6 ms·
Oklahoma woman charged with felony for not returning VHS tape 21 years ago
- fortran77 6y agoMcBride said over the last 20 years, she's been let go from several jobs without being given a reason why. She told FOX 25, now, it all makes sense. "This is why... because when they ran my criminal background check, all they're seeing is those two words: felony embezzlement," McBride said. If she can prove that, I'm wondering if anyone can be held liable for damages?
- jakelazaroff 6y agoWhat damages? Most employment in the US is at will. You can be fired without notice for almost any reason.
- smileysteve 6y agoDiscrimination of criminal record is covered under eeoc title 7. She can only be fired for any reason as long as there is no memo or background check paper trail that a criminal history is the reason; or notified if criminal history was the reason and it was a reasonable business risk (which felony embezzlement qualifies for) for the employer
- jakelazaroff 6y agoThat is incorrect: > The EEOC enforces Title VII, which prohibits employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. Having a criminal record is not listed as a protected basis in Title VII. Therefore, whether a covered employer's reliance on a criminal record to deny employment violates Title VII depends on whether it is part of a claim of employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/enforcement-guidance-consideration-arrest-and-conviction-records-employment-decisions http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/enforcement-guidance-consi...
- atemerev 6y agoNope. This is how the system works.
- newacct583 6y agoFor what? It's a real charge, legally on her record and correctly reported. Now, is it a just charge? Almost certainly not. But that's a question that courts have to answer, it's what they're for.
- mindslight 6y agoIt's not a legitimate charge - she was never served notice, and so was never able to answer it. That the state didn't pursue it any further for twenty years demonstrates that they didn't consider it a real thing either.
- rovr138 6y agoShe hasn’t proven it’s not true. She could possibly go after the person she was dating and, if she had evidence he did it without her knowing, she could maybe sue him for lost wages.
- hirundo 6y agoThe DA is responsible, and they have absolute immunity. https://www.nlg-npap.org/absolute-immunity/ https://www.nlg-npap.org/absolute-immunity/
- dataflow 6y agoQuick summary on the ruling: https://www.oyez.org/cases/1975/74-5435 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1975/74-5435
- fortran77 6y agoWell, I asked if _anybody_ had liability. Like the store that (perhaps) filed the charges without determining for sure if she had rented that title and/or was given the opportunity listed in their (presumed) terms to replace it. I know the business is no longer in existence, but did a business file the criminal complaint, or did a person?
- Ariarule 6y agoI'm surprised no one else in response has brought up notification requirements for background checks: "...if the employer thinks it might not hire or retain you because of something in the report, it must give you a copy of the report and a 'notice of rights' that tells you how to contact the company that made the report." -- https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/background-checks-what-job-applicants-and-employees-should-know https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/background-checks-what-jo...
- spoonjim 6y agoDon’t do the crime if you can’t do the time.
- stemlord 6y agoLol. Apparently she's not even the one who rented it
- jhgb 6y agoDon't do the comment if you can't think for a moment.
- astrea 6y agoI'm sure that rental store was really feeling the pain from a single un-returned copy of Sabrina the Teenage Witch. God forbid your mind ever slip.
- tomhoward 6y agoIn their defence, if there was no possibility of serious consequences, people would have kept tapes all the time and the store would've gone bust well before the internet killed them. The real issue here is that she apparently didn't even make the rental herself or know it was being done in her name, and that the store or the authorities didn't bring it to her attention and allow her to sort it out at the time.
- totalZero 6y agoThe real issue, in my mind, is that she had an outstanding charge for felony embezzlement that was reported in background checks but never scheduled for a court date. The government basically hamstrung her economic marketability for 22 years without giving her so much as a summons and a chance to clear her name in court.
- tomhoward 6y agoYep, as I wrote: "... and that the store or the authorities didn't bring it to her attention and allow her to sort it out at the time".
- atemerev 6y agoI have ADHD, and forgetting such things is quite common for me. I read these stories with horror.
- ed25519FUUU 6y ago> McBride said over the last 20 years, she's been let go from several jobs without being given a reason why. She told FOX 25, now, it all makes sense. > On Wednesday, the DA's office said after reviewing McBride's case, they've decided to dismiss it. I’m surprises the DA doesn’t regularly review these cases. The shop closed in 2008. Even if they wanted to pursue it, wouldn’t it be beyond the statute of limitations? Yet it haunted her for decades. What a sham.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Even if they wanted to pursue it, wouldn’t it be beyond the statute of limitations? Probably not, because the charges were filed timely in March of 2000 and an arrest warrant issued. She may have legally been a fugitive from justice until the DA dismissed the charges, which would toll the statute of limitations.
