10 ms·
Out-of-control Chinese rocket expected to fall to Earth in the coming days
- asmos7 6y agoPpl are talking how we need regulation. We can't even spot China from putting ppl in concentration camps how are we going to regulate their rocket program.
- wlll 6y agoDoesn't the fact that you're commenting on a story about their rocket program with a comment about them putting people in concentration camps show that we can spot both, at least from a high level?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> show that we can spot both, at least from a high level? Think it was stop*.
- swiley 6y agoThey also have a habit of letting early booster stages fall in mainland China. There are videos of remote villagers walking around crashed boosters with lovely red NOx smoke coming out.
- themaninthedark 6y agoOn 15 February 1996, the Long March 3B launch vehicle failed during launch, veering off course immediately after liftoff and crashing into a village near the launch site (probably Mayelin Village).[1] An enormous explosion destroyed most of the rocket and killed an unknown number of inhabitants.[3] The nature and extent of the damage remain a subject of dispute. The Chinese government, through its official Xinhua news agency, reported that six people were killed and 57 injured. However, American estimates suggest that anywhere between 200 and 500 people might have been killed in the crash; "dozens, if not hundreds", of people were seen to gather outside the centre's main gate near the crash site the night before launch.[4] When reporters were being taken away from the site, they found that most buildings had sustained serious damage or had been flattened completely.[4] Some eyewitnesses were noted as having seen dozens of ambulances and many flatbed trucks, loaded with what could have been human remains, being taken to the local hospital.[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelsat_708#Launch_failure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelsat_708#Launch_failure
- xienze 6y ago> We can't even spot China from putting ppl in concentration camps how are we going to regulate their rocket program. We can, we’re just not going to do anything about it because decades of outsourcing American (and others) industry to China has made us a bit dependent on keeping them happy. Edit: tell me where I’m wrong folks...
- spaetzleesser 6y agoSeems about right to me. Same with Saudi Arabia. We like human rights but money even more so as long as there is money to be made, human rights will be second priority.
- sgift 6y agoThought experiment: Let's assume we wouldn't depend on China for industry. What could we do in your opinion?
- HDMI_Cable 6y agoIf MacArthur were still alive, he would say "let's bomb them".
- bingbong70 6y agoThen it is a good thing he is dead. Rather not inadvertently cause the creation of the Chinese version of MacArthur with this view about the US due to short term thinking.
- lupire 6y agoEven without outsourcing, there are challenges to stopping a genocide by strong military power.
- mulmen 6y agoRegulation is something a government does within its own jurisdiction. The only country that can regulate China is China. This does not imply a lack of ability to impose effective regulation on the part of any other sovereign nation. Regulation is not something you do to a geopolitical adversary.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't take HN threads into nationalistic flamewar. It's not what we want here. Unsubstantive comments on flamewar topics are flamebait generally. Please don't post those. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- yonixw 6y agoI heard that because earth is 70% water, it will probably land in water. But according to [1], its movement is almost evenly split between land and water in the uncertainty interval. [1] https://aerospace.org/reentries/cz-5b-rocket-body-id-48275 https://aerospace.org/reentries/cz-5b-rocket-body-id-48275
- tlamponi 6y agoBut still, the last time China did this metal parts sprayed down on a ~150 km wide land stripe in the Ivory Coast... If it would just hit those ignorant people not caring about such impacts they would maybe re-think...
- iamgopal 6y agoYes, ignorant people should think and rethink twice before becoming ignorant.
- wungsten 6y agoThey meant China should re-think, not the victims.
- lupire 6y agoWere there damages reported? Low population density areas give low odds of collisions, plus free metal to be scavenged/recycled Article here mentions metal found but not damages. https://www.newsweek.com/chinese-rocket-rained-metal-ivory-coast-earth-orbit-1588865?amp=1 https://www.newsweek.com/chinese-rocket-rained-metal-ivory-c...
- tremon 6y agoI'm not sure how to read that chart. Is it showing the object is expected to circle the earth 4 more times, then crash somewhere to the west of Australia?
