6 ms·
Paternoster Lift
- efrafa 6y agoThere was one at the college where I studied. Scary as hell :)
- Someone 6y agoThat page got me to https://www.humphrey-manlift.com/belt-manlift/ https://www.humphrey-manlift.com/belt-manlift/ It surprises me that, apparently, you can still buy these. They look too risky to me for modern risk-averse society (what if personnel carries a ruck sack? Is too voluminous to fit through that floor hole?)
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoI assume this is addressed by only having them accessible for trained personnel vs. the general public. It could also be solved by having a pressure sensitive, breakaway panel that stops the lift (triggers one stopping distance before a hard edge is reached).
- bombcar 6y agoI don’t really see that as much more dangerous than various other forms of heavy equipment - think bucket trucks and those forklift attachments that turn them into bucket trucks - vs climbing a power pole.
- jjt-yn_t 6y agoWhile they were in use in the 1980s, where I worked, 50 yards or so away was the elevator option if you were carrying anything, say, not belt-attachable thus leaving both hands free for the manlift. Great timesaver. Some years later removed and the concrete space covered with a metal plate.
- magnawave 6y agoThought the exact thing the first time I saw one in a Chicago full service parking garage. And they had very stern signs about being for employees only. So ya that’s likely how they solve the liability problem. But man they looked really cool. So wanted to try it out ;)
- URSpider94 6y agoFunny, that’s the one and only place I’ve seen one as well (it was 35 years ago, on the Gold Coast just north of downtown...). I was just gearing up to post about this when I saw your post.
- analog31 6y agoMy dad told me about those, in the factory where he worked. He said that once a guy put his tool caddy on the platform, the guy at the top forgot to take it off for him, and the whole place was raining tools.
- jjgreen 6y agoTerrific things, there is one at the University in Sheffield. At the start of each academic year, freshers dare each-other to "go around the bottom" to the extent that there are stern warnings posted about this unbalancing the mechanism and leading to it stopping working (I'm pretty sure that's not true).
- dash2 6y agoEssex has (had?) one too, with the warning/invitation: "Overtravel in lift is not dangerous, but not recommended."
- scroot 6y agoShout out to the arts tower at Uni Sheffield, the first place I ever saw one of these!
- shazzy 6y agoHere is a segment that The One Show did on the University in Sheffield one, for anyone who is interested in seeing it in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAjYAfb_HPk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAjYAfb_HPk
- KineticLensman 6y agoWe routinely over traveled in the paternoster in the Lecture theatres at the Uni of Leeds in the 1980s. If you were on the top floor the queues to go down could be very long so it was faster to go up and over and effectively jump the queu. Never saw any injuries, incidentally
- dang 6y agoIf curious, past threads: Paternoster Lifts: Cyclic Chain Elevators with No Buttons, Doors or Stops (2016) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16562742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16562742 - March 2018 (112 comments) Lovin' their elevator: why Germans are loopy about paternosters - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058885 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10058885 - Aug 2015 (56 comments) Paternoster - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9284672 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9284672 - March 2015 (72 comments)
- Waterluvian 6y agoI'm shocked that they're estimated as being only 30x more dangerous than conventional elevators. I would have guessed thousands of times more dangerous.
- hibbelig 6y agoHaving used one, I guess people just behave differently. For example, when riding an elevator, you might be looking at your smartphone, but if you take the stairs, you don't. Getting onto and off a paternoster is pretty exciting, so you won't be bored enough to look at the smartphone :-)
- zeotroph 6y agoConventional closing-doors elevators are just absurdly safe, even stairs (moving or non-moving) are more dangerous. People die around elevators when climbing onto the roof when it gets stuck or forcing the doors open instead of staying put. Once it gets moving again bad things can happen. But as hinted at in the safety section, with modern sensors and some brains behind them paternoster can be made safe. You can even make them wheelchair accessible by gradually stopping a cabin and informing all other passengers about that. And when a department in a large and busy office building is spread across a few floors then a paternoster is the most efficient way of moving between floors.
- throwawayboise 6y ago> Conventional closing-doors elevators are just absurdly safe, even stairs (moving or non-moving) are more dangerous. I used this argument when my workplace was encouraging people to "take the stairs" for supposed health reasons. It was rejected because science and statistics are only accepted when they support one's desired conclusions.