- kodah 6y ago> On Wednesday, the DA's office said after reviewing McBride's case, they've decided to dismiss it. I feel like she's owed damages, not just dismissal. What motivates a DA to charge someone with a felony over a VHS tape? A similar situation is when DAs stack on extra charges for a crime. The addon charges almost never make sense to the actual crime too, it always reads more like a gotcha. It turns what should be a Class C misdemeanor into a Class A, extraordinary fines, and jail time.
- xvector 6y agoStories like this are infuriating. DA should be required to pay for 20 years of lost invested wages and missed career progression opportunities, alongside a hefty premium for the emotional distress caused by this issue. The lack of accountability of public offices towards citizens is problematic. I think is a general apathy in government jobs. It doesn’t matter how incompetent you are, and how many people you hurt - you’ll never go “out of business,” tax payers will pay for your mistakes, and you won’t be held responsible for the impact of your actions. So why even try? There ought to be some feedback loop that forces the public sector to improve itself.
- bluejekyll 6y ago“There ought to be some feedback loop that forces the public sector to improve itself.” There is. We live in a democracy. Work to elect better and more accountable officials. If none exist, consider running yourself.
- itake 6y ago> If none exist, consider running yourself. Setting expectations of "don't like it? Well quit your job, give up 12 mo of your life to campaign and fix it yourself!" is not healthy for our society.
- optimiz3 6y agoThe recursion in how one would effect change like this amuses me. But this is by design since policy affects all.
- henvic 6y agoThis is one of the most awful things of the current state justice systems around the world: persecution of victimless and minor crimes. In the came of victimless crimes, well, just get rid of it! In the case of minor crimes, reparation should be a priority, instead of punishing the actors. It's even better not to persecute than waste a lot of resources in a case (what would be completely inadmissible if we were talking about private justice).
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoDo you honestly think this will ever lead to a prosecution with significant jail time rather than the news being spectacular as always? The worst that will happen in this case is the lawyers coming to an agreement that the suspect will pay the late fee and the case be dropped as the defence can surely convince the prosecution that wasting money of this is in no one's interest. As for victim-less crimes, they exist because despite most people chanting that they do not want them, they in fact do want them, but simply are convinced there is an actual victim in the cases where they want them.
- dls2016 6y agoYou have a collect call from Rikers Island, do you accept the charges? Edit: the "joke" is the number of people (notoriously) held in Rikers island for ridiculous "crimes". https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/06/before-the-law https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/06/before-the-law
- lolinder 6y agoRead the article. This woman says that she was dismissed from multiple jobs over the last 20 years without explanation. Her charge was felony embezzlement, so I don't blame the employers for being freaked out when they saw it. It's on the DA for filing this charge for something so stupid. She doesn't have to be prosecuted to be persecuted.
- gambiting 6y ago>>This woman says that she was dismissed from multiple jobs over the last 20 years without explanation. Surely.....even such a barbaric country as United States has at least some absolute minimum of protection against unfair dismissal? The whole at will employment alone is insane, but even with it, surely she could sue for unfair dismissal if she wasn't told why she's being let go?
- colour 6y agoRather sad all of her prior employers are without any regard to humans.
- lolinder 6y agoThe charge on her record was felony embezzlement, which would totally freak me out if I saw it on a background check for an employee. Yes, maybe they could have asked her about it, but from a legal perspective it's safer for them to just dismiss her without explanation. That's not their fault, that's the way that the system is set up.
- smileysteve 6y agoIt is their fault if they don't notify the candidate as to why she was terminated. Eeoc title 7
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gravypod 6y agoA very worrying component of this: are they dropping the charges because they see this is ridiculous or because it's gotten media attention?
- amelius 6y agoDon't we have judges to simply dismiss absurd cases like this?
- jonnycomputer 6y agothe answer is, unfortunately, obvious. though, it could also be the case that prosecutors need an excuse to drop cases like this, and negative coverage in the media is a good one.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> though, it could also be the case that prosecutors need an excuse to drop cases like this I don’t see why they would need an excuse. They have wide latitude on prosecutorial discretion: https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/prosecutorial-discretion-leeway-prosecutors-decisions-criminal-charges.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/prosecutorial-discre...
