15 ms·
I thought one of the big use cases for this was to track stolen items, like a backpack or maybe even a bicycle. But the "anti-stalking" feature will notify som
by crazygringo 6y ago
I thought one of the big use cases for this was to track stolen items, like a backpack or maybe even a bicycle.
But the "anti-stalking" feature will notify someone if an AirTag they don't own appears to be traveling with them.
Does this render it useless for anti-theft, then? Since it will just notify a thief that the bike they just stole is being tracked, and they can look for the AirTag and throw it in the nearest trash can?
Not criticizing Apple here -- anti-stalking is super-important -- but just looking for clarification if this will help you find lost items, but not stolen ones.
- shuckles 6y agoVanmoof seems to have adopted the Find My spec and integrated it into their bike hardware itself. AirTag is for lost items. Hardware manufacturers can build Find My support into their product to defend against stolen items. I’d guess that’s the strategy.
- lylecheatham 6y agoI still think Tile lost out on a gigantic market by not making it easier for hardware manufacturers to integrate into their ecosystem. They should have been practically begging oems to embed it.
- FabHK 6y agoYes, and they refuse (apparently) to join Apple's Find My, and instead want users to install their Tile app (and their tags are then only findable by users that have the Tile app installed). They want to own the entire relationship, but I think here they'll lose out.
- manmal 6y agoThey might still capture the (worldwide way larger) Android market.
- yurishimo 6y agoThey've had 5(?) years to do that already but they gained initial success and then sat on their laurels while off-brand competitors tried and failed to break into the market. I tried a couple of cheap Tile competitors but they all wanted you to use their apps and thus weren't very valuable. I almost bought some Tile products around the last Apple event in Fall 2020 but waited because I thought AirTags were going to be released then. I'm still tracker-less so I'll be picking up a 4 pack of these and I am excited to use them. Here in the US at least, Apple has great marketshare to support a service like this and a proven track record with Find My already. I'm planning a cross country road trip that starts in about 2 months, and I'll feel a lot better about not accidentally leaving my wallet behind at campsite or hotel while I'm in a rush to get back on the road. Then, even if I did, all it takes to hopefully get my stuff back is for someone with an iPhone to walk by it to update it's location. Unless Apple royally screws up this rollout, I don't see how Tile can continue to dominate marketshare for this sector.
- ehsankia 6y agoDoes anti-stalking only work for Apple users? I assume it won't notify someone who doesn't have an Apple phone, making it kinda useless for half the population.
- crazygringo 6y agoThe article isn't entirely clear, but suggests that it will use the network of iOS devices around it and that the AirTag will start beeping as well. Seems like it should be able to detect that it's always traveling together with a single Android phone's WiFi signal, for example.
- Hitton 6y agoI wonder how hard would it be to disable beeping. There is probably a speaker that can be drilled through.
- ehsankia 6y agoThat kinda kills the whole purpose of the tag, which is to beep when you lose it. I guess you can still kinda find it with the UWB chip on your iPhone, but that's much harder than by sound.
- ChristophGeske2 6y agoThe plastik part seems to be the resonator replacing it with a soft material that absorbs sound would be the easiest step. However it might be better to disconect the speaker which should save lots of energy the peeper would consume otherwise. I don't think apple checks for the speeker to be connected if the speaker breaks for example it would make the tag unusable resulting in more warrenty complains.
- fencepost 6y agoSeveral factors play into it - how much is it used for 'lost' vs 'stolen(?)' as well as 'if stolen, by someone savvy enough to be checking for tags?' and 'if stolen how long before anti-stalking alerts? Does it alert during daily commutes on the same train? Only after 2+ hours? 3+?'
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y ago>Does this render it useless for anti-theft, then? It's hard to make tracking devices hidden. They need to phone home, so that means they emit a signal. Someone can sniff that out using a RF detector. that's why tracking devices tend to be integrated into the product itself (eg. into the ECU for cars, or part of the CPU/motherboard for computers).
- inasio 6y agoIt's much easier to have a phone that will easily tell you if there is AirTag around you than having an RF detector.
- gruez 6y agoA RF detector costs $15-$25 shipped from china. If RF anti-theft devices become common (either the GSM or the bluetooth variety), I'm sure it'll be part of a thief's toolkit.
- Voline 6y agoThe majority of bike thieves in Portland are not going to buy a $15-$20 RF detector because that would have to come out of their meth budget. They are not a tech-savvy lot.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI suspect some posters are imagining bike thieves as part of some kind of international black market for high end bikes...maybe that exists but 99% of bike thefts are done by the local crackhead who either wants a ride or wants to trade it for $20 for some crack or meth.
