16 ms·
Association of sleep duration in middle and old age with incidence of dementia
- BugsJustFindMe 6y ago"However, this study cannot establish cause and effect" is the only part of this article that matters, and it demonstrates the ineptitude of the article writer.
- scotuswroteus 6y agoget some sleep
- coding123 6y agoI will when I finish just one more zombie night in 7 days to die. Just one more I promise.
- senux 6y agoI agree. This sort of article is partly the reason why we so often here something like "science can't make up its mind" or "x is good now but was bad before, and will be bad again soon". Instead of sharing accurate information about the findings of these researchers, news organizations use them to write catchy, clickbait-y articles. Needless to say, researchers are often to blame as well, since they participate in interviews using vague language so that they can benefit from the exposure, well aware of the repercussions of their behavior. This issue goes beyond just researchers and news organizations, though. There have been plenty of discussions here in HN and other places about how scientific research is somewhat broken due to how it rewards quantity versus quality for example.
- zarq 6y agoIt's really hard to fight this though, because it may take many years, even decades, to thoroughly answer a follow-up question. By then, everyone has forgotten about the original reason something got published.
- tinyhouse 6y ago> researchers are often to blame as well, since they participate in interviews using vague language so that they can benefit from the exposure, well aware of the repercussions of their behavior. I would also add that like everything in life, there's a large distribution of researchers. Some do poor research. This is true for all fields. One example is when a researcher has an hypothesis in mind which they try to force even if the results don't really support it. Doing great science is hard and researchers in the end have pressure to publish papers.
- busyant 6y ago> Needless to say, researchers are often to blame as well, since they participate in interviews using vague language so that they can benefit from the exposure, well aware of the repercussions of their behavior. Universities also have PR departments that tout their faculty research. I imagine these PR groups contribute to the hype.
- fighterpilot 6y agoYeah, the headline isn't a conclusion that can be drawn from the study, and is guaranteed to mislead most people who come across it. Shame.
- gentleman11 6y agoAs people age and that their brains change, many end up sleeping less automatically, so it could be a common cause for both
- roguson 6y agoThis article makes me question my time management ability. I should tweak it so I can't make the chances worse. I guess I'll sleep right now.
- irrational 6y agoSo, anyone with kids is probably going to have dementia?
- emteycz 6y agoUsually parents can't sleep well only for a year at most, even 6 months old children are sleeping whole nights.
- growt 6y agoThat's just half of the picture. My kids are older but they have a talent to get up at 6 in the morning on weekends. And need to get up at similar times for school during the week.
- stagger87 6y agoIf you have kids getting up at 6 for school and you haven't adjusted your sleep schedule to match, isn't that kind of on you now?
- SethMurphy 6y agoAs a parent I need both my own down time and time alone with my spouse to feel mentally healthy too, and that is usually after they are in bed and asleep. Maybe more than 6 hours is easy, but it's usually less than 8 if I manage to do all my normal expected activities. Often I do sleep instead now though as I quickly realized my temperament is only agreeable with enough of it as I age, and the other things I need to do suffer. Others may not make the same choice, and it's not a wrong to prioritize other important aspects of mental and physical well being.
- wonderwonder 6y agoHow does one do this? Parents get up at 6 to get their kids ready for school. Then take the kids to school, shower, have breakfast and then work until 6. Picking up the kids at some point in there. Then make dinner, family time and then kids go to bed at 8 or 9. Now you have the option of going right to sleep which is fine if you desire no personal time / partner time. But if you have your own hobbies or goals then you spend a couple hours on those and bang you are sleep deprived.
- overcast 6y agoUnless it's an emergency, I've ALWAYS prioritized sleep. It's just too important for health regardless of these latest findings. I'd call in to work if I didn't get a full nights rest in the past, it's not worth feeling like shit for the rest of the day. The culture of glamorizing working longer and harder till early hours of the mornings on zero sleep, has always been nonsense. Musk is notorious for bragging about this, and the dude is a rough looking 49.
