5 ms·
A big part of their purpose is to short circuit the bureaucracy within a company. Instead of filtering everything though the fiefdom owners, management has hire
by Spooky23 6y ago
A big part of their purpose is to short circuit the bureaucracy within a company. Instead of filtering everything though the fiefdom owners, management has hired guns get shit done.
They hire smart, personable people who can run with whatever. If the numbers or analysis is bullshit, it’s because the org gave them that data.
That said, dealing with the BCGs and McKinseys of the world is a pain in the ass. Once you do it a few times, they are pretty easy to manipulate and manage up.
- pottertheotter 6y agoI think a bigger reason is “nobody ever got fired for hiring McKinsey.”
- killingtime74 6y agoDidn’t that use to say IBM
- p_l 6y agoAnd Cisco, and recently AWS/Azure
- Guthur 6y agoCisco is networking, and aws/azure are cloud services i don't think it's really the same as consulting. The horror story of some consultancy is akin to going to a palm reader. Whereas the example you have is more like going to buy a family car and getting upsold to a Ferrari. There is nothing wrong with the Ferrari you just should have known you only needed the Mazda. You still don't get what you wanted but one is selling you snake oil and the other is just good at sales.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andi999 6y agoUsing webex is hopefully an exception.
- smcl 6y agoOriginally yeah, but in time the saying became generalised for any big established company in a given space.
- Traster 6y agoI think almost the opposite is going on often. What's often happening is you have 1 manager building his fiefdom, and other managers trying to build theirs and there's only so much money to go around and only so many directions a company can go. So manager 1 hires in BCG so that he can use BCG's reputation to get his pet project funded by the executive team. BCG doesn't cut through the bureacracy, it's a tool of the bureaucrat to beat the other bureaucrats- which is why the conclusions match what the manager wants, not what is best. It's about the bureacracy, not about getting anything particular done.
- bsenftner 6y agoThis is the situation. Been there as a developer/MBA consultant.
- kangaroozach 6y agoWell stated.
- Spooky23 6y agoWell, yeah. You can spend 3 years getting a bunch of disinterested people to agree or spend $3M and get it done. The ability to get the $3M is exec endorsement of the alpha bureaucrat.
- thowawaybcg1 6y agoDon't buy this anectode. BCG is too expensive to be hired by managers to convince executives. There are cheaper ways to do that. Most common scenario is that the executives want to prioritize between 100s of managers' pet-projects, then they hire us to swift through. End result is that a company (correctly) focus on a few high impact projects and a bunch of middle managers get hurt because their pet project get underfunded.
- Traster 6y agoYeah I don't mean manager as in "has a team of 5 people" I mean someone responsible for big teams, I'm just using manager as the generic, it could be a "head of" or "General Manager" or "Director" etc. Looking at teams that are a 2%+ of the size of the company.
- GoodJokes 6y agowhich begs the question...why even have a fiefdom. In my experience management brings in consultants to repeat what workers have been telling them for years and then taking the credit.