14 ms·
Public-ownership rental as a third option to renting or owning a house
- seibelj 6y agoIf this is such a good idea, why don’t they raise private funds from various charities and rich people to fund an experiment? Why am I as a taxpayer constantly asked to fund ever more schemes? This one has the all markings of a non-profit, and if you involve the government and associated bureaucracy it will become an entrenched quagmire like the huge housing projects that have been torn down in many cities. I don’t see why we need a trillion-dollar slush fund to make this happen.
- zhdc1 6y agoExpanding on this, there are already similar schemes out there, and they've done nothing to stop property price inflation. Abstracting away ownership from the property to a collective legal entity ignores the main reason why people 'own' property in the first place - property needs to be actively maintained, and when it's not, those affected need to be able to identify and movitiate a responsible party. Even when you own stock in a cooperative, you're responsible for the part you live in. Once you tie in financing, insurance, and utilities, you're left with something that looks an awfully lot like property ownership, except with a slightly different fee structure.
- chii 6y ago> ignores the main reason why people 'own' property in the first place no, the main reason people own property is to extract profit from it (or extract utility - essentially the same thing). Maintenance is merely a hinderance that they put up with in order to maximize said utility/profit extraction. If it were possible to create a property with no need for maintenance, the owners would opt for that!
- zhdc1 6y agoOwnership is a legal fiction. In the context of common law countries, the state originally held final "ownership" over all land. People largely weren't allowed to own property in the modern sense of the term until after the Statute of Westminster (1290), which was passed after it became too difficult for courts to resolve who, exactly, was responsible for what (and for how long, and what was owed in return) under the older feudal system. I'm sure a lawyer or someone with a better understanding of the history behind all of this can chime in, but the concept of ownership is very much tied to the state's need to know who is responsible for each piece of land, whether for taxation, ensuring upkeep, or for resolving court disputes.
- bennysomething 6y agoI agree. Also how does this system change the cost of housing over all. I don't see how it changes anything. The simple reason rents are high in some areas is supply and demand. Will this increase supply? Or reduce demand in those areas. Doubt it.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThis is "the rest of the story" on a recent HN submission which was not as it turns out the "rent vs. buy" polemic much of the discussion seemed to expect (not without some basis given the headline and structure of the article), but actually a fairly radical, and intersting, housing policy proposal. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26824383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26824383 The article's author has in fact written a book on the subject, a chapter of which is exerpted here. (I've chosen the chapter title rather than article title for the submission.) The previous article had somehow managed to completely omit mention. The book itself is The Affordable City, by Shane Phillips, from Island Press: https://islandpress.org/books/affordable-city https://islandpress.org/books/affordable-city
- dang 6y agoYou're right that https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26824383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26824383 was completely derailed by its title, which often happens with sensational titles, especially about universal topics like housing, food, health, transportation. But I don't think https://www.planetizen.com/features/110948-affordable-city-offers-solutions-us-housing-affordability-crisis https://www.planetizen.com/features/110948-affordable-city-o... (the URL you submitted here) is a very good alternative—it seems kind of boring (mostly platitudes and cheerleading), and doesn't seem to cover the interesting bit, which is the specific proposal that you reference. So I've changed the URL back to the Atlantic article for now, with a variation of the subtitle which references that specific idea. If there's a third article which is even better, we can change it again.
- dredmorbius 6y agoYeah, it's kind of a hard dig. The Atlantic piece at least eventually gets around to describing the proposal. It manages to completely avoid any mention of the author's book (which I'd submitted as an addition), which is ... several shades of perplexing. The chapter extract also isn't the best though at least it points to the larger work. The two items in tandem ... kind of help get the message through? (I'm doing some further digging on the initiative, proposal, Lewis Center, and Phillips in parallel with the discussion here. In a world of pretty tired and unimaginative suggestions regarding housing, this at least has some novel and possibly even likely elements, though it probably needs to be combined with other initiatives, most especially those discouraging idle land and real estate asset inflation. Phillips could use some coaching on persuasive writing and outreach as well....) This is good for now.
