8 ms·
In Singapore, Covid vs. privacy is no contest
- einpoklum 6y ago> Life in Singapore during the pandemic has become about tracking, tracking, tracking. Wherever one goes, one has to scan QR codes that log entry into malls, restaurants, shops and office buildings. Heh. In Israel, and even before the pandemic, the political police (the "Shin-Bet") has the cellular operators save your location history (indefinitely? who knows) for them to query for their shady ends, and sometimes even for regular police to have access to. During the pandemic, this was used to retrace movements of sars-ncov-2-test-positive people, and to inform people they were in contact with they should self-quarantine. The funny thing was that the quarantine had a bunch of loopholes, and you don't have to carry your phone with you, and nobody would check up on you, and the airport was basically wide open until early this year, so the whole clamp-down was half-theatrical and we got the further legitimization of mass surveillance without even the potential upside. (Now, In Israel, things have improved because of vaccination, not other reasons; but the government won't allow the Palestinians in the 1967-occupied territories, the ones without citizenship, to get vaccinated, so they're not faring that well.)
- bdamm 6y agoSounds kinda like genocide eh?
- einpoklum 6y agoIt's pretty terrible, but there are gradations of abuse below genocide... also, technically, the Palestinians "didn't pay for it", although of course they are under occupation and would not have been able to pay for it etc. Anyway, it's pretty bad.
- zibzab 6y ago1. Singapore is not a democracy. It is a dictatorship, although a well run one. 2. Did it work? How many died in Singapore compared to your country? EDIT: sorry all. maybe "authoritarian" is a better word?
- fvdessen 6y agoIs the number of deaths really the best criterion to compare life in different countries last year ? Since when has the world become an utilitarian contest ?
- neither_color 6y agoProbably not. If all countries had in the beginning the same amount of travelers coming from the origin point THEN you could directly attribute case/death counts to safety measures. Some countries dodged the wave and take credit for their mandates, others didnt lock down and also dodged the wave(thus erroneously giving people confidence that doing nothing works). Even within large countries there are regional differences. For example the earlier cases of covid were appearing on the west coast, but New York got hit the hardest before either side took any particular action. Could it be because it was a busier travel nexus? We shouldn't berate ourselves for not performing the same way island nations in the southern pacific ocean did.
- antientropic 6y agoAccording to https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/, Singapore has a total of 31 coronavirus deaths, one of the lowest per capita death rates in the world. So it seems to have worked very well.
- xiphias2 6y agoThat's great, so the most important data point was missing from the article: that it was worth it, as lots of lives were saved. It's just the opposite of the 2nd world war tracking where it caused deaths.
- api 6y agoSingapore is also small. Countries that small can much more easily coordinate pretty much everything. Every aspect of governance is simpler and there is significantly less controversy around things. The USA is enormous and has many distinct cultures with very different ideas and interests.
- fvdessen 6y agoWhile I can't say I am that surprised about that happening in Singapore, a country that already had a reputation of placing order above everything, I am surprised at how easily fundamental freedoms have been taken away in more democratic countries like in Western Europe. We reassure ourselves that those measures are temporary, but people have come to see a lot of those as now being part of life, turning their anger instead at those who question the effectiveness and lawful nature of those measures. I am afraid that as this virus will stay, even if becoming far less threatening thanks to vaccines, society will keep seeing those measures as necessary to 'keep numbers low' and that we'll never really go back to the way things were before
- bdamm 6y agoMany share your fear, but like the Spanish Flu, this too shall pass. The virus is real, and the end of restrictions are near. If not by pragmatism, then surely by election.
- zibzab 6y agoAnd how do you know the measures are not temporary? And do you feel your country should go back to normal (a) when the danger is over or (b) when You feel You had enough?
- fvdessen 6y agoWhat does 'when the danger is over' mean in practice ? When it becomes zero ? When nobody dies of corona anymore ? If it is that, then the measures are permanent, and if not, what ?
- mikestew 6y agoAs if there were not clear, published guidelines for such things. In about 6.8 seconds I found this page for my own U. S. county to get you started: https://kingcounty.gov/depts/health/covid-19/data/key-indicators.aspx https://kingcounty.gov/depts/health/covid-19/data/key-indica... That's just one page of many on that site, for just one county out of however many counties there are in the U. S. So I believe it unnecessary to act as if there are not easily-accessed answers to your questions.
- unholiness 6y agoEDIT: I am incorrect: TraceTogether is now using its own, non-anonymized technology[1]. Thanks detaro for correcting me. I'll still leave the comment because I'm interested in the ending question – This same damning article could have been written if TraceTogether had done everything right, so how do we effectively motivate governments to get everything right? -------- It feels wrong to loop in the anonymized TraceTogether technology with other genuinely egregious privacy violations of the Singaporean government. The Android/Apple exposure notifications API[0] rolled out in the early days of the pandemic is a pretty solid example IMO of handling privacy correctly. The protocol generates you a new anonymous ID every 20 minutes and locally remembers the last ~30 days of ids. Through BTLE, it collects the anonymous ids of other phones that it's within range of (and for how long), and remembers them locally for ~30 days. When someone voluntarily self-reports as COVID-positive, the API broadcasts the list anonymous ids used during their likely contagious period, allowing other phones to locally recognize if they've been exposed, and for how long. It's hard to imagine a more private version of this with any amount of usefulness. Unless I'm missing something (which I may well be!), the privacy loss the article refers can only happen if: 1. The police can legally and physically confiscate and unlock your phone 2. The police can legally and physically confiscate and unlock the phone of the person they suspect you of being/not being within 20 feet of 3. It was less than a month ago 4. There were no other eyewitnesses or evidence of the contact The first one, of course, also gives them access to plenty of other data we think of as private. Because this scenario exists, you can definitely make an argument that phones are a little less private with TraceTogether than without. But with the rarity and narrowness of the breach, I have a hard time putting it even remotely close to the other pieces of the article, describing 24/7 security cameras and exposing confidential lawyer correspondences. The article concludes: > What’s less considered is the sheer volume of data, and the variety of types of data that the state is collecting, allowing it to piece together people’s lives with much more detail than we might realise. ...and, well, I completely agree. That's exactly the context the article seems to lack. It's also a broader problem: How do we effectively define and communicate a right to privacy when the volume is what's so important? [0] https://www.google.com/covid19/exposurenotifications/ https://www.google.com/covid19/exposurenotifications/ [1] https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/apple-google-contact-tracing-system-not-effective-for-singapore-vivian-balakrishnan https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/apple-google-contact-...