11 ms·
Can there ever be a non-work related conversation between employees that is not a "societal and political discussion"? In the past week I have spoken to coworke
by paxys 6y ago
Can there ever be a non-work related conversation between employees that is not a "societal and political discussion"? In the past week I have spoken to coworkers about high housing costs (bunch of us are testing the market right now), property taxes, EV rebates, weed legalization, homeless/drug use problem on the streets. All of this is apparently a fireable offense at Basecamp?
People are going to say "obviously stuff like this is okay", but to me that's even worse. The company can and will apply arbitrary rules to whatever they think is unacceptable political speech.
And if they do strictly enforce that employees must only ever communicate about work (and the weather or whatever), then that sounds like a very depressing and dystopian workplace.
Is it really that hard to hire adults who can have reasonable adult conversations (with sometimes differing opinions) without it being a "major distraction"? And is the best response to this really to bow down to the loudest voices on either side and shut down conversation for the 99% who are just...normal?
- tshaddox 6y ago> In the past week I have spoken to coworkers about high housing costs (bunch of us are testing the market right now), property taxes, EV rebates, weed legalization, homeless/drug use problem on the streets. All of this is apparently a fireable offense at Basecamp? > People are going to say "obviously stuff like this is okay", but to me that's even worse. The company can and will apply arbitrary rules to whatever they think is unacceptable political speech. From reading this announcement, it seems like they are going with the former. The article specifically mentions "every discussion remotely related to politics, advocacy, or society at large." Of course, it remains to be seen how exactly they apply this rule. The announcement doesn't mention how they will go about enforcing this prohibition, but to me it's very clear that the examples you mentioned obviously fall under this prohibition, as well as many other topics I would expect to be discussed at work, like vacation and holiday policies.
- sktrdie 6y agoYeah. More than questioning the ethical implications of their decision I was simply struct with a... damn that must be a boring place to work at.
- temp8964 6y agoMaybe they want to hire people like to work on the things the company do.
- mikl 6y agoTry reading the OP again. The headline is “No more societal and political discussions on our company Basecamp account.” They’re not saying you can’t chat with your colleagues about politics, they’re just saying it shouldn’t happen in the space everyone has to use for work.
- williamsmj 6y agoThat's a recent edit: https://twitter.com/waxpancake/status/1386810666221150210/ https://twitter.com/waxpancake/status/1386810666221150210/
- nemo44x 6y agoYou can have these conversations but you can’t have them on company property. But if you want to create your own forum with other coworkers then go ahead. So no more using the company Slack for this type of thing. I think people are starting to see how some groups have been undermining and infiltrating every organization they can. It’s literally in their literature to do this. Replicate what they’ve accomplished in universities and journalism - it has spread to tech workplaces, non-profits, and elite private schools. The goal is to politicize everything and then seize power and then pillage for personal gain.
- damagednoob 6y ago> All of this is apparently a fireable offense at Basecamp? I think you're being needlessly hyperbolic but fear not, DHH has you covered: > If you're in doubt as to whether your choice of forum or topic for a discussion is appropriate, please ask before posting. But if you make a mistake, it's not the end of the world. Someone will gently remind you of the etiquette, and we'll move on. This isn't some zero-tolerance, max-consequences new policy. https://world.hey.com/dhh/basecamp-s-new-etiquette-regarding-societal-politics-at-work-b44bef69 https://world.hey.com/dhh/basecamp-s-new-etiquette-regarding...
- meowsnow 6y agoAll of the communications on these channels are typically legally discoverable, so it makes sense you don't want to introduce potential vectors for political discrimination in an increasingly remote world. There are plenty of non political topics to cover...Gardening, pets, clothing, home renovation, local music events and festivals, kids, etc. In all the teams I've been on, political topics never came up. It's okay to find friends outside of work and discuss politics with them; your social network doesn't have to center on the workplace.
- threatofrain 6y agoWhat if you want to discuss gay spousal benefits? Or how medical insurance is going to work for gay couples?