- zhdc1 6y agoHow is this any different from owning shares in a housing cooperative? Aside from the risk being - possibly - divided across multiple properties, I don't see how this would solve the main issues driving appreciating housing prices any better than attacking their root causes (build more housing supply, limit housing speculation, and prevent overleveraging).
- nemo44x 6y agoThat’s what I was thinking. However, there are some co-Ops in NYC that allow you to buy shares at a really cheap price VS what the market would pay. But when you sell, the co-op sells the shares so although you profit, you won’t be as much as if it were sold at market value. But you paid below market so it works out. However, these aren’t just open to anyone. You need to know people to get in. It’s a self policing community that takes care of each other over generations. Even if you’re “in”, you’ll likely be on a waiting list until availability opens up.
- zhdc1 6y agoA lot of older condominiums in the states were originally housing cooperatives because the legal structure at the time didn't have an easy way to handle communal living (e.g., apartments). There are even more of them in Europe, although you're generally expected to pay a significantly higher amount up front and actively participate in common area maintenance and (in some cases) participate in social activities and the like.
- bennysomething 6y ago"those losses aren’t equitably distributed, either: Nearly 2 million mortgages are underwater in the U.S., and they’re disproportionately concentrated in Black and Latino communities. Tenants in coastal cities, meanwhile, know the pain of forking over more and more rent every year, unable to save for a down payment and living at the mercy of sometimes unscrupulous landlords." What on earth does not equitable mean in terms of distributing losses? Secondly "living at the mercy" hold on, renters aren't tenant farmers who can't leave their lord's land. People do actually choose to live in expensive rented accommodation. They make the choice that the property location etc is worth more than the cash, to them.
- berdario 6y agoPeople cannot actually choose the location, without giving up their work. "You can only find work in a big metropolitan center that demands 60% of your salary in rent? Though luck..." Let's say that you work in London... if you are 1h away from your work, you're still likely in zone 3 or 4, which is pretty expensive. Your choices then are: a 1h30/2h commute (each way) or giving up on having a place only for yourself, and start flatsharing
- aeternum 6y agoYes, we should probably treat land as much more of a public good, especially in cities. The true value of land has much more to do with the services nearby: jobs, shops, parks, emergency services. The majority of tax should be based on the land value, independent of the cost of structures built on that land. A single-family home (whether it be a shack or a million dollar mansion) in a city center with high land value is depriving the city of a lot of potential utility and should be taxed in proportion to that.
- drewmate 6y agoYou might find Georgism [0] interesting. Its tenets include a (steep) land value tax that proponents believe would sort out the 'best use' of land in city centers. It's a compelling idea, but unfortunately the driving force behind American government seems to be once you have something (property, a business, etc...) nobody can do anything that adversely affects it. And Americans (over age 40) already own a LOT of property and would not take kindly to new taxes on it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism#Main_tenets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism#Main_tenets
- fallingknife 6y ago> A third option is necessary: a way to rent without making someone else rich. I care how much I pay. I don't give a shit who gets it.
- berdario 6y agoIf buy-to-let is profitable, people will do it as a business... If people do it as a business, it'll drive the price of housing up even more, and since businesses have more capital than workers, the latter will be priced out (if lucky, they'll be able to afford a 90% LTV which will take decades to repay, but most workers cannot afford it on their own) If you care how much you pay, you care about who is extracting money out of you
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat does not follow - they are still fulfilling housing demand by renting it and more capital means more ability to build houses. The whole premise appears telological - landlords are intrinsically bad ergo everything they do will make the housing situation worse.
- berdario 6y agoYou're mixing up home builders with landlords. The latter aren't fulfilling housing demand: they are capturing it by outcompeting people who cannot afford property prices (prices driven up by buy-to-let demand). You say that landlords are intrinsically bad: lots of people agree with you on that... I stop short of it, since there's a minority of people for which renting is a preferable solution (at least temporarily) and nationalising the whole housing market is infeasible.
