8 ms·
Everybody Hates “FLoC”
- rektide 6y agoit's less evil and easier to block than every other piece of shit vile scheme on the table, so just fake endorse it please.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoThat's a good point. Blocking it or feeding it with fake data will be trivial. I wonder what Google is planning to prevent this. For a company with their resources I'm sure they planned many steps ahead. I also wonder if this will really reduce the adblocking phenomenon. People are used to clean sites now. Privacy may have been the reason to sway people to install them but it's not the only benefit.
- vikbytes 6y agoGoogle doesn't have to listen to anyone, this is what having a browser market share of 70%+ grants you. Question is, will their move chip away at that market share? If people actually care, it should.
- deusum 6y agoSwitch to FireFox, it's way better than ever, and integrates so well across devices. What holds one back is that Chrome has made itself indispensable. It's remembered your passwords, your credit cards, your addresses, etc. All part of a plan to keep you happily in its garden. No conspiracy, just business.
- throwawayboise 6y ago> It's remembered your passwords, your credit cards, your addresses, etc. That's the one of the first things I disable when I install a browser or create a new profile. Along with history, third party cookies, search prediction stuff, etc. Also clear all cookies and cache when I exit the browser.
- agogdog 6y agoYeah I use other tools for passwords, etc and turn off a lot (though not history! that's serious business) I also use a pihole to block ads and trackers more completely, but I do like having an additional browser-level feature with "enhanced tracking protection"[1] – if it did nothing else, I like simply having the list of attempted-tracker on every site easily available at all times. [1] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enhanced-tracking-protection-firefox-desktop https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enhanced-tracking-prote...
- Black101 6y ago> Switch to FireFox, it's way better than ever, and integrates so well across devices. I still use Firefox but it is not way better then ever... they keep removing useful features... especially on mobile where you can't even use most extensions anymore.
- XorNot 6y agouBlock Origin works - everything else I can take or leave.
- Black101 6y agouBlock origin is one of the most useful, but I also need at least Redirector to fix Reddit, Keepass helper, Smart Referer, Theater mode Youtube to fix youtube and a few others that are very useful. But it is Ridiculous that only about 15 out of the thousands of addons work with the latest version of Firefox Mobile. All of them used to work in the previous engine of Firefox Mobile... nice downgrade.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoI think it exposed exactly the reason why it's so bad to have a browser monopoly. I hope it will also spur others like Microsoft to reconsider using Chrome's codebase and thus add to browser diversity. Because Google will keep making it harder to cut this stuff out. I never understood why microsoft was suddenly so hell-bent on rebuilding edge. The engine they used had nothing to do with me not using it. I just didn't want to jump from one corporate toy to another. This still goes except they're marketing it so heavily to enterprises now that it's become the standard browser at work. I still use Firefox there when I can though :)
- petre 6y ago> I never understood why microsoft was suddenly so hell-bent on rebuilding edge. They want a piece of the analytics pie.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYes but they could have had that with the old Edge.. I just don't understand how the browser engine was a barrier to adoption. It didn't perform badly at all every time I tested, it worked just fine. I think it was just the marketing effort that got Edge Chromium more adopted, not the move to chromium itself. Every time we had a call with a MS consultant (about any unrelated topic) they had to bring it up again, it was crazy.
- petre 6y agoIt didn't have enough adoption despite the ads in Windows 10. Also it there was too much functionality to duplicate. So they decided to use Chromium instead, keep the Edge UI andthe ads. A good decision actually. Less bug to bug compatibility needed as most websites target Chrome anyway. I'm happy about it, there's one less browser engine to support that I dont care about. We target FF and Chromium. Safari is enough of a nuisance, only high impact bugs get fixed. It's the new IE.
- danbolt 6y agoChakraCore was a cool JavaScript engine as well. I miss it being actively developed!
- skybrian 6y agoI suspect there will be a preference to turn it off by the time it launches for real. Then, maybe people who care will turn it off instead of switching?
- akmittal 6y agoThis may change in near future, Chromium edge is biggest threat to them. Chromium edge is best of all worlds > Speed/UI of Chrome > Firefox like privacy > Backed by Big brand so cant be sold out(Opera/Vivandi/Brave)
- asddubs 6y ago>> Backed by Big brand so cant be sold out I mean, it can, it just doesn't have to involve a sale
- aarchi 6y ago“Everybody” is too strong of a quantifier. The named companies (EFF, Mozilla, Brave, Vivaldi, and DuckDuckGo) are all well-known privacy advocates. Not included are user perceptions or competing adtech views.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jcranmer 6y agoAs the article notes, there hasn't been a single company not named Google that came out in favor of FLoC.
- refulgentis 6y agoThis is a disaster for ad tech outside Google, Apple, and Amazon: Google and Apple still have tons of targeting data in a world without FLoC, and smaller ad tech will wither on the vine. That's fine, or maybe it's not. There's always tradeoffs, but it's strange to me how little coverage there is of how this is exactly the end game the 'regulation is bad' crowd predicted.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoThis is exactly what I thought. Google is using this to establish their already-majority share of the advertising market intoa monopoly by controlling the browser. Using privacy laws as an excuse and doing just the minimum to skirt those laws (complying with the letter but not the spirit of those) I think this should be addressed with stronger privacy laws, but Google is capable of moving much faster than the EU government.
