32 ms·
White House eyes subsidies for nuclear plants to help meet climate targets
- hirundo 6y agoI support nuclear power and oppose subsidies for it. A better approach is to remove subsidies from their dirtier competitors.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI feel like it would be far more politically practical to add subsidies to Nuclear rather than take away existing subsidies on other things.
- gameswithgo 6y agoIdeas about how to run governments need to be thought of in context of how the government operates. If was emporer of the USA, I would do what you suggest. But if I was president, I probably could not.
- frereubu 6y agoWhy not both?
- halfmatthalfcat 6y agoNuclear power capital requirements (up front) are one of the biggest roadblocks to building new plants, followed by regulatory complexity and cruft that hasn’t been streamlined to allow new reactor designs to be implemented. Doing both, removing subsidies from dirty energy and moving them to nuclear, would be the best case.
- xroche 6y agoNuclear power requirements (up front) has also a big issue: the cost of money. The only viable solution is to have state-owned nuclear energy, because only states can borrow cheap money (ie. even at negative rates), where private companies are required to bleed interests during decades. Nuclear is the cheapest energy when state-owned, but struggle to compete against coal/gaz otherwise.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoHave the Navy run them, make the land Navy bases (Crane Naval Support [1] near Bloomington, IN comes to mind). Encourage efficiency, require transparency, but have no tolerance for safety deficiencies or shortcuts. [1] https://www.navsea.navy.mil/Home/Warfare-Centers/NSWC-Crane/ https://www.navsea.navy.mil/Home/Warfare-Centers/NSWC-Crane/
- Spartan-S63 6y agoOr have the government own the plants and lease out operation to a qualified commercial operator with rigorous certification requirements and regular recertification requirements.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI have more faith in the military chain of command versus a contractor who isn’t going to give AF if they lose a contract and the US gov has to pay out to rehabilitate a facility that wasn’t properly maintained. Contractors have less fear than someone who can be jailed (and let’s be honest, contractors and other commercial entities are never held accountable when they cut corners for profit and pollute with wild abandon leaving us with Superfund sites).
- danans 6y ago> when they cut corners for profit and pollute with wild abandon leaving us with Superfund sites The military doesn't have a great track record on Superfund sites i.e: https://cumulis.epa.gov/supercpad/cursites/csitinfo.cfm?id=0902731 https://cumulis.epa.gov/supercpad/cursites/csitinfo.cfm?id=0... However, I agree that at least the military has the culture that will follow orders if asked, and more importantly, it's the only government program that the US population is willing to put unchecked amounts of money towards. As Reagan said: "trust, but verify".
- minikites 6y agoWhy does it need to be run by a commercial operator at all? What advantage does that confer?
- epistasis 6y agoI hear about regulatory cruft, but have never heard of examples of what would be changed. We have two recent build sites in the US, one failed entirely, and the other is hobbling along. I've read lots of analyses and postmortems, and the only regulation-related criticisms I've found are that the NRC doesn't regulate enough. By only looking for safety of the design, Westinghouse was able to submit designs that were safe, but not particularly buildable. If the regulators had checked the work of Westinghouse to include basic build ability in addition to safety, tens of billions of dollars might have been saved, and we might have been building more nuclear reactors. But I would like to hear more specific complaints about how regulations could change, if it has the chance to improve nuclear.
- R0b0t1 6y ago> By only looking for safety of the design, Westinghouse was able to submit designs that were safe, but not particularly buildable. Because the commission is biased towards safety above all else. They need to be more realistic and not cave in to fearmongering. The design needs to be safe, but against a realistic threat model. The designs also need to be assembly line and not so highly customized. French style reactor designs are good for this reason. Part that holds the reactor? Fine, evaluate for weather and calamity resistance and build per location. The reactor? Hope you like black.
- epistasis 6y agoWhat is an example of this fearmongering, and what expense did it cause?
- agloeregrets 6y agoFrom the outside, you have large-scale accidents that caused a lot of fear that killed the drive for us. Notably Three Mile Island in the US and the effects of seeing what happened in Chernobyl that was drummed up by the US government to show failures by the Soviets (even though the Soviet reactor design was far more dangerous). Additionally, I live near a plant and they hold extreme safety training on iodine distribution and such to school children that makes kids fear the plant.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jkingsbery 6y agoWhether subsidies are a good idea or not in general for nuclear is an interesting question. The article states that the current plan is to give production tax credits - tax credits for energy produced. Such a subsidy, which does not help mitigate the up front capital costs, would therefore not really address the root problem in the US. To the more general question though: subsidies are to incentivize people (or companies) to do a thing (or do more of a thing). In the case of nuclear power, the timelines involved in building a power plant are so long, and given the uncertainty of having the same tax credits staying in place for long enough to impact financial plans, it seems unlikely that it would actually have the effect we'd want on nuclear power production.
- EricE 6y agoSo don’t build big plants. Micro reactors are far cheaper, easier to maintain and a distributed network of micro reactors would greatly reduce the burden on our already archaic national electric grid. Kill two birds with one stone and all that…
- dukeyukey 6y agoI love the idea, but how much energy to micro-reactors provide today, on a commercial basis?
- EricE 6y agoAs much as you need. Modern designs are modular - chain together as many as you need to provide base load and also provide some overage so you have coverage when they do inevitably need servicing. Or since they are modular if significant long term loads shift geographically, you can easily move them around to where needed too. I agree the concepts of massive plants aren’t desireable - luckily there are alternatives if we can ever get past the emotional arguments and actually discuss things rationally.
