11 ms·
Is the shortage of lumber getting Americans to try other materials like brick and stone?
by chrisseaton 6y ago
Is the shortage of lumber getting Americans to try other materials like brick and stone?
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoBrick and stone are still more expensive than lumber and require more technical know how to do it right.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoBut they stay in place for 300 years. They withstand hurricane winds, floods and crowbars.
- lazide 6y agoYour average American moves every 5 years [https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.mymovingreviews.com/move/how-often-and-why-americans-move/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.mymovingreviews.com/move/ho...] with most Americans moving 11 times over their lives [https://www.census.gov/topics/population/migration/guidance/calculating-migration-expectancy.html https://www.census.gov/topics/population/migration/guidance/...]. The people who built the house aren’t going to care if the house lasts 40 years or 300. They will care if it costs 5x more to build/live in/buy/rent.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe idea is that if something js 5z as durable but is 2x the price, its more economical. Secondly - there are areas like SF and London where house prices are like 5x the national average because of land. Surely they can afford better materials?
- spenczar5 6y agoIt's more economical only if the original buyer is there to reap the benefits of the durability. Because American houses change hands so fast, durability is the next guy's problem. This is exacerbated by the fact that a huge number of homes are built by developers who want to sell the thing as soon as it's built, and then move on. In a long-term, societal sense, you're right that it's kind of irrational. It's really unfortunate.
- lazide 6y agoI wouldn’t take the economical argument too seriously on this front. One factor that is a big issue in Europe is energy efficiency, and recent/updated electrical. With so much of the stock being ancient, and societal trends towards keeping older structures (and large investments in very durable structures being more of a norm), they have huge issues with a large stock of very inefficient and difficult to upgrade or fix structures. It is entirely possible to make energy efficient and modern buildings in Europe of course - it just doesn’t happen as much (because there is so much existing stock), and it is REALLY expensive compared to the US. Even Munich which got bombed to smithereens and rebuilt not that long ago (so less a problem than most), it’s not common to have well insulated walls or what American’s would consider modern electrical. Lots of retrofit work, surface mounted outlets and conduit, etc. What most Americans would consider a normal remodel (adding a bathroom, changing the layout of some rooms though modifications to non-exterior walls, whatever) are essentially impossible or crazy expensive in many of these buildings too because of the concrete masonry construction. Wood frame construction is cheap and easy to reconfigure, drywall and wood frame is easy to rip off and upgrade what is underneath, then replace, and all of these are easy to stuff with insulation. They’re also remarkably strong, durable, and flexible. They do have flammability and pest issues, but those have good solutions in modern structures. They all do use a lot of wood; which is a bit of an issue now.
- cycrutchfield 6y agoYou will not find very many brick or stone buildings in SF...
- lmm 6y agoThe whole reason those areas are so expensive is extremely restrictive planning rules.
- nemo44x 6y agoI wouldn’t consider bricks better than wood. Especially in an earthquake prone area. Now, steel - that would be better. But if thinking about the future I think wood framing is superior. In many places in Europe the old brick or stone homes have a lot of issues by modern standards and they are expensive to renovate. They tend to have floor plans that made sense 200+ years ago but not today. Like small rooms to better conserve fireplace heat. But again, it’s very difficult to renovate these homes to have a sensible, modern floor plan. Old wood frame homes are fairly easy to renovate either to modernize or to renovate.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoThe only thing unusually expensive about houses in SF and London is the ground it's sitting on. Even a house that's going to fall over in a year would be worth 75% as much as one that would last 1000 years.
- ghaff 6y agoI'm pretty sure "average" is doing a lot of work there. I'm willing to bet that number is skewed a lot by younger people moving from apartment to apartment. I certainly moved a lot in my 20s, especially if you count school. But I've been in the same house for over 20 years and I'm sure that's not at all unusual. (Although I don't disagree with your point that most people won't pay a big premium just to have a house that could be standing in a few hundred years.)
- lazide 6y agoIt usually does! One thing to consider - during those years you were moving, you also reinforced the market position of not caring too much about long term durability for a large number of properties/landlords/sellers, and your current place you’ve only influenced in the other direction for one property/landlord/seller, correct? A dollar sitting under the mattress for 20 years affects GDP/the economy a lot less than the dollar that gets spent all the time. It isn’t as simple of course as ‘who cares, I’ll be out of here in a few years’ - though a surprisingly percent of the time I’ve literally heard people say that and use it as justification for writing off obvious maintenance issues or buying a place that clearly has problems.
- xyzzyz 6y agoNot earthquakes though, and these are a significant issue, at least in the west.
- bluGill 6y agoWood frame does just as well. In some cases better. I've been in wood framed buildings in Europe that are more than 300 years old. Brick is harder to the touch, but that doesn't translate into anything useful for mechanical strength.
