7 ms·
This is where China achieves victory. All the PRC has to do is give priority to domestic manufacturers for small parts. Exports of finished items are preferred
by Animats 6y ago
This is where China achieves victory. All the PRC has to do is give priority to domestic manufacturers for small parts. Exports of finished items are preferred over exporting raw materials and parts. That was part of the Made In China 2025 plan.
If some other country starts to develop an in-house supply chain for some specific item, exports for that specific item are turned back on and possibly sold at a loss until the threat ceases. That's what happened with rare earths. Remember rare earth shortages. China cranked up the price, Molycorp got the Mountain Pass CA mine going again, China dropped the price, Molycorp went bankrupt. Same strategy Amazon uses with Amazon Basics.[1]
This is an explicit national strategy of the PRC. There's no secret about it.
[1] https://www.mining.com/caught-between-rare-earths-and-chinese-dominance-the-story-behind-everything-no-one-is-telling-you-part-one/ https://www.mining.com/caught-between-rare-earths-and-chines...
- chrisweekly 6y agoThis seems like a straightforward description of the problem; what potential solutions / mitigations are available?
- wmf 6y agoOnshoring supply chains and keeping them working whether they're profitable or not.
- cortesoft 6y agoI.E. subsidizing.
- icegreentea2 6y agoDecide on what industries or areas are strategic, and subsidize the crap out of it, and be ready to deal with all the negatives (see farming and oil and gas subsidies) that come with that. If it's important enough, then it's worth negotiating the pitfalls.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoYeah, as far as I can tell we only really have three options when dealing with a trading partner that will subsidize exports: either we ban importing from that country until they drop the subsidies or we levy duties and other taxes to offset the subsidies or we subsidize ourselves. “Free market” thinking won’t work because the market already has been interfered with by a foreign government.
- jkepler 6y agoWait - wasn't it relatively free-markets and rule-of-law property rights that enabled the west to outcompete the USSR, spending just a small fraction of GDP on defense compared to the Soviet defense percentage of GDP? And didn't relatively free markets succeed while soviet communism collapsed under its own economic weight?
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoit might be more accurate to say free-er markets won. The US has been subsidising some industries for a long time.
- Ericson2314 6y agoNot really. a) It's amazing Russia went from just out of feudalism to as industrial as it did. b) If there even was a mistake, it is probably that more demand and nicely flexible demand (as the consumer economy can provide) would have helped. But that's not about free trade per se. Pretty sure West-East trade was already pretty limited from both sides, and I don't think there were many intra-USSR limitations to trade. For example, the border between Russia and Ukraine has caused many economic issues in the years since.
- magicsmoke 6y agoYou could model economic systems as alternating layers of centralized and decentralized decision making. Individual teams in a company make decentralized decisions about how products should be made, but the centralized decision about what the company's strategic direction should be is made by company executives. Likewise, individual firms compete in a decentralized economy, but the government makes centralized decisions about what sectors are crucial to national security and are subsidized. The USSR had no decentralized layer of decision making at the firm level, all firms produced according to quotas made by the central government, and were ultimately less efficient than the US's decentralized layer of competing firms. This does not mean that centralized layers aren't necessary. Both the US and the USSR had a layer of centralized decision making at the government level subsidizing key national industries during the cold war. Both kinds of layers are necessary, but after the cold war the US saw that their decentralized layer of firms made them more economically successful than the USSR, thought that was the whole formula, and tossed national economic strategy out the window to let the firms do whatever they liked. Now the pendulum's swinging back to correct this misconception with China growing quickly using a layer of centralized national economic strategy that the US discarded.
- Mathnerd314 6y agoIf there are frequent shortages but it's a different part every time, then flexible manufacturing techniques like 3d printing that can adapt to the market and print expensive parts.
- jeffreygoesto 6y ago3D printed parts lack stability and precision for like 99% of all use cases. Especially for expensive parts. Precision is mostly what makes them expensive.
- sbierwagen 6y agoYou could try a WTO-style tit-for-tat sanctions on individual dumping cases. Or you could ban all trade with China.