- dukeyukey 6y agoThey sound awesome, but as far as I know they still haven't been commercialised so their potential is still largely unknown.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoNuScale is still moving, but they have slipped on schedule and budget, far enough some of their project partners have pulled out. So far everyone who's pursued this small modular reactors built by factories approach has failed in the ambition. Doesn't mean it's impossible but just maybe we should be a bit more bearish than bullish on the idea of this sparking a revolution in the capital costs and time scales of nuclear power.
- thinkcontext 6y ago
- wffurr 6y agoThis isn't about new reactors, it's about operating subsidies to keep existing ones running.
- king_magic 6y agoI'm fine with subsidies for nuclear power given the absolutely terrifying stakes of unchecked climate change.
- _huayra_ 6y agoYes, I'd much rather that my taxes go to an up-front long term investment than have it blown away reacting to something that could have been prevented! It's a good investment for taxpayers, unlike subsidizing dino juice.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe notion that there are large subsidies for fossil fuels is not backed up by the data. There are currently more subsidies for solar and wind.
- cameldrv 6y agoThe subsidy is that they get to emit CO2 for free.
- hackeraccount 6y agoJoin the club? I mean, if they're doing it for free then we all are - if we're paying then so are they.
- p1mrx 6y agoYes, that's why taxing carbon would be useful; it encourages all emitters to find solutions in parallel.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The notion that there are large subsidies for fossil fuels is not backed up by the data. The absence of Pigovian taxes to internalize te environmental externalities is a de facto subsidy equal to the value of the externalized negative impacts (it's paid by society at large through the externalized impacts rather than through government, but the impact is the same.)
- moreira 6y agoCalling it a subsidy makes it seem like it's something governments are doing on purpose. That they can easily say "this subsidy has expired, we're not giving it to you anymore". That is not the case. Implementing a new tax for CO2 emissions is a much, much bigger political endeavour than simply letting a subsidy expire and not renewing it. That's why there's not much value in perverting language to somehow argue that fossil fuels are subsidised. They are not, there's no way to "remove subsidies from their dirtier competitors", as the parent poster suggested. There is a way to tax CO2 emissions, but that's a different discussion altogether.
- exabrial 6y agoCouldn't say it better. Subsidies don't work out the way you want. Look at ethanol: it's an incredibly dirty fuel source (using tons of diesel to make "fuel", smart!) but the ethanol lobby and unions have entrenched themselves permanently so its not worth the fight.
- galangalalgol 6y agoIt just occurred to me that the EV transition will also affect food prices, that should be interesting. Big agro and big oil batting against it. Not sure how we are making even the little progress we are.
- thinkcontext 6y agoIndeed, 40% of US corn is used for ethanol so the potential effect could be huge. However, there's a lot of movement afoot in the ethanol industry for using carbon capture. My guess is given the Ag lobby biofuel will be retained for some time.
- telchar 6y agoWhat unions are involved in ethanol? That's primarily the corn farmer/big ag corps' interest.
- minikites 6y ago>A better approach is to remove subsidies from their dirtier competitors. I see this argued a lot for many industries, has it ever actually happened for any of them? It doesn't seem realistic, but I'd love to be wrong.
- hindsightbias 6y agoAs someone opposed to nuclear power, I agree with both points. Nuclear power cannot exist without subsidies for development, construction and all the externalities. It can't exist in a free market or a leveled playing field.
- orthecreedence 6y ago> It can't exist in a free market or a leveled playing field. Right, because free markets are not capable of pricing in externalities (and in fact they actively incentivize externalities). If they were capable of this, fossil fuels would be prohibitively expensive, and nuclear would be cheap.
- citilife 6y agoI think a better approach is to change some of the regulation. Most of it is good, but some of it is kinda insane. My father worked on nuclear plants in the 70-80's. According to him, from the 80's on it effectively was so much regulation that it was not at all worth building a plant. With technological advancement, a little change in regulations could go a long way.
- nebukadnezar 6y agoGood book what should be done: https://www.amazon.com/Why-Nuclear-Power-Been-Flop/dp/1098308964/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&qid=1620226677&refinements=p_27%3AJack+Devanney&s=books&sr=1-2&text=Jack+Devanney https://www.amazon.com/Why-Nuclear-Power-Been-Flop/dp/109830...
- Tostino 6y agoIf you know, I would love to hear some of the specific regulations that he thought were ineffective and or hampering our nuclear power construction. I've seen it mentioned in this thread without specifics.
- citilife 6y agoAccording to my father, the unions were requiring some crazy stuff like you had a pipe fitter do X, then a different pipe fitter do Y. Both had to be on seperate days. My dad actually left his role when he was stuck in a pipe shaft in 120 degree heat. A pipe fitter went up and the person who helped him out of the pipe and was fired for not following protocol. The regulation came in when they started codifying the union rules. There was also an incident where Westinghouse and GE were faking inspections. I don't have specifics on hand. Generally though, it seems corrupt. At least at the time, the unions essentially controlled construction and wanted to line their pockets, the politicians also lined their pockets. Eventually, the cost was too high to build.
- lalaithion 6y agoNuclear radiation safety is assessed using the "As Low As Reasonably Achievable" standard, which essentially says that if you make a nuclear power plant produce power at half the price of the next-door coal power plant, you have to spend all of the increased profit on increased safety measures. Nuclear can never out-compete non-nuclear power under that regulatory regime.
- eloff 6y agoIn general I oppose subsidies, but I think it's a good idea here. Nuclear solves some major problems with other types of clean energy - it's just prohibitively expensive. I'm all for exploring all alternatives to fossil fuels in parallel - I think the seriousness of the climate situation warrants it. But that cost is largely a function of strong regulations and lack of innovation. If the government gets the ball rolling with subsidies it might get to the point where it doesn't need them anymore. Reducing regulation where appropriate could help too - but in general there are risks and regulation is warranted. And because it makes so much sense - implement a carbon tax that ramps up slowly to the full cost of the externalities of fossil fuels. It's the most effective thing to fight climate change, but instead of doing that we actually subsidize fossil fuels?!? I don't get it.
