6 ms·
What Should We Do If Extraterrestrials Show Up?
- irrational 6y ago>It would be most appropriate to allocate taxpayer funds to the search for our cosmic neighbors I think this is the main focus of this opinion piece. I don't know who the author is, but I wouldn't be surprised that he would be someone writing grant proposals to get a piece of these funds.
- airza 6y agoHe is the guy who has been harping on ʻOumuamua being a UFO for the last few years.
- gus_massa 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avi_Loeb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avi_Loeb Aka the guy that proposed that the ʻOumuamua is a solar sail. (IIRC he is a good astrophysicist, but he is pushing the idea of the alien solar sail too hard.)
- bluGill 6y agoFirst thing is stop all grants to existing physicists. The law of relativity would have to be so wrong that we ccouldn't even trust our ability to turn on a light anymore. The speed of light is far too slow. If they exist (might or might not, either way is extraordinary), they are probably too far away to even know we are here (100 lightyears at the most, and probably less considering how fast radio weakens ), and then even longer to get here. In short they can't get here in anyone's lifetime.
- awb 6y agoThey could be as close as 4.2 light years away: https://www.space.com/proxima-b-alien-planet-earth-sized-espresso.html https://www.space.com/proxima-b-alien-planet-earth-sized-esp...
- happytoexplain 6y agoWhat's more, if they were already traveling through interstellar space before deciding to come this way, they could be anywhere, I suppose.
- bluGill 6y agoSure, but the number of possible stars within 100 light years is pretty small. The argument that there must be life all rest on the total number of stars within the universe, but the relevant life to humans communication needs to be within 10 light years (even then a 20 year round trip gives good odds we have figured out the answer to our question before we get their reply)
- tuatoru 6y ago> The speed of light is far too slow. Solar system escape velocity is about 5.5% of c according to a quick web search. So ca. 3000 years for 100 ly, allowing for acceleration and deceleration. The aliens would be fanatics to still be interested after that time. But in order to come to rest here, they'll have got around the laws of thermodynamics and the momentum-kinetic energy relation to produce engines with impossibly high specific impulse, thrust and efficiency. What we'd do is watch them whizz past.
- FridayoLeary 6y ago>3000 years for 100 ly, allowing for acceleration and deceleration. The aliens would be fanatics to still be interested after that time. Have you taken into account the relativity of time? If i've understood it correctly, time stops at the speed of light. For an alien travelling at that velocity, moving from one end of the universe to the other will take no time at all! No fanaticism required. How will they have time to stop? Also, does anyone know if an object with mass even move at the speed of light?
- watertom 6y agoFirst they would observe and they would learn that humans are fiercely bigoted and largely dependent on mythology, religion. Unless earth has something they want or need I doubt they would bother with us. If we did have something they needed a warlike, or non-peaceful race of aliens would come down and declare themselves as our God and creator, and after some advanced science demonstrations, all of the religious people of the world would fall in line. A peaceful or benevolent race of aliens would still probably avoid us unless it was absolutely necessary to contact us, and then I’m still not sure we’d be smart enough to understand everything that was happening.
- uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh 6y agoI like to imagine they've mastered FTL travel and adminstration of their vast empire by enslaving some other interstellar species and having them quite literally man the space sails and push space paper. Then they come to trade with us for our computer tech and food, in exhange for how they acheived FTL tech with nothing but prison labor.
- owyn 6y agoThere's an old short story by Alan Dean Foster touching on that idea. Earth is isolated behind a force field because it's considered so dangerous until an alien empire under pressure from an undefeatable foe has no option but to ask for help. No spoilers but it's a good story... With Friends Like These https://archive.org/details/withfriendsliket00fost https://archive.org/details/withfriendsliket00fost Another great story from that collection inspired the board game "Car Wars".
- saltyfamiliar 6y agoHard agree on both counts. I think people on the internet tend to underestimate how religious most people on earth still are. I know a person that's convinced that ufo sighting could potentially be "angels." And this is a fairly intelligent person with a first world education. I can only I imagine the havoc that an alien encounter would wreak on other parts of the world...
- 6y ago
- sys_64738 6y agoRun.
- mgarfias 6y agoMy thought too
- luckman212 6y agoYeah I'm sure you'll be able to outrun those silly aliens and their second-rate ships.