- anm89 6y agoThen read your contract. Discussing these things does not change what the contract you signed says. If you don't like it, renegotiate or leave. If your negotiation is an ultimatum on these points you should probably consider it equivalent to deciding to leave in most cases, but maybe if you have enough leverage you will win.
- katbyte 6y agoexcept if your co-workers never know they they never have a chance to stand up for you and demand change. this is a great way to silence minorities because talking about the challenges they face is now forbidden.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoOne might also consider forming a union with your fellow coworkers, and negotiating with management with said union. As you mentioned, if you have enough leverage, you win. If that's your jam, grab for the crowbar of labor rights. Organizing is federally protected.
- 6y ago
- quotemstr 6y ago> Can there ever be a non-work related conversation between employees that is not a "societal and political discussion"? If you're tendentious enough, you can make anything political. But if you start talking about the post-colonial geopolitical implications of your coworker's son's new chocolate chip cookie recipe, expect everyone to roll their eyes and walk away.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ljm 6y agoAdd small talk, banter, and shooting the shit into that. And, maybe, becoming friends or at least more acquainted. There's a whole breadth of interpersonal communication and humanity that exists outside of the realm of politics, society, and activism. It's self evident, otherwise what do you expect to achieve from talking politics and activism except to be able to talk even more about politics and activism?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SergeAx 6y agoIn the past week I have spoken to coworkers about custom keyboards, sail racing, gym routines and upside of hiring a personal trainer, travel, 3D-printing, I can go on forever. I believe it is fundamentally possible to have an interesting and relaxing conversation with coworkers and not to touch political topics.
- katbyte 6y agoit's all fun and games until you slip and your co worker finds out your gay and their entire tone and demeanor changes and they treat you different but then when you go to your manager "no politics in the workplace". Or your black and find out your co-worker is a member of the KKK and is a well known racist, but no politics at work ok
- exegete 6y agoWhat you described is talking about personal interests and activities, and I agree that is the kind of stuff that is easy and fun to talk (and hear) about with others. I’m starting to think many people don’t have personal activities and interests and don’t know what to fill in small talk with other than what they saw on social media or the news.
- bart_spoon 6y agoOr rather, an increasingly large number of people's personal hobbies essentially consist of reading, tweeting, blogging, and talking about politics.
- tshaddox 6y agoWhat about people whose personal interests and activities directly involve politics? Like people interested in political analysis or reporting, or people interested in competitive policy debate, or even people who actively do advocacy work in their free time? Is small talk about the advocacy work you did over the weekend worse than my small talk about building drones over the weekend?
- throwawayboise 6y ago
- PascLeRasc 6y agoA friend of mine is a software engineer in a conservative industry, and their company brought out the same "no politics at work" last summer. Their benefits package has some language specifically referring to only extending health insurance coverage to hetero spouses, and only permitting time off for a new child if the employee gave birth to it, so nothing for adoptions, fathers, or surrogate births. People have been trying to bring these issues up to HR but they get immediately shut down, "That's politics. Stop trying to force the company to pick a side. Please refer to section 7(a) revision 2 of your employee handbook".
- anm89 6y agoRight, this is how it should be. If that is a deal breaker then find a different employer. Work is not a forum to compete for your personal views. It is a forum to exchange your time for money or equity as per your contract. If you feel it should be different, make sure you are holding enough equity to set the rules or as I mentioned, find a new job that agrees with you.
- katbyte 6y agoso a conservative employer gets to just discriminate against blacks/gays/women/ect and that's ok with you? do you see the problem here when employees can't speak out and are shut down with "no political speech or your fired" "if your not christian you shouldn't work here"
- chii 6y agowell luckily, some particular traits have been made illegal to discriminate against, because in the past, terrible consequences have been had from such discrimination. > blacks/gays/women/ect But this doesnt mean that _every_ trait falls afoul - and if you want your trait to gain the special status of being illegal to discriminate against, this work (aka, activism) should be undertaken with private resources, not the resources of the company for which you are employed. Trying to recruit people into your cause during work hours should also be discouraged - but giving invites to dinners/lunches and having private discussions outside workhours should be allowed.
