6 ms·
Taxi medallions are bullshit because they have decided in advance that taxi’s only get to use X amount. The actual free market solution would be per mile tolls
by kortilla 6y ago
Taxi medallions are bullshit because they have decided in advance that taxi’s only get to use X amount.
The actual free market solution would be per mile tolls that increase with congestion and charge regardless of vehicle type.
The last thing you want to do is charge ride sharers and not single commuters, which are much worse.
- wolverine876 6y ago> taxi’s only get to use X amount Right; road capacity is a scarce resource. There isn't an unlimited amount available. > The actual free market solution would be per mile tolls that increase with congestion Sure, modern tech allows more flexible pricing than periodic capacity auctions. However, I wonder if it allows long-term investment, given that tomorrow your capacity could effectively disappear. > and charge regardless of vehicle type That ends up being regressive taxation. Public resources are public goods; they are for everyone, regardless of ability to pay. I absolutely oppose effectively restricting poor people from the roads in parts of the city - and what happens if there is a lot of traffic in their own neighborhood? Can they pull out of their parking spot? > bullshit Well if you put it that way ...
- crowf 6y agoI don't have a car. why should I pay for your right to drive on the roads for free, but yet be forced to pay a tax when I use (semi-)public transportation?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 6y agoFirst, you aren't forced to pay any tax, the ride-sharing company is. Businesses like to say that taxes are passed on to their customers, but that's not actually true (depending on the elasticity of demand). If Uber could increase revenue by charging more to cover some new tax, they'd already have done it to increase their profit. > I don't have a car. why should I pay for your right to drive on the roads for free That's an issue with every public good, from schools to police to public health to courts to real estate records office, etc. None are utilized anything like equally across the population. Yet we chip in and pay for them because we decide, collectively, that they are important for the community. Also, you do use the roads all the time even if you don't drive yourself. Your hair stylist uses them to get to work, your groceries get to the store, your customers come to your store, etc. etc. Imagine your situation if there were no roads. > (semi-)public transportation It's a private, for-profit company.
- crowf 6y ago> First, you aren't forced to pay any tax, the ride-sharing company is. I am forced to pay taxes for the roads since you can't possibly fund all of the rodes solely by taxing ride-sharing companies. > Businesses like to say that taxes are passed on to their customers, but that's not actually true. Eh. Economics is not an exact science so there is no way for me to prove it to you. If you don't believe in that (and have another reason why iPhones are more expensive in higher taxed countries) then let's leave that. > That's an issue with every public good, from schools to police to public health to courts to real estate records office, etc. None are utilized anything like equally across the population. Yet we chip in and pay for them because we decide, collectively, that they are important for the community. Then why not subsidize cars, or better yet, offer a free car per citizen? In fact, "we" decided that we should tax cars and maybe we should also tax car usage (gas, roads, pollution, ...). > Your hair stylist uses them to get to work [...] Imagine your situation if there were no roads. There should be roads. And private drivers shouldn't get out of paying for them. > It's a private, for-profit company. Taxis are private and for profit, yet they are considered public transportation.
- wolverine876 6y ago>> That's an issue with every public good, from schools to police to public health to courts to real estate records office, etc. None are utilized anything like equally across the population. Yet we chip in and pay for them because we decide, collectively, that they are important for the community. > Then why not subsidize cars, or better yet, offer a free car per citizen? In fact, "we" decided that we should tax cars and maybe we should also tax car usage (gas, roads, pollution, ...). OK, why or why not? Are you proposing something? > There should be roads. And private drivers shouldn't get out of paying for them. They do pay, via their taxes, which is the generally appropriate way to fund public goods.
- crowf 6y agoI was responding to your proposal that businesses pay extra, via medallions to use the roads, while private drivers use the road for free (ie. no extra). Rather, I am saying that every user of the road should par for it.
- moron4hire 6y agoWhy should people pay any tax for any public good that they don't use personally? Schools, healthcare, parks & rec, homeless shelters, space exploration, national defense, fire fighters, vaccine development. Because we live in a society.
- luckylion 6y agoPersonal transportation isn't like the things you mentioned. It has -by itself- value to the individual, but not to society. Having no fire fighters quickly becomes an obvious problem. Not having people drive their personal cars all over the city does not.
- moron4hire 6y ago"Value to society" is the summation of "value to individuals". Arguing that people should not have personal transportation is arguing that "we" have the right to dictate people's lifestyles to them.