- Ajedi32 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- system16 6y agoIf you've ever worked in Mainland China in virtually any field, you've undoubtedly heard workers or managers use the phrase "chabuduo" accompanied by a shoulder shrug. It translates to "close enough". When you've purchased some cheap product that is Made in China and falls apart after a few months, or when you hear a building in China has collapsed due to cutting corners or cheaping out on materials, or when an accident occurs because safety measures at a factory were non-existent, or when rocket pieces come crashing out of the sky... you can be sure somebody involved mentioned this risk and there was a decision maker who shrugged it off with a "chabuduo". To be clear it's an attitude very prevalent in Mainland China and not culturally specific to Chinese - I haven't encountered this in Taiwan, Malaysia, Singapore, or even Hong Kong - and I think it's an attitude that is really holding China back from its full potential.
- imagineerschool 6y agoWatch out that commenting on Chinese culture doesn't get you branded as a racist! I made these stickers to put on my ChaBuDuo machines so no one in my lab gets confused: https://www.redbubble.com/i/sticker/UPGRADED-REAL-CHINESIUM-WOW-by-topqualitynow/77004945.EJUG5 https://www.redbubble.com/i/sticker/UPGRADED-REAL-CHINESIUM-... Edit: I should have expected these downvotes from people who have never spent any time in Mainland China and the wumaodang. JiaYou!
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoI have heard “chabuduo” in both Taiwan and Malaysia. You are definitely into something, though. Let me elaborate a little more: I think the thing that makes this more prevalent in China, besides the larger population, are the incentives put in place for the winds of exaggeration to blow. These failures occur when you mix that micro level idgaf with a macro level one.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago"chabuduo" is a common expression in Chinese used in everyday language. Not just "close enough" in English but also "more or less", "-ish", etc in every language so yes it will be heard everywhere people speak mandarin. What may be specific is to use it to brush off substandard work. Edit: In this case, I don't think mentioning "chabuduo" (as a brush off of substandard work) is apt, though. I think it's more about their can-do and "move fast, break things" attitude.
- interestica 6y agoTrack https://orbit.ing-now.com/satellite/48275/2021-035b/cz-5b/ https://orbit.ing-now.com/satellite/48275/2021-035b/cz-5b/
- dotdi 6y agoProbably going to be downvoted into oblivion, but I think China is pushing and pushing to make such things "normal". The rest of the world need to start sanctioning China whenever the government acts in bad faith or with recklessness, before others follow suit. Leaving these things unanswered is an open invitation. It's not the first time this happens. Without response it won't be the last.
- Jiocus 6y agoWhat supports your belief that China are pushing this to become normal, as opposed to not being already the norm? A closer look at some of the large objects which has re-entered[1] as well as a few cases of incidents[2] and their origins, suggests the USA together with USSR then Russia normalised this practice decades ago. Edit: A natural consequence of them being the first and largest players in the game of slinging large objects into orbit. - [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_reentering_space_debris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_reentering_space_debri... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_debris#On_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_debris#On_Earth
- kingofpandora 6y agoTwo uncontrolled entries since 1967 doesn't sound like normalized behaviour.
- Jiocus 6y agoI don't know where you got 'two' from, nor why '1967' is a significant year. Care to elaborate?
- kingofpandora 6y agoIt's data from the Wikipedia article you shared. You said it's normal practice but I say it's only happened twice in over 50 years.
- deleted 6y ago
- foobarthrowaway 6y agoA single American company that started less than 20 years ago has just landed a heavy rocket on a bullseye on a ship for the 9th time meanwhile the full weight of the Chinese communist machine keeps coming up with these ramshackle embarrassments and we're expected to believe China is about to eclipse the west any day now.
- rscoots 6y agoIn small ways them eclipsing the US technologically seems preferable to this macabre Dunning–Kruger situation we see now. Falling rockets, sloppy & ill-considered eugenics programs, releasing worldwide pandemics from laboratories... Just a thought, and China certainly isn't the only offender. Hell, the US was firmly in this catagory for much of the last 100 years.
- kleiba 6y agoRegarding your COVID19 conspiracy theory, allow me to quote Wikipedia: Echoing the views of scientists internationally, a World Health Organization (WHO) mission said that a laboratory leak origin for the virus was "extremely unlikely", supporting what most experts already expected about the likely natural origins of the virus and its early transmission. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigations_into_the_origin_of_COVID-19#Scientific_consensus_on_origins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigations_into_the_origin...
- rscoots 6y agoCiting Wikipedia aside, the WHO exists in large part to get large, competing nations to cooperate on matters of public health. This often involves placating these nations. You should take some time to read up on the many respected and qualified institutions who've done a much deeper dive on this "conspiracy theory" than the WHO ever intended to.
