18 ms·
Apple Approves Parler to Return to App Store
- GoldenMonkey 6y agoWhether you agree with the censorship of Parler or not. Big tech showed it's hand. And how it is willing to organize, to ban competing services. I am getting calls weekly on how to deplatform off AWS services. These are normal businesses, not social media or news organizations. Decentralization is going to happen.
- allsystemsgo 6y agoLots of Big Tech apologists in this thread. I agree. Decentralization is the future.
- larkost 6y agoI don't see any evidence of coordination or organization. Rather they all saw a dangerously out-of-control situation where they could be found liable, or at least involved (in the court of public opinion) in armed insurrection. They all demanded some form of the same thing: moderate the dangerous conversations that were calling for rebellion and violence. But they did not demand a particular methodology (which you would have seen in an organized endeavor). If your service suddenly becomes synonymous with an armed uprising, and your response is to talk about free speech and how it is not your fault... then ya, you are going to loose business partners left and right.
- krona 6y agoIf your service suddenly becomes synonymous with an armed uprising Did parler have particular features enabling these so called 'armed uprisings', beyond what e.g. Facebook also offers to its users for free?
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoYes, they had the heavily advertised feature of not removing posts when you plan an armed uprising.
- jb775 6y agoDude you drank too much of the communist media kool-aid. There was no "armed insurrection". That's all communist media BS. They literally didn't allow guns into the entire Washington DC area. What happened was big tech cutting communication channels because they didn't like Parler's politics. And they'll do it again the second it suits them.
- cozuya 6y agoSo the mob shouting "hang Mike Pence" would have.. had a pleasant debate with him, had they found him alone in the hallways of the Capitol? If not, what do you think would have happened?
- rOOb85 6y agoArmed does not just mean firearms. You can be armed with....let's say a flagpole or fire extinguisher(both were used as weapons against the police by the insurrectionists)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leereeves 6y agoThe story that a Capitol Police officer was attacked and killed with a fire extinguisher was a lie. > Officer Brian Sicknick died of natural causes after defending Capitol on January 6, medical examiner says > the autopsy found no evidence of internal or external injuries https://www.cbsnews.com/news/brian-sicknick-capitol-riot-died-natural-causes/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/brian-sicknick-capitol-riot-die... > The autopsy found no blunt trauma to the head. Sicknick's own family kept urging the press to stop spreading this story because he called them the night of January 6 and told them he was fine — obviously inconsistent with the media's claim that he died by having his skull bashed in — and his own mother kept saying that she believed he died of a stroke. https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-media-lied-repeatedly-about-officer https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-media-lied-repeatedly-a... > Authorities have reviewed video and photographs that show Sicknick engaging with rioters amid the siege but have yet to identify a moment in which he suffered his [supposedly] fatal injuries, law enforcement officials familiar with the matter said. > According to one law enforcement official, medical examiners did not find signs that the officer sustained any blunt force trauma, so investigators believe that early reports that he was fatally struck by a fire extinguisher are not true. https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/02/02/politics/brian-sicknick-charges/index.html https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2021/02/02/politics/brian-sicknick-c...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI really don't understand this perspective. There was a severe emergency situation which prompted this response! It's like watching the police lock down an apartment building in response to an active shooter, and saying "they've shown their hand, cops just want to keep everyone locked inside their home".
- saurik 6y agoI assume you mean the riot, for which all the organization happened on Facebook, not Parler?
- jamespo 6y agoI guess that's partly why they're reinstating the app then
- dataangel 6y agoParler users GPS data was leaked, showing Parler users deep in the capital during the insurrection: https://gizmodo.com/parler-users-breached-deep-inside-u-s-capitol-building-1846042905 https://gizmodo.com/parler-users-breached-deep-inside-u-s-ca... These geniuses were posting videos on Parler showing themselves during the insurrection.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y ago"All" isn't an accurate description. Much of it did happen on Facebook, and in response Facebook swiftly put in place new policies to prevent the situation from escalating. Unlike Facebook, Parler was unwilling to enact emergency measures, so instead emergency measures were enacted on them.