- snowwrestler 6y agoThe market solves this problem. If China makes things too hard on intl businesses, the businesses will invest to go around China. That’s what the rare Earth mine example shows. China needs big intl businesses. The Chinese domestic market is not big enough to support their current pace of economic growth, and the government relies on that growth for social stability.
- goatinaboat 6y agoThe market solves this problem. If China makes things too hard on intl businesses, the businesses will invest to go around China You’re forgetting the time aspect. A government can play a longer game than most private investors. Markets: 0.25 years Western govts: 4-5 years Autocratic regimes: lifetime of dictator
- snowwrestler 6y agoThe lifetime of an autocratic regime is limited by their ability to control their population—see my 2nd paragraph.
- Siira 6y ago> their ability to control their population Seeing the results of protests in recent years, this ability seems to be ever increasing.
- hliyan 6y agoAgree about free markets and time. Adam Smith's invisible hand moves slowly. The free market might solve all our problems (including pollution) over time, but our generation (and maybe even the next) may not be alive to see it. And the human casualties may be high. Which is why regulation and subsidies are a practical necessity.
- remarkEon 6y ago>The market solves this problem. If China makes things too hard on intl businesses, the businesses will invest to go around China. That’s what the rare Earth mine example shows. What the rare Earth mineral example shows is that China is willing to incur environmental and human rights costs that the West is not, in order to carve out a seat at the table for negotiating future power projection. >China needs big intl businesses. The Chinese domestic market is not big enough to support their current pace of economic growth, and the government relies on that growth for social stability. Really not following this point. If anything, this is evidence that elites in the west - who get rich off of the kinds of "market solves everything" solutions you may or may not be alluding to - will continue to ignore the problem as long as the stock market goes up. I also don't understand your point about the size of the domestic market in China. It's well over a billion people. International business looks at those demographics and see nothing but dollar signs. The difference here is that China's government will only let in that business insofar as they see it as enriching their country, and they make this point explicit. Size alone here is an advantage.
- jollybean 6y agoIt's not so straight forward because China is not a centrally planned economy, and very few products prices are as priced in a straightforward way as are 'rare earths'. Imagine telling Huawei to stop selling a massively profitable product overseas for example. I don't really see this strategy being carried out other than in the most general sense. Where are these supply chains popping up and getting swamped? And remember, this is very costly to China as well - selling at a loss, so they can then sell 'very cheaply'? The problem with the above thesis is that all of this is a 'secondary economy strategy' i.e. it's good for catching up, it's not very good for surpassing. You need domestic consumption, and the ability to export goods at the highest end of the value chain, both things China will struggle with.
- Animats 6y agoThe problem with the above thesis is that all of this is a 'secondary economy strategy' i.e. it's good for catching up, it's not very good for surpassing. China is past the "catching up stage" in the industrialized areas. Median income in Shenzhen is comparable to US median income. Current policy is to increase domestic consumption and have an internal economy which is less dependent on exports, while still dominating key international markets. This is called "Dual Circulation". Here's a summary of the 14th Five Year Plan.[1] "President Xi called for building “independent, controllable, secure, and reliable supply chains to ensure industrial and national security with access to at least one alternative source for important products.” President Xi said China should “use existing global dependencies on China as a counterweight to pressures to shift manufacturing out of China” and “use the pull of China’s market to attract global resources and deepen global dependence on China.”" The "Made in China 2025" plan, issued in 2015, listed 10 sectors where China wanted to be self-sufficient by 2025. - New information technology - High-end numerically controlled machine tools and robots - Aerospace equipment - Ocean engineering equipment and high-end vessels - High-end rail transportation equipment - Energy-saving cars and new energy cars - Electrical equipment - Farming machines - New materials, such as polymers. - Bio-medicine and high-end medical equipment. Most of those goals have already been achieved. Again, none of this is a secret. It's stated policy of the PRC. [1] https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11684 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11684
- slv77 6y agoTax foreign savings so that trade surpluses can’t be recycled into US assets. https://carnegieendowment.org/chinafinancialmarkets/83365 https://carnegieendowment.org/chinafinancialmarkets/83365
- Ericson2314 6y agoSee https://phenomenalworld.org/interviews/trade-wars-are-class-wars https://phenomenalworld.org/interviews/trade-wars-are-class-... for a very good explanation of another dimension. Trying to convince the US government to do something about this seems quite difficult. I feel like the easier tactic perhaps is trying to get international trade to be less dollar-oriented. Indirect doesn't necessarily mean harder.