- cptaj 6y agoI know this one! Lets freak out in cable news networks and social media until we reach a fever pitch of cultural overheating where all rationality collapses and we lose our ability to function as a civilization.
- waheoo 6y agoBit late.
- darepublic 6y agoStop writing JavaScript for a moment and have a drink
- happytoexplain 6y ago> it took ‘Oumuamua more than 10,000 years to traverse the entire solar system Is there an error in this sentence or is the popular understanding (that it passed through briefly, for some definition of brief) incorrect?
- edgyquant 6y agoIt took 10,000 years from what I’ve read, which is a brief period for an astronomical timeframe
- optimalsolver 6y ago10K years is a blink of an eye in cosmic terms.
- bitcurious 6y agoI think the solar system as defined here extends out to the edge of the Oort Cloud. >https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oort_cloud https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oort_cloud > The outer limit of the Oort cloud defines the cosmographic boundary of the Solar System > The Oort cloud...is a theoretical cloud of predominantly icy planetesimals proposed to surround the Sun at distances ranging from 2,000 to 200,000 au (0.03 to 3.2 light-years).
- happytoexplain 6y agoThat explains it. I always forget the orders of magnitude involved between the smallest colloquial definitions of "the solar system" and the largest technical definitions. It looks like it was only in the planetary region for under a decade.
- zeeshanqureshi 6y agoWhat if they don't show up? What if man is like a virus to the universe and the answer to fermi paradox is that other life forms are intentionally distancing from us? I mean, just look at us.
- ghthor 6y agoA bit of a hyperbole to stereotype all humans as destructive.
- zeeshanqureshi 6y agoBeing destructive is alright, it is part of existing. We are non-aware and so we take limits lightly and act like there won't be consequences. Also I don't hate us. I just think we can do a lot better :) And hopefully we will.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Morvan 6y ago>humans you can say human beings or men, it's okay
- awb 6y agoWho knows what a million or billion year old civilization looks like, but there might be a decent chance that the first sign of extraterrestrial life is really mundane like some alien tardigrades floating through space inhabiting an asteroid. Or a small alien space probe with little to no identifying features of the civilization that built it or where it was launched from. If we’re talking about advanced aliens showing up in person, then we probably just acquiesce to whatever they want, or die resisting.
- ChrisSD 6y agoYour last paragraph is assuming they'd be interested in imposing their will upon us. They may simply not care. Meeting us may just be an interesting diversion or pure curiosity. Or they may be reluctant to get involved but sympathetic enough to offer a select few technological advances, if we want them. There are a lot of possibilities which don't result in full surrender or a fight to the death.
- dsyrk 6y agoEarth is likely very very valuable galactic real estate. Terraforming barren planets or moons is incredibly energy intensive. Assembling habitats in space also potentially quite frustratingly complex. Earth from a technical perspective has incredible resources. Aren’t we already pointing our latest telescopes at nearby solar systems looking for “habitable” planets? They are gonna want your planet sorry. Maybe they will work out an Indian reservation like proposal because the guilt is hard for them.
- kiba 6y agoIt takes ridiculous energy to get here. They can do that at home with all the resources available to them. Beside, why the heck would you transform an entire planet when you can build your own custom made space habitats? Anyway, we're looking for habitable planets not to colonize them but to find signs of life elsewhere in the universe.
- 6y ago
- de6u99er 6y agoI would ask them to take me with them.
- haolez 6y agoI've always found curious that we think extraterrestrials must be a civilization. If we define life as an entity that strives to perpetuate itself, then the fact that we are separate individuals is just a hack to make us evolve and survive in a harsh environment. After some level of technological advancement, a futurist civilization might simply converge into a sole being, an unified intelligence. I'll wait for the science fiction experts to point me to some books exploring this idea :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jtsiskin 6y agoYou may like this, one of my favorite short stories: https://templatetraining.princeton.edu/sites/training/files/the_last_question_-_issac_asimov.pdf https://templatetraining.princeton.edu/sites/training/files/...
- e-master 6y agoAsimov’s Foundation series is pretty much what you’re talking about.
- eikenberry 6y agoStar Trek's Borg are an interesting step along this line of thought. They are a collective intelligence, described as a collection of individual consciousnesses, which may or may not count as a "sole being". But how their collection is unified and organized is interesting to think about.