- Symbiote 6y agoThe health improvements might outweigh the risk of injury from falling on the stairs. This is the case for cycling vs driving to work in at least some cities.
- amelius 6y agoProbably more dangerous than a Peloton threadmill.
- lmilcin 6y agoI think this is wrong way to use word "dangerous". "Dangerous" should be left for when it easy for a normal person to get hurt or get somebody else hurt even when they are attentive and act rationally. A device that can suddenly explode when correctly used is "dangerous". I think this lift is perfectly safe as is Peloton threadmil, knives, cars, and bunch other stuff, because each can be operated safely and more than that, it is with a capability of a normal person to operate the device safely. Whether they choose to do so is another matter. The threadmill cases were due to adults leaving safety keys in the threadmill. How is a threadmill with a functional safety key described as "dangerous" because some stupid parent left it with a key in? If you are a moron you can make anything dangerous.
- dbavaria 6y agoWhat stops a child/pet from injury even when an adult is properly using the safety key? Plastic bags are not inherently dangerous to most adults, but we consider them to be a danger for animals and small children. Danger in this context extends to more than your target demographic for a product.
- alisonkisk 6y agoYou'll find communication easier if you use the common shared meanings of words.
- rozab 6y agoTom Scott: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgJBD1wf-YQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgJBD1wf-YQ
- the-dude 6y agoIn the 80ies I saw a paternoster filing cabinet at a municipality.
- lb1lf 6y agoPaternoster lifts (or a close relative[0]) are sometimes used in warehouses; at a former employer we had two units with X shelves - probably around 20 - each, storing a metric shitload of parts. (Each shelf being approx. 1x4m/3.3x13ft) Did sound a bit like the Götterdämmerung while it did its thing, but absurdly efficient space utilization. 0) Close relative as the mechanism is the same, however they tend to only run when a specific storage location is requested, not continuously.)
- throwawayboise 6y agoHave seen them at libraries. Somehow they are able to dump off containers of books at the proper floor for reshelving.
- dukoid 6y agoThe police office in Babylon Berlin has one
- cecja 6y agoI worked in an agency that had one of these in germany. You are not allowed to build new ones but the ones that are installed can still be used. It's kinda scary for the first three or four times but after that it's an amazing use of transportation in an office. The thing that most people freaks out is going over the turn because everything is dark and you see the motors directly in front of your face. We dressed ours up as tunnel of horror on halloween, good times.
- omnibrain 6y agoThere is also the "man engine" which was used in mines until the developement of steel cable based lifts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_engine
- rkagerer 6y agoThe animation looks dangerous, but it's neat to read workers liked them and they were safer in practice than ladders.
- karmakaze 6y agoThe first I ever knew of it was in the 1985 German comedy Manner (Men) that featured it in the credits. Intensifyingly funny. [0] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0089656/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0089656/
- ndom91 6y agoHave ridden the ones at Goethe Uni in Frankfurt, Germany. Love them!
- eliaspro 6y agoAlthough new Paternosters most likely will never be built, the Thyssen-Krupp Multi has been in development for quite some time now and the result partially resembles Paternoster, but adds things like per-cabin independence and freely routed (also horizontal) movement to the whole idea. https://youtu.be/E7QlAsxJP-g https://youtu.be/E7QlAsxJP-g I don't know whether there are plans for an actual deployment of this technology right now, but the idea and concept by itself is fascinating.
- flog 6y agoBy the voiceover, I can always tell a German company produced english video. There's a very particular accent.
- majewsky 6y agoInteresting. I'm German, and I cannot recognize any sort of German accent in this.
- lbotos 6y agoNot OP for me, Mobility at 47 was a hint, but it's not super noticeable. Dunno what they were picking up on.
- somedangedname 6y agoSeconding grandparent's assessment. The speaking style in the video is very similar to Deutsche Welle broadcasts that I used to watch in uni. Not sure if this style happens organically when native German speakers master English or if it's a deliberate choice like the Transatlantic Accent of early 20th century American actors.
- ac42 6y agoPerhaps not the accent. But there's a chance you would cut your sentences a tinge differently when not based on a German original.
- 6y ago
- dTal 6y agoI wonder what it is about this that captures the Hacker News imagination? Something about it being a "better" solution which we, as a society, have been inexplicably denied?
- nelsonmandela 6y agoWhy don't they have them tick like clocks so it actually stops at a floor?