- Sparkle-san 6y agoIn a free market perhaps, but nuclear power comes with loads of government oversight and regulations (and therefore costs) due to the inherent risk factors. Given that, subsidies seems appropriate.
- EricE 6y agoOne would think the ultimate “subsidy” would be making the current regulatory environment more rational, no?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- spamalot159 6y agoThe capital requirements for starting a nuclear company is likely much large than starting, say, an EV company. Subsidies for EV companies greatly helped in getting the technology off the ground. Subsidies might be a necessary evil in this case.
- natch 6y agoAccording to 2014 Elon Musk, if you cover the same square footage as taken up by a nuclear power plant and its exclusion zone with solar cells, you’ll get more electricity than the nuclear power plant would have supplied. 2014 was a long time ago. It’s possible both technologies have improved since then. I wonder why we don’t hear about this comparison more.
- JoshTko 6y agoThat's for conventional nuclear. Small reactors will take a order less as they have structurally safer designs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- natch 6y agoDon’t you love vaporware? It can do anything! Real-life non-vaporware solar + battery combo installations are improving and spreading all the time. By the time vaporware small nuclear materializes outside of demonstration projects (10 years? 20?) there’s no telling how efficient and ubiquitous solar + batteries will be.
- bluedino 6y agoIn Tuscon, or Seattle?
- natch 6y agoEastern Washington gets plenty of sun and it’s not that far as grids go.
- politician 6y agoThat didn't seem right, so I looked up nuclear exclusion zones -- those things are huge! [1] https://cdn.britannica.com/s:800x1000/00/196800-050-E30A2B4A/Map-exclusion-zones-accidents-Chernobyl-Fukushima-Japan.jpg https://cdn.britannica.com/s:800x1000/00/196800-050-E30A2B4A...
- caffeine 6y agoYou are assuming the objective is clean power. But if the objective were to curry favour with as many people as possible, subsidising everything works better than leveling the playing field. Everybody gets a taste.
- deelowe 6y agoPolitics is like 25% solving problems and 75% a popularity contest and that's being generous. No sane politician would ever remove something providing a benefit until well after it's outlived it's usefulness.
- Mvandenbergh 6y agoIn the absence of a carbon tax, the next best approach is a subsidy that only applies to non CO2-emitting technologies funded from general taxation. Since there is not sufficient political consensus for the former in the US, the latter is a good interim solution.
- Robotbeat 6y agoYeah, agreed. And it’s super annoying when people use the fact that a subsidy isn’t as efficient as a carbon tax (or some other broad measure) as justification for ending it (without a carbon tax replacement). For instance, Virginia (a Blue state) passed a usage fee on EVs (that’s actually higher than the typical state gas tax would be for the same distance traveled in a regular vehicle) in order to “compensate” for the fact that EVs don’t pay gas tax. Therefore turning the Pigouvian gas tax into an anti-Pigouvian fee for acting on the desire to use more efficient and lower emissions transportation. (Not to mention you ALSO were taxed on electricity and the battery... plus personal property tax for the battery... just to add insult to injury.) I guess because of the (false) perception that only rich f**ks buy electric cars. “Oh, but it’s JUST for paying for the roads!” Yeah, like the Pigouvian aspect didn’t matter and as if the state gas tax is solely used for roads.
- downrightmike 6y agoBoth
- macksd 6y agoClearly you don't know how to run up $28 trillion in debt.
- orthecreedence 6y agoI support not destroying the planet. Whatever gets the job done at this point. Removing subsidies is a political shitshow, and you're effectively saying "I support a decades-long political sparring contest while the planet burns." I think it's safe to say we're not operating under a democracy/republic anymore, so whatever will appease the coroporate/banking overlords the quickest is the best path forward.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI support serious measures to address climate change and oppose anything that gets in the way of such measures. If the government wants to give a free pony to people who installs solar panels, that's fine by me. More optimal policies are preferably, of course, but that's a secondary concern. Right now, it seems the most likely outcome is that we keep using fossil fuels, so I'm desperate for anything! (The exception are measures such as banning plastic straws, which I oppose because it's actually a significant inconvenience—which means spent political capital—but will do exceedingly little for the planet.)
- datavirtue 6y agoThe french didn't need anything fancy. They stadardized and then scaled production of reactors. They now have the cheapest energy on the planet, sell excess to others, and have no carbon output from electricity generation. "Freedom fries?"
- pfdietz 6y agoThey now are moving away from nuclear because they are finding it impossible to build new ones affordably. Also, I think you're confusing cost and price there.
- anonuser123456 6y agoNuclear is expensive because of regulatory interference. The NRC literally has a mandate to increase cost. If nuclear had to compete with coal on actual safety, nuclear would already be cheaper than coal.
- asdff 6y agoThe problem is capital doesn't care about the big picture. Nuclear power is an upfront costly measure, you don't see a return for perhaps decades. That's fine if you are a public agency since in time, this will pay for itself, and the concern is about bettering the public in the best way possible, not making a quick return on investment. It's not fine if you are a private energy company with shareholders who are looking to take on a gain and who are only looking at life one quarter at a time. Executives would rather invest in something cheaper where their investors will see a quicker return, because that's how executives keep their jobs. Executives and shareholders care about themselves and their profit, while the government is designed to care about the collective, although its great power is frequently commandeered by individuals seeking personal profit.