- toxik 6y agoA bike thief isn’t going to go rf sniffing
- jrochkind1 6y ago
- kjakm 6y agoI thought it was intended for lost items rather than stolen items. I've had my phone stolen multiple times and thieves know exactly what to do to prevent 'find my' activating. I'm sure it wouldn't take them long to find/disable AirTags either.
- gruez 6y ago>I've had my phone stolen multiple times and thieves know exactly what to do to prevent 'find my' activating. I'm sure it wouldn't take them long to find/disable AirTags either. ...putting it in a faraday bag? Since tags are cheap, they can even smash it.
- crazygringo 6y agoYes but you know a phone can be tracked. If it's someone's backpack or leather jacket, it won't be obvious in any way if there's an AirTag slid deep into some pocket. Sure a professional thief might check, but plenty of things are stolen casually by people who simply see something lying around.
- randyrand 6y agoIt’s for both.
- unicornfinder 6y agoOn the upside as long as you have Find My iPhone activated when you did have the phone it doesn't have a huge amount of value to the thief, particularly on newer models where individual components can't even be swapped without issues.
- tchanglington 6y agoIt’s going to be real funny if non Apple users are basically fair game for AirTags tracking and you have to get an iPhone to protect yourself from AirStalking
- captn3m0 6y agoApparently they can be disabled with any NFC enabled device: https://apple.com/newsroom/2021/04/apple-introduces-airtag/ https://apple.com/newsroom/2021/04/apple-introduces-airtag/ >[...] And even if users don’t have an iOS device, an AirTag separated from its owner for an extended period of time will play a sound when moved to draw attention to it. If a user detects an unknown AirTag, they can tap it with their iPhone or NFC-capable device and instructions will guide them to disable the unknown AirTag. It is better supported on iPhones, but that's acceptable: >iOS devices can also detect an AirTag that isn’t with its owner, and notify the user if an unknown AirTag is seen to be traveling with them from place to place over time. I'd like this detection to come in stock Android, similar to how the Contact Tracing thing was shared b/w Apple/Google.
- moooo99 6y ago> I'd like this detection to come in stock Android, similar to how the Contact Tracing thing was shared b/w Apple/Google. This would be an ideal scenario, even if it took longer to roll out for Android phones thanks to the OS fragmentation Even if that's not happening, I think its not entirely unreasonable for some reliable third party app to pop up an make disabling the AirTags with an Android device almost as easy as an iPhone.
- kelnos 6y ago... and if all else fails, you can always whack it with a hammer a few times. Or just take its battery out.
- fay59 6y agoI’m assuming that instructions to disable the AirTag are basically instructions for how to take off the battery.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> Does this render it useless for anti-theft, then? The other question is: when presented with evidence of stolen property, will the local PD enforce the law and assist with the retrieval of said property?
- mikestew 6y agoThat's already been answered. Stories abound about "Find My Doohickie said it was at this address. I even knocked on the door, and the person that answered said, 'yup, have your phone, whatta ya gonna do about it?'. Cops said file it with insurance." Cops don't care about a $1000 phone, they're not going to care about your bicycle, either (which has also been proven on multiple occasions).
- randyrand 6y agoThe do care about stolen vehicles tho. Motorcycle theft is a big problem.
- moooo99 6y agoAirTags would probably be the cheapest option for relatively reliable motorcycle tracking. However, there are already devices that can be connected to the bikes battery, hence basically run for ages, that also connect to GPS and GSM. Tracking with AirTags assumes the thief (or someone closeby) uses an iPhone AND has the 'Fine my' feature activated, which is, given how motorcycle thieves operate in some areas of the world, is relatively unlikely. So you're probably still better off using a GPS+GSM tracker
- dmitrygr 6y agoThat depends on the state you are in. That is how it will play out in CA, not at all how it will play out in TX.
- djrogers 6y agoStates can be pretty large and diverse - the town I live in in California would have a couple of officers at my door in short order if this situation were called in...
- amelius 6y ago> But the "anti-stalking" feature will notify someone if an AirTag they don't own appears to be traveling with them. Another case of your device working against your interests. I don't care if you have something to hide or not. This just sucks at a fundamental level.
- duskwuff 6y agoIf the "interest" that you're worried about AirTags "working against" is being able to stalk people by attaching trackers to them or their belongings -- sincerely, fuck you. It is entirely appropriate for Apple to build functionality into their products to mitigate this sort of abuse.
- randyrand 6y ago....It’s alerting thieves that the device they stole is being tracked. That’s anti-user. The user is the one trying to do the tracking.