- jonnycomputer 6y agoUnderstood. However, that was not what I meant. What I was thinking was in terms of the culture and how decisions like this might look to peers, supervisors, etc. I might guess that going easy on people might be looked down upon, and that the usual fear is being blamed for the person that could have been prosecuted, but wasn't, and then did something bad. "lenient prosecutors" vs "tough prosecutors"
- lotsofpulp 6y agoOh, yes, that’s a good point!
- 6y ago
- gcatalfamo 6y agoNo one is commenting about the “processing” cookie opt-out of this website?
- tims33 6y agoThe thing I don’t understand is why she was never formally charged. How do they go 20 years and never let her know in any way she’s charged with a felony. I could understand if it was a parking ticket, but not a felony.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI don’t understand how it’s showing up on her background checks if they are just charges. > Blau told FOX 25 Thursday that McBride will need to get her case expunged in order to clear her record moving forward. Why would her record even need clearing if she was not convicted of anything.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Why would her record even need clearing if she was not convicted of anything. Charges and arrests are recorded even without convictions, and are public records. They aren’t legally punishments (though people may make adverse decisions based on them) so they neither require conviction nor automatically disappear without one.
- tims33 6y agoInteresting. That seems like a flaw in background checks. I could imagine it being useful if someone was charged a few months ago and awaiting trial, but in this case it certainly seems unfair.
- smileysteve 6y agoShe has an eeoc title 7 case unless her employers (that terminated her because of a record of charges) can say that they feared the charges directly impacted her possibilty of doing the job.
- dragonwriter 6y agoBeing a current fugitive on a felony charge creates reasonable fear of direct impact on the possibility of doing any job, so that’s a pretty easy bar for the potential defendants. Now that its a record of charges that have bee dismissed it would be a different story with future potential employers, of course.
- sio8ohPi 6y agoReminds me of Computers Don't Argue. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computers_Don%27t_Argue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computers_Don%27t_Argue
- kstenerud 6y agoWow... That TrustArc cookie preferences thing on their site sure is a piece of work. It takes 30+ seconds to completely load such that you can alter the preferences (or you can click allow all immediately), and then after you change it to turn off advertizing cookies, it goes through a slow percentage calculation. I gave up after 3 minutes, when it was at 64%. It's quite obviously delaying as a dark pattern to make you give up and allow everything, but I wonder how legal that is? Update: I left it running to see what would happen. Once the artificial delay completes, you're presented with an ominous warning: "This page transmits information using https protocol. Some vendors cannot receive opt-out requests via https protocols so the processing of your opt-out request is incomplete. To complete the opt-out process, please click here to resubmit your preferences." Clicking on that link brings you to another page on their site that basically does the same thing, except with the following warning: "Some opt-outs may fail due to your browsers cookies settings. If you would like to set opt-out preferences using this tool you must allow third party cookies in your browser settings."" All preferences are of course set to "Yes". Changing them to "no" and submitting again does the same artificial delay with percentage that slows down the closer it gets to 100% (and then sticks at 100% for good measure). After this 5 minute process, it finally says my preferences have been saved, but with all these caveats, I wouldn't be surprised if it's tracking me anyway, using those warnings about browser settings as a fig leaf to hide behind.
- cabaalis 6y agoHow was this allowed to go for 20 years without her knowing or facing the charges? What options does she have? Hasnt she been deprived of a right to speedy trial, leaving a lifetime of troubles for lost wages?
- dagaci 6y agoThis is a reminder to put doing a background check on yourself firmly into your own calendar. You can't sit back passively and hope for the best.
- gumby 6y agoThis highlights one of the hazards of a highly-automated future. A reason to put judges, purses, and other humans into the mix is to look for injustices and give people the right to make ad hoc exceptions. If a mechanical process were to, say, photograph you at a red light camera, ticket you, and perhaps automatically take the funds from your account you might have no recourse. And once we have such a can imagine worse with opaque ML models and few to no humans in the loop. Of course the system we have is also ripe for abuse, and can be unthinkingly rigid as well (think of “Brazil”). But better than full automation.
- smileysteve 6y agoTo disagree; this highlights that manual systems are flawed, have inappropriate priorities - or at best have inappropriate resources in the process things manually. Imagine, if instead of a prosecutor adding this to a record, a computer did it and the prosecutor's office could spend time reviewing outstanding non violent charges.