- ineedasername 6y agoIf we're treating this as a world-critical issue, we shouldn't wait for market forces to fix it. Like evolution, market forces may converge on good solutions, but not quickly enough to save a species from near extinction. So, yeah, stop subsidizing dirty companies, but also subsidize those solutions that get us out of this mess faster.
- aspaceman 6y agoThere’s a power plant near me that might be closing. Hope this is able to save them.
- exabrial 6y agoIf it's a 1950s-1960s design, it's probably best to let it close, or be retrofitted.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt takes long enough to build a nuclear reactor that it makes more sense to build it somewhere else than on the site of an operating reactor which is still viable to continue operations. Keep all the existing plants that can reasonably be kept operating online until after the last coal plant is shut down, then start retrofitting existing reactors.
- flavius29663 6y agoby then, it might be easier to retrofit them with solar panels and batteries, or H2 power to gas, who knows? Not joking, the lines and transformers are a very big part of a new plant cost, and you already have that setup in place.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoSo retrofit the existing coal power plants into being new nuclear power plants.
- flavius29663 6y agonot sure that's going to work, because nuclear requires some massive concrete insulation bubbles. Also the cooling is wildly different, nuclear power plants are built on large bodies of water, If there isn't one, sometimes they built a large dammed lake to have enough water to cool down the reactors in case of an emergency. Instead, there are coal-> gas and coal->biomass retrofits. Gas works because the installations are TINY compared to coal. Look at Drax, this plan would have replaced the entire capacity of the coal plant. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/jan/30/uk-sued-for-approving-europes-biggest-gas-power-station https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/jan/30/uk-sued-... (I think the plan was dropped eventually). Nuclear to solar I think there is Chernobyl as an example. New nuclear is a challenge right now, because they're not standardized and the costs and timings are insane. Also, everyone wants nuclear, unless it's in their county. I think we have a good chance of seeing factory produced small nuclear reactors that are easier, cheaper and faster to install than what we have now.
- periheli0n 6y agoWhat happened to nuclear being so much cheaper than coal? Is it really just subsidies for coal that tip the balance? Then the logical consequence would be to remove subsidies from that. But I suspect the "nuclear=cheap" mantra is not the end of the story.
- yaacov 6y agoNuclear is cheaper than coal, which is why coal market share is collapsing way faster than nuclear’s is shrinking. But they’re both having trouble competing against cheap gas and solar.
- cameldrv 6y agoNuclear is cheaper to operate, so existing reactors mostly keep running. Construction costs are high for nuclear though. Given the current interest rate environment, nuclear should be looking more attractive.
- periheli0n 6y agoWhat is the TCO of nuclear, factoring in waste disposal and eventually cleaning up the site? The one thing Germany learnt from exiting nuclear, is that proper demolishing and removal of nuclear power plants is quite costly. Plus, there's nowhere to safely store the waste.
- ryan93 6y agoYou can easily store waste underground, the democrats wouldnt allow it in arizona.
- periheli0n 6y agoStoring nuclear waste safely underground requires having a rock formation that is geologically stable over 100,000+ years. Not easy to find. Otherwise the waste will eventually enter ground water and from there inevitably the food chain.
- boringg 6y agoNuclear + Solar + Wind + Storage + Hydrogen + Biogas + Small hydro. Subsidize all of the above to the point that they are on an even playing field of coal and O&G (who are heavily subsidized). To everyone's point removing subsidies is politically challenging (especially as this is almost a red / blue state issue) - however subsidizing something else so that it has a competitive advantage is essentially the same thing albeit the money flow is a bit different. Edit: Why is this getting downvoted so much without any negative comments? weird...
- exabrial 6y agoI was very much for hydro until I joined a wildlife society in college and saw how incredibly destructive it is to habitats.
- boringg 6y agoAgreed - hence small hydro! It takes the energy out of the river systems which very much need to keep that majority in there.
- exabrial 6y agoI fail to see how "removing energy" from a river system isn't directly destroying a habitat. Things like water surges play an important role in create sand bars and other microhabitats. It's best to leave them alone.
- boringg 6y agoI think you misread my comment. I was agreeing with you in that we need to keep the energy in the water systems. Only small hydro which doesn't destroy rivers / ecosystems make sense.
- fighterpilot 6y agoI ask this out of ignorance: How is coal heavily subsidized? Do you mean it's subsidized because they're not being charged for the emissions that they generate?
- metalliqaz 6y agoThis should not happen without a long term plan for where are they are going to put the waste.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoWhat is your long term plan for what to do with all of the carbon dioxide we're putting into the atmosphere? Both are immense problems with immense dangers, but it seems to me that one is clearly easier to solve.
- moate 6y ago"Repair an entire planet's atmosphere" vs "store a few hundred tons of radioactive material safely" are definitely very different levels of problems. Not to mention the possibility that spent fuel could be of use to future generations for some kind of future science and it would all conveniently be in one place.
- EricE 6y agoor if you burn today’s “waste” in reactors that can easily do so, you not only don’t have to securely store it while also getting carbon neutral energy that will displace existing fossil fuel derived sources. Nuclear is predictable which means it’s perfect for base load generation. Something all the other “clean” technologies are not.
- metalliqaz 6y agoso we didn't plan for the problem in the past, so we shouldn't bother this time? that's pure whataboutism and not helpful
- nharada 6y agoThe urgency is different. You don't earthquake-proof your house while the living room is on fire.
- belorn 6y agoThe current strategy in many countries is to first generate as cheap energy as possible, and then subside alternative sources to be ready when the cheaper energy can't fulfill demand. The cheapest energy source get determined by market forces, while the alternative is about the government buying stability. I would suspect that the nuclear subsidies is taken from the later strategy and not the former. Companies can still compete on the market to produce the cheapest possible energy, while the government are moved away from fossil fuels and into alternatives that are clean and provide the desired stability for which existing subsidies are paying for.