- api 6y agoThe Borg are much easier to imagine today than they were in the 90s. Incredibly prescient bit of sci-fi. How does the collective work? They’re all jacked into the boards constantly meme-ing each other. That’s how the whole thing got started in the first place too. You had a weird cult like Qanon get memed into existence and then they got Neuralink. Then the cult became a malignant superintelligence that set about conquering the universe to exterminate the Satanic pedophiles. “We are Borg! Resistance is futile! Where we go one we go all!” Something like that... very easy to imagine. We are close.
- javajosh 6y agoIntelligent life might show up on a ship of some kind, perhaps in a desperate last attempt to outlast the techno-eco disaster that destroyed their ecosphere. Then, of course, they'd be weak from the journey, and we'd kill them and find a reason to ignore the obvious lesson.
- elliekelly 6y ago> Then, of course, they'd be weak from the journey, and we'd kill them... Are there any examples from human history where explorers have arrived on “new” land and have then been defeated by those already inhabiting it? It seems like those arriving tend to have more advanced technology and even when they’re starving and weak manage to conquer. For humans, at least, I suspect “victory” goes to the visitors far more often. But if, by some miracle, the humans prevailed I think you’re unfortunately correct about us conveniently ignoring the lesson.
- cgriswald 6y agoYes. Lots of examples. The problem for the natives is that there were more coming. That may or may not be the case in the scenario the GP describes.
- tzs 6y ago> Are there any examples from human history where explorers have arrived on “new” land and have then been defeated by those already inhabiting it? Europeans in North America. For a long time any colony that was founded only survived if the natives allowed it. Yes, the Europeans had guns vs. bows and arrows, but the guns at the time sucked. Bows and arrows were faster to fire, faster to reload, and had better accuracy. It wasn't until some tribes that were not doing well in wars with other tribes made alliances with the Europeans that Europeans really started to get established. Later the diseases that came with the Europeans tore through the whole continent, rapidly reducing the native population by over 90% and then Europeans could pretty much take over anything they wanted to.
- meowster 6y agoWell, this story is a part of our history in the sense that we wrote it: The Road Not Taken by Harry Turtledove (It's a great, short sci-fi story for anyone that may be interested. It should be pretty easy to find the PDF.)
- Simplicitas 6y agoarticle admits we have a million years to think about this
- King-Aaron 6y agoWe'd ignore them, and a bunch of people on HN would militantly deny that they couldn't possibly have navigated the vast distances across space to get here. Then we die from their space smallpox.
- gruez 6y ago>and a bunch of people on HN would militantly deny that they couldn't possibly have navigated the vast distances across space to get here. This is a mischaracterization of their position. What those people probably meant is that given an unexplained phenomena, the chances that an alien involved is small, therefore we should look for more benign and more likely explanations. It doesn't mean that if an unambiguously alien ship showed up on earth that they'll deny its existence.
- kiba 6y agoThen we die from their space smallpox. Unlikely we will die from their version of smallpox, because they aren't likely to share human DNA. Remember, we are literally surrounded by viruses. We eat them all the time. The vast majority are completely harmless anyway. They have their specific targets.
- cgriswald 6y agoI don’t share your confidence. We’d be exposed to multitudes of new viruses any one of which could potentially find a host in us. We’d have no specific defenses and they may have novel (to Earth life) means of infecting hosts.
- koolba 6y agoDon’t forget the part where instead of trying to create something useful from the vast technological advances that they’d provide, we instead use it to compute cryptographic hashes slightly faster than the week prior.
- platz 6y agoWhat if they are like a space fungus.
- 6y ago
- booleandilemma 6y agoHope they treat us with the same level of respect, civility, and kindness that we would show to aliens if we were a spacefaring civilization? /s
- motohagiography 6y agoThe things that would necessarily be true would be that, they would have superior weapons and tech, they would both arrive and reveal their presence (generally) on purpose, the outcomes are pretty binary where it's either to elevate our species or suppress it, they are somewhat like us (as to huge ones we might as well be bacteria, and to microscopic ones, we're monsters) and there would need to be some condition they were waiting for that made revealing themselves both economical and necessary. Mere benevolent altruism doesn't justify the energy costs to travel space, there has to be something else they need from us. The discipline that has the most predictive power about their intentions is likely economics. Maybe they want to use us as an expendable species of space-apes for further colonization of new planets. It's an upgrade the same way being a research chimp is an upgrade. However, given the time/distance they've traveled they'd be adapted for space faring, and not planet dwelling, so in terms of their deficits, muscles developed under gravity aren't their specialty. Their bodies would be the absolute minimum necessary to contain and sustain their minds, reproduce, and operate their tech, to where what we encounter or perceive would likely be exoskeletons. What minerals are unique to a planet like ours (other than life) that can't be found with less hassle than getting here, elsewere in the universe? What should we do? Listen. Learn. Then negotiate. They need us for something, and anything less than the fairest possible terms is going to be very bad for our species.