- saurik 6y agoFWIW, while I appreciate that you can technically pick at the word "all", if--as many people (I think correctly) believe--Parler was ancillary to the coordination (as in, without it existing the riot would certainly still have happened) but Facebook was key to it (as in, without it existing the riot might not have happened), I think the word "all" is appropriate, as that is how the word is used by actual English-speakers... think of the phrase "all of the nutrition in that meal is coming from the side of broccoli". Regardless, it doesn't seem like Facebook put in these supposed emergency policies anywhere near quickly enough, right? Here is an entire article talking about the nuances of blame here... I just really get the feeling like a big part of what happened with Parler was "big tech" realizing their own culpability and then having to organize around a scapegoat, lest anyone decided to come after them instead. https://www.salon.com/2021/01/16/despite-parler-backlash-facebook-played-huge-role-in-fueling-capitol-riot-watchdogs-say/ https://www.salon.com/2021/01/16/despite-parler-backlash-fac...
- commandlinefan 6y ago> Decentralization is going to happen. I wonder about that. If you think about it, Parler isn't particularly "decentralized", either. It isn't Twitter, but it is controlled and curated by a fairly arbitrary authority. In theory, if you didn't like Twitter's rules, and you didn't like Parler's rules, you could just move off to another competing service - if you or somebody else started one up (easy) and did the legwork of advertising it far enough that enough people used it to make it useful (hard). True decentralization would be something like Tor, I2P or Freenet, where all the users cooperate to share bandwidth and there's no plug to pull and no central dictator to ban content. However, truly decentralized services have been around for a long time now (I seem to recall installing Freenet once in the late 90's), and they have yet to catch on. As much as some of us fear the power of central planning, it seems as though the majority of people like knowing that there's nuclear kill switch that can be pulled if the communication platform gets to be too contentious.
- diebeforei485 6y agoBitclout is actually quite promising as a decentralized service, but they do require a phone number at signup (or alternatively, a payment at signup) as an anti-spam measure.
- throwawaymanbot 6y agoI'm surprised to see so many with agendas on here.. and by that I mean, blaming Apple. need we be reminded, Parler was used as a comms app for incredibly unsavory speech (being polite), and ultimately as an aid to some who wanted to try to overthrow the elected govt of the USA, not to mention calling for the Hanging/Murder of the Vice President of the USA (Its funny how the Law and Order group want rules bent for their own little adventures.) Free speech is one thing, but there's consequences for some of that "speech", and getting kicked of the apple platform is a fitting, if ludicrously light punishment for what was accepted as "speech" on Parler.
- shadowgovt 6y agoMy prediction (extrapolating from other large human-built systems) is that the infrastructure of the web will evolve into a soft bifurcation of companies that can leverage centralized Cloud infrastructure and companies that can't (for whatever reason... Infrastructural load too weirdly shaped, application too risky for service providers to want to sign off on it, pissed off the wrong people, etc.). People in the out-group will build more ad-hoc infrastructure for serving their needs, and we'll have a bifurcation into basically the "cleanweb" and the "trashweb" that will somehow (probably by URL shape) bubble up into the view of the end-user. Things on the cleanweb will be average, safe, and predictable. Various deviations from user expectation will be punished (up to and including having your service provider yank a piece of your service Jenga tower out from under you if they're irritated enough about the offense). The trashweb will spawn some serious beauty and truly novel things and an awful, awful lot of scams, hatred, illegal transactions, and garbage. And most people will constrain themselves to the cleanweb but the trashweb will see a robust userbase.
- bobthechef 6y agoWould be great if the internet and social media were treated like utilities. You could then prosecute people legally according to state laws for doing things like inciting violence.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI feel like "the damage is done" so to speak and Parler will forever be associated with negative connotations. Not just the associations with January 6th, but also with security breaches and having such detailed personal information leak from it. It missed it's shot at becoming a social media platform and I don't see why people wold come back to it now that it is on the App Store again. The free speech crowd has moved onto other platforms and the Trump people are awaiting Mike Lindell's new platform and/or the Donald Trump social media site that's rumored to be in the works.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoAFAIK the people that hold the negative connotations are not the people that were on the platform in the first place. I think people who were will likely flock back to it.
- r00fus 6y agoPerhaps all of that negative association was well deserved. I also feel the data dump of Parler messages was worse than getting delisted.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> Parler will forever be associated with negative connotations. Parler was created so people would be free of Twitter "Censorship". About the only thing Twitter censored was threats of violence or rape, election misinformation, or extremely blatant racism. Their only appeal was to people who found that kind of speech acceptable. If you market primarily to violent and racist people, you are absolutely going to be associated with negative connotations.