- molszanski 6y agoTotally support it. The doomsday clock is ticking and we don't have time to waste debating. We must buy time now
- LatteLazy 6y agoSo cheap it needs huge subsidies. So safe no one will insure it. So clean we have no idea how to deal with the waste. So simple they take decades to build.
- MR4D 6y agoA better idea - have the navy build them and then sell the completed, operational plant (say, after a year of successful operation) to the highest bidder in an auction. Put whatever constraints are needed on the sale, and guarantee the construction for a decade.
- pow_pp_-1_v 6y agoHmm. That's an interesting idea. Seems like they are experts in building relatively small nuclear plants and maintaining them in harsh conditions for years. Wonder if it's feasible though. Maybe they are too slow to build. Maybe they are too expensive.
- evgeniysharapov 6y agoWhy Navy ? Does it have to be in the sea ? If on land then Westinghouse or Duke could build it just as well if not better.
- beastman82 6y agoBecause they're already doing it regularly
- natch 6y agoThey don’t contract it out to Westinghouse or other similar companies?
- dv_dt 6y agoNuclear makes little sense for climate targets. The construction is too expensive and too slow - allocating capital to nuclear ends up slower than allocating the same capital to renewables for hitting climate targets. If you look at reports of lifetime costs for utility scale energy, Nuclear is the most expensive and will likely remain so for the foreseeable future. Solar and wind is already 3-4x cheaper than nuclear, and by the time the decade is out it will likely be 10x cheaper even with attendant storage. https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020 https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020
- vlovich123 6y agoThat’s only because nuclear hasn’t seen serious investment in generations. That’s why solar and wind has come down.
- dv_dt 6y agoChina seriously invested in it heavily, met a modicum of success in building a wave of nuclear plants, but near the middle of the full plan decided to halt any new construction. I think even with low regulation, and a focused investment it was turning out more expensive than the alternatives. Personally, I think looking at the data so far, we should just stop investing in fission plants, continue research of fusion plants, but put a practical focus on building renewables to meet climate targets to get the most reduction for the buck.
- thinkcontext 6y agoLoan subsidies passed under GWB were supposed to result in a nuclear renaissance in the form of Westinghouse's AP1000 GEN III+ reactor. The 2 projects started under Obama have been unmitigated financial disasters. One was cancelled after spending $9B on a hole in the ground, the other is about to come online after going 2x+ over money and time budget. All other AP1000 projects in the US have been cancelled. No one in the US is going to order an AP1000 unless the government takes on construction risk.
- oconnor663 6y agoCasey Handmer has a related take: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/06/21/is-nuclear-power-a-solution-to-climate-change/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/06/21/is-nuclear-pow... > The reason solar is winning is because the manufacturing technology can be iterated every six months, so the learning curve is much faster. Nuclear power plant technology is iterated roughly every 25 years, or twice in the lifetime of a plant. Many first generation plants are still operational, while few third generation plants have been commissioned, and fourth generation plants are still in the planning stage. Even if every design iteration was a factor of 10 better than the previous one, solar, iterating 50 times faster, could outdo this improvement over the same timescale with a mere 5% improvement per iteration. Since this is roughly the solar learning rate, we can now ask if each nuclear design iteration is 10x better than its immediate predecessor. Obviously not. There's definitely an argument that some part of that slow iteration speed for nuclear is political and unnecessary. Clearly if we built more plants they would iterate faster. But realistically at this point...is it going to happen?
- williesleg 6y agoI like burning oil and shit.
- sradman 6y ago> competition from plentiful natural gas, wind and solar power, which are rapidly becoming less pricey. No one questions whether the zero emissions target is rational. Natural gas in North America should complement the variability of wind and solar, IMO.
- clieagle 6y agoI guess subsidies make sense but I think it could make a lot more sense of the government acted as capital investors or something of the sort. Regardless I'm very curious to see how this goes. It'd be neat if they used thorium.
- lolsal 6y agoWhen it comes to acting on climate change, we really need to stop thinking about 'money'.
- pfdietz 6y agoMoney is just a way to represent resources; thinking about money is optimizing to get maximum result per effort. Your statement there is the equivalent of "work harder, not smarter."
- threwaway4392 6y agoBuilding a startup for on-demand nuclear plant submarines for coastal cities worldwide. Coastal mayors and governors have access dashboard to order nuclear submarines and pay by the hour. Submarine plant comes within a week, plugs itself to the local grid from the shore and electricity flows in. You may want to reserve an instance for a year or the submarine may move to a higher bidder municipality. Emergency cooling handled by construction even in worst case scenarios, no pumping necessary. Regulations are fine because the submarine plants are not built in your country. Nuclear waste moves out of the country with the submarine when submarine is done powering your local grid. A real-time marketplace lets cities and countries worldwide bid to host the waste for good money.
- mywittyname 6y agoCute idea, but nuclear submarines aren't that powerful. Output for ballistic submarine reactors are in the 150-250MW range. For reference, natural gas power plants can hit the GW range easily. Even those diesel backup generators you see outside of hospitals and such are about 1kW. You could throw a bunch of those on a tanker ship and probably provide more power output than a nuclear sub reactor.
- anon9384929 6y agoThis is misleading. Gas turbines used for power plants usually put out 100-250mw. Most gas plants just stack 3-5 of them together in a common location - same thing could be done for small reactors.