- duskwuff 6y agoAnd not the user of the phone that is reporting the location of those tags to a stalker? Their interests are important too. Anyways, I don't think there was ever any intent for AirTags to function as an anti-theft tracking device. Anti-theft is much harder to do well than anti-loss (which is what Apple is targeting), and is very difficult to distinguish from stalkerware for a mass-market product.
- roughly 6y ago> stalkerware for a mass-market product which is specifically a problem Apple has had with "Find My", so it's nice to see them taking it seriously here.
- jfengel 6y agoI'm not sure it's really Apple's fault. You could do the same thing with a Tile or other beacon. That's the entire purpose of the device. Apple's trying to prevent misuse of their device. They want you to use it to find your keys, not your ex. If you consider that an invalid limitation of your device (by notifying your ex that they seem to be carrying an unknown tracker)... well, let's just say I disagree.
- Lunatic666 6y agoMaybe this changes when you turn on stolen mode for the tagged item.
- jedberg 6y agoSo if you want to stalk someone you put your airtag into stolen mode first? Kinda defeats the purpose of the anti-stalking feature.
- zxcvgm 6y agoI too, found the anti-stalking features might hinder the use of AirTags for locating intentionally stolen items: (1) it has a removable battery, and also (2) "someone can tap [the tag] with their iPhone or NFC-capable device and instructions will guide them to disable the unknown AirTag". The anti-stalking feature also seems to contradict its privacy features: > Bluetooth signal identifiers transmitted by AirTag rotate frequently to prevent unwanted location tracking. But also, in the next sentence: > iOS devices can also detect an AirTag that isn’t with its owner, and notify the user if an unknown AirTag is seen to be traveling with them from place to place over time. If an AirTag is supposed to be "anonymous", then how can a user be informed that this tag has been seen with them over an extended period? This would mean that there is a way to identify a particular AirTag in the first place.
- randyrand 6y agotags rotate identifiers, but only every hour or so.
- crazygringo 6y agoAirTags are anonymous to other end users. Obviously Apple is internally maintaining an association between the AirTag's permanent identifier, and its current temporary signal identifier. This isn't E2EE or anything.
- mercutio2 6y agoHuh? It certainly is E2EE. "Whether attached to a handbag, keys, backpack, or other items, AirTag taps into the vast, global Find My network1 and can help locate a lost item, all while keeping location data private and anonymous with end-to-end encryption."
- crazygringo 6y agoIs the E2EE applying to the Bluetooth ID's? I think it's referring to other aspects of the system -- this sentence is specifically referring to location data, not Bluetooth ID's. In any case, my point remains that obviously Apple has to be internally associating the Bluetooth ID's with owner ID's.
- OkGoDoIt 6y agoI wonder how this works in practice? My main use for an AirTag would be to put on my cat’s collar. But if it starts beeping randomly that’s going to be a problem.
- FateOfNations 6y agoApple's response would be that AirTag isn't designed for that use case, and that you should purchase a "Find My network enabled" collar for your cat from a third party (it's only a matter of time...)
- Spivak 6y agoI actually kinda doubt this situation would happen because it would be a little silly if you could bypass the anti-stalking protection just by buying a 3rd party device.
- nerfhammer 6y agodesolder the speaker or piezo.
- neuronic 6y agoPlease, if possible, do not put collars on cats :( If they're outside they can get gravely injured as they pass through the smallest holes and cracks. There are very NSFL images of resulting injuries. The collars often lead to suffocation or very bloody scenes - no matter how well they seem to fit. https://www.pdsa.org.uk/taking-care-of-your-pet/looking-after-your-pet/kittens-cats/cat-collars https://www.pdsa.org.uk/taking-care-of-your-pet/looking-afte...
- fingerlocks 6y agoBreakaway collars are standard at the pet shops near me. Having a bell on a collar seriously hinders a cat’s ability to hunt birds and other wildlife, which is a huge problem in some places.
- 6y ago
- gnicholas 6y agoThis is a good question. I wonder what the period of time is required before it notifies you about potential stalking. If it is more time than would typically take for someone to realize that the item is stolen, then perhaps it’s not such a big deal. But if it’s only 30 minutes or so, a thief could be notified that they’ve stolen a bicycle that’s being tracked before you come out of the grocery store, movie theater, etc. A related question: can you geofence an airtag so that you are notified if an item leaves an area without you? This could be especially helpful for things like bikes that you would park for long periods of time and would want to know if they’re being moved by someone other than you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fshbbdssbbgdd 6y ago30 minutes seems totally infeasible. People hang out for 30 minutes all the time.
- gnicholas 6y agoThe anti-stalking warning is only triggered if the airtag isn’t near the owner.