- bobthechef 6y agoWho told you that? I know of many cases where accounts were silenced for none of these reasons. Most recently, the Project Veritas guy was banned from Twitter for his "fake account" after posting a video of a CNN technical director describing CNN's role in ousting Trump[0]. [0] https://techcrunch.com/2021/04/15/twitter-bans-james-okeefe-of-project-veritas-over-fake-account-policy/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/04/15/twitter-bans-james-okeefe-...
- yabones 6y agoFrom the linked article [1]: > In court filings and elsewhere, Parler has said that it had been developing an artificial intelligence-based content moderation system when the larger platforms' crackdown took place. I can't see this ending well... ...Also, did they finalize a deal for hosting? I recall seeing their absurd hosting spec [2] that would have cost >$250K/mo, and I don't see that working anywhere other than AWS/GCP/Azure or a dedicated datacenter. [1] https://edition.cnn.com/2021/04/19/tech/apple-parler-app-store/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/04/19/tech/apple-parler-app-sto... [2] https://twitter.com/th3j35t3r/status/1350612426115452935 https://twitter.com/th3j35t3r/status/1350612426115452935
- input_sh 6y ago> ...Also, did they finalize a deal for hosting? Seems like it's SkySilk. NPR has more info about them: https://www.npr.org/2021/03/19/978210584/why-skysilk-came-out-of-nowhere-to-save-parler-after-capitol-riot https://www.npr.org/2021/03/19/978210584/why-skysilk-came-ou...
- yabones 6y ago> "It's not a side business for anything. It's not a shell company for anything," he said. I don't see how a company with "less than 50 employees" could possibly host something with that spec, reliably and securely. Maybe it's just grifters all the way down.
- tyingq 6y agoInteresting. They don't seem capable of matching the proposed specs: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Er5WmBxXUAEpICW?format=jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Er5WmBxXUAEpICW?format=jpg Maybe somebody reeled in the specs to something more reasonable.
- CodesInChaos 6y agoI wonder which of those "b"s are bits and which are bytes. e.g. is the external traffic 2 Gbit/s or 16 Gbit/s. And how many users do they have to need that amount of hardware?
- shadowmore 6y agoIs there some reason no digital platform producing company ever washes its hands of all moderation and leaves control of illegal activity to the people actually responsible for it (the FBI, NSA, local law enforcement, etc.)? Are companies actually liable somehow if they don't take proactive steps to mitigate illegal content, which nowadays also leads into heavy-handed censorship because of what they interpret as being borderline illegal (like "hateful speech")? In other words, is this a purely risk assessment related action, or an ideological one as someone like Alex Jones would shout into a mic?
- themacguffinman 6y agoDoesn't matter who's "actually responsible" for hateful and toxic speech if no one - neither users or advertisers - is willing to patronize your business for hosting that speech. Would you be willing to pay to use 4chan? If you ran another business, would you advertise on there? So ask yourself: if you owned a digital platform where users/advertisers were fleeing left & right because they constantly see vile content that they don't want to see or associate with, would you be content to wash your hands of moderation and impotently say "well actually the FBI/NSA is responsible for this, not me" as your platform dies around you?
- NathanKP 6y agoThe goal of most platforms is to get more adoption and more users. People who post hateful, weird, and/or borderline illegal content are mutually exclusive with the vast majority of other "normal" people. When the majority of people view something as tainting then the platform will remove it because hosting it will taint the platform and the majority of people will leave the platform, or not join it in the first place. Remember Voat. They wanted to be "free speech Reddit" but predictably they turned into a cesspool of degenerate users, even for a time hosting the r/jailbait folks who had been kicked off Reddit a long time ago. And unsurprisingly Voat never got mainstream and now it is dead, while Reddit is still online and growing more and more all the time. It isn't "censorship". It is optimization.
- zepto 6y agoWould you work for a cigarette company?
- pdog 6y agoThe chilling effect is real. Even if service is reinstated, the precedent is now that major platforms can arbitrarily censor your news stories for weeks, shut down your servers, and remove your apps from their app stores. Why would anyone build anything remotely controversial on these platforms?