- shadowfaxRodeo 6y agoNuclear power isn't safe. If it were, then massive amounts of money and time wouldn't go into trying to make it safe. Nuclear control rooms wouldn't be locked down like Fort Knox. And every major population center would have a nuclear power station nearby. There's this idea that the only thing stopping nuclear from saving the world is a bunch of hippies perpetuating a myth that it's not safe — like nuclear energy is a genetically modified tomato. It's not that. It's actually just not safe — or rather, the only way of making it safe is by having round the clock security, big brains monitoring it the whole time, and lots of money. So, given that climate change will bring with it more pandemics, civil unrest, and natural disasters, is it wise to assume that there will always be people around who know how to look after nuclear power stations? Or people who can stop terrorists who want to make dirty bombs from the waste? There's a reasonable argument to be made that it's a risk we should take to avoid worse distasters. But, given that there are cheaper alternatives, that don't take a decade to build, why don't we just not build nuclear? Let's generate non-controversial power, while massively reducing our usage.
- EricE 6y agoNuclear power is very safe - far safer in aggregate impacts to the environment than any other technology. And even more important, it’s predictable - something most other “clean” energy sources are not. As for “cheaper” - citation needed. Especially for handling base load requirements in reliable and predictable ways. Most of the cost around nuclear power, especially in the United States, is from bloated, ineffectual policy decisions designed to artificially suppress it. I do agree we should be doing more with the existing “waste” - we should be burning it in better reactor designs instead of burying or storing it. Note I didn’t say newer or modern designs - we have had the technology since the 50’s to burn what we (ridiculously) term “waste” today but it wasn’t pursued for numerous political and ill informed social issues. These designs also coast to a natural stop if their support systems are interrupted, negating the problems of active systems (like cooling) failing leading to problems in most of our currently deployed reactors.
- dukeyukey 6y agoI think OP meant nuclear is only safe because of massive capital expenditure making it safe. A community of almost any size can run a bank of solar panels or wind turbines safely, but a nuclear planet needs an well-trained and expensive staff on standby to monitor and address any issues.
- roamerz 6y agoI’d prefer to see continuing or additional tax credits for solar and battery storage directly to the consumer. This would dovetail nicely with an infrastructure plan by making the incentives higher for panels made in the U.S.A. Keeping the incentives directly to the consumer would take a good deal of the chances of corruption and back room deals out of the equation I.E. the Solyndra scandal.
- xwdv 6y agoSomeone once told me don’t make the perfect be the enemy of the good.
- tharne 6y agoWe're not talking about the perfect vs. the good here. We're talking about a power source (nuclear) that can result in virtually unlimited harm to human life in cases of serious failure vs. power sources that, while not as well-developed, are much lower-risk long-term.
- asd4232 6y agoNuclear is still better than coal and gas. At this rate we will never limit temperature below 2.1C pre-industrial, so anything that gets helps getting rid of fossil fuels ASAP is a good deal. Also, even worst-case scenario like Chernobyl ultimately wasn't that bad. Several natural disasters in the 2000's have killed way more than it did.
- tharne 6y ago> Also, even worst-case scenario like Chernobyl ultimately wasn't that bad. The problem with statements like this is that we don't actually know what a worst case scenario truly looks like. The day before Chernobyl, the worst-cast scenario, by definition, not as bad as Chernobyl. Similarly, the engineers who built Fukishima were aware of tsunamis and earthquakes and built the plant to withstand what was considered the worst case scenario at the time. Then an even worse case scenario happened.
- tharne 6y agoWhat could go wrong?
- betterunix2 6y agoProbably very little? Modern reactor designs do not have the same risk of catastrophic failure that older designs like the Fukushima plant had.
- tharne 6y agoFolks thought the same thing about Fukushima at the time. If history has shown us anything, it's that we're consistently not as smart as we think we are.
- betterunix2 6y agoIt is not as though the Fukushima operators were blindsided. They knew exactly what would happen if they could not restore power within a certain period of time; they could not restore power and the disaster proceeded as anticipated. What makes modern reactors different is that the worst case is not a catastrophe, and a loss of power does not cause a catastrophe. With older reactors the design philosophy was to make the worst case sufficiently unlikely; with newer designs the philosophy is to not have a catastrophic worst case.
- clomond 6y agoYeah While on one hand I am supportive of more money going to clean energy tech / infra build out, I can’t help but be disappointed that this legislation ISN’T technology agnostic. We are at the point now where there are enough “options on the table” (solar, onshore offshore wind, hydro, nuclear, various storage applications ) that incentives should go towards the cheapest “clean electrons”, regardless of technology. This way the money contributed as subsidy can go the furthest distance. Nuclear power’s Achilles heel on the economics side are particularly problematic for new builds. With increasing construction costs (compared to declining solar and wind), an almost 10 year timeframe to build out, and potentially half a century operating lifespan, it can be hard to ultimately pencil out. That said, nuclear refurbs and upgrades of existing setups is probably a better direction, even if life extension is likely to be more limited.
- antattack 6y agoGive green power a chance - fully invest in solar, kinetic energy power projects for 10 years and only then decide if nuclear power is needed.
- asd4232 6y agoIt's safer to invest both in green power and nuclear. As long as we get rid of fossil fuels ASAP it's a victory, we can always replace those nuclear plants with solar/wind in 50 years if that seems to make sense by then.
- rangoon626 6y agoYes, for ten years we should mine lithium in massive quantities and dump the toxic dirt into the waterways surrounding the mining sites.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- doczoidberg 6y agowhat are we doing with the nuclear waste? I mean in reality not in theory. Aren't renewables cheap enough also with energy storage? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PM2RxWtF4Ds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PM2RxWtF4Ds
- EricE 6y agoWe should be burning it instead of burying a viable energy source.
- kingsuper20 6y agoMaybe they could sneak the funding into the F-35 program.
