5 ms·
I'd just point out that this is largely a cultural phenomenon. In some countries it is normal to post everyone's salary (similarly, student grades are posted on
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I'd just point out that this is largely a cultural phenomenon. In some countries it is normal to post everyone's salary (similarly, student grades are posted on the wall after exams).
A lack of transparency really only aids the employer (after all, the employer knows what everyone makes, and with salary comparison services they know exactly how competitive their salaries are).
- lotsofpulp 6y agoPrice transparency is a basic requirement of functioning markets. It’s funny that it’s so taboo in the US, with such a significant voting population espousing pro “free” market, pro business sentiments.
- gigatexal 6y agoYup. By keeping salaries secret it’s how companies create inefficient markets to screw over candidates from making true market rates.
- pottertheotter 6y agoThis bothers me all the time. Several of the assumptions required to have a "free market" aren't met in the United States. If you try to have a conversation around that, you're a "communist", even though you're literally discussing how to have a free market.
- pasabagi 6y agoCommunism is basically orthogonal to the whole free market thing, though. Capitalism is defined as a system in which you can pay somebody a wage that's less than what you get from selling the products of their labour. Other than some basically technocratic stuff (how do you make sure workers are properly compensated) there's no specific communist problem with free markets I can think of. There's also no shortage of capitalist nations that were extremely anti free markets. It's at least somewhat coincidence that communists have typically gone for high state involvement - Russia was, before it was communist, basically an entirely non-free market, and most industry happened at the behest of the Tsarist bureacracy, which was massive. So the USSR was big on state planning kind of as a continuation of that.
- unityByFreedom 6y ago> Price transparency is a basic requirement of functioning markets Is it, and does it apply here? The employee is the seller who would declare the price. Employers are purchasing workers and I don't blame them for not trying to apply prices to products too much. Flipping those roles is like telling customers to name their price when they enter a store. Customers would pay as little as possible, such businesses would fail to keep losses at bay, and other businesses that don't behave this way would survive. The burden is on the employee to name their value, and the business can decide whether or not they want to buy. When employees don't name their value upfront, they're the ones acting like a shady business that wants customers to guess the price, since an unknowledgeable patron is likely to overpay.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Is it, and does it apply here? Yes, price movements are how buyers and sellers in the market know the supply and demand curves are moving. > The employee is the seller who would declare the price. Both buyers and sellers can declare the price they are willing to buy and sell at. But that’s not important, only the price the transaction clears at is important for others to know. > Flipping those roles is like telling customers to name their price when they enter a store. Price transparency has nothing to do with whom puts out the first price in the negotiation. It’s only about knowing what other transactions cleared at so you have an accurate idea of supply and demand. Also, people looking for long term employment is not analogous to purchasing a low cost item in a store. > Customers would pay as little as possible, such businesses would fail to keep losses at bay, and other businesses that don't behave this way would survive. This is not true. Depending on supply and demand, buyers or sellers can have the upper hand in a transaction and who is naming the price first has nothing to do with which price is accepted by both parties, and certainly does not predict what business survives and not. > When employees don't name their value upfront, they're the ones acting like a shady business that wants customers to guess the price, since an unknowledgeable patron is likely to overpay. Bartering on price is not shady business. People do it all the time with large purchases, such as cars, real estate, wages and in poorer countries, even clothing and food. When employees don’t name their value, they’re simply might be doing so because they don’t have the clear upper hand in the negotiation, and are not willing to upset the other party. Or they want to let the other party name their price, and go from there. There’s nothing wrong with various negotiating strategies. What is clear, is that 90% of people have very little information of supply and demand for the labor market compared to employers, so they obviously are at a disadvantage. The solution is websites like levels.fyi, that even the playing field so employees know how the supply and demand curves are actually moving.
- stevewodil 6y agoYou can just ignore the question and answer "I'd be looking for a TC of x". See what they say. Make sure to add 20% to the TC because they didn't answer the question
- pmichaud 6y agoI see this sentiment a lot, but it seems blatantly false. This assumes that employees are a fungible commodity whose price should be set by some efficient market rate, but that's not true at all. Under the current regime, the setup helps top performers be compensated more highly, without torpedoing morale. You can fantasize about a world in which the salaries are transparent and everyone has frank conversations like "Yes Jill makes 50% more than you even though you're nominally at the same level. Her compensation reflects her superior contributions to the company." But that's just not how it is.
- shawabawa3 6y agoAt my previous job the most highly paid developer used to regularly say at standups "yesterday I did nothing, today I will do nothing". However he was confident at good at negotiating
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoWas he actually doing nothing?
- pmichaud 6y agoI think your point is that not everyone who gets paid a lot deserves it on merits? I agree with that. Still, do you think that compensation and merit are correlated? I do.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoIt's weird that you call this "blatantly false" and talk about "the current regime", but my whole point is this "regime" only exists, culturally, in a relatively small subset of countries. I don't need to "fantasize" about how this would work because many other countries are already completely transparent about salaries. Not to mention that even in the US there are some locales that post everyone's salaries in government jobs, from the mayor down to the teaching assistant at the local university. Also, FWIW, Joel Spolsky pretty famously detailed his company's transparent compensation plan, which took into account both experience and unique skill set. https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/08/30/fog-creek-compensation/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/08/30/fog-creek-compensa...