- decafninja 6y agoI think Elon Musk looks his age, and looks pretty ok for a 49 year old. Granted he has money, and he's had hair transplants, but I've seen many late 40s early 50s people in much worse shape.
- maxerickson 6y agoHe's approaching the Brimley/Cocoon Line.
- benatkin 6y agoPassed the Wendt/Cheers Line two years after Tesla was founded and three years before he became CEO.
- mywittyname 6y agoHe's had a lot of cosmetic...improvements. Plus he can afford personal chefs, trainers, doctors, stylists, etc.
- matwood 6y agoIME, the biggest predictor for people looking younger than their age is exercising and avoiding alcohol. I'm sure sleep is in there since people who do the other 2 normally also sleep ok.
- burade 6y agoSleep is in there, trust me. I'm 29 and look 40.
- abledon 6y agonurses and doctors, the 'health' workers, and other erratic schedule-shifting shift workers... RIP
- gumby 6y agoThis is well known, and there is a movement to change this for residents, at least. So far nothing has changed. More proximally: the level of care you can receive / number of errors committed is seriously affected by the loss of sleep by your carer.
- The_rationalist 6y agoMelatonin intake (300 mcg) is useful for falling asleep faster.
- fish45 6y agoMore accurately, middle aged people who get less than 6 hours of sleep a night are 30% more likely to get dementia. I'd expect that people who get less than 6 hours of sleep are also more stressed and less health concious though.
- CerealFounder 6y agoThis guy infers. This seems like a tough study given the correlation factors.
- pmiller2 6y agoSure, I'd agree with the "more stressed and less health conscious" bit. But, the article does give some good reasons to suggest that either midlife insomnia is a very early symptom of dementia, or that sleep deprivation itself leads to dementia. Nonetheless, we are talking about people who have pre-existing insomnia before being diagnosed with dementia. According to the Mayo Clinic[0], the most common causes of insomnia are: * Stress. * Disrupted circadian rhythms due to shift work or frequent travel. * Poor sleep habits. * Eating too much late in the day. Further down the list are: * Anxiety disorders. * Medications. * Other medical conditions. * Sleep disorders. * Caffeine, nicotine, and alcohol. * Age (older people sleep less than younger people). Of these, anxiety disorders; sleep disorders; and caffeine, nicotine, and alcohol seem the most interesting to me. Anxiety disorders probably have an effect much like that of chronic stress, except that simple chronic stress generally goes away eventually. Sleep disorders seem interesting because we have some evidence that sleep serves a function related to brain health, but, really, we don't know exactly what sleep does for us. And, alcohol, nicotine, and caffeine are interesting because the former two carry their own, independent health risks. Caffeine is interesting because, of course, it is active in the central nervous system, and it actually shows some limited evidence for a protective effect against Alzheimer's disease. [1] Cross referencing that with the list of things they control for ("age (timescale), sex, ethnicity, education, marital status, alcohol consumption, physical activity, smoking status, fruit and vegetable consumption, BMI, hypertension, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, GHQ depression, and CNS medications"), we can (lightly) cross age, nicotine, and alcohol off the list of interesting things. All this makes me wonder if either insomnia is an early dementia symptom, as they suggest, or if one of the causes of insomnia is the instigating factor. And, it seems to me the most interesting causal factors for insomnia left on the board are anxiety and stress. Oh, and guess what? Anxiety, stress, and PTSD have been independently linked to the development of dementia! [2] To me, that's interesting because anxiety is known to impair both working memory and cognitive processes[3], things which are both impaired in dementia. I don't mean to suggest that anxiety and stress cause dementia all by themselves, but I do think this might point to a more significant role for anxiety and stress than is typically considered these days. Anyway, these are just some idle thoughts from someone who is neither a doctor, neuroscientist, nor biological researcher of any kind. If anyone has anything else to add, or would care to riff off this, I'd love to see it. --- [0]: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/insomnia/symptoms-causes/syc-20355167 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/insomnia/symp... [1]: https://content.iospress.com/download/journal-of-alzheimers-disease/jad091387?id=journal-of-alzheimers-disease%2Fjad091387 https://content.iospress.com/download/journal-of-alzheimers-... [2]: https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/blog/there-link-between-stress-and-dementia-risk https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/blog/there-link-between-stress... [3]: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/anxiety-fear-and-hate/201902/how-anxiety-impacts-the-way-we-perceive-and-think https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/anxiety-fear-and-hat...
