11 ms·
Accused money launderers left a path of bankrupt factories
- bluetomcat 6y agoThis is not an isolated case in the post-soviet space. The general pattern is - squeeze lots of money domestically via your privileged position of operating whole key sectors of the national economy and spend them comfortably abroad. Everything from banks through insurance companies through delivery companies to media groups is owned by people formerly involved with state security. It's an exclusive social network in which political decisions and private economic interests are tightly coordinated. The worrying thing is that the West gave international legitimacy to these wealthy elites, while only pointing fingers at the endemic corruption in their countries.
- pinkybanana 6y ago> The worrying thing is that the West gave international legitimacy to these wealthy elites, while only pointing fingers at the endemic corruption in their countries. Wouldn't it be quite difficult to prevent foreign money being laundered in some other country? I would guess verifying whether the money is legit coming from some weird foreign jurisdictions is probably quite difficult. The only way to work around that would probably reject all customers who are sending money from there.
- bluetomcat 6y agoThose oligarchs are a tiny minority of the country population and their international financial endeavours are almost always tracked by Western intelligence agencies, but the pragmatic interest of the West is to welcome that money. They buy the most expensive real estate in London without even negotiating, send their kids to elite schools, buy their wifes jewellery at outrageous prices.
- kjrose 6y agoThis. And the problem I've found is whenever anyone gets to a position that could legitimately deal with this issue, they become either compromised or they become involved themselves in the situation. Basically there's another very rich black market that won't be stopped easily.
- hourislate 6y ago>And the problem I've found is whenever anyone gets to a position that could legitimately deal with this issue, they become either compromised or they become involved themselves In Post Soviet Countries challenging the Oligarchs is like asking for a death sentence. What is required is a Western effort to go after these Crooks helping the elected Government to implement a system that can be trusted.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoNo western country would do anything that helps solving the problem because they benefit from the situation.
- stevespang 6y agoAll this is nothing compared to the Mexican drug cartels, need much more press coverage on them . . .
- imagica 6y agoAll what it takes is to digitize the whole infrastructure and make transparent all the public spending with details of details of the details all the way down to where the money currently is, all that is including large loans. Public spending? No privacy whatsoever, no hidden transactions nor business trading behind curtains. Oligarchs buy popular support as well, they own televisions themselves to manipulate local politics, but with detailed accounting all that could potentially be stopped. Of course the efforts to implement these would be gargantuan because they would fight back.
- jszymborski 6y agoI don't think the problem is that people don't know _who_ the problem is.
- vkou 6y ago
- murkt 6y ago> Everything from banks through insurance companies through delivery companies to media groups is owned by people formerly involved with state security. Not the case with Kolomoisky, who was not involved with state security. Generally, Ukrainian oligarchs do not come from state security background.
- kgeist 6y agoRussian oligarchs generally don't come from state security background either. I don't where the OP got that from.
- avrionov 6y agoIt seems that he was referring to the Bulgarian oligarchs. Some of the early ones were part of the security services or were married to a family members who were involved in security. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilia_Pavlov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilia_Pavlov
- bitL 6y agoWasn't Kolomoisky one of the oligarchs that backed the overthrow of the previous pro-Russian government as well as financed the current president of Ukraine? I am wondering what went wrong for him with the US, was it just Trump in power instead of a more friendly politician?
- crusty 6y agoIt seems like this scheme was unraveling before Trump came into office. If it hadn't been, Trump may have proved to be good for him, in driving renewed optimism for domestic steel production and simultaneously stripping regulatory bodies like the EPA of oversight and enforcement capacity. That this scheme was even considered seems like a more general enddictment of the history of US corporate and industrial regulatory oversight... Just put it on the wall next to the SEC and Wall Street, with highlights on Bernie Madoff and the subprime mortgage crisis.
- bluetomcat 6y ago
- baybal2 6y ago> The worrying thing is that the West gave international legitimacy to these wealthy elites, while only pointing fingers at the endemic corruption in their countries. The whole Western commitment to anticorruption is on display on Mayfair street in London.
- ttul 6y agoOh, you mean the part of town where an apartment is so expensive that it is out of reach even to London bankers?
- nick_kline 6y agoCan give some more context about this situation? A web search didn't find the obvious answer, other than it was an expensive area.
- baybal2 6y agoIt's like a half of Russian mafia owns mansions there, right in the open, laughing in the face of UK courts, and its money laundering laws.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xnyan 6y ago>an expensive area This is a bit of an understatement. If Mayfair is not the most expensive neighborhood in the world, it's close. A large number of the residents of Mayfair are former soviet state security who became oligarchs with the money to live there by pillaging their country then funneling that cash to the west with the aid of western banks including British banks.