- refulgentis 6y agoFLoC, much like AMP, was an honest and earnest try to extend the same benefits of Apple's closed ecosystem to actors outside it. Google is trapped between either not getting rid of 3p cookies and pissing us off, or trying something like FLoC, which I'm still a little surprised backfired. The only option they're left is to copy Apple's business model, exactly
- cma 6y agoWhy not make it opt in?
- sircastor 6y agoThis implies (as the article states) that we’re bound to accept whatever Google’s alternative solution is to their own problem. We as consumers and users are free to our own third preference: “I don’t want _any_ tracking”. That’s why it backfired. The effort may have been in earnest, but it’s just another expression of Google’s bravado. The pain they’re facing is that people don’t want to be tracked, and tracking/cohorts are the only edge that Google has. Without that they’re must another advertising wholesaler.
- okareaman 6y agoI like FLoc because I've long wanted a local profile that I can control to some extent. I am aware that ads pay for all the free services I get, so I am not opposed to ads. I would like to edit this local profile to at least help them show me relevant ads when I do see them.
- nitrogen 6y agoDoes FLoC provide any control to the user? The articles and comments posted here recently give me the impression that it's 100% under the browser's control and hidden.
- okareaman 6y agoI'm assuming that people are good at prying into such things will jailbreak it
- dcow 6y agoWhat? You don’t need to jailbreak anything to: document.interestCohort = null;
- jakopo87 6y agoBeing a function, probably is safer to do: document.interestCohort = () => null; so it does not cause error in Javascript execution.
- okareaman 6y agoI meant learning how to manipulate advertising data so it was more relevant, not disabling it
- livre 6y agoYou are assuming it will be a read-write property but there are a few properties and methods in JavaScript that can't be overwritten and nothing prevents Google from making this one read-only.
- Black101 6y agomost users are clueless, why should they be included? and we already know what ad companies want... I bet you are working for some ad company?
- ehsankia 6y ago>I bet you are working for some ad company "Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing" https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > most users are clueless, why should they be included? Privacy groups, average users and ad-tech companies aren't the only 3 groups of relevant parties. What about the millions of websites that run on advertisement. While the majority of HN would love to see ad-tech entirely disappear, the reality is that it pays for the majority of the web currently. I'm sure most websites wouldn't be happy seeing their ad-revenue slashed.
- youngtaff 6y ago> While the majority of HN would love to see ad-tech entirely disappear, the reality is that it pays for the majority of the web currently. I'm sure most websites wouldn't be happy seeing their ad-revenue slashed. This is the challenge, how do we pay sites for content? Trouble with the current ads market is vendors like Google, FB etc extract most of the value leaving little for publishers
- bozzcl 6y agoPersonally, I think the Patreon model works great... except content creators charge too much for each tier. When you're subscribed to a hundred or more channels and want to compensate them for blocking their ads, $2 to $5 for each subscription adds up quick. In my case, I just overrode the Patreon subscription tier and limited each one to at most $1. I don't need exclusive Discord access and all that crap, it doesn't add too much value IMO. So if content providers had monthly contribution systems (or better integration with third-party ones) to make it easier for viewers to donate), and if content creators were more sensible about what they charge (say, start at $0.25 a month) I could see this getting better traction.
- monkeybutton 6y agoI find the visceral reaction against FLoC interesting. On paper it is an improvement over explicit 3rd party tracking cookies that are used to monitor the sites you visit and are ultimately used to categorize you. Just something about "we're gonna stamp you with some labels and broadcast them to every site you visit" really provokes people even though the end results are the same as before.
- olliej 6y agothe problem is that people don't like the status quo, and FLOC is advertised as solving that but it doesn't. So it's a new technology, with new complexity, and unknown additional attack surface (in the sense of attacks on user privacy) that doesn't do anything to actually reduce the tracking of users.
- henearkr 6y agoThe average person will also put ads on their blog to generate revenues.
- ehsankia 6y agoThe status quo is advertisers tracking every single website you visit, and keeping a personalized profile of you with all your data in there. The system under FLoC means they don't see anything about you and which site you've visited, they only get a single cohort ID, which is group roughly representing your browsing behavior. How are these the same?
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoWho controls the cohorts? Can membership in the wrong one mean a death sentence in some countries?
- Mehdi2277 6y agoGoogle does and the cohorts are opaque and data generated based on history. They're not actually using this specific approach but roughly what they're doing is like taking your browser history, representing it as some vector of numbers and then clustering nearby points together and giving each cluster a cohort id. Cohort ids are also updated periodically (roughly weekly). The clusters are most likely to be surface level interests. The id itself doesn't give you that though and you'd want many users with same cohort ids, correlate there behaviors, to try to guess what underlying browse trend it means which is a lot better than the current state of things of effectively having a user id with 3rd party cookie.
- tjpnz 6y agoOn a more superficial level FLoC is also a terrible acronym. I'm sure whoever thought of it felt very clever but if the stated goal is protecting privacy they need to be able to communicate it in a way the layperson can understand.
- akmittal 6y agoGoogle has always abused Chrome's dominance by implementing features benefiting them. The real reason is no one trust Google no matter how they implement this.
- smitty1e 6y agoLet us form a "Federated Learning of Cohorts Opposition for Freedom" and see if the FLOC OFF message reaches Google.
- ChrisArchitect 6y ago"Everybody".