- lvs 6y agoYou do if it exacerbates wealth disparity and inflation.
- ahoy 6y agoThe amount you pay is set by the people who get it.
- 1996 6y agoAnyone who has seen how public owned goods turn out would realize how much of a bad idea it is: for a budget similar to the DoD, you may get wait lines like in a DMV, with as much administrative fiddling as the NASA, with a quality of service as good as the DHS. If you are lucky, you may get as many choices as their are public transportation option in the midwest. Thanks but no thanks.
- jkbbwr 6y agoCare to provide some evidence to back up your claim or are you just on the red scare train.
- 1996 6y agoEvidence is the cleanliness of public transportation, the derelict public bikes and other 2 wheel battery assisted devices, the derelict laptops in school that provide them to student... Maybe it's just a big anti communist plot, or maybe it's just human nature to not take care about things you do not own.
- ahoy 6y agoI live in a new york. Our subway is clean and regular, the bike share docks in my neighborhood are stocked and well-maintained. The busses, though sometimes crowded, run on time. Public transport works well when your city prioritizes it. I spent my youth living in places that don't and I literally cannot imagine going back.
- 1996 6y ago> I live in a new york. Our subway is clean Litteraly where I stopped believing you. It's dirty. Only DC has a somehow-clean subway, which stands out as a nice exception to the rule.
- ahoy 6y agoDo you want me to send you a picture of my license with my home address? The subway, especially post-covid, is clean.
- airhead969 6y agoIsn't this what terrible public housing is already? Could it be less terrible or would it always devolve into a housing caste system because middle-/upper-classes would never use it? Set-asides for "affordable housing" in new developments are an absolute joke because there are very few units, they often have separate "servant-like" entrances, and may not be treated equally compared to other residents. Also, the root cause isn't housing prices, it's a lack of supply because of NIMBYs, a lack of fast/cheap transportation, developing for maximum traffic/commute times like LA, and a lack of development around walkable/self-contained living areas.
- arcticbull 6y agoThe root cause is way too little development relative to demand, orchestrated via zoning regulations. Wikipedia spells this out in detail for San Francisco [1]. > Since the 1960s, San Francisco and the surrounding Bay Area have enacted strict zoning regulations. Among other restrictions, San Francisco does not allow buildings over 40 feet tall in most of the city, and has passed laws making it easier for neighbors to block developments. Partly as a result of these codes, from 2007 to 2014, the Bay Area issued building permits for only half the number of needed houses, based on the area's population growth. At the same time, there has been rapid economic growth of the high tech industry in San Francisco and nearby Silicon Valley, which has created hundreds of thousands of new jobs. (Supply << Demand) -> Price goes up. If we're to solve the housing affordability crisis, city councils simply need to drop onerous zoning regulations and permit construction such that supply can meet demand. Anything short of this is just a beat-around-the-bush bandaid that hasn't and won't achieve anything. For instance, rent control. What a regressive concept, with tons of unintended consequences. [edit] for real do you think there'd be a housing shortage or affordability crisis if the entire southern and western 3/4 of San Francisco was allowed to build up from 4 stories to 6? Basically everything other than districts 3 and 6. [2] That'd easily add 50% more housing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_housing_shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_housing_shortage [2] https://voterguide.sfelections.org/en/san-francisco’s-supervisorial-districts https://voterguide.sfelections.org/en/san-francisco’s-superv...
- 6y ago
- nemo44x 6y agoRenting is underrated but owning is nice too if you want to root. However I think a lot of renters or people that complain they can’t afford a house also forget about the costs of property tax and maintenance. Those are 2 costs that never end and don’t remain fixed (in most places) over time. For instance, anywhere reasonably commutable to NYC and close to a train line is going to probably have 10’s of thousands a year in property taxes...
- bombcar 6y agoAnd anyone who owns a house (especially an older one) knows that property taxes are relatively minor compared to maintenance costs (which are erratic and often unaccounted even by small landlords). They really add up.
