards Group (who worked to push open source standards) to standardize Linux. Only one of these groups started with an exclusive Linux focus, and that same group also focused on the enterprise & driving adoptability.
- jerrysievert 6y ago> and that same group also focused on the enterprise & driving adoptability. well, sort of. there were a couple of half-assed pushes with things like linux for data centers, but mostly it was a data center filled with hardware that got very little use other than one asterisk system sitting in a corner, a stack of machines/disk that could be "checked out", but mostly got used for automated testing, and an NEC numa itanium machine that barely worked. add to that, projects that intel no longer wanted to support being shoved off, and you have a pretty good view of day to day life at the OSDL. source: worked there, doing day to day life at the OSDL.
- RGamma 6y agoThe planet won't benefit from this. Agricultural overconsumption with a more efficient or open technology supply chain is still overconsumption.
- danuker 6y agoHow do you know it's overconsumption?
- RGamma 6y agoHalf the habitable land is farm land and farm land is ecologically dead (with pesticide use having damaging effects on the surroundings) and not available for carbon sequestration for instance. Also "livestock accounts for 77% of global farming land. While livestock takes up most of the world’s agricultural land it only produces 18% of the world’s calories and 37% of total protein" And the trend is growth.. https://ourworldindata.org/land-use https://ourworldindata.org/land-use
- ahepp 6y agoWon't improving ag tech improve the efficiency of farming land? And allow better ecological management?
- tome 6y agoBeware Jevons paradox. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- RGamma 6y agoEven 100% efficient agriculture is meaningless in the face of overburdening absolute demand. Raising efficiency and means of exploitation may also induce demand ("oh we're so eco-friendly"). The point is: Life needs (contiguous) undisturbed wilderness. And ecological management? That this would even be necessary is testament to our fuckup, but yeah that might actually be topic's biggest benefit I suppose. Pre-industrialisation life managed itself just fine for millenia.
- wokwokwok 6y ago> “Just like an operating system, we feel there will be a whole universe of applications that can be built and consumed using AgStack,” Johal added. “From pest prediction and crop nutrition to harvest management and improved supply-chain collaboration, the possibilities are endless.” ...said AgStack executive director Sumer Johal according to venturebeat (1) in another meaningless statement that provided no concrete details. Their high level architecture (2) comfortably encompasses everything from ML to shells to security; “like an operating system” the press release claimed, careful to avoid saying they were actually building an operating system, because that would be daft. ...but who is Sumer Johal? Well, no one very interesting (3) it turns out, but he’s been involved in agtech for some time... So... I guess I’m left puzzled? What does this have to do with the Linux foundation? Well, turns out the place to go to find out is... surprise, the Linux foundation: https://www.linuxfoundation.org/en/press-release/linux-foundation-launches-open-source-digital-infrastructure-project-for-agriculture-enables-global-collaboration-among-industry-government-and-academia/ https://www.linuxfoundation.org/en/press-release/linux-found... “Through the AgStack Project, the Linux Foundation will provide valuable cohesion and development capacity to support shared, community-maintained infrastructure.” Or something. You read it and decide for yourself; 20 different companies coming together to collaborate with completely different ideas of how and on what. Sounds like open office. Can’t wait to see how it goes... [1] - https://venturebeat.com/2021/05/05/linux-foundation-launches-open-source-agriculture-infrastructure-project/ https://venturebeat.com/2021/05/05/linux-foundation-launches... [2] - https://agstack.org/projects/ https://agstack.org/projects/ [3] - https://www.crunchbase.com/person/sumer-johal https://www.crunchbase.com/person/sumer-johal
- juststeve 6y agowhat about some optimism?
- waihtis 6y agoWhat I've been very interested in lately is whether there's a way for us to enable local food production (local meaning on the individual/family scale) via some technological or business innovation. Maybe something along the lines of automated remote farming which would factor in the lack of local space to farm + time limitations. Something that concerns me personally is the globalistic nature of the food supply chain and just from a risk management perspective it would be great to push it into a more localized state. But I don't think a world where everybody moves to homesteading is realistic, quite the opposite. Just superficial pondering. If there's some nice initiatives / startups / other working on this would be keen to learn more about them.
- openthc 6y agoTake a look at spacebuckets ( eg: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceBuckets/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceBuckets/ ) works awesome for cannabis -- but also: lettuce, herbs, cuke, growing aquaponic pineapple in the winter in Oregon, etc. You can get a bucket (or larger controlled envrironment) and control the whole thing via Pi and this thing is cool too -- https://github.com/kizniche/Mycodo https://github.com/kizniche/Mycodo e: and we're working on this :)
- kickout 6y agoCan't do it at the individual/family scale. Gotta go back thousands of years for that model. Population is too great (mostly enabled by highly scaled, highly efficient agriculture)
- LAC-Tech 6y agoRemember the blockchain hype? Well it turns out it's actually incredibly practical for food traceability and provenance. Governments around the world are starting to demand transparency around this, and in the near future it will be common for consumers to be able to see where their food was grown, processed, shipped to, and how long that took. So, scan the QR code and pick the produce with the shortest supply chain. If consumers demand it, local food production WILL be a big thing.