- wildermuthn 6y agoI think there’s a difference between questioning if this was an accidental lab leak based of legitimate scientific research, as compared to conspiracy theories that blame China for intentionally creating and releasing a bio-weapon. There’s a large spectrum between rational inquiry and conspiracy theories. Until the source of the virus has become more clear, it seems fair game to speculate about a lab leak without being subject to criticism as a conspiracy theory. Having said that, I agree that there should be pushback against assigning blame for Covid. Determining cause and assigning blame are done most accurately when decoupled. Even if the cause was a lab leak, the blame may belong to poor lab management rather than the Chinese government. Or maybe it was one individual’s fault. Or maybe it is just one of things that happen in dangerous lab work. Or maybe the blame really goes to world leaders who didn’t shut down air travel sooner. Blame is much harder to figure out than cause, and it’s a lot easier to point fingers at others instead of at ourselves.
- La1n 6y agoTo those saying it's cultural, or China is pushing this to be normal, or China needs to be sanctioned. Do you respond the same when SpaceX drops space junk to earth? https://www.forbes.com/sites/ericmack/2021/04/04/spacex-rocket-that-burned-up-over-seattle-also-dropped-space-junk-on-a--farm/?sh=5177dacf3643 https://www.forbes.com/sites/ericmack/2021/04/04/spacex-rock...
- Tade0 6y agoYes. High-speed space trash is high-speed space trash.
- tcskeptic 6y agoIsn't the difference here that one was a deliberate design decision and one was a de-orbit burn failure? While the risks posed by both are significant (though the chinese rocket is much, much larger) there was no intent by SpaceX that this outcome was "good enough". That does not seem to be true here. They should probably both face sanctions, but the sanction for deliberate design choices should be much more severe than those for failures.
- Ajedi32 6y agoSpaceX usually deorbits their second stage rockets over the ocean in a controlled manner. The article you linked is about a one-off case where the rocket engine failed to re-light and ended up reentering in an uncontrolled manner. There's a big difference between something like this happening due to an accident, and it being done on purpose as a matter of course.
- onepointsixC 6y agoThere is a meaningful difference between a failure to de-orbit properly as planned, and planning to not have a controlled de-orbit.
- EarthIsHome 6y agoThere seems to be a difference on how space junk is described based on who the source of the space junk is. e.g. see these headlines: https://imgur.com/a/FwzuMVK https://imgur.com/a/FwzuMVK
- anovikov 6y agoFirst of all this is not the first, but second stage (because rocket has a parallel layout and second stage engine starts at same time with the first, it can be called "core" stage, but not "first"). First stage are the boosters on the sides. For example, Soyuz also has same layout (plus an upper stage, LM5 also has it, just not for LEO launches), and it's core is never called "first stage". Also, this isn't a sign of anything going wrong. Upper stages very commonly enter orbit and sometimes stay there for long. It happened to SpaceX Falcon 9 too, it's just their rockets are smaller.
- JshWright 6y agoNo, this is unusual because it is a first stage booster (it is lit on the ground, making it "first" stage in most people's common usage of the term (in reality, there's no hard and fast definition)). It is definitely not the "second stage" (the second stage of the Long March 5 is the CZ-5-HO). This would be like the center booster of a Delta IV Heavy making it to orbit. Second stages pretty much invariably make it to orbit. To say "it happened" to SpaceX makes it sound like something went wrong... it's just how rockets work. The central booster of a Long March 5 making it to orbit is unusual (though it has happened before).
- anovikov 6y agoJust because this is launch of a very heavy payload onto a low earth orbit. So there is no upper stage as there is no need for it. Center core of Delta IV Heavy can't make it to orbit in any normal circumstances.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JshWright 6y agoI haven't done the math, but I would be surprised if a Delta IV-H couldn't fly a similar profile, resulting in the first stage being in a low orbit. DIVH and LM5 have similar LEO payload capacities, and the mass of everything above the first stage (dry second stage, propellant, and payload) is ~90t for both. So, quick napkin math looks like it works (obviously there are a lot of other complexities I'm ignoring here, for the sake of simplicity).