- nemo44x 6y agoDepends where you live really. Live in an in-demand suburb of NYC and there’s a good chance you’re paying 20-40k a year in property taxes. Certain parts of north New Jersey and southern Connecticut contain really pricy real estate compared to national averages, for example. Maintenance will be far below that most years. But if you can afford a million dollar+ piece of real estate then a few k in maintenance per year isn’t an issue. In certain areas the land is worth more than the structure on it. The east coast has a good bunch of that.
- aidenn0 6y agoI now pay more per year in property taxes outside of town than I did for rent on my first apartment (~15 years ago) walking distance from downtown. Granted it's considerably less than what rent probably is on that apartment now; rent has roughly doubled in that time.
- larsiusprime 6y agoHow does this contrast with more old-school approaches to the housing crisis, like say, Georgism & Land Value Tax? There was a big review on Progress & Poverty over at Astral Codex Ten recently on the subject: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/your-book-review-progress-and-poverty https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/your-book-review-progr... This proposal seems to address the same problem, but the mechanism is pretty different, and I'm wondering if it improves upon what the Georgists have already proposed, or if it is less efficient by being different.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI think you're on the nose here. The public ownership rental option goes nowhere without a capability to acquire (and retain) properties for the programme, and the ability to move unproductive or underproductive real estate into same. California's property tax situation (e.g., 1977's Proposition 13) makes this an all but unsolvable problem for that state. Short a countervailing proposition, a (state) constitutional amendment, or a state or federal supreme court reversal, that law is going nowhere, and is pretty much a Land Value Tax's antiparticle / kryptonite. One potentially promising alternative is the growth of land banks, mostly in the Eastern and Midwestern US, notably Illinoios, Ohio, and New York, possibly elsewhere. Though not based off a land value tax, tax-delinquent properties are acquired by the land bank which then attempts to return them to productive use. Pairing the land bank and public ownership rental models strikes me as a potential viable route to expanding both concepts.
- eastWestMath 6y agoBanking seems like the best way to phrase this to prevent people from screaming about socialism.
- dredmorbius 6y agoYour insight has been growing on me each time I re-read it.
- unsigner 6y ago"Think of a woman who buys a home in one part of town, takes a new job in another area a few years later, and is then stuck with a 90-minute commute, or of a man who turns down the better job because he doesn’t want to sell his home or be saddled with a long commute. Now multiply that by millions of households across the country. Homeownership locks people in place, in large part because of the high transaction costs of buying and selling property." This assumes that you exist first and foremost to work jobs, and anything that impedes this is bad and needs to be optimized away. This is very American, very contemporary - don't accept it as universal. Move a little to the side in time and in space and people are "from somewhere", live there, and optimize their life to improve them living there - possibly by taking jobs in the vicinity.
- nerdponx 6y agoYou assume that there are good jobs (read: reliable sources of income and health coverage) in all places, and that nobody is putting down roots or attempting to invest in their local communities. Your assumptions are wrong. Maybe the real problem is that the only way to have income is to have a job. But that's another story.
- jawns 6y agoI'm a distributist, so I would prefer to see this type of system operated as a private cooperative, 100% owned by participants, rather than a government-run program. Why? Because then the people who get to make the decisions are the co-op participants themselves -- the people with the most skin in the game -- and the government can instead focus on areas where the participants actually need help, e.g. at the regulatory level, to make sure these arrangements are not unjustly disadvantaged. * If you are not familiar with distributism, see this primer: https://shaungallagher.pressbin.com/blog/distributism-for-kids.html https://shaungallagher.pressbin.com/blog/distributism-for-ki...
- InvertedRhodium 6y agoHow does that differ meaningfully from home owners associations and the like?
- mgerdts 6y agoThe one time I lived in a neighborhood with a HOA, i found it provided a private pool and and a way for neighbors to be more exclusive, not inclusive. For instance, one of the HOA rules was that you cannot have any vehicle with commercial signage or lettering (like a plumber's van) parked outside over night. If my parents were to stay the night, the rules said that their pickup with lettering advertising their small business was not welcome in my driveway. As I was writing this, the term "sundown law" came to mind.