- luckylion 6y ago> "Value to society" is the summation of "value to individuals". I disagree, not necessarily, and probably not in the case of unnecessary personal transportation (which is most of it). Everyone in society profits from fire fighters or hospitals, even when they don't need either just this instance. That's not the same for some luxury that some/most people enjoy and want everyone to fund. > Arguing that people should not have personal transportation is arguing that "we" have the right to dictate people's lifestyles to them. And we do, and we don't consider that an issue. People shouldn't have personal nuclear bombs, even though some would like to. Also, few people are arguing that personal transportation shouldn't exist, just that the required infrastructure should be funded differently.
- chriswarbo 6y agoYes, in principle. Frustratingly, for a goal like 'moving around cheaply, conveniently and safely, with minimal environmental impact', then subsidising driving is a worse investment than public transport.
- heavyset_go 6y agoYou in particular don't pay for permits, parking, tolls, fuel and sales taxes, licensing, registrations, etc. You do, however, get to enjoy all of the benefits of living in a society with ubiquitous transportation and democratized access to roads and infrastructure.
- woah 6y agoNone of the minor fees you mention gets anywhere near to the cost of road maintenance, not to mention the effects on the health of people near roads, all the people killed in traffic, the environmental damage, etc etc
- sokoloff 6y agoDo you purchase goods which were moved by road? Where does your food come from and how does it get to you? How do you generate your income and does any of that rely on transportation?
- bluGill 6y agoAll of that could be done on gravel roads which are a lot cheaper than paved roads. Or trains once we are beyond the last mile. Paved roads are required when there is a lot of traffic, but all the uses you named are a fraction of road uses.
- Kye 6y agoThis is why diesel has a higher tax.
- oftenwrong 6y agoThis would be a good argument if the road network was sized for transporting goods primarily. As it stands, road networks in population centres are largely sized to accommodate private motoring.
- vineyardmike 6y agoThe company that transports goods should pay for their use of roads. I pay for that through proper pricing of said goods.
- sokoloff 6y agoExactly; if the roads are subsidized (as in GP's concern), then some of that subsidy is showing up as a reduced price of goods.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> That ends up being regressive taxation. Public resources are public goods; they are for everyone, regardless of ability to pay. I absolutely oppose effectively restricting poor people from the roads in parts of the city - and what happens if there is a lot of traffic in their own neighborhood? Can they pull out of their parking spot? There are two separate problems. One is insufficient road capacity at time X for Y number of vehicles of size Z. You can adjust X, Y, or Z, all with the use of variable tolling. Platitudes such as “public resources are public goods; they are for everyone, regardless of ability to pay” will not solve congestion. A second problem might be there are too many people in society too poor to be able to make use of a fair amount of limited resources, such as road capacity. This is a separate problem, and can be solved by giving poorer people money so they can pay to use the roads at peak times.
- wolverine876 6y ago> Platitudes such as “public resources are public goods; they are for everyone, regardless of ability to pay” will not solve congestion. Calling it a platitude doesn't address that critical issue; it does suggest you don't know how else to address it?
- kortilla 6y agoIt’s an issue that exists now. How exactly is it that you think a poor person without a car is able to make use of the interstate?
- parineum 6y agoBy purchasing anything that requires the interstate to move product. So literally everything.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI did offer a solution to address it. It’s a platitude for the purposes of solving congestion, which I specifically identified as a separate issue from poverty.
- kortilla 6y ago> That ends up being regressive taxation. “Regressive taxation” is a term for people paying what something costs. Carbon taxes are also a “regressive taxation” as well as sales tax, alcohol tax, etc. Public resources are public goods, but they are rivalrous. If you don’t make people pay in a fair manner, you’ve just implemented government rations which incentivize all kinds of stupid shit (illegal taxi services for one). > and what happens if there is a lot of traffic in their own neighborhood? If they can’t afford it then they don’t drive. It’s that simple. The complexity only comes from trying to solve poverty (“oh, but that’s regressive”) at the same time as trying to solve a specific issue. Just give poor people cash stipends for transportation if transporting the poor is the problem you want to tackle. Then they can choose if they want to spend it on bus fares or use it towards ride shares, biking, whatever. Prescriptive “there shall be 10 taxis for the people and they will enjoy them and no more” laws have basically never had good outcomes. Hedge funds paying millions of dollars to analysts with mountains of data have difficulty predicting market demand trends, there isn’t a chance in hell some bureaucrat is going to correctly balance a market.
- imtringued 6y agoThis is a common pattern, poorest member M of society Y is not well off enough to do X, the cost of X is lowered for everyone until M can afford X. Except the members of Society Y that do X primarily consists of rich people, it looks fair because everyone is treated equally, in practice the support didn't solve the problem at all, and in the process a bunch of people got a free gift so they don't mind the damage. The reason why politics doesn't work is that people aren't interested in solving the problem, they just want some kickbacks. The end result is a "fair" but dysfunctional society.