- jollybean 6y agoIt's not just 'post Soviet' it's also 'current Rest of World'. Business outside of 'established rich places' may often include huge sums for bribery and that money comes back in many ways, including 'very expensive real estate in NY / London' etc. and Dubai is becoming a major centre of such activity. [1] The question is, how long can Dubai balance it's claims to legitimacy and integrity, while at the same time looking the other way? Will nascent powers like India and China even care? It's going to be an interesting next 50 years. [1] https://www.transparency.org/en/news/the-united-arab-emirates-a-key-piece-in-the-global-money-laundering-puzzle https://www.transparency.org/en/news/the-united-arab-emirate...
- nradov 6y agoThat's not so different from how the European noble families established their privileged positions centuries ago. It's just that they were military leaders rather than state security officers.
- dv_dt 6y agoThe West gave legitimacy to this because it's own elites do the same thing with monopoly enterprises. Microsoft did it with OSs, Google with search, Telecoms expanding from wired phones, to wireless, now to entertainment media ownership, etc... Though perhaps the private equity companies come closest to the methods of operation described in the article.
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>Everything from banks through insurance companies through delivery companies to media groups is owned by people formerly involved with state security. Carry over from the massive corruption created from handing control over the entire population to the state bureaucracy, in the name of creating a non-exploitive communist economy.
- cs702 6y agoGreatly informative piece about shady characters laundering money in the US at a pretty large scale by investing in, or outright buying, struggling US businesses such as steel mills. Managers and employees think they're getting a lifeline. In reality they're getting a new owner who cares very little about the long-term health of the operation and the safety and well-being of its employees. The new owner will use financial engineering to extract as much cash as possible while cutting capital expenditures as much as possible. Eventually, the business will have no choice but to file for bankruptcy. Along the way, all cash paid out of the business will have been legitimized. Employees and towns suffer the consequences. Ugly and sad.
- pinkybanana 6y agoI would guess that if you are laundering money, launderer would happily spend extra money on safety and other issues to prevent getting too much attention. Here the case sounds like if the laundering oligarch hadn't been stingy on those things he wouldn't have gotten caught.
- dazc 6y agoMaybe this is happening already and we don't know because some other oligarch is not being stingy? Welcome to London.
- vmception 6y agoof course it is happening people think “money laundering” is hard or impossible and will point to articles like this one as “see they got caught” it is completely unfalsifiable when the reality is that money is fungible and it is a complete waste of resources to try to enforce a whitelist it isn't necessary to have no evidence of the money, but that is also possible too but wasnt necessary here or in most areas of reintegration the whole economy has practically no separation from licit and illicit sources and they routinely traverse back and forth
- intricatedetail 6y ago
- alfl 6y agoCanada has a huge money laundering problem (source: my company makes anti money laundering tech). Interesting how the article shows how this translates to destruction of capital assets and, eventually, people. That’s not necessarily clear otherwise.
- spurdoman77 6y agoProbably all wealthy countries are big destinations for dirty money. Wouldnt make sense to bring dirty money to poor country because there it would attract more attention.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoI don't know about Canadian laws, but in the United States we let foreigners buy real estate with a phone call, or email. So basically we let foreigners buy our land. They can't live in the house/building, but they control the people whom do. We make it difficult for hard working Americans to buy a home, but let foreigners scoop it up with funny money? This has bothered me for years. Especially when it's not easy for Americans to buy foreign land. (Supposedly the government asks about the origin of the wealth before the sale now, but in my county (Marin County) it looks fishy. I have neighbors who don't speak a lick of english, but are living in mansions. My gripe isn't cultural. I just have doubts on the origin of the cash they buy houses/land/buildings with.)
- hippich 6y agoIsn't there like 30% immediate tax that is required to be withheld by the agent and then later buyer is responsible to file a return to attempt to get that money back? I am sure some do, but for the rest - it looks like it is a price paid to the USA for the privilege of owning real estate there.
- Scoundreller 6y agoLocal LLC owned by an offshore corp. Buy/sell the offshore corp, ergo no change in an US ownerships and poof, no withholdings. Actually, I think you can skip the LLC part. That becomes an issue if you want to later sell to a local, but if it's unaffordable to locals, who cares. Might be a non-issue if there's a tax-treaty reduction on withholding if the US was dumb enough to sign one with a tax haven (Canada does with Barbados and Bermuda) and you form the corp there. Not a lawyer/US resident/citizen.
- raincom 6y agoThe scheme Ihor Kolomoisky perpetrated is very popular in the third world countries. In India, for instance, many politicians and industrialists take loans worth hundreds of millions of dollars from the public banks for their supposed projects, then funnel the loan funds to their personal coffers. Years down the line, these public banks add these unpaid loans as "non performing assets". The same public banks are very reluctant to lend money to the average guy.
- marcinzm 6y agoThose probably aren't loans, they're semi-hidden bribes.