- gumby 6y agoStill human-in-the-loop which I think is crucial. I was highlighting he drive to fully automated systems, as is increasingly the case in the private sector (due to sheer volume if nothing else).
- mshroyer 6y agoI agree we need humans in the loop for things like the administration of justice. But this is a case where humans _were_ in the loop yet acted like automatons themselves. They failed to apply the baseline level of judgment that would have stopped them filing felony charges for "embezzlement" of a VHS tape featuring a talking cat.
- grishka 6y agoThis exact thing is already happening with internet corporations. Google and Facebook can literally take away most of your digital life for you doing nothing wrong, and you'll have no recourse to get it back. You'll be hitting a wall of faceless automated replies saying that "your account will not be reinstated at this time and this decision is final".
- alex_young 6y agoThe real story here is the countless number of times this woman and millions of others have been discriminated against in employment, education, finance, housing and other areas, without any notice, for the mere suggestion of some long past wrongdoing. Wouldn’t a modern democracy, as we hold ourselves up to be, disallow the unfettered snooping into of ones past for most employment, housing, etc?
- keeglin 6y agoI would think, more importantly, how many more people were charged for felony embezzlement for failing to return a video rental in Norman, Oklahoma, 20 years ago without their awareness? What motivated that chain of events? This whole story needs some gravity, and more than what the local news station is giving it.
- tyingq 6y agoMcBride said over the last 20 years, she's been let go from several jobs without being given a reason why. She told FOX 25, now, it all makes sense. "This is why... because when they ran my criminal background check, all they're seeing is those two words: felony embezzlement," McBride said. Someone shared with me how they deal with this in Australia, and I wish they did that here in the US. Employers can't just run background checks and interpret the data any way they want. You send the job description to the police, and they run the background check and just return the employer a "yes/no" as to whether the person is okay for the job description, based on the specifics of the job and the background. Edit: Yes, there are concerns about doing this in the US. I thought it was worth sharing anyway, as there are probably changes you could make to get the "good" part of this working here.
- haswell 6y agoWhile this is interesting, it seems really problematic that the police have the power to say “yes/no”. I guess this is a matter of trust, and and given the...issues...with US law enforcement, it’s hard to imagine them getting this right. The general concept is interesting, though.
- tyingq 6y agoTrue, though it would probably make it easier to centralize some policy, like "convictions only, not arrest data".
- Jeff_Brown 6y agoCould it be handed to someone more impartial than the police and with more time to spare than a judge? A social worker, maybe?
- brianwawok 6y agoSo what happens if you have an abusive ex who works at the police? You can’t get a job anymore? Seems worse to put so much power in someone else.
- 6y ago
- MikeUt 6y agoHow often does the reverse happen? How often are ISP executives charged with felonies for hiding fees, misleading consumers, or charging for routers they never delivered? No, not consumers, consumer, singular, because it was one VHS tape, not thousands or millions affected.
- g8oz 6y ago"McBride said over the last 20 years, she's been let go from several jobs without being given a reason why. She told FOX 25, now, it all makes sense." These criminal background checks are out of control. There has to be a smarter way of doing things.
- freesports 6y agohttps://www.paccp.ca/advert/fight-liveufc-261-livestream-on-ppv/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/fight-liveufc-261-livestream-on-... https://www.paccp.ca/advert/ppvlivestreamufc-261-live-free-on-fox/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/ppvlivestreamufc-261-live-free-o... https://www.paccp.ca/advert/ppv-ufc-261masvidal-vs-usman-live-stream/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/ppv-ufc-261masvidal-vs-usman-liv... https://www.paccp.ca/advert/liveufc-2612021-livestream/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/liveufc-2612021-livestream/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/watchufc-261-live-stream/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/watchufc-261-live-stream/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/fightufc-261-live-stream-reddit-free/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/fightufc-261-live-stream-reddit-... https://www.paccp.ca/advert/liveufc-261-live-stream-free-2021/ https://www.paccp.ca/advert/liveufc-261-live-stream-free-202...
- johnohara 6y agoProbably a bench warrant gone rogue over time. Surprised it didn't make its way into the NCIS system, ending up as a felony arrest related to a simple traffic stop. Dispatchers and police don't have full access to the details of the warrant either. They see "felony" and immediately change the interaction protocol, as we have seen too often the past few years. Ms. McBride will probably spend another ten years doing the "expunge" dance as well. Lazy, unaccountable, and inexcusable.
- LinuxBender 6y agoIs it no longer the case that non violent crimes have a statue of limitations?