- stephsmithio 6y agoWhile I hear the, "But anything could be viewed as societal and political discussion", it's kind of a straw man argument. We all know what types of discourse Jason and David are referring to and they augmented their request with, "But if you make a mistake, it's not the end of the world. Someone will gently remind you of the etiquette, and we'll move on. This isn't some zero-tolerance, max-consequences new policy." From my POV, they're taking a difficult stance to rid the workforce of the extreme forms of toxic distraction (which happens across the political spectrum and is pretty recognizable) and for the most part, doing exactly what you articulated: returning to reasonable adult conversations that 99% of people are capable of doing.
- wry_discontent 6y agoDo we all know? I don't. I have no idea. Is it cool for me to talk about housing markets? About markets in the abstract? About marijuana markets despite it being illegal where I live? About policies in other states that differ from mine, like marijuana policies? There's no reasonable line, because unless you're stupid as can be, politics isn't some abstract thing that happens over there; it's a thing that happens everyday in your life. I'm immensely disappointed in DHH for this take.
- educaysean 6y agoWe all know? Good thing you're the self-appointed representative for all of "us". Because I have absolutely no idea where to begin drawing that line.
- Breza 6y agoPlus I doubt anybody will get in trouble for having a lunchtime video chat with a coworker and talking politics.
- mattdeboard 6y agoI actually do not know what types of discourse they're referring to. Can you specify?
- baggy_trough 6y ago
- anm89 6y agoYou are actively misinterpreting what they said. a) They explicitly state that employees are allowed to actively discuss these things, just not in group chat. b) They explicitly state that this isn't "some high consequences zero tolerance policy" and that the consequence for violating the rule will be that you are reminded of the rule. It's sad that this is the top comment.
- paxys 6y agoThe "not in group chat" part was added later after the backlash. The original version of the post said employees can't talk about it, period. And the severity of the punishment isn't what is being debated here, but the fact that there can be punishment at all.
- drusepth 6y agoWithout any insider information, it seems equally as likely that they just better clarified what they originally meant versus backtracking in response to backlash. "Reminding people not to talk about politics and then moving on" doesn't really seem like a "punishment".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- snotrockets 6y agoNo, original post had don't discuss. They backtracked to "not on main", maybe after realizing this could be read as barring protected activities.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bradleyjg 6y ago> Is it really that hard to hire adults who can have reasonable adult conversations (with sometimes differing opinions) without it being a "major distraction"? What do you do when you have someone that sits in a work slack channel all day fiercely debating politics? Counsel him, sure, but then ultimately you’ll need to fire him. Inevitably people will wonder if he was fired because of the positions he took (which everyone is fully aware because he never shut up about them) rather than because he wasn’t doing any work. Modern HR best practices foreclose transparency (“we fired so-and-so because he committed just four lines of code in the last two months”). What’s the best option here?
- paxys 6y agoYou just outlined the solution yourself. If someone isn't doing enough productive work then fire them for that. Whether they were talking about politics or anime doesn't really matter.
- bradleyjg 6y agoBut if he’s the only outspoken Trump supporter or trans-rights activist at the company you are going to spark a lot of rumors and ill will when you fire him. Whereas firing the biggest anime fan isn’t going to garner any notice.
- paxys 6y agoI'm not sure what point you are trying to make. With these new policies in place it's more explicit that you are firing an employee for being a Trump supporter or trans-rights activist.
- detaro 6y agoYou can (publicly) tell people to stop getting into politics debates all the time without banning all mentions of things that touch politics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 6y agoThe post specifically contains "People can take the conversations with willing co-workers to Signal, Whatsapp, or even a personal Basecamp account, but it can't happen where the work happens anymore." That seems entirely reasonable to me.
- StanislavPetrov 6y ago>Can there ever be a non-work related conversation between employees that is not a "societal and political discussion"? I think there are two questions. How much work time is taken up by non-work related conversation, and how much does an employee's non-work related political advocacy disrupt their work and the work of other employees? The unfortunate truth is that many (especially younger people) believe it is not only their right, but their duty, to agitate for the political and social change they believe in, at all times, and, in many fields, this mentality isn't compatible with a functional (much less efficient) work environment.