- skybrian 6y agoIt sounds more like a scheme to defraud banks. An actual business with a factory is going to look like pretty good collateral to a bank making a loan, but the bank loses money on the loan when the company goes bankrupt. It’s not in the bank’s interest to do this. But bank employees could’ve been bribed, sure. So this sounds like a form of “long firm fraud” or maybe “control fraud.” For more about it, I recommend reading Lying for Money: How Legendary Frauds Reveal the Workings of Our World. (Not that I’m an expert; I just read a book.)
- gruez 6y agoI think gp's saying that the banks are in on it. ie. they knew in advance that the loan was going to go bad, but that was fine to them because they saw as a price of gaining favor (bribe).
- skybrian 6y agoIf the money comes from the bank, it's hard to see how the bank (as a company) benefits from it. Maybe by selling the loan?
- 6y ago
- pupdogg 6y agoGreat read! Aside from software development, I run a metal fabrication shop where we purchase and process approx. 20k lbs of steel and aluminum (monthly). Having been in the industry for the past 10 years, I’ve always referred to all metal suppliers as folks that deal with “funny money”. There’s no transparency in pricing whatsoever. You can’t easily lookup or guesstimate metals prices without having core subject matter expertise that come with experience. It might as well be called an undercover hedge fund market with killer profits!
- zafka 6y agoAre you getting better prices on feedstock as automobile production slows?
- selimthegrim 6y agoMatt Levine's jokes about the aluminum merry-go-round suddenly acquire another dimension.
- 55555 6y agoIsn't the markup for a certain product basically it's weight times the spot market price of the metal with an added constant markup depending on how much more complex it is than a lump of ore? I have no idea what I'm talking about but am interested.. Please elaborate!
- dwater 6y agoThe metal market I go to generally uses prices per pound for the basic shapes of different metal types, and the system lists pounds per piece. But this information isn’t readily available, it’s only after your purchase when you get an invoice that you can see what the cost is. Otherwise you have to stand at the counter and ask how much each different piece is.
- lazide 6y agoAdditionally, there is the additional dimensions of grade/composition of metal, heat treating (and heat treatability), dimensional stability/accuracy, and finish (pickled? Oiled? Mill finish?). And that’s just for ferrous. Non-ferrous is even weirder in many ways.
- bullen 6y agoIs it only me or is Cyprus and Ukraine in the wrong spot on the map about a quarter down? Nitpicking but Cyprus is not in China and Ukraine is not Mongolia.
- atdrummond 6y agoCan you share a picture? The map is fine on mine.
- bullen 6y agoOk, that explains it... I'm on 5:4 screen... they made it for widescreen! :D
- rory 6y agoI see an animation where they start in the right place, but then the focus countries zoom in, while the world map remains the same, putting them in Asia. The should probably have faded out the world map when zooming in.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway98797 6y agoThis is hard to follow. Were the factories profitable? If not seems like the money benifited the employees. Looks like the front line employees got hurt and the community but every other employee made off with dirty money.
- skybrian 6y agoThe factories (and businesses) are used as collateral to get loans from banks. The banks are getting defrauded when the company goes bankrupt and the loan isn’t repaid. The injured workers are collateral damage. If they got away with it then it would just look like a normal bankruptcy. Extracting the money already happened with more or less legitimate-looking business expenses.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The factories (and businesses) are used as collateral to get loans from banks. The banks are getting defrauded when the company goes bankrupt and the loan isn’t repaid. Defrauded? This is the entire concept of collateral.
- selimthegrim 6y agoNot when the book value of the collateral bears as much resemblance to reality as that Spanish old lady’s shoddy restoration job of that Jesus fresco.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt’s the bank’s job to do proper due diligence and perform a good appraisal.
- skybrian 6y agoYes, and preventing fraud is why they do that, and sometimes, the due diligence isn't good enough. In this case, though, apparently the bank was in on it.
- seibelj 6y agoThis is another reason why I like cryptocurrency, specifically bitcoin. These shenanigans are enabled at the core through the ability to print money via a central bank. The central bank is corrupt, they give money effectively straight to those connected, who use the new money to buy foreign assets as well as extremely complex schemes to loot their country. With a universal money unit that cannot be corrupted, you eliminate a lot of this nonsense.
- yowlingcat 6y agoI don't think BTC doesn't make the messy people problems any easier. That doesn't mean it's without value -- I do think there is some incompressible utility to having a globally decentralized "universal money unit" as you say. But that's no shortcut to curing socioeconomic corruption.