- axiosgunnar 6y ago
- danuker 6y agoUgh, I can't select text on the page. I do it to read more easily.
- manifoldgeo 6y agoI came here to say this! I highlight lines as I read pages to stay focused, and when highlighting is (purposely) broken like this, it's really frustrating.
- IgniteTheSun 6y ago> Ugh, I can't select text on the page. I do it to read more easily. If you are on firefox, try this: View -> Page Style -> No Style and scroll down. Hit <cntl>+ to enlarge if needed. I do this on many sites nowadays - wish there was a way to make this a default setting for all sites. (Other browsers probably have a similar feature but I don't have one in front of me to give the step-by-step instructions.)
- Mumps 6y agoGenuine question: why do some websites do this overtly hostile anti-highlighting anyway?
- williesleg 6y agoIs that why bill gates is buying up all the Midwestern farmland?
- openthc 6y agoThis is promising; but in the Ag space there are 100s of providers all doing it their own way. The same problem is staring in the cannabis/hemp space too. We've been working for 5+ years to herd all these cats together -- and now another one (cue XKCD about standards). We'll likey join this initiative but, I'm concerned how it will work with the 100s of others who are way more interested in building their own walled garden, or saying "here's a standard API (ours!)" w/o any outside inputs. And @tomhoward on here brings up loads of good points -- in N farms we've seen N unique implementations ("bespoke") of monitoring, recording, measuring and pumps and processes and power-systems and all that.
- _skhan_ 6y agoAlong the same lines, there is https://farmos.org/ https://farmos.org/ It is a kind of like a CMS/ERP for agtech. I am using it for basic farm management purposes like inventorying equipment, chemicals, etc. It is built on Drupal which I personally do not like. Overall, the open source nature of the project allows anyone to contribute new modules. I was building my own app before I found it and am glad it's one less project I have to 20%
- wolverine876 6y agoFarmOS is included in AgStack under 'members and partners'.
- _skhan_ 6y agoThanks I didn't notice that!
- axiosgunnar 6y agoWhat do you mean by „to 20%“?
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoSoftware has not eaten the world yet - not even reached the starters, it's just finished the bread roll. There is a tension between closed and open source here that is going to occur in every industry, in every country. And we shall all sit on the sidelines bemoaning the lack of standards ... unless ... err I have to admit I don't know how to build dynamic detail based standards that don't die in committee - how do we get YAML / JSON and not SOAP? I suspect it is best to start with a 100 Million dollars, and create open mailing lists for each industry, and invite the best of each industry to conferences each month.
- mindentropy 6y agoMaybe someone can help me, how can an individual benefit from Linux Foundation? Help means work/career opportunities, business opportunities, consulting opportunities. I want to have first mover advantage in AgStack.
- pm90 6y agoI’m concerned about the Linux Foundation being involved in all these projects. I expected it to be an organization dedicated to Linux. But it seems to have expanded to a myriad of different spaces and it’s endorsement is often used to legitimize really bad products, ideas and initiatives (look at the finops nonsense). Can’t they just be stewards of Linux kernel development and focus on that? If there are other initiatives just create other foundations or redirect funding to those areas.
- ghaff 6y ago>Can’t they just be stewards of Linux kernel development and focus on that? If there are other initiatives just create other foundations The way a lot of these other initiatives are organized is they are their own foundations/projects under the LF umbrella which lets them share infrastructure, piggtback on events, etc. Meanwhile Linux seems to be doing quite well from where I sit. I'm not sure what activities are lacking around Linux that a more focused (and inevitably much leaner) organization would drive.
- walleeee 6y agoIf this interests you, check out Phenome Force, they do weekly webinars featuring the open source/DIY agtech tools people are building: https://phenome-force.github.io/PhenomeForce/ https://phenome-force.github.io/PhenomeForce/ We need more software/hardware engineers in open source ag. Be warned, you may need to live in a somewhat rural area, accept a modest paycheck, and occasionally get your hands dirty, but it's a lot more fun than writing code to shuffle forms or finances around imo
- olafura 6y agoFor me Farmbot ( https://farm.bot/ https://farm.bot/ ) is some of the most interesting thing happening in open source farming and they aren't apart of this initiative. None of the projects are really something your need a framework for. I think what some of the projects involved are doing is laudable but it's not really revolutionary. Then again I don't do farming though some of my family and friends of my family do.