- jokoon 6y agoIt's time we understand that renewables have a poor benefit/cost ratio when you compare it to nuclear. Renewables + batteries will NEVER supply enough energy in a world that will require more electricity if it uses electric vehicles and move away from fossil fuels. The coal and gaz industry love renewables because you NEED gaz and coal if there's no wind or sun. Please look at the number.
- pjc50 6y agoThis is not reflected in the actual electricity market prices.
- wtallis 6y agoIt's not clear to me how current market prices contain enough information to support or refute the assertion that renewables won't be able to supply enough for a hypothetical future where fossil fuels are no longer used even for transportation. I think you need to also demonstrate that renewable energy prices can remain low even when required to scale up significantly beyond current levels, and that we won't run out of locations amenable to cheap and easy deployment of wind, solar and hydro power.
- EricE 6y agoDrop the solar subsidies and then let’s talk about “market” prices.
- adrianN 6y agoThere are many solar plants around the world that produce cheap power without subsidies.
- EricE 6y agoYup - but they aren’t everywhere. Power transmission doesn’t happen without loss. One of the many issues with solar that doesn’t get addressed. Don’t get me wrong - I’m a huge proponent of solar when it make sense. I grew up in the Desert Southwest so it can make a lot of sense there in particular. But solar is NOT a replacement for technology like nuclear energy.
- intrasight 6y agoEven in the super unlikely case that we institute a (much needed) carbon tax, I just can't see nuclear ever being competitive in a free market. By "competitive" I mean no insurance subsidies.
- downrightmike 6y agoReally? Just spend the billions to build them directly and cut out the bloat.
- typeformer 6y agoThis won’t end well
- antattack 6y agoThe title should be: White House eyes subsidies for existing nuclear plants to help meet climate targets.
- class4behavior 6y agoYou mean a title for those who don't read the article but still vote or comment as if they did? But as far as I know, the purpose of titles is to make you want to get the paper or visit the site and read the article, not fully summarize the topic. .
- 1970-01-01 6y agoWhat ever happened to those shed sized fission generators that were going to be safely running under or next to our houses? Did we forget about them?
- thinkcontext 6y agoThere are a variety of small modular reactors (SMRs) under development, not shed sized more like small town sized. NuScale is the furthest along, they are licensed by the NRC and have a project due to come online towards the end of the decade.
- 1970-01-01 6y agoThank you, I couldn't remember what they were called. There were stories of 1kW vSMRs which would be placed near a house: https://www.reutersevents.com/nuclear/mini-reactor-builders-eye-fleet-savings-supply-canadas-icy-north https://www.reutersevents.com/nuclear/mini-reactor-builders-... Seems like this idea didn't get traction.
- wffurr 6y agoNote that this is for keeping existing reactors open, not build new ones.
- thinkcontext 6y agoA broad carbon price that starts small but rises gradually over time would be better than passing a hodge podge of half measures. Virtually all economists say this would be more economically efficient (cheaper) and it doesn't create distortions by favoring politically popular projects over less sexy but more effective solutions.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoExactly. Put the costs where they really are. I would make a bit of of a change, though--make the carbon tax refundable. Lets say you tax CO2 emissions at $100/ton. You then pay $100/ton to anybody who effectively sequesters CO2. In fact, I would pretty much scrap the emissions rules and replace them with taxes of this sort. There should be no acceptable level followed by fines, there should be a cost from the first gram.
- travisporter 6y agoIs this different from the "trade" of cap and trade?
- sagarm 6y agoYes, because in cap and trade the amount of pollution is decided by policy and price by the market. In this fine-based policy, the price is set by policy and quantity by the market.
- p_j_w 6y agoNot sure if a price that "starts small" is enough at this point. It may have been 15 years ago, but it seems like now it won't be enough to stave off a massive disaster. If there's only political will to start small, then obviously we should do that. It seems like the can kicking of the past has come to bite us in the ass, though, and these sorts of actions will not do it.
- orthecreedence 6y ago
- Robotbeat 6y agoIf you want to treat climate change as an existential threat, then you do whatever it takes to keep all existing nuclear running until fossil fuel plants are gone from the entire continent. And you put a little money to subsidize/stimulate new nuclear on the off chance some of the advanced nuclear concepts work out (or as a backup in case renewables improve slower than we think). You don’t have to stop or even slow renewables deployment to do this. They are fairly different industries with different workforce’s, so there are resources to do both simultaneously without significant interference. And you’re not going to get “too much” electricity as cheap abundant electricity will help accelerate decarbonization of other things like building heat and transport and industrial processes. Existing nuclear ESPECIALLY must be protected. And existing hydro. Number 1 and number 2 (tied with wind) clean energy sources. Nuclear power produces as much energy in our country as coal. We can phase out coal twice as fast if we at very least keep nuclear around a few years longer.
- NullPrefix 6y ago>cheap abundant electricity will help accelerate decarbonization of other things Thinking about them Dogecoins
- surajs 6y agoachievement unlocked, but seriously, not a single mention of fuckushima this deep in the discussion, oh how quickly they grow up!