- alisonkisk 6y agoWikipedia days Hitachi launched one that does that. Why never before? Because modern elevators were invented.
- inglor_cz 6y agoThere are some Paternosters still in operation in Czechia. Funny stuff when you're young, but any infirmity or trouble walking pretty much precludes you from using them.
- jiripospisil 6y agoI used to use one almost every day when I was studying at CVUT FEL. Sure it looks cool but riding it is not all that great. If you are alone, it's relatively fine. But when multiple people want to get in or out it becomes quite a hassle because you need to move before the lift fully reaches the floor, otherwise there's not enough time for the others. Also, do you know what happens if you touch the inside of the lift's shaft? The whole freaking thing immediately stops. Guess how I know. If you're curious about what it actually looks like when you loop around, have a look at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ey5b3qm3-EI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ey5b3qm3-EI
- Scene_Cast2 6y agoSki lifts & air trams solved this problem by uncoupling the passenger unit from the cable at the entry / exit stations - the chairs therefore "loiter" around the passenger area for longer. I think another commenter mentioned a similar system, too.
- ddek 6y agoSadly, impractical in this case. The ski lifts work because there are (usually) only two (but occassionally 3) terminals. In contrast, the point of a paternoster is that every floor is a terminal.
- bombcar 6y agoIf it hadn’t been surpassed by regular elevators you could easily design one that would “drop” a car at a floor and then the next hook would pick it up. Or just stop turning for a bit. Not worth it likely.
- ddek 6y agoNot at all, IMO. I did a little bit of reasoning after reading this thread (I fucking love paternosters), and thought that any measure you could take to improve the safety or efficiency would likely have a detrimental effect. For example, if you did decouple the carriages at the floors, then there would be a period of accelleration where embarkment would be much more dangerous. People would still attempt to jump onto the carriages during this phase, because we can't avoid people being people. I know for sure I'd take that risk. I think the way they're run now (slow and steady) is ideal, and investing heavily in sensors so they can stop and restart quickly elevates this. Overengineered solutions about coupling and (god help us) doors will probably solve a couple of minor issues and create a few new major ones.
- iancmceachern 6y agoI did a senior design project in school with the Coors Brewery, largest in the US (world?). I'll always remember their "manlifts" that never stop, and can take you to all floors of the Brewery. Like these... https://youtu.be/fCPRAjWn8hU https://youtu.be/fCPRAjWn8hU
- andyjohnson0 6y agoThe university that I went to in the late eighties had a paternoster in a tall (10+ floor) building and they were great fun. Very quick and easy to move between floors. I always liked using them. I remember zoneing out once while riding them and accidentally going over the top. From what I remember there was a sign on the wall that faced the compartment after it passed the top floor cautioning you to keep still - presumbly so you didn't trigger a motion sensor while your cab engaged with the drive wheel. It was no big deal. Second year students used to scare the nervous first year newbies by going under or over and emerging standing on their hands.
- brundolf 6y agoThe name was the most interesting part for me: > The name paternoster ("Our Father", the first two words of the Lord's Prayer in Latin) was originally applied to the device because the elevator is in the form of a loop and is thus similar to rosary beads used as an aid in reciting prayers.
- dcminter 6y agoHuh. I always assumed it was because they looked a bit like a confessional with the two doors side-by-side. Many years ago I worked in Viscount House (since demolished) at Heathrow Airport where there was a paternoster lift. One day a workman tried to take a wooden ladder through it - it didn't fit. The result was... loud. I thought it was quite fun to use, but for years after I had minor nightmares about being in the thing with various things going wrong. My subconscious apparently wasn't a fan!
- vbsteven 6y agoIn Flemish (and probably Dutch but not sure) the word paternoster is used for rosary beads. I had never heard of the paternoster lift before now but just hearing the name made it immediately clear to me what it was.
- dcminter 6y agoIt makes perfect sense; I just never questioned the etymology I invented.
- User23 6y agoNah, the joke was that you ought to say your prayers before using the thing.
- zeke 6y agoThere were several in Stuttgart. One at a Uni building, which I've heard is now defunct. Two are in the Stuttgart Rathaus. They may still be in service. I was showing my son that the floor will fold up so it won't cut your foot off, but I did not see the switch attached. The floor edge folded up, the switch stopped the Paternoster and sounded the alarm. I apologized to people there that there was no real problem and waited a few minutes for them to turn it back on. My son told on me when we got home.