- andred14 6y agoCNN lied constantly in 2020 and before. People are still watching and reading their stuff? This is more propaganda - a story to cover up the thousands of vacc1ne reactions that are happening
- sokoloff 6y agoI always wonder about the direction of causality (if any) in these studies. I’m fortunate to mostly live without an alarm clock. I naturally get up before any scheduled activities, only early morning flights (previously) or EU time zone meetings require an alarm. Even without an alarm, I typically wake up feeling fully refreshed after 5-6 hours, rarely more than 7. If I end up with dementia (family history indicates likely), is the same root cause of dementia causing the 5-6 hours of sleep now, the other way around, or neither?
- tinyhouse 6y agoNot an expert. But if you're fully refreshed I think you're fine. Many people would take it, that's for sure. Research is useful. But nothing is more useful than listening to your own body. When something is wrong there are usually signs.
- k__ 6y agoGood to know. Five years ago I stopped setting an alarm and now I get about 8-9h of sleep every night. Let's see how this plays out in the long run, haha.
- carbocation 6y agoIn contrast, a quasi-causal analysis (via Mendelian randomization) found no causal effect of sleep duration on Alzheimer's risk. > There was little evidence to support associations of increased sleep duration with ... Alzheimer's disease risk [OR = 0.89 (95% CI = 0.67-1.18); P = 0.41]. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31062029/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31062029/
- gumby 6y agoThere are other forms of dementia than Alzheimer's.
- carbocation 6y agoAre there causal analyses of sleep on those other forms of dementia?
- sixstringtheory 6y agoI'm not well versed on different kinds of studies... could you explain the differences between "causal analysis" and whatever the study linked in the article is? They mention a longitudinal study and that the "finding was confirmed in analysis using sleep duration measured by an accelerometer." I assume a causal analysis would also determine the direction of the causality, e.g. if it turns out that people predisposed to dementia have more trouble sleeping in middle age. That definitely seems like a tall order and probably not exactly what the linked study can answer.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoAccelerometers tell nothing about the actual sleep duration. Is this another one of that quack sleep doctor’s ”everyone needs 8 hours of sleep every night” studies?
- carbocation 6y agoCorrect, the study design in the original article cannot answer causal questions (although of course it can generate hypotheses). For example, if an omniscience informed us "actually, people lose sleep in middle age as a consequence of the early stages of dementia", that would make sense as well. The best causal analysis is interventional, but many times (such as in this case) it would be both extremely challenging and likely hard to do in any ethical fashion (I can't imagine how it could be done, but perhaps someone could). Short of that, you're left with instrumental variables. Genetics offers a very nice instrumental variable, since the causal arrow largely goes one way if you setup your study design carefully. That is generally performed as Mendelian randomization, which has several assumptions but, if met, has nice properties. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mendelian_randomization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mendelian_randomization
- Tycho 6y agoI wonder if there is a very simple effect involving blood flow to the head. When you sleep, you lie horizontally, and so presumably it's easier for blood to circulate through your entire body. Maybe if you don't get enough horizontal time, it leads to head related problems like dementia and hair loss.
- TheBlight 6y agoPossibly related: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/deep-sleep-gives-your-brain-a-deep-clean1/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/deep-sleep-gives-...
- tinyhouse 6y agoMany people who don't sleep enough at night do spend the same time laying down as one with a full night sleep. Many people would spend like 5 hours sleeping and another 2 hours laying down resting.