- asdff 6y agoIt is so upsetting to see CA close down precious nuclear power plants, not because they have built a better alternative to using natural gas or other dirty fuels to cover this load, they haven't, but because it is unprofitable to do the required maintenance and necessary improvements. The need for profit is killing our planet. When it comes to basic essential things like shelter, energy, food, water, profit is pure parasitic loss and should be eliminated. These things really should run at a loss, considering these things generate all other economic activity there is, but we insist that they must be run privately and for profit.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoThe biggest joke about this is that subsidies are not what's preventing nuclear power. It's your states DNR, the EPA, NIMBY's, and the market containing very few people to employ for the job. How is getting a subsidy gonna help when the EPA protects wetlands? How is a cheaper reactor for a power company going to help when the DNR says you have to fulfill absurd rules when constructing in an area that ruins wildlife but satisfies the NIMBY's? What about NIMBY's who get to petition construction near them? Nuclear power just isn't gonna happen here and subsidies are just gonna be trickle up kickbacks to CEO's. There is too much government mandated bureaucracy involved that prevents this. Environmentalists and pro nuclear power people typically want their cake and eat it too. Too bad to make for "greener" energy, you have to destroy a significant part of the world to do it meaning lax EPA regulations. But to do that would be an affront for some outrageous impossible to maintain morality system. Sometimes you gotta bend the rules to get good things done.
- pkaye 6y agoI think we should switch to some of the newer nuclear reactor implementation. There is one that Bill Gates was funding which is supposed to substantially safer according but other similar ones should be evaluated.
- superkuh 6y agoNuclear power in the united states can never be economical because the laws are designed to make it so. I am not being hyperbolic. Literally, the standards call for all emissions to be ALARA: As Low As Reasonably Achievable. https://rootsofprogress.org/devanney-on-the-nuclear-flop https://rootsofprogress.org/devanney-on-the-nuclear-flop > This might seem like a sensible approach, until you realize that it eliminates, by definition, any chance for nuclear power to be cheaper than its competition. Nuclear can‘t even innovate its way out of this predicament: under ALARA, any technology, any operational improvement, anything that reduces costs, simply gives the regulator more room and more excuse to push for more stringent safety requirements, until the cost once again rises to make nuclear just a bit more expensive than everything else. Actually, it‘s worse than that: it essentially says that if nuclear becomes cheap, then the regulators have not done their job. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26836075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26836075
- rland 6y agoImho, if we want to move forward as a species into something like the "next level" of civilization, we need to pour trillions of dollars of effort into building a full stack of nuclear energy. University programs, technical schools, research labs, and a robust supply chain for plant construction and maintenance. The energy density of nuclear fuel would have convinced any higher rational society to do this decades ago. There is no contest, not with solar, not with coal or NG. Pound for pound (including all of the cladding, reactor vessels, and everything else), nuclear plants produce just so much energy.
- suster 6y agoI have seen this argument about energy density before, I still don't understand it. Why is the density of energy generation so important?
- rland 6y agoThe quantity of easily extractable energy available from nuclear fuel dwarfs anything else known. A single nuclear fuel pellet contains the same amount of energy as a ton of coal. 20 tons if all of the energy is extracted. How many tons of easily exploitable coal/ng/etc exist in the world? Nevermind easily exploitable: how much energy exists, period, in fossil deposits? It's dwarfed by nuclear fuel. 1 cm3 to 20 tons. Energy density also makes things easier. You can transport a year's worth of energy on one train. You can ship it to remote areas. To get a lot of energy out of the ground, you don't need a huge extraction process like fracking or strip mining.
- gfiorav 6y agoMaybe it's because I'm not a native speaker, but verbs that could be nouns in a title always has me doing 3 takes to get it right. Kind of annoying.
- nabla9 6y agoNuclear energy is one answer to the question of how to supply 24/7 base load, especially in the night in all conditions. Cheap high capacity energy storage is needed to make renewables competitive as a base load. Until that happens, nuclear is better than goal or gas.
- jbunc 6y agoLoL, 40 years too late. The irony is that if the anti-nuclear environmentalist movement hadn't had as much strength in the 80's, we would be electric carbon neutral and just have transportation to go.
- ineedasername 6y agoanti-nuclear environmentalist movement This movement was heavily pushed along by the established fossil fuel power industry. It's much less "grass roots" than it appeared to be on a surface level.
- omgJustTest 6y agoBrief and speculative but very timely[1]. Displacement of carbon is critical, as well as permanent carbon economies that tax at 50-100 $/tCO2. Systemic and sub-systemic shock is one core.[2] [1] https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/white-house-eyes-subsidies-nuclear-plants-help-meet-climate-targets-sources-2021-05-05/ https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/white-... [2] https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-09/9-9-20%20Report%20of%20the%20Subcommittee%20on%20Climate-Related%20Market%20Risk%20-%20Managing%20Climate%20Risk%20in%20the%20U.S.%20Financial%20System%20for%20posting.pdf https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-09/9-9-20%20Re...
- omgJustTest 6y agoBrief and speculative but very timely[1]. Displacement of carbon is critical, as well as permanent carbon economies that tax at 50-100 $/tCO2. Systemic and sub-systemic shock is one core. [1] https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/white-house-eyes-subsidies-nuclear-plants-help-meet-climate-targets-sources-2021-05-05/ https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/white-... [2] https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-09/9-9-20%20Report%20of%20the%20Subcommittee%20on%20Climate-Related%20Market%20Risk%20-%20Managing%20Climate%20Risk%20in%20the%20U.S.%20Financial%20System%20for%20posting.pdf https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-09/9-9-20%20Re...
- coward76 6y agoMake individual consumer grid energy taxpayer provided and pay the cost to optimize cost down and make long term investments to provide renewable energy. Do the same with internet and water and target wasteful bitcoin miners with asset liquidation.
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 6y agoThe WH needs to push congress for a carbon tax (which, unfortunately, they are too cowardly to even try). We don't even need to be subsidizing nuclear, it will miraculously become profitable when fossil fuels' externalities are properly priced in.
- maxcan 6y ago1. Ensure that ALARA based regulations keep new entrants out of the nuclear market. 2. Subsidize existing, inefficient providers. 3. Profit! (for entrenched players, not us)