- woah 6y agoCar infrastructure is not a public good.
- aaron-santos 6y agoIt's 2021. We should be minting exclusive rights to operate for taxi owners in the form of NFTs.
- moron4hire 6y agoCan't tell if this is sarcasm.
- c22 6y agoIf the person you're "sharing a ride" with is just going to keep driving around after they drop you off it's not entirely clear to me that single commuters are much worse.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- creato 6y agoI think ride "sharers" with a single rider are strictly worse. That driver is going to drive a non-zero amount of miles to pick up his next passenger. Those miles are traffic that wouldn't exist if the two passengers drove themselves. The only thing ride sharing reduces is parking requirements, unless the ride sharing is truly carpooling.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoDynamic tolling is such an obvious solution, easily implemented with license plate scanners.
- smt88 6y agoAs someone who has been working on ways for people to self-report driving habits in a privacy-respecting way: People in the US absolutely loathe the idea of being taxed based on license plate scanners. The combination of automation, surveillance, and taxation is basically toxic across the political spectrum.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoLicense plate scanners exist everywhere on the east coast at all the toll booths, and probably elsewhere too. They probably exist at every toll booth, and who knows where else. I’ve seen cop cars outfitted on all corners with license plate scanners driving around. I even saw parking enforcement cars outfitted with them to track which cars were spending too much time parked in spots with time limits.
- smt88 6y agoI understand that. It doesn't mean people know or think about it on a regular basis, and it's not used to send them bills every month. People are used to surveillance in law enforcement to some extent. Once you tell them it's a tax agency, they lose their minds. I have participated in large-scale, state-funded studies that have shown this.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI see. I found it very convenient to drive in Canada and not worry about having a specific toll system transponder. It seems so archaic. I even got the bill in the mail in the US.
- MagnumOpus 6y agoGasoline taxes at European levels of $4/gallon is a far more obvious (and effective) solution without additional infrastructure costs. Has as little chance as dynamic tolling because there's a loud swing vote who wants their road trips and commutes paid from the public coffers.
- barrkel 6y agoNote that most tolls are regressive taxes. Poor people pay a larger proportion of their income and wealth on such tolls. Also transport costs - or, more specifically, commute times - interact with house prices. Poor people often have to travel longer and further for work, increasing the tax they have to pay even on an absolute basis.
- katbyte 6y agoNot to mention it can cost quite a bit of money to collect these tolls/taxes!
- jackson1442 6y agoIn places like Texas it’s mostly a solved problem, everyone either has a toll transponder on their windshield or uses Pay By Mail, which just reads your plates as you drive through the gate. No stopping, no slowing down at all. You can go through these gates at 120mph and it’ll still catch you (and won’t even write you a speeding ticket). Paying cash isn’t even an option anymore.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt’s solved even better in Canada. All toll plazas are reading license plates, regardless of a transponder. Just send a bill to the owner of the license plate. No need for a transponder.
- kortilla 6y agoThat’s... worse. Why should the person who gets the toll bill be locked to the license plate registration?
- jackson1442 6y agoI think most technically do that here, the transponder is more as a backup. With one exception— the DFW airport will only read NTTA tolltags for some reason last I heard. There’s also some interoperability- my Texas TollTag works in Oklahoma and one or two other states so it’s all consolidated with the lower rate. Those with TollTag accounts pay a lower rate on toll roads as it acts more like a gift card than a bill, it just autoreloads each time your balance gets low. Another cool thing is that some parking garages can read your TollTag if you let them to open the gate for you. It doesn’t bill you, it just acts as an access card if you have a standing agreement with the garage owner (you can see this at UT Austin for permit holders).
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoThe other reason is medallions are very open to corruption - especially in the USA where until relatively recently major cities ran machine systems where spoils where handed out to people on your side.
- imtringued 6y ago>The last thing you want to do is charge ride sharers and not single commuters, which are much worse. Are they? They only drive in one direction park and then drive the same route back. No need to go from customer to customer, no need to "circulate" waiting for a customer. The only miles a commuter drives is the miles he has to drive, not a single mile more. I always thought the "your car is idle 99% of the time" statistics are meaningless, yes it's idle, it's idle exactly where and when I want it, there is zero waste. Of course there are problems with cars, but they also apply to "ridesharing" as well.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>Taxi medallions are bullshit because they have decided in advance that taxi’s only get to use X amount. why is that bullshit, it might create artificial scarcity of taxi services but it helps prevent the kind of congestion that this article discusses.