- trhway 6y agoI always felt that the alternative version of Vulcan contact is more true to life. After all we've successfully dealt with other human species, and the highly developed aliens who probably overcame their anger, violence, etc. may be in for a surprise.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- plank_time 6y agoIf a civilization is so advanced that it can reach us, then we have to assume that they are here to take our resources. We can take a peaceful approach but we should have our finger on a nuclear arsenal in case they decide they are bored with us and want our water and minerals. But chances are they would know everything about us already and would anticipate that as well.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoHere is my thesis by which humans can never be exterminated by an aggresive alien race directly via attack: For a universe that is infinite and provided there are no aggressive alien races within our inmediate stellar neighborhood, it would break the rules of economics for humans to be attacked, whether for resources or for sport. This is because for any alien to actually visit us, they would need FTL travel tech. If they do have FTL, then such tech would dramatically reduce the cost of travel to nil. This would make any point in the galaxy reachable inmediately at almost no cost. Therefore, at that point, any valuable resource of earth... would also be reachable at the same cost at another earth-like planet. Except the latter would be without pesky humans on it. Or, if you had infinite kit Kat bars in front of you, you would always pick the one without any ants on it. Similarly, any aggressive alien race with FTL would not exterminate humans for sport. They may kill some similar to how you handle a roach, but any species unrestrained by resource limits (again, FTL) the tendencies for conflict will have naturally died out of the gene pool.
- platz 6y agoWe don't know that the universe is infinite. Also, even if space was infinite, that doesn't mean that low-entropy energy/matter (to extract energy/work from) is also infinite.
- orwin 6y ago> low-entropy energy/matter (to extract energy/work from) A word i like for that is exergy. Energy you can extract.
- xwolfi 6y agoYou also don't know for sure (or have not explained) the rationale for saying that: - a society (really ? Do they also have city halls and a bi-party congress?) - unrestrained by resource limits (that you understand, because I can tell you that when you swallow suns you possibly have a limit eventually you wouldn't want to run out of) - lost its tendency for conflict - front the gene pool (that's very optimistic to think they would have genes, working like ours, in a context of natural selection similar to ours: with a bit of luck, we could have had 2 intelligent, non-sexually compatible, species of hominids, and I suspect things would have been very different in term of what sport-killing means). Me I can absolutely imagine a species of metallic robots created by a far away biologic equivalent who are so absolutely bored that reducing biological life to ashes became a way to escape, to feel something. They can switch off time perceptions, travel everywhere at whatever speed, reproduce programmatically and don't suffer from maternal instinct or mirror neuron empathy. Their vast intelligence does generates curiosity, which in turn generates boredom when there's nothing new to do or see. We became their latest weekend sport event, and they'll move on as fast as they've exterminated us, on to the next surprise of life.
- donclark 6y agoSphere movie plot via 1998? https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120184/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120184/ spoilers = we cant handle (arent ready for) the truth
- ufmace 6y agoImpossible to say in general. It depends on how they got here, what kind of beings they are, what their intentions are, etc. Could be ignore, cooperate, bend over and kiss your ass goodbye, or any number of other things.
- eucryphia 6y agoBe nonchalant: G'Day guys, we've been wondering when you'd show up.
- mrbonner 6y agoThe prime directive would prevent them from revealing their true self to us :-)
- ncmncm 6y agoChances are they came to visit with the sequoia redwood trees, and will be very upset to find them all cut down. Then we will have about a decade until they notice and react. http://cantrip.org/slow.pdf http://cantrip.org/slow.pdf
- drivingmenuts 6y agoAny civilization capable of crossing the vast distance of space, intact, has sufficiently advanced technology to render anything we have as pointless. We better surrender immediately and pray to whatever deity we do or don’t believe in that the newcomers are benevolent. Our species might survive, but our society is toast.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoTL;DR: We don't know. Let's look for aliens first. What the hell, Scientific American.