8 ms·
> You could argue that the entire market is a mania. Objectively, the big publicly listed companies are growing and have stellar financials. I can think of no
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
> You could argue that the entire market is a mania.
Objectively, the big publicly listed companies are growing and have stellar financials. I can think of no better place for someone to invest, other than maybe diversifying into real estate with high demand, if they already have a significant amount invested in public equity markets.
Public equity market prices are also backed by the federal government, at least on a 5+ year (maybe even 3+ year) timeframe per events over the last few decades.
- kingsuper20 6y agoIt's worth considering that what you are buying is a dividend stream and/or the possibility of a company being bought, which simply gives you more stock. When you essentially lend money to GOOGL or AMZN, what are you actually getting back besides a story? Don't get me wrong, in the timespan of an individual's life it may well make sense to heavily buy into this system. I'm just making the point that it's current form is rather new and appears loosely connected to the real world and is subject to change. To me, the current stock market seems like a fiat currency without the threat of physical force. Maybe the temptation will be to increasingly merge government with large companies in order to keep the plates spinning.
- JohnPrine 6y agoJust because a company isn't distributing dividends doesn't mean you're only buying a story. AMZN still has lots of room to grow. If I'm an investor in AMZN I would much rather them reinvest profits into a data center that will produce even more future profits than distribute the money to me. Once these growth companies top out in terms of their market share they'll pivot to distributing dividends, same as large established companies like Coca Cola
- ahi 6y agoCocaCola currently has a P/E of 32
- robjan 6y agoYou own the stock in perpetuity, not just for a year. As long as you don't expect the company to go bust any time soon that's not a bad PE ratio.
- ISL 6y agoAs recently as 2011, KO had a P/E of 9. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KO/cocacola/pe-ratio https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/KO/cocacola/pe-rat... There are two ways that a P/E can return to a quasi-normal value. Either the price can go down or the earnings can increase. The mean and median values, since 1880, are about 15. "This time, it's different" https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio
- nostrademons 6y agoSo if earnings increase 3x the P/E goes back down to ~10. KO has excellent margins - last time I looked they were around 60%. That means prices * sales only has to increase by 5x to bump earnings up 3x. Food prices have been inflating at 10-15% recently; 15% inflation over 11 years will get you there, and that doesn't include any growth in sales at all. These aren't unreasonable assumptions, given the macro environment: another 1970s inflationary episode would do it. (Indeed, Warren Buffett made a lot of his money investing in Coca-Cola and See's Candies during the 1970s.)
- kgwgk 6y ago> margins - last time I looked they were around 60%. That means prices * sales only has to increase by 5x to bump earnings up 3x. I am not sure about the logic (are you assuming marging expansion?) but probably you are trying to say something else than revenue has to increse "only" five-fold for earnings to triple. > Food prices have been inflating at 10-15% recently; Sure.
- ISL 6y agoI'm not sure I follow all the arithmetic here (I'm pretty sure that, at fixed margin, revenue would only need to increase by 3x to increase earnings by 3x), but I did follow up to see what Berkshire had paid for Coca-Cola. This thoughtful Quora post claims that Buffett made his first purchase of KO at a P/E of 29. https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-P-E-Buffett-paid-for-Coca-Cola https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-P-E-Buffett-paid-for-Coca...
- kingsuper20 6y agoPersonally, I'm not smart enough to pick individual stocks. At some point (perhaps now) Amazon growth is predicated on cannibalizing other companies. After all, the broad market can't exceed the GDP generally for the long term. My primary point here is not to argue about investment concepts, merely to state a concern about the artificiality of it all. Financialization is real and rather spooky.
- skystarman 6y agoThe thing is there's a FRACTION of a percentage of people who are "good at picking stocks". Most PROFESSIONAL stock pickers don't beat the market. And those that do, a tiny fraction can do it consistently over a 5-10 year time frame. This is backed up by decades of data. But we still have millions of people who apparently think they are smarter than the thousands of professional stock-pickers who have MAs, PhDs and years of experience and do it full-time and still don't beat the market. And sure, many average joes were wildly successful with GME or whatever the latest meme stock is. Just as many people made a ton of money in the last tech bubble. Check back in 5-10 years...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- confidantlake 6y agoExactly. Just like if you get 1000 people in a room, odds are one of them will get a coin toss right 10 times in a row. Doesn't mean that guy is good at predicting coin tosses.