- dangerbird2 6y agoIt seems like this is a consequence of the Long March 5 using a variation on the "stage and a half" design where the main engine fires from liftoff to orbit, with side boosters being discarded in a suborbital trajectory. The Atlas Rocket family (prior to Atlas V), Energia/Buran, and the Space Shuttle had a similar design, with a bulky central stage left in low earth orbit, where its will probably deorbit in an unpredictable location. Fortunately, in the case of the shuttle, the engines were on the orbiter, so only the relatively light fuel tank had the problem, while the Atlas used a balloon tank[1] which relied on the pressure of its fuel and oxidizer for structural integrity that would presumably collapse and break up in an atmosphere. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balloon_tank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balloon_tank
- Denvercoder9 6y ago> Fortunately, in the case of the shuttle, the engines were on the orbiter, so only the relatively light fuel tank had the problem The Shuttle external tank never entered orbit. At separation, the perigee of the trajectory was still inside the atmosphere. While the Shuttle burned its OMS engines at apogee to complete orbital insertion, the external tank remained on a ballistic trajectory, and its impact point was controlled at all times.
- terom 6y agoHad to re-read the photo caption a couple of times: > A module that launched with the rocket, Tianhe, is expected to re-enter Earth's orbit on May 9. I suppose having the space station module re-enter Earth orbit would be a good thing? I wonder if that would actually be a historical first :)
- Symmetry 6y agoAt least this is a 5B without the hypergolic third stage and the potential to poison people on the ground.
- quyleanh 6y agoSubmitted here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27020317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27020317
- dang 6y agoReposts are allowed on HN if a story hasn't had significant attention yet. Here's a past explanation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25530246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25530246.
- publicola1990 6y agoThe sentiment in most western sources on this is predictable. IIRC the US Skylab did an uncontrolled deorbiting, and was a much larger object than this booster. Much of the articles on this have much second guessing/indirection, but ideally it would have been better to get a quote from the CNSA on this, but I haven't seen any news sources trying to get a direct comment. My guess is that they require 3 launches in this configuration where the whole booster reaches the orbit for delivering the core modules of their space station, and they might have computed the odds that the uncontrolled deorbiting will cause major damage to be insignificant considering the 3 launches, expecting that whatever reaches the ground if any may be small dispersed fragments. Of course a small fragment could be lethal, but then again a falling coconut could be lethal as well, but people consider it an insignificant risk.
- jessriedel 6y agoIn expectation the damage this will do is miniscule. Yes, China ought to compensate for damage/clean-up to whoever this falls on, but overall this is a non-issue. If they were able to reduce launch costs by 1% by not including the fuel/equipment to de-orbit in a controlled way, then it's a good trade off. Every time you drive with your windows down you run the risk of something getting blown out of your window and causing a wreck behind you, but as long as you don't keep a bag of nails perched precariously on your window this is so rare it's not worth any hand-wringing.
- Giorgi 6y agoBecause China has not done enough damage by COVID19.
- t0mbstone 6y agoWhat I don't understand is how we still don't know where the damn thing is going to land. We know where it's at, we know its velocity, and we know its altitude. And yet nobody seems to be able to calculate the math for the its de-orbital trajectory? Is our rocket science after all these years really that much of a joke?
- mulmen 6y agoIt’s out of control. The atmosphere is not uniform.
- t0mbstone 6y agoAnd there are no simulations that can at least figure out a rough landing area?
- mulmen 6y agoThat is what this website [1] does. Simulating global weather from the surface up to the Thermosphere [2] a week in advance with the required fidelity to notify even continents would be an enormous undertaking. It would require detailed models of solar activity including how it reaches Earth. As we get closer to reentry time the estimates will improve because there are fewer variables. This particular case is notable because it is a deliberate uncontrolled reentry. Typically reentry is controlled, allowing for fine adjustments. Launch profiles typically also have some safety margin built in where even if a controlled launch becomes uncontrolled the spacecraft will still end up somewhere safe. None of that is the case here so the impact point is at the mercy of the wind. [1]: https://aerospace.org/reentries/cz-5b-rocket-body-id-48275 https://aerospace.org/reentries/cz-5b-rocket-body-id-48275 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth#Thermosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Earth#Thermosphe...
- mulmen 6y agoIt’s too late to edit but I attempted to reference my own comment and realized this link has already rotted. It now redirects to a useless Twitter thread. See https://orbit.ing-now.com/satellite/48275/2021-035b/cz-5b/ https://orbit.ing-now.com/satellite/48275/2021-035b/cz-5b/ for an up-to-date estimate. Unfortunately it doesn’t have the nice visualization aerospace.org has decided to revoke for this mission specifically.