- kickout 6y agoI do farming. I'm intrigued by this concept, but am hesitant. I don't see any value add off the bat.
- olafura 6y agoFrom my understanding how you can help farming with software. You have supercharging current methods which most of the projects in the OpenTeam initiative are doing which seems to be turning into the AgStack Foundation if I understand it correctly. Think adding smart sensors might be some of what they are planning with the framework and importantly all the planning and managing of farms which the strangely named FarmOs is doing ( I say strangely since it's not an OS ). The other is doing things with hardware and software that aren't mimicking or supercharging current methods but just implementing a new and more efficient way of doing things. Think the difference between making a perfect robot hand and making thing that grips. Both do the same thing but one is not trying to do the same things as the other. So here you have things like Farmbot that probably need so be split into separate stages of operation if it is going to scale at a farm field level. I feel like we are past the making a better tractor and other farm machinery phase and are moving into automating everything we can phase. Because the problem with our current processes is that they are stressing soil and the nature too much. By having diverse crops in the same field you both minimize the impact of soil, groundwater problems, salting and stuff like that, but also minimizing the risks in farming where you rely on futures commodity markets instead of having a wide balance of produce. But I'm no expert and haven't put much thought into this. Just want us to head in the right direction and make sure we invest in the right things.
- olafura 6y ago
- dementiev 6y agoThis is very needed for the industry. I'm a co-founder of agtech startup https://geopard.tech https://geopard.tech, we act as a platform and infrastructure for ag businesses (provide analytics and APIs) in the precision agriculture niche. When we created the company, it was the idea - to support agtech companies to launch their software faster/cheaper (our engine analyses yield, soil, topography, satellite, ground sensors, drone data and provides analytics on top of it). Before GeoPard we had another agtech company acquired by ag giant Bayer in 2015, then inside Bayer, we built Xarvio digital farming system. So, this is very needed, I know what I talk about. It takes usually minimum few years to launch solid agtech product. The biggest issue I see right now is where to get valid data. Model is nothing without a huge amount of validating datasets, which only have ag giants. They will not share the data so easy since all of them build their digital platforms and understand the value of data.
- bourgwaletariat 6y agoNot unsurprising to me, I have a contrarian view to most of the comments here about this. This project is supported by, among others, https://www.farmfoundation.org/about-farm-foundation/board-of-directors/ https://www.farmfoundation.org/about-farm-foundation/board-o... which includes US Bank, McDonalds, John Deere... among others who tend to invite derision here. What this does is extract even cheaper labor from the masses. 9 in 10 people used to be farmers. Now it's 1 in 300. I find it hard to believe we have a problem with productivity in this industry. The end game here is to further centralize the power structure into the corporations who already control most of the supply chain. Look at how they treat seed farmers around the world. They pay them pennies for seeds and then charge thousands of dollars for them on the global market. Again... I don't see it. I see the trees, but where's the forest?
- metalman 6y agoI live off grid small,on an old overgrown farm,lots of worn out land around,lots of small farmsteads,no spray operations. Teck has helped with marketing and bieng able to get parts and supplys delivered without losing a day or two going to town. Some interesting teck I have heard of includes planting equipmemt that works like a printer,with indivual planting heads able to plant multiple crops and comensal plants in one pass.Huh?what then? Harvest the whole mess,weed seeds and all and then pass it through an airjet curtain where sensors identify each sead by type and push it where it needs to go. A similar system was pionered by debeers in the 1960's and led to a massive increase in diamonds bieng recovered. Laser weeders are here now and many are working on laser bug zappers. Satelites are bieng used for very precise fertilizer aplication and all the big tractor companys are working on or running fully remote equipment that will allow teams to remotely operate the mega equipment that is common now.They would make the equipment bigger but roads will not acomodate it in most places. What else,gps for ultra precise field grading to control slopes for irigation. Combining solar and wind power with agriculture where it works.Such as putting solar over irigation canals,reduces evaporation,and cools the panels while useing ,free space. Lots happening
- LAC-Tech 6y agoI've been making software for the agricultural industry for 5 years, and I'm really not sure what to make of this. The big problem agtech has isn't that we don't have enough "open-source agtech initiatives". The big problem is the divide between 'ag' and 'tech'. A few individuals bridge it well, but for the most part most ag people don't know about tech and most tech people don't know about ag. And often they don't want to know. The standards mentioned are largely ignored and that will continue to be the case. Public data would be useful, but I don't see it as a game changer. Happy to be proven wrong, but problems here aren't in tech, it's in the lack of two way communication that lets us apply it effectively to solve industry problems.
- pranavdotexe 6y agoWhere's the code?