- crusty 6y agoI wish there were more details on the kind of money they were able to pull out of this scheme. All of the dollar values in the article refer to the amounts stolen in Ukraine, moved through she'll companies, and used to purchase properties and businesses. Traditionally, we hear about money laundering involving low-overhead, cash-oriented businesses where money can be injected and extracted by falsifying volume. But these were large capital purchases into an industry in destress with numerous facets of regulatory exposure, from the industry's risk to the environment and the high potential safety risks for workers to the special status of the industry to national security - it invites scrutiny of lots of alphabet agencies, especially if your scheme involves ignoring all of their requirements to juice profits. This leads me to believe the "masterminds" only ever saw it as a short-term play, so back to my original bewilderment, how much were they able to extract in just several years compared to the large upfront costs? And were they skimming so much from neglect that it wouldn't have been worth it just to run these as legitimate, sustainable businesses? I wonder if the had just maintained these steel facilities and avoided the safety and environmental problems, and made it into Trump's presidency intact, would they have just been able to sell them off high on the back of Trump's protectionist, domestic steel revival rhetoric and made a killing and be sitting pretty today, given that all the legal pressure on them for this is from the US and they seem to have already been given a pass for stealing $5.5 billion in Ukraine from Ukraine.
- crusty 6y agoOther comments point to the scheme using the asset purchased with stolen money as collateral for a loan that the bank is left with in a much depreciated state. That would make the ongoing extraction of profits is irrelevant. My alternate set of questions about this loan fraud scheme are in a different comment. Ha. And I don't really get how that "launders" the money trail. The only point at which the transfers of funds seem murky is when they go through the she'll companies in the BVI. This feels like the makings of a great article that some editor said, "write up what you have, we're just going to publish it and move you onto something else." There are just so many things unexplained or unexplored.
- exogeny 6y agoThis is somewhat unrelated to the story, but I am happy and proud of the Post-Gazette for digging into this. The PG is my hometown newspaper -- although I haven't lived in Pittsburgh for fifteen years, it's still home -- and they like most newspapers have been absolutely gutted by layoffs and piss-poor management. You might recall a controversy a few years ago about their firing of the political cartoonist because he refused to be pro-Trump as the owners wished. Local news is critical for reasons I hope I don't need to explain here, as are investigative departments that dig in deep and uncover things like this. The PG (IIRC) got a Pulitzer for their work on the Penn State/Jerry Sandusky scandal some years back and it makes me proud to see them still doings like this, the Block family be damned.
- jtsuken 6y agoThis specific article is terribly written, however. I've spend over 5min trying to get the gist of the story. Which seems to be: A business owner with a background in oil and metals asked the bank he owned to fund levereged-buy-outs of rundown US steel factories, some of which had accidents, some of which later shut down. DOJ and the prosecutors in Ukraine investigate if the schemes used in the process of take-over could be fraudulent.
- selimthegrim 6y agoThis story has been covered many times, the unique bit is interviewing the steelworkers.
- jtsuken 6y agoWhich is exactly my point, the article and the clickbaity headline sound like a detailed report about a newly uncovered scheme, but there is actually very little information about what happened.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoSo is Ukraine basically the playground where all of the worlds corrupt elite steal millions? I recall a certain person being hesitant to send US tax dollars there because of corruption concerns.
- crusty 6y ago> "I recall a certain person being hesitant to send US tax dollars there because of corruption concerns." I think you meant IIRC, but the C is the problem. That certain person had no problem with corruption in Ukraine, it was just that he needed some of it's corruption to act in his favor first. And the jump from the article to "So is Ukraine basically the playground where all of the worlds corrupt elite steal millions?" Is a little (not a little) broad. It's a former Soviet bloc state and this is pretty much table-stakes corruption for those.
- bumbada 6y agoI had a girlfriend that was from Ukraine and visited the country in summer. Ukraine has probably the most fertile soil in the world. Like Egypt it has fed Europe and then Russia for a long time. It is also one of the most corrupt countries in the world, like Russia and China. Most Westerners just can not imagine what corruption is at those levels. For decades the grain was put into trains and half the grain had "disappeared" in destiny. This happens at all levels. Nobody goes there to help the country. Like lots of countries in Africa the big guys (Russia or EU, or USA) go there to plunder the country. It is too rich and too strategic. It is also the playground for big countries to fight. Instead of fighting WWIII and fucking the entire world with radioactive waste, the big guys play on playgrounds like Ukraine their power games. The US does not want Europe to dismantle NATO after it is not necessary anymore where Europe can arm itself. It also does not want Europe and Asia to integrate further because that means the end of USA hegemony in the world. Also the military industrial complex in the US needs a reason to exist. If threats do not exist, they will create them in order to survive or "their money" will be redirected to things like social welfare. Americans need to feel unsafe all the time so they agree to pay for new weapons in new taxes. UE wants to expand to get the wealth of Ukraine resources and Russia does not want to lose them. That is very bad for Ukraine. The people that can, like my ex girlfriend, just leave the country.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/Iq3zy https://archive.is/Iq3zy
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hamandcheese 6y agoHow is one able to buy the factories using dirty money in the first place?