- kaydub 6y agoIt has nothing to do with me thinking I'm smarter than all those guys. The market is irrational. I'm counting on being luckier than those guys more than anything.
- skystarman 6y agoThat's a certainly more rational position than believing your are smarter than the thousands of people with PhDs in finance or CS who pick stocks full time. Any yes, what people on WallStreetBets are doing is gambling. Which is perfectly fine, I just wish more would acknowledge it.
- runako 6y ago> When you essentially lend money to GOOGL or AMZN, what are you actually getting back besides a story Buying a stock is not lending money to a company. It's purchasing an ownership claim on future earnings realized by the company. For AMZN, the expectation of its investors is that it should not realize substantial (relative to revenue) earnings now so that it can grow further and thereby increase the long-tail earnings to which shareholders are entitled. GOOG, on the other hand, is returning money to shareholders now. In fact, they just authorized a program to return another $50B to shareholders. Our tax regime skews payout preferences, so that instead of paying dividends, some companies opt for share buybacks. But the net result is that cash is transferred from the company to its shareholders. You can see GOOGL's buybacks over time here, looks like they returned ~$31 billion to shareholders in 2020: https://ycharts.com/companies/GOOG/stock_buyback https://ycharts.com/companies/GOOG/stock_buyback .
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoWhere does Amazon get all of the stock for employee compensation? Do they just have a large pool of outstanding stock in reserve?
- drewmate 6y agoI'm not sure about Amazon in particular, but generally companies (especially tech companies) hold some percentage of stock in reserve for employee compensation. However, the company can also buy back stock on the open market either to take it out of circulation (and thus increase the value of outstanding shares) or use it for employee compensation. Finally, if the board (as a proxy for individual owners) permits it, a company can issue new shares for any purpose including selling to raise cash for operations, or giving to employees as compensation. This isn't free money, however. New shares tend to dilute the value of existing shares. So owners often prefer to raise money other ways, like debt that doesn't convert to an ownership claim in the way stock does.
- BurningFrog 6y agoI don't know Amazon's specifics, but I believe that's how it's typically done. It doesn't have to be that large a pool as percentage of the company.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoI think a lot of newcomers to stock investing in the past year have been given the wrong ideas about the stock market. When all of the headlines are about GameStop and Nokia and AMC and some kid who made it lost a lot of money on RobinHood, the stock market can feel like a place for gambling. Now that cryptocurrency prices are listed right next to stock prices, many people don’t even understand that stocks are ownership shares in real businesses instead of just another ticker symbol to gamble on. Several times a week there are conversations on HN where commenters can’t understand how crypto currencies are different than stocks or how stocks are any different than gambling or why stocks can have any value without paying dividends. I suspect many of those newcomers will be shaken out of the market during the next protracted drawdown. It’s unfortunate, because they stand to lose a lot over the course of a lifetime of investing.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y ago> the next protracted drawdown We should have seen this drawdown last year.
- thoughtstheseus 6y agoThe longer the bubble builds the bigger the bust. We’ve chosen growth over stability, fundamentals, and robustness. Once the U.S. struggles to stimulate its economy through deficit spending it’ll hit a wall. It’ll be fine for people but there will be a massive dislocation in the economy.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoI understand this. I'd much rather deal with the bad decisions of yesterday today than tomorrow. I guess for people that won't be alive in twenty years this is immaterial..
- willcipriano 6y agoCheck out the ages of elected officials, most are in the "won't be alive in twenty years" camp so the lack of foresight is unsurprising.
- highfrequency 6y agoThere’s a big difference between saying that a company is growing and has stellar financials, and saying that it is a great stock to invest in. Surely the current price is relevant. Everyone can agree that Amazon is worth A Lot Of Money. The question is: is it worth $2T? or $3T? or $1T?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tarsinge 6y agoBut what are you investing in? The probability to sell (dump) <something> to someone in the future for a better price? > Objectively, the big publicly listed companies are growing and have stellar financials. If you don't invest for dividends then it doesn't give intrinsic value to the stock you own, it's just a proxy to the odds of your bet to dump it for a profit in the future.