- joshe 6y agoIt would make sense to do the anti stalking notification after say 4 days. This would make stalking labor intensive since the stalker has to swap tags frequently. So if you leave one in someone's car or drop it in a bag, you'd have to steal it back and replace it. Also if the stalker is unable to track it down, the victim gets notified automatically which makes stalking with these much more dangerous for the stalker. For a stolen item you'd have that much time to track it down. They could even track if different non-owned tags track the same person to stop stalkers diligent enough to swap these frequently. It's an impressively good balancing of usefulness and avoiding bad spillover effects.
- JohnBooty 6y agoIt would make sense to do the anti stalking notification after say 4 days "Your privacy and safety are important to Apple. We won't let anybody use these devices to stalk you for more than 96 hours." You haven't thought this through! Seriously, the use cases for 96 hours of tracking are frightening. 1. Meet victim in club/bus/supermarket/wherever 2. Drop AirTag in their bag/pocket/whatever. 3. Now you know where they live and/or work assuming they go to one of those places in the next 96 hours.
- pmastela 6y agoWon't be long before magazines start offering tips on how to best avoid getting AirTagged.
- BoorishBears 6y agoSeeing as you can literally give someone a USB cable that tracks them, I don't think AirTags are enabling anything particularly new: https://www.walmart.com/ip/OURLEEME-Car-GPS-Tracker-Vehicle-Car-Tracking-Device-Micro-USB-Cable-Real-Time-GSM-GPS-Tracking/584408325 https://www.walmart.com/ip/OURLEEME-Car-GPS-Tracker-Vehicle-...
- nielsbot 6y agoMaybe so, but consider the optics...
- JKCalhoun 6y agoNot all thieves are smart. In fact I would hazard to say most are not.
- stunt 6y agoThey don't all have to be smart. A few smart thieves will share the tricks. Probably many smart peoples are even going to try building detector devices.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- spoonjim 6y agoThe anti-stalking feature seems to be... preventing someone from tracking your movements with an AirTag? I don’t get it.
- SilverRed 6y agoThe future is having most items with built in tags. So yeah, your iphone tells you the bike you stole is tracking you but its not realistic to remove the tracker from it so you have to dump the bike.
- pmastela 6y agoThe future is here [1]: > Available from today (April 7, 2021), the latest VanMoof S3 & X3 bikes will work with Apple’s Find My app, which means you can track your ride securely using the vast and global Find My network, made up of hundreds of millions of Apple devices. With the new Items tab in the Find My app, you can locate your bike on a map from your iPhone, iPad, or Mac. 1: https://www.vanmoof.com/blog/en/find-my-bike https://www.vanmoof.com/blog/en/find-my-bike
- warmwaffles 6y agoSounds like a strong degauss tool would render that useless.
- rurp 6y agoSo if a friend lends me some keys with one of these attached and I don't have the right kind of phone on me, the keys will start beeping incessantly? That seems pretty darn annoying.
- katbyte 6y agoi think only if they are marked lost?
- gnicholas 6y agoNo, it's an anti-stalking feature, so it's triggered when it's been away from the owner for some unspecified period of time, and only when the tag is moved. If someone is using AirTags to stalk someone, they would never mark as lost, which is why beeping isn't tied to this status.
- Rapzid 6y agoJust tape over the air holes it needs to transmit the sound waves.
- adamlett 6y agoSo maybe ask your friend to take off the AirTag if you have to borrow their keys for more than a few days?
- snowwrestler 6y agoApparently any phone with NFC capability can disable any Apple Airtag.
- gofreddygo 6y ago"Jealous 15 year old uses Apple AirTag to stalk friends" Vs. "AirTag notifies bike thief about itself" For Apple this is a no-brainer.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SergeAx 6y agoThat's super-important, and also will dramatically raise sales of iPhones among petty thieves.
- soapdog 6y agoI don't think it ever claimed to be anti-theft. It is more focused on "finding something you misplaced" than being a security tracking device.
- wyclif 6y agoI could see a smaller version of this, without the speaker, having some real potential for preventing musical instrument theft (especially electric guitars), or at least speeding recovery. The AirTag could conceivably be placed in the electronics control cavity of the guitar.
- pkulak 6y agoSeems like the anti-stalking thing could take at least a couple days? In that case, I'd still love to hide one of these things on my bike. If my bike gets stolen, I'll know about it very quickly.
- sytelus 6y agoIt has to be this way. Imagine if I stick AirTag over someone’s backpack and then track that person all day. You cannot have it both ways.
- qecez 6y agoMight be possible to destroy the beeper.