- greggman3 6y agoI totally get how that sucks but, if I lived in such a neighborhood, for that particular problem, could I solve it by buying a car cover? Not that I should have to, just curious.
- mgerdts 6y agoThe solution, as described by a wealthy neighbor when discussing something different (placement of plants?), was to just ignore the HOA. The HOA has a shoestring budget and a $10k legal bill would bankrupt it. So, if you are wealthy enough to hire expensive lawyers, rules don't apply to you. That neighbor was a doctor that ran clinical trials. The discussion with him on HOAs and other topics left me disillusioned in so many ways. The entire point of my earlier message was to point out that HOAs of the form I've seen are not a means to encourage diversity or inclusion. Rather, they are about maximizing home values by ensuring conformity to the target market.
- jrochkind1 6y agoI don't know why they're not talking about cooperative ownership too! Limited-equity cooperative ownership seems to me seems the real third option. (Full-equity cooperatives like say NYC's market-rate alternative to condos is not what i'm talking about, and is just a form of ownership rather than another option). https://shelterforce.org/2017/04/25/will-limited-equity-co-ops-make-comeback/ https://shelterforce.org/2017/04/25/will-limited-equity-co-o... To make it accessible to all necessary income levels, it may need government subsidy, and has sometimes had it in the past (just as obviously government-owned housing would be assumed to get subsidy). But tenant-controlled cooperatives seem preferable in all ways to straight-out government ownership (which yeah, isn't that just public housing), and limited-equity tenant-controlled cooperative ownership has a pretty successful track record in the US and other places. https://nationalcooperativelawcenter.com/co-ops-are-better-and-we-can-prove-it/ https://nationalcooperativelawcenter.com/co-ops-are-better-a...
- thex10 6y agoThis is what I thought the linked article would be about!
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago"Spending so much on a rental feels wasteful—irresponsible, even—when you could pay a similar price on a mortgage, at a constant level for the next 30 years, while also building substantial wealth" Unless your home insurance rises every year and your monthly ownership costs double in 4 years. Many of us lost houses in the oughts to exactly that.
- bombcar 6y ago“Renting is insane why would anyone do it” “Also SaaS and the cloud is the future of everything” HN summed up but they don’t seem to see the connections.
- don-code 6y agoI didn't quite glean a thorough understanding of the model from the article. It sounds like it's: 1) Public funds provide capital to build a new dwelling; individuals move in at rates similar to market rent. 2) Rather than rents paying a landlord, rents act like principal payments on a personal mortgage - e.g. I own $10,000 worth of shares of the property after paying $1,000/mo for ten months. 3) Eventually, I own enough of a share of the property that I no longer have to make payments, similar to having paid off a mortgage. I'd be responsible for upkeep (e.g. roof repairs), property taxes, that sort of thing. What I'm not understanding, though, is how this passes down. If I'm a partial owner and move, doesn't the next buyer have the same issue raising capital that the model tries to address? Does it not also mean that I could become a landlord in my own right, and begin renting to another occupant, who stands to build no wealth themselves?
- sokoloff 6y agoThere's an element of rental housing which is an act of pure consumption. Real estate taxes (either paid or foregone), maintenance supplies, maintenance labor, common area utilities, paying the bond used to build the building, insurance, etc. Plus, there is a notion in the article that this would be an incoming-producing asset and that income is presumably coming from the rents paid. Unless this is a massive Ponzi scheme, there's consumption going on (and therefore you're not building equity with all of the rent payments). There's no realistic way you're going to have 100% (and likely not even 50%) of a rental payment going to building equity.