- User23 6y agoI’d like to know if the Rathaus one is still going. I rode through the top once and it was a little scary.
- ddek 6y agoI wish they weren't as dangerous. They really are a huge improvement on the conventional elevator in terms of efficiency. At Sheffield, many people are scared of the paternoster so choose the elevators opposite. I'd guess the paternoster riders still outnumber that crowd, by at least a factor of 5. Despite the pressure, there was rarely a queue for the paternoster at 0845, but there was for the two massive elevators opposite. The elevator congestion gets so bad the university employs an attendant, with one carriage assigned to the odd floors, and the other the evens. The paternoster is just so much easier. You don't have to press a button, wait ages, then have multiple slow stops en-route. You do occassionally have to wait for a carriage - Sheffield had max 2 per carriage, and it is generally considered rude to get in a carriage with a stranger outside of peak hours. There's also the risk of stoppages, which are particularly painful if your carriage is in the ~1.5m window between floors (+/- 1m based on your athleticism) where you can't find a way to get out. In that case, I hope you're not claustrophobic.
- d1sxeyes 6y agoI'm not sure when you were there, but when I was there, there were huge queues in the morning. People used to sneak downstairs and jump on the paternoster either before it went under the bottom or as it was going up. Very bad form, but people did it. Admittedly, more often at 0859 than 0845...
- andrepd 6y agoObligatory Tom Scott: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgJBD1wf-YQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgJBD1wf-YQ
- edem 6y agoWhen I was a kid I always wanted to go up to the top but I was afraid that it would turn upside down and I'd fall on my face. I still regret not trying it.
- Vaslo 6y agoLiterally lost 30 mins on YouTube watching these things in action. Thanks?
- FiddlerClamp 6y agoIn David Lodge's novel, "Small World," there's a great scene where one character chases another through a paternoster. The one being chased thinks that the compartment will flip over when it reaches the top, and comes down standing on his head!
- herodoturtle 6y agoCame here expecting to find a heart-warming hitch-hiking story about the quaint village of Paternoster in South Africa. Learnt about an inventive passenger elevator instead! :-)
- grishka 6y agoRiding one of these is definitely on my todo list, but afaik we don't have any in my country.
- inopinatus 6y agoHey, it's a ring buffer for people. Traditionally, "rotating" a ring buffer meant incrementing the pointer to the start, or (equivalently) the offset within the ring. But, given where modern processor architectures are at; if the data fits in CPU cache, could there be circumstances where it's better to rotate the entire buffer?
- flybrand 6y agoI checked one of these out in Prague after seeing this in a past HN posting. Pretty cool. Definitely some safety concerns, but it beats the stairs in an old walk-up.
- vages 6y agoI see a lot of links to the Tom Scott video in this thread, but I found this one from Atomic Frontier more informative: https://youtu.be/-Kq1D6FS7LM https://youtu.be/-Kq1D6FS7LM
- mbalyuzi 6y agoI remember the Sheffield ones well from the early 90's. I imagine Sheffield University are stuck with them, there simply isn't enough space in the building core for conventional lifts to meet the requirement to move a lot of students up and down the building in the short space of time between lectures. I do remember the conventional lifts being quite big, but with long waits.
- aidenn0 6y agoI wonder: We have ski lifts that detach from the cable so that they can move at a different speed when loading than when transporting. It seems like a similar thing could be done with an elevator so that there is a continuously moving cable, but it detaches from the cable to stop at a floor, and then reattaches after loading. You could add traditional doors, and a safety mechanism that halts the cable if a door fault causes a potential collision. Perhaps added costs of this system make it less desirable than just adding more elevator shafts.
- cjjp 6y agoThis would basically be a cable car but vertically? I remember being most fascinated by the Skyride at Alton Towers as it works like this.
- felixg3 6y agoI am so glad to live in the city with still operational, publicly accessible Paternoster. The city is called Wuppertal and it the Paternoster is in the city hall. Its worth a visit, we also have the Schwebebahn. Otherwise its a bit of a screwed up post-industrial city. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternosteraufzug#/media/Datei:GER_Wuppertal_Rathaus_002_2013_-_Paternoster.jpg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternosteraufzug#/media/Datei... https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternosteraufzug#/media/Datei:GER_Wuppertal_Rathaus_002_2013_-_Paternoster.jpg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternosteraufzug#/media/Datei...