- zepto 6y ago“Remotely controversial” might be an exaggeration.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sneak 6y agoTumblr's alt-porn community would like to disagree.
- zepto 6y agoWould they? What have they got to do with this?
- 1123581321 6y agoTumblr made it difficult to view NSFW content to appease the App Store. https://mashable.com/article/tumblr-bans-adult-content-policy/ https://mashable.com/article/tumblr-bans-adult-content-polic... There are some parallels as Tumblr similarly could not control its content sufficiently to both allow most of it and also ensure the problematic content did not persist. Just explaining, not defending either social network or Apple.
- zepto 6y agoOk but that isn’t ‘anything remotely controversial’.
- kokanator 6y agoTech censorship is very very real. https://censortrack.org/ https://censortrack.org/
- sneak 6y agoThis site seems like partisan agitprop. I agree that tech censorship is a problem, but it's a problem for humans, not just the american right-wing.
- kokanator 6y agoCompletely agree. Simply pointing to someone actually tracking censorship activities. It would be nice to see an inclusive set so we the humans could make our own decisions.
- throwawaysea 6y agoIt is a problem for everyone. Unfortunately just like censorship and political repression was used by the right in the past when they were dominant (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism) it is now used by the left. There are almost no organizations standing up for those civil liberties now. The ACLU is abandoning this mission (https://reason.com/2018/06/21/aclu-leaked-memo-free-speech/ https://reason.com/2018/06/21/aclu-leaked-memo-free-speech/) as they have become explicitly leftist rather than neutrally focused on fundamental civil liberties, so new institutions are needed. Right now, the side with the most motivation to champion this cause is the American right, which I think is why we're seeing sites like this.
- jb775 6y agoWhat a joke considering the damage is already done. Big tech coordinated to censor a major communication channel based on politics they didn't like.....during a presidential election season. This should be used as ammunition to break up Apple's monopoly on the app store.
- akiselev 6y agoThe election season was already over and the inauguration was less than two weeks away when Parler got banned.
- taxidump 6y agoAre you implying the ban was warranted at any point in time?
- knz_ 6y agoAre you admitting to supporting a terrorist group?
- Qub3d 6y agoThe reason for the ban was for failing to have a content moderation system at all. I think that was a fair thing to require. And now that Parler has proven it has a system in place, Apple has allowed them back on to their storefront. There are a lot of potential issues with the Parler ban -- namely the revelation of how monopolized online distribution is. But the ban had legitimate reasons behind it.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoPlanning a coup is not legitimate political dialog and no company should be required to host it.
- diebeforei485 6y agoApple is making the right call here. They are framing their actions as something they had to do in the moment due to the potential for violence, but don't want it to be permanent. I hope Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter unban Donald Trump next. None of the justifications they provided in January exist any longer. If they don't, I hope decentralized alternatives like BitClout start to take off.
- alexilliamson 6y agoI wish I had the data to create a Venn diagram of people who believe that bakeries should be able to refuse gay customers, and those who are screaming that big tech can't just arbitrarily decide who it does business with. I hear a lot of voices in these threads that would occupy the overlap of that Venn Diagram. The cognitive dissonance is really something.
- diebeforei485 6y agoThe issue with Big Tech is that: (1) They can't be sued (read: your case would be dismissed) for any of their decisions, because of Section 230. (2) They are also not a common carrier, and not subject to those restrictions. Essentially they get many of the benefits of being a common carrier, but without being a common carrier and having the associated obligations. That's the difference between Big Tech and bakeries. Big Tech could literally object to all LGBT content on their platform and because of Section 230, your case would be dismissed. Bakeries don't have anywhere near the amount of freedom as Big Tech enjoys from Section 230.
- tzs 6y ago> Big Tech could literally object to all LGBT content on their platform and because of Section 230, your case would be dismissed. I don't see how Section 230 is relevant there at all. Section 230 is about content that appears on your site, not content that does not appear on your site.
- indigo945 6y agoWhile I don't think bakeries should refuse gay customers, you have to admit that there is a difference in terms of social capital and political power between a local bakery and a multi-national company with more revenue than entire nation states' GDP?
- threatofrain 6y agoThis went to the Supreme Court, and will thus have a sort of permanence that may outlast your lifetime.
- anon776 6y agoand Parler is down due to them not understanding DNSSEC.