6 ms·
I think it's time we revisit the commonly applied interpretations of the First and Second Amendments and see of there's a way to better balance exercise of indi
by bitwize 6y ago
I think it's time we revisit the commonly applied interpretations of the First and Second Amendments and see of there's a way to better balance exercise of individual rights against public safety. Perhaps if/when the Supreme Court gets expanded, some less absolutist rulings can be handed down.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoBy "see of there's a way to better balance exercise of individual rights against public safety" you must mean completely gut them.
- amznthrwaway 6y agoIt’s a shame that unhelpful and extremist views such as yours make it a challenge to engage in anything resembling civil discourse in this country. Fortunately for you, this website is moderated by individuals who go to lengths to make far-right extremists feel comfortable and unchallenged; so your account is safe. The fact that your post not only added nothing, accused another user of being dishonest about what they wanted, and made it harder to have further discourse is irrelevant. You’re a while, male, right-wing extremist, so your account is safe.
- chroem- 6y agoHypothetical scenario: Donald Trump's political career miraculously comes back to life in 2024 and he is elected president. He does just as you propose and expands the supreme court with justices of his choosing, and curtails the first and second ammendments. Do you still support these policy changes?
- majormajor 6y agoI might vote for Trump if he promised to fight against the second amendment. Enough lives have been lost because of our desire to potentially be heroes in a hypothetical uprising. The second amendment has been ineffective against so many government abuses to date, and enabled so much citizen violence. Nice idea to try, shame it didn't work, time to fix it. Not so much the first, though...
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoWhy not just live in a state with more strict gun laws and let people of other states live like they want? As someone in the rural US, guns are part of my heritage. Police response times can be 40+ minutes in non-urban areas, and removing legal guns would just make us vulnerable.
- majormajor 6y agoBecause the Republican party and the Supreme Court has been eroding the ability of states to HAVE more strict gun laws? I live in California, why don't the folks who want guns GTFO themselves, instead of trying to change our laws through activist judges?
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoSo we're in agreement that regional cultural differences need to be embraced and allowed in the legal system. Good! Now what do we need to do to make this a reality in our justice system?
- majormajor 6y agoI'm actually NOT convinced that such differences should be allowed, but given that you ARE: you should change the constitution - or the members of the courts interpreting it - to allow my state to restrict guns, because right now the claim is that such a thing violates the second amendment.
- willcipriano 6y agoWhy are you so concerned about how people in other states choose to live?
- majormajor 6y agoGuns don't stay where they start. Hell, it's even an INTERNATIONAL thing - US guns end up enabling violence in Mexico, too!
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> Hypothetical scenario: Donald Trump's political career miraculously comes back to life in 2024 and he is elected president. He does just as you propose and expands the supreme court with justices of his choosing, and... Forget what he does. In this scenario, do you still support expanding the Supreme Court?
- chroem- 6y agoAbsolutely not, and that's the point. People are only considering this right now because it happens to be politically advantageous in the short term. It is incredibly reckless to subvert rights and institutions for political goals like that, and no amount of whataboutism can change that.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoAbsolutely. What it will do is destroy forever the independence of the Supreme Court. That is far to high a price to pay for temporary political advantage, for either side. (Which is not to say that somebody won't try...)
- AndrewUnmuted 6y agoPerhaps we need to lock everybody down and forbid them to leave their own homes, so that we can take stock of the situation and figure out what's going on.
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoEveryone should wear two vests too to stop the spread of bullets.
- haram_masala 6y agoThe First and Second Amendments don’t grant you the right to free speech and to bear arms. Being born a human being is where those rights come from. The amendments simply proscribe the government from infringement upon them. Not a hundred SCOTUS judges, not a thousand, not a million of them will change that.
- exporectomy 6y agoWhat's the general principle you use to determine that a right comes from being born a human?
- bjt2n3904 6y ago"We hold these truths to be self evident..." Either you see them, or you don't. If you don't see them, explaining why is an exercise in futility.