- Spooky23 6y agoMy dad administered a similar program for getting historically disadvantaged people owning multi family homes. Basically, folks would sign up for home ownership education, do a bunch of stuff related to maintenance, etc and shop for a two family. The housing authority (through a grant) would essentially provide a loan for 20-30% of the purchase price for down payment and some repairs. The loan would be forgiven in 5 years. It was pretty transformative and really changed lives for the better. About 90% of the participants made it through year 5.
- 6y ago
- ctdonath 6y agoDoes nobody consider the carrying capacity of an area, that only so many people can live in an area under given zoning regulations, and that further increase of population density necessarily causes fundamental change to living conditions? Romantic as the notion of avoiding displacement is, either density increases or price increases - both unpleasant. Exponential population increase in a geographically limited mostly-2-dimensional area can’t retain the same quaint culture. Change happens. Stability can’t be decreed.
- thinkski 6y agoMuch of Eastern Europe tried this between the 1940s through the late 1980s. The result was blocks upon blocks of cramped, drab apartments with long waiting periods to get one. If you were married, you could get one sooner, which resulted in unhappy marriages. It sounds good in theory, in practice it didn’t work.
- DavidAdams 6y agoI don't think that what this article is describing is similar at all to Eastern Europe-style public housing. The US also had a big experiment in public housing in the 20th century, that also had a lot of bad results.
- Pfhreak 6y agoThe US had a history of spending capex on flashy high rise housing. Then failing to spend the opex necessary to maintain what they built. Large buildings are harder to maintain and require more specialized labor. Means testing and segregation also impacted public housing in the US. (Better not make too much money or you'll have to leave!) There are several instances of successful public housing efforts in the US and Europe, typically more low rise or mid rise distributed properties.
- bombcar 6y agoPart of the problem is the false dichotomy between single family suburban style dwellings and high-rises. The middle ground, medium density row houses and similar, is almost impossible to build anymore in many locations. The costs and regulations are such that either you build a single family dwelling or fight for a high-rise.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt’s a dichotomy because politically active and influential people do not want density near their detached single family suburban style homes. Everyone wants to live around people at or above their level. If you’re a developer, then fighting against this group will take a lot of resources and it’s risky, so you can’t bet on medium density to make it worth it, you have to aim for more.
- ksherlock 6y agoThere's a second third option (or first third, as it already exists) -- community land trusts. The basic idea is that you own the house but the land under the house is owned by a non-profit. https://slate.com/business/2016/01/bernie-sanders-made-burlingtons-land-trust-possible-its-still-an-innovative-and-effective-model-of-affordable-housing-today.html https://slate.com/business/2016/01/bernie-sanders-made-burli...
- prestigious 6y agoThis is the reason why First Nations reserves are universally terrible places to live.
- gewa 6y agoIsn't this, what a housing cooperative are about? They are very common in Germany and seen as valuable cultural heritage. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_cooperative
- dredmorbius 6y agoCo-ops address only one aspect of a three-element triad: supply, stability (co-ops here), and subsidy. In his book, and the chapter exerpt I've linked in an earlier comment, Phillips explains why all three elements are key. Co-ops (or similar co-housing or community-housing arrangements) cannot of and by themselves address the greater supply problem, or provide subsidies for at-risk, disabled (temporarily or permanently) individuals, children, or retirees. They're useful, but insufficient.
- 6510 6y agoLand tax is a must but I have an even funnier idea. Tax corporations per employee and adjust the amount to the housing shortage. Make the tax truly terrifying if there is a big shortage. If you really must run your shop in that ultra expensive location you just pay for it. If you cant afford it you simply do not have what it takes, the area is not for you and you should leave. Make room for a business that belongs OR turn the building into housing. You would still have home owners who want to continue to ride the housing ponzi but they would be directly opposed by corporations. The revenue should be reserved for subsidies on constructive construction. Free money for anyone who [partially] solves the problem.
- imtringued 6y agoYour proposed tax could be based on a "housing pressure index", basically squarefeet of livable space per person or people per squarefoot. This index would measure if there are lots of families living in cramped conditions or people living with room mates. If housing pressure is too high, tax corporations more.