- corty 6y ago> I've been in wood framed buildings in Europe that are more than 300 years old. That is a selection effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selection_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selection_bias
- quixoticelixer- 6y agoNo it isn't
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoThe wood being used in this construction is not for the exterior of the home, but for the frame and internal walls. Most homes in the US are built with wood frames but brick and / or concrete exteriors.
- rubidium 6y agoI know people are looking more at stone patios then wood decks but the cost was already higher for those. And that’s seen a rise too (though not as dramatic). Brick and stone are still a lot more cost though than fast grown sh* pine.
- chrisco255 6y agoUnfortunately the third little pig has cornered that market.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- annoyingnoob 6y agoI recently built a couple of side tables for our living room, brick and stone just wasn't the right choice. I went with reclaimed wood and it was more expensive than I expected.
- chrisseaton 6y agoUsed railway sleepers (I think they're called 'ties' in the US) were really popular in the UK once, then we literally just run out for good.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoI used cargo decking from old semi-trailers (lorries), the wood that makes up the cargo floor. Its nice maple butcher block. I don't think they'll stop building and retiring those trucks any time soon.
- programmarchy 6y agoIn the US they’re treated with a chemical called Creosote which is carcinogenic so shouldn’t be used inside or in the garden, unfortunately.
- samcheng 6y agoAnecdotally, I've noticed an uptick in metal-framed house construction in my neck of the woods. So, yes, there are alternatives, even in the US. I doubt this results in lower homebuilding cost all-in, though.
- koolba 6y agoI love the look of metal framed houses while they’re under construction. It reminds me of Wolverine’s adamantine skeleton.
- fy20 6y agoThe other comments seem to be missing the point of this, but as I understand it's in reference to building construction. In Europe pretty much nobody builds stick frame houses today. I'm building a house right now, and the only wood that'll be part of the structure is the roof struts. Floors are concrete and walls are made of clay air bricks. In milder climates these walls are insulated enough that you could get by without any extra insulation (here it gets to -25c/-5F). The interior is finished by plastering, and the exterior by cladding or concrete render.
- coderintherye 6y agoPart of the reason everyone builds stick frame houses in the U.S. is because county building codes are restrictive and have not adapted to new ways of building such as with cob. Even California is way behind in this regard. That and consumer demand towards stick frame houses.
- swiley 6y agoWe really need to do something about our local building codes.
- parhamn 6y ago> new ways of building such as with cob Ha! Cob is like as old as history. Im sure there are other reasons. When you add sprinklers wood isn't a bad choice especially for making modifications later. Adding a wiring/outlets/making modifications is a lot easier to.
- chrisseaton 6y agoDo you not have a problem with noise when all your walls are just hollow wood frames?
- lazide 6y agoIf you share walls with neighbors? Sometimes though modern buildings no. Gaps and other engineered voids cut that out. I had more issues in Singapore with concrete construction and noise than with a modern townhome and shared walls.
- spenczar5 6y agoNo, because the dominant cost of construction is still labor, not materials. Masonry labor is waaaaay more expensive than stud framing labor.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThat’s funny I wonder why that is - in the UK carpentry is considered more skilled than bricklaying and a carpenter is much more expensive than a brickie.
- kasey_junk 6y agoFraming is considerably simpler than finish carpentry.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoBecause not that long ago the UK was more or less totally deforested and the only people doing stuff with wood were the well to do and as is typical with these sorts of things the yacht builder is held in higher regard than the barge builder.
- jandrewrogers 6y agoNot really, though it depends on what you are building. A large portion of the US is at risk for strong seismic events, and this is reflected in the regulations for building materials. We learned it the hard way. Building with brick and stone to earthquake standards is quite expensive, it doesn’t make sense. If you see brick or stone in a modern building, it is applied as a facade over a wood or steel frame. Parts of the US were originally built with brick and stone but were destroyed in earthquakes. Civil engineering, along with the ample availability of timber, changed the way the US designed buildings. New England, which does have a lot of stone and brick construction, suffers damage when they experience the rare, moderate for the US (M5-ish) earthquake. Earthquake safety and cost will never recommend brick and stone in most of the US. They are more likely to switch to steel than brick. There are a lot of brick houses, I grew up in some, but they were built before modern seismic codes. Parts of the US people don’t think of as being earthquake prone have surprisingly large earthquakes. For example, severe earthquakes in New Madrid Seismic Zone[0] in the southern Midwest. In the US, learning the extent of seismic activity in North America was often paid for in blood. Like Japan, everything modern is engineered for it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Madrid_Seismic_Zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Madrid_Seismic_Zone
- f6v 6y agoThat's interesting, I haven't heard of an earthquake in the US since... forever.
- daniellarusso 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Loma_Prieta_earthquake https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Loma_Prieta_earthquake This collapsed a freeway.
- moron4hire 6y agoLiving in Philadelphia 7 years ago, an earthquake cracked the foundation of the 100 year old stone house I lived in, then a tropical storm 2 months later flooded the basement. We had similar storms previously that only gave us an inch of water, but after the crack, the basement filled up at least 3 feet.