- krapp 6y agoThe Declaration of Independence doesn't claim rights are derived from human nature, but that "certain inalienable rights" are "Endowed by [a] Creator." So I guess that solves it. We can have all the guns we want because God said so.
- rainbowzootsuit 6y agoThe Declaration of Independence isn't part of the U.S. Constitution. The words "god" or "creator" don't appear in the Constitution or Bill of Rights that I'm aware of. It seems quite secular. https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/ https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/
- yeetawayhn 6y agoThe Declaration of Independence is not a legally binding document either.
- seiferteric 6y agoWe have ways of changing the constitution. If there was support for these changes, it could be done, as it is it won't happen because there is not enough support for what you are saying. Any other method of subverting the constitution is wrong would violate the "contract" we have with our government... only bad things can result.
- majormajor 6y agoAnd yet the reason we have the interpretation of the second amendment we have today comes down to a small panel of people ruling at a particular moment in time. Do you think you could pass an amendment expanding the second amendment had the court ruled more narrowly on it? I don't. It's a thin line of interpretation currently, so we shouldn't pretend that there's overwhelming support for the status quo either. The reason these court challenges happen in the first place has been because large groups of Americans have chosen to try to restrict guns. So let's keep having the conversation until we decide to fix the constitution.
- mgarfias 6y agojust how could the court have ruled more narrowly than 5-4? Maybe Thomas only counts as 3/5 of a vote cuz hes black?
- majormajor 6y agoInterpreted the second amendment more narrowly. Think for a second.
- mgarfias 6y agoYeah, I did. A better ruling would have been on P&I grounds, as Gura had asked the court and Thomas concurred. THAT would have nuked the drug war from orbit, along with every other instance of modern federal over reach. As far as I’m concerned the ruling was stupidly ruled, and very carefully crafted to not upset any apple carts. ETA: reread your statement above, it was very easy for me to misconstrue “narrow” as in the vote tally.
- xdennis 6y agoIf the party in power now packs the court, the other party will pack it the other way when it gets in power.
- sigzero 6y agoOne of the many reasons it's a stupid idea.
- majormajor 6y agoThe reasonable end game is probably something like justices with term limits, or a fixed number of appointments per presidential term. We probably will never get there without having to play stupid political games in the meantime, given the state of our political parties.
- Acrobatic_Road 6y agoYou don't understand. The party that packs the court should have enough votes to make sure they never lose power again. If the party in power packs the court, what's going to happen is the other half of the country will just declare the federal government illegitimate and form their own.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoI'm counting at least one Supreme Court justice robbed of the American people. Two more are ... questionable....
- lindy2021 6y agoWhich is why they are pushing to make DC the 51st state in tandem to ensure that doesn't happen. https://www.npr.org/2021/04/22/989119412/house-democrats-pass-bill-to-make-d-c-the-51st-state https://www.npr.org/2021/04/22/989119412/house-democrats-pas...
- majormajor 6y agoYeah, fuck those people, they don't deserve representation cause it would be bad for the Republican Party.
- int_19h 6y agoThe most extensive 2A ruling from the Supreme Court to date is DC v. Heller. The majority opinion has the following bit in it: > Although we do not undertake an exhaustive historical analysis today of the full scope of the Second Amendment, nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms. As well as: > We also recognize another important limitation on the right to keep and carry arms. Miller said, as we have explained, that the sorts of weapons protected were those “in common use at the time.” ... We think that limitation is fairly supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of “dangerous and unusual weapons.” Are you seriously claiming that this is an "absolutist" interpretation?
- culturthrowaway 6y agoRefraining from packing the court is one of the very last truces still in place just barely holding the country together by a thread. I truly wonder what you suppose the marginal odds are that you or someone you love is killed in an event that your proposed action would prevent, vs the marginal odds that you or someone you love is killed as a somewhere-down-the-line butterfly effect of your trying to take that action?