- fencepost 6y agoI think reading the entire article is important here. My initial response was that the headline writer was sloppy about risk, correlation and causation, but towards the end it notes some studies where one or more nights of poor sleep appeared to cause measurable increases in substances that are present in elevated levels in dementia patients. If those studies did a reasonable job of showing causation, then this could be an extension of that work.
- Tenoke 6y ago~6 hours or just above it in general seems to be the sweetspot. Most negative effects (especially broad ones like all-cause mortality) only really start showing up under 6 (or over 7 hours)[0]. Too bad the majority of reporting exaggerates and starts scaring people for going under 8 (and sometimes 9!) when yet again it seems like 6-7 is likely best, with very little 'loss' between 7 and 6. Just don't go much lower than that for long unless you need exceptionally less. 0. https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/full/10.1139/apnm-2020-0034 https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/full/10.1139/apnm-2020-0034
- matwood 6y agoYeah, I naturally sleep around 7 hours. If I get < 6 I really notice it the next day. 6+ is a normal day. But it is weird just how much I notice going less than 6 though. Another thing that my wife hates (ie, is jealous of), is my head hits the pillow and I'm out. Also, during that 6 hour sweet spot, I can sleep through almost anything.
- serpix 6y agoMy dad is like this. Please tell me as I am curious, do you tend to self-reflect or have a vivid inner world? I'm trying to understand how my dad does this and my current theory is that he simply does not dwell on things and runs mostly on instinct.
- IneffablePigeon 6y agoFwiw, I can also usually do this and I would consider myself a world class dweller. For me, it's about - consistent bedtime - doing as little as possible involving a screen in bed - consistent bedtime routine - consistent bedtime Screwing any of these up can quite easily cause me to start worrying about things instead of falling asleep. But I also think in part I'm just lucky and I can't really explain what causes it. I was always able to fall asleep in the car when I was younger, almost instantly. I can't fall asleep on public transport or planes at all though unless I'm really shattered.
- matwood 6y ago
- datavirtue 6y agoTypical mainstream click bait.
- gregf 6y agoI'm screwed then. Due to a mental issue and my sleep paralysis I'm lucky if I sleep 3-4 hours a night as much as I would like to sleep more.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoWorrying about sleeping enough is certainly more detrimental to one’s health and well-being than getting too little sleep.
- pvarangot 6y agoThat little sleep has way more possible dire consequences that just dementia. There's literature all over the place about it, I don't even know where to start. How old are you? I don't know anyone that can live with getting that little sleep unless they are also on amphetamines.
- gregf 6y agoTurning 40 in August. I haven't slept this badly all my life. It's got worse over the years. Specially the last 5 or so. I'm bipolar II, I take my meds as I'm supposed to, but I still seem to frequently cycle with manic episodes that keep me up working on projects all hours of the night. I then refuse to sleep all day, so I'll go to bed at say 3-4am and get up by 9am. Nights I can go to bed, I suffer from horrible sleep paralysis and that will have me waking me up throughout the night. Some of it is pretty disturbing, at least to me. So I end up giving after it happening several times in a night and just not sleeping any longer. Sleep issues run in the family though. My father is a logger and I have never seen him sleep longer than 5-6 hours my entire life. *EDIT* not abusing Amphetamine's BTW. Sorry forgot to even talk about that. Just lots of mania I would guess. Like right now, I have been kinda down and depressed all afternoon. It's now 6pm where I'm at, and I just had a switch go off, and now I'm full of energy and will probably end up coding till I drop. I'm my own worst enemy, I know.
- pvarangot 6y agoI'm really sorry you have to live with that. Yeah few people understand how a manic episode works, that can definitely be masked as being a functional person but you are still harming yourself. Maybe it's time to change your medication? The brain changes as you age, maybe you can have a better quality of life if you try new stuff.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoMany forms of dementia destroy dopaminergic neurons, and this process begins much earlier than symptoms of dementia itself manifest. From what I’ve gathered from reading studies across the years, less dopaminergic capacity seems to be associated with less restful sleep. The conclusions of this study seem to have it backwards. It’s not lack of sleep that causes dementia, it’s early dementia that causes insomnia. Edit: it’s also possible that a third factor causes both of these. For example, both people low on dopamine and the sleep-deprived are likely to turn to coffee to keep them functional. If they drink too much coffee, they might accidentally poison themselves into dementia, because some of the Harmala alkaloids in coffee are neurotoxic and like to deposit themselves in brain fatty tissues for a long time.