- 6510 6y agoIf you go by squarefoot large homes would distort the picture. I was thinking some formula counting people who want/need to live there.
- chii 6y ago> If housing pressure is too high, tax corporations more. It's always "tax more to solve problem X, as long as the target of that tax isn't me".
- 6510 6y agoThe target of the tax should be the party creating the problem so that they themselves can solve it. Before you plant down your office in some densely populated area you make a cost benefit analysis. The housing problem is part of the cost. We've traditionally expected others to deal with it (read pay for it) but it doesn't work. Or put differently, we've failed employers in creating housing for their employees. So now that we've proven ourselves incompetent we might as well put the puzzle in front of those who created it. It's easy to ignore your staff being unable to afford a roof over their head if you are relatively unaffected by it. The moment you get billed for it you can assign the task to someone and create a budget. If there are also subsidies we can expect corporations to attempt to solve the puzzle. If they are unaffected by the problem it is really hard to get some solution going internally. Who knows, perhaps they are more competent than the rest of us? If not the number of jobs (demand) can be scaled down to fit supply.
- TedShiller 6y agoHaha
- thesz 6y agoThis is an introduction of a discussion about removal of ownership of means of production, basically. This is a step towards socialism.
- eastWestMath 6y agoUgh.
- andrepd 6y agoYes, and that's great.
- why_Mr_Anderson 6y agoSure, because it worked so well in every country that tried it...
- chii 6y agoThere hasn't been any historical precedence for which removing the means of production from being owned has turned out well. Because, either it has never been truly attempted - but just a thinly disguised usurpation of property by force, or that it failed and devolve back into ownership model anyway.
- williesleg 6y agoI wanna live for free, I'm just gonna squat in Los Angeles, it's OK there.
- varispeed 6y agoThe problem is that when you are from a poor background, you will have difficult time saving money for a new house if you chose a path of working hard, getting educated and then getting a good job. All because of progressive tax, that is being sold to public as tax on the rich, but reality is that it prevents people from escaping poverty and makes sure people don't grow beyond a certain point. The rich on the other hand don't pay the same taxes as anyone else - they have money to get around any system that is put in place. I think the first step should be removing the higher tax bracket, so that people can save money quicker. For example: If there is 0% tax up to 10k 20% up to 40k 40% from 40k And you got a good job and want to live like your colleagues, likely your costs of living will take up all salary up to 40k. Then above that for any 1000 you make, you have to give 400 to the state. Let's say you make 60k. So 20k will be taxed at 40%. It will take you over 8 years to save 100k. If 40% bracket was removed, then it would only take you around 6 years to save. So the difference is 2 years of sacrifice. If you had that extra money, you could spend 2 years on improving your skills, starting a business etc. For some reason I see both sides want to keep progressive tax - the left wants it, so that people keep being poor and therefore their clients. The right wants it, so that the rich amongst them can feel special - as the club is kept being small. I think how tax affects people from poor backgrounds should be looked into.
- tonfreed 6y agoI've certainly noticed this. I'm not from a rich family, I was raised on welfare and I've managed to work my way into finally being able to buy my own three bedroom home in my 30s. Have a lot of friends who don't make anything near what I do, but middle class/rich parents that were able to give them a kick along the road with a house deposit telling me "oh, I'm surprised you lived in a tiny two bedroom apartment on your wage". Knowing that I have to build my own retirement really makes me resent that so much of what I earn is going to the state to pay for what, a few shitty public art sculptures that no one likes, a crumbling public transport system that somehow has all the money in the world to pay for all sorts of diversity programs but not enough to actually deliver the services everyone thinks they should, and health department bureaucrats that are more interested in bogging healthcare providers down in paperwork than actually letting them tend to the sick. It's all very tiring.
- 6y ago
- Black101 6y agoThat could be good for the valley as long as the US government is paying for it and not CA
- iandanforth 6y agoThe proposal seems untenable unless it creates a marketable asset. The more detailed description (http://www.betterinstitutions.com/blog/2021/2/2/rental-pension-social-housing-compete-with-homeownership http://www.betterinstitutions.com/blog/2021/2/2/rental-pensi...) calls it "Social Security" for housing.