- pixl97 6y agoThe last person that tried to take trade off the petrodollar got killed.
- cutemonster 6y agoWhat was his (her?) name?
- bildung 6y agoThey probably meant Muammar al-Gaddafi (Lybia).
- justicezyx 6y agoSo when US practice it's company behavior, when Chinese company practice it, it's national strategy? Like everyone wants to fxxk Chinese or Asian American with racial discrimination like denying qualified candidates in college education? This nation indeed lost her mind, or maybe the nation had always been like this. Let's see when will the hypocrite finally get punished... Good luck then.
- resonantjacket5 6y agowouldn't just having a small mineral stockpile alleviate much of the danger while turning back on the mine? while having a chip stockpile for too long isn't really too feasible because of how fast chips are deprecated. Though I know it is a bit more complicated with refineries etc...
- remarkEon 6y agoMinerals aren't evenly distributed on planet earth.
- redis_mlc 6y agoI can't think of any mineral that the US doesn't have (in the ground.) However, some are no longer mined in the US, like tin, since 1993. (For people unfamiliar with "rare earth minerals", they're not rare. But today their mining and processing is mostly done in China.)
- remarkEon 6y agoThat isn't really the point, though. The US may have "all of the good minerals", but does it have enough? With the right purity and consistency? In areas where the minerals are extractable without major environmental implications?
- redis_mlc 6y agoYou're sealioning, but yes, I've never heard of the US not having enough mineral deposits for any particular mineral. > In areas where the minerals are extractable without major environmental implications? AFAIK, the US has everything (if not, Canada has it, including uranium and gold), but the eco law issue is definitely the #1 problem today. It's a policy issue, not a technical issue. The US has to be careful that the CCP doesn't "eco law" us when we decide to open mines - they can force shortages by US sponsoring apparent arms-length eco reviews and lawsuits via lobbyists and related law firms. (I read the 2020 smartphone app lawsuits were financed via CCP lobbyists, and the 2021 billion dollar lawsuits from Dominion voting machines were on behalf of the CCP, who apparently owns Dominion.) To follow up on my previous post, tin is actually fairly rare, and valuable for alloys, including bronze. So it's great that the US also has tin (in the ground.) Because of CCP dumping, as seen with rare earths,the only way we'll get back into mining is if the US govt. agrees to cooperative eco policies, and buys mine output for the national reserve. The govt. can just use the price before the mine opens, and pay that for say 10 years, which will circumvent CCP dumping for that mineral.
- wnevets 6y agoand self-proclaimed capitalist love it because "free market" while blaming unions for those items not being manufactured in the US.
- toiletfuneral 6y agoWhy is this being downvoted? Finance capital not wanting to pay “high” union wages is literally the main driver of manufacturing being in China and just in time manufacturing is to keep every possible penny moving. Be as mad you want but I’m not hearing any alternative theory of how we got in this mess.
- roenxi 6y agoIn the US, government spending accounts for ~40% of GDP. It is difficult to say what the ratio is for China because I don't know how to reconcile their state owned businesses with a western public-private model. But Wikipedia's list claims that their direct spending is 24% of GDP [0]. The opinions of free market capitalists aren't in the driver's seat of the US economy. Since the 70s the US has been transitioning to some sort of mixed model. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending
- o_p 6y agoIts almost like China is doing the right things and maybe you need goverment control to protect the nation interests instead of giving control to the magic hand of the free market.
- ojbyrne 6y agoFundamental argument against this: Victory? What exactly is that? Some particular nation state is advantaged over some other nation state. How exactly does that work for the individuals in that country? So many questions…
- foobar1962 6y agoVictory means that in the Race to the Bottom, you look back and see nobody behind you. Now you can stop and start walking backwards, and still be competitive.