- gundmc 6y agoCoffee causing dementia is a pretty shocking claim that I haven't heard previously. Do you have more reading on this?
- nsxwolf 6y agoI've always wondered if coffee studies are just something they give bored grad students to do. I've heard about what seems like hundreds of them in my lifetime and they contradict each other in cycles over long stretches of time.
- crocsarecool 6y agoSame! One week it’s terrible for you. The next week it’s curing cancer. I just try not to have any past a certain hour so as to not interrupt my sleep.
- ineedasername 6y agoThe behavior of drinking coffee or not is also very socially mediated-- portrayal of coffee drinkers in movies, coffee as a common activity for preliminary dates, or to meet someone new at a cafe... All of this means that coffee drinkers are going to self select for various other features that add confounding factors. Imagine you were doing a study on marriage patterns: I wouldn't be surprised if "Drinks their coffee in the cafe itself" was more highly associated with being single. And the headline will read "Dedicated coffee drinkers less likely to find a partner"
- kazinator 6y agoWe must avoid using causal words like "raises" when a statistical relationship is found. To raise something is to cause something lower to become something higher. What the study found is that the pattern of sleeping less than six hours is seen more in people who develop dementia. The study's own discussion states: "There is evidence of a bidirectional association between sleep dysfunction and pathophysiological changes in dementia{citations given}, highlighting the need for a longer time frame in studies."
- paultopia 6y agoI really hate these kinds of news stories. It's like: yes, here are some more ways that not getting enough sleep will kill you. Add dementia to weight gain, worsened immune function, etc. etc. Gee, let's all call the Magic Sleep Fairy and ask her to make it possible to sleep longer, as if jobs, family members, noisy neighbors, and all the rest of actual pieces of human existence that make adequate sleep impossible for many of us don't exist.
- TaupeRanger 6y agoReverse causation not ruled out. Typically useless study within this field where no real progress has been made in years.
- dmje 6y agoIt's irritating how these articles always position stuff as if us insomniacs have a choice. I'd chew my own arm off to get a solid 8 hours a night but it just doesn't happen.
- daneel_w 6y agoPercentage or percentiles?
- gyrgtyn 6y agoThis just stresses me out about sleeping even more and makes sleeping harder than it already is.
- slt2021 6y agodo investment bankers have dementia later in their lifes? i heard they work 9-5 (9am-5am next day)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JCM9 6y agoThere are lots of stories of the “I can work harder and longer than others because I require very little sleep” types having serious issues later in life. This study would seem to put some hard data behind this logic being a really bad idea for ones long term health and well being. The public discourse now seems to be shifting to one where “successful people prioritize sleep.”
- eurasiantiger 6y agoI think those people already have serious issues and are escaping them through working.
- zapita 6y agoAlternative title: people without children have less risk of dementia.
- Jallpowawe 6y agoAfter following nearly 8,000 people for 25 years, the study found a higher dementia risk with a "sleep duration of six hours or less at age 50 and 60" as compared to those who slept seven hours a night. In addition, persistent short sleep duration between the ages of 50, 60 and 70 was also associated with a "30% increased dementia risk," independent of "sociodemographic, behavioural, cardiometabolic, and mental health factors," including depression, the study said.
- ineedasername 6y agoWhy assume lack of sleep is the cause? Why not reverse it, that dementia causes people to sleep less? The study makes it clear that it's an association. It never says it's an assertion of directional causality.
- arisAlexis 6y agoMaybe a bit extreme conclusions? One day or one week of bad sleep detrimental? So people that have more than one kid and had bad sleep for years are all doomed? Like all humanity?