- elefanten 6y agoFor a time. Everything affects the global environment, which opens new possibility.
- anoncow 6y agoAn absolute win strategy for the one who employs it (Amazon, countries). It appears to be a lose-lose srategy for everyone else. Is there anyway that Molycorp could have won? Better technology? Is there anything that companies selling stuff on Amazon can do to prevent Amazon Basics from killing them tomorrow?
- WJW 6y agoFor Molycorp: seek to become nationalized either de jure or de facto (by lobbying for massive subsidies or import tariffs). A private enterprise will have a very difficult time against a nation state with effectively unlimited cash and manpower. For the SmallCo vs Amazon example: either superior branding&marketing or protection via patents. If you try to differentiate through pricing, Amazon can sell at a loss for too long for you to survive. But tbh in either case it is like a third world dictator asking "how can I win" when the US is already invading. You can't, the best option now is to cut losses and retreat so you at least stay alive.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoYou know, I would support a law that requires everything on Amazon basic to be entirely vertically integrated in the country that it is being sold in. For example, consumer batteries, where everything is mined and manufactured in the specific country. Because, if it is on Amazon basic, there is no new intellectual property protecting it, so it should be a commodity that is completely optimized. Companies need to move on and make better things, protect them with IP, and then Amazon can’t just copy it and make it a basic object.
- anoncow 6y agoFor the small fry then, the answer is IP.
- roenxi 6y agoI'm standing in opposition without disagreeing - lets just compare this to the US strategy. The US has been pushing all its externalities onto 3rd world countries for decades so it can enjoy a high standard of living while pretending that it doesn't have an environmental cost. China & Africa have endured some very dodgy waterways and extremely questionable air so that America gets iPhones and other electronic gizmos. Several American administrations and a couple of powerful political lobby groups have been everything short of openly hostile to the mining industry. Although the worst of the ire was directed at coal, the thumbscrew tightening approach to regulation affected everyone. China's strategy is to get a lock on rare earth production. The US's strategy has been for someone else to have a lock on rare earth production. The States has not been a prime destination for mining investment in the last 30 years, and their market for consumption hasn't been growing all that much. The only thing in their favour is that with the rule of law the mine probably won't be nationalised. China isn't acting unilaterally here. It is illegal in the US to do what China does to get ahead.
- hliyan 6y agoIs this a consciously executed strategy on the part of the US, or just an emergent outcome of the economic and policy climate? I used to think the US was able to orchestrate such multi-decade strategies, but observing the country during the last few years, I've become skeptical.
- lumost 6y agoArguably the U.S. operates on persistent "consensus" e.g. containment, free-trade, isolationism etc. These aren't so much orchestrated strategies as they are operating principals. The business consensus for the last 3 decades was to outsource the supply chain to the cheapest bidder. That the cheapest bidder had no environmental regulations was an ignored outcome. That the cheapest bidders were all closely related and existed within a new competing network of suppliers was likewise ignored. I suspect the lack of direction that's been apparent for the last ~8 years is partially due to a general view that one or more of free-trade, free-enterprise, environmental protection, or national security/international posture needs to change.
- 6y ago
- Proven 6y ago"China" doesn't achieve anything. The CCP lowers the living standard of both owners and employees forced to work towards its political goals. Considering that the alleged CCP's strategy is well known, foreign buyers can bite the bucket and make long term commitments to alternative (non-China) suppliers. Larger ones could acquire stakes in alternative suppliers.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSmart people in America have known about this for decades, the problem is that politicians benefit financially by doing nothing about this. I don’t see a solution in sight.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> If some other country starts to develop an in-house supply chain for some specific item, exports for that specific item are turned back on and possibly sold at a loss until the threat ceases. Notice that this is not a new thing. It's the classic strategy used by 19th century robber barons before there were antitrust laws. Have a large conglomerate, if anyone tries to compete with you in any industry, use profits from other markets to sell below cost until they go out of business and you have a monopoly again. The question now is how to effectively enforce "antitrust laws" against a government.
- gregable 6y agoTariffs usually