- aidenn0 6y agoSomething that bothers me is this: In California, 75% of renters support building more housing, 51% of owners support building more housing, and yet housing gets built at a glacial pace. I'd like to know why this is. Some wild-ass guesses: 1. A majority of Californians support housing being built, just not too close to where they are 2. The 75% or Renters and 51% of homeowners skew younger and are thus less likely to vote or complain at community board meetings 3. The permitting process in municipalities near me is so byzantine that it's expensive in both time and money to build new construction; the added time could be particularly problematic because that's greater risk that housing prices will plummet before construction is complete.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoIf you're paying someone else to live in a house, then you are on the losing side of the power dynamic.
- aidenn0 6y agoWhile this is broadly true, it's not universally true. I was far better off renting when I moved to this town. I had a down-payment, but my rent was less than the just the interest on my mortgage for a condo would have been and I likely would have had a commute instead of a sub 10 minute walk. Instead I invested my money and was able to buy a house after the housing crash. For the house I purchased, I ultimately paid about half the original asking price. If you are forced to pay someone else to live in a house, then you are on the losing side of the power dynamic. The above anecdote was in the crazy real-estate market of coastal California. If you generalize for the rest of the country though, housing prices track inflation on average, so if you are leveraged 5:1 you can expect to gross 5x inflation on your house before you account for taxes, interest, insurance, and maintenance. You may end up ahead of the market at that rate, but it's not exactly a sure thing. It's not unreasonable to say that the flexibility of being able to move will improve your lifestyle by more than the difference. OTOH, we can say that 100% of the people who own houses have the means to own a house, but obviously much less than 100% of the people who rent have the means to buy a house, so the point is taken.
- illustriousbear 6y agoNo thanks, I'd rather own my home. We should be working towards the practical goal of making owning a home practical again. I don't want to live in some box owned by a collective.
- sologoub 6y agoNormally, I wouldn’t hold up SF as any kind of functional example of city managed, BUT they do have one program that I think strikes an interesting balance between public interest in affordable housing and building wealth for underprivileged - BMR (below market rate ownership program): https://sfmohcd.org/bmr-ownership https://sfmohcd.org/bmr-ownership In exchange for deed-restricting certain units to BMR, developers receive over concessions and density bonuses. BMR units are restricted to sale only to individuals or families that make under certain amount (indexes to inflation and area incomes). They get financing from preferred lenders under good terms. Equity is built up from principle payments and some appreciation. The catch is that when they sell, they need to sell to another BMR-approved person, which caps appreciation. It’s not a goldmine, but better than renting (usually).
- willhoyle 6y agoI’ve always been curious - what if we imposed a law disallowing owning more than 1 home. Wouldn’t this reduce demand and, in doing so, lower prices from less competition? I’m sure there’s other aspects I’m missing which make this a bad idea but there’s something that doesn’t feel right about people owning 2-3 homes while others can’t get on the property ladder.
- Proven 6y agoIf this approach works, why isn't it used by greedy capitalists? I'd rather invest my money in private company doing this and get a 2% return every year than be taxed to pay for a poorly run government program and get nothing in return. The former will deliver value to customers, the latter won't.
- _nalply 6y agoIn Switzerland many people rent and many landlords are pension funds. In a way this is public-ownership rental in the sense that it is a common rent relationship (as a tenant you pay a monthly rent and the landlord is responsible for the upkeep of the property) but that the landlord is a quasi-public organization (quasi-public because the pension fund is a private company working in a heavily regulated market helping people saving for their retirement). This is just an example how this might be solved in other countries. I think however the private pension fund system in Switzerland has many problems: firstly the employer selects the organization for you and not you yourself (Chilean system), and secondly for some people working in the trade it is a secure get-rich scheme, and that's not all. (A note: both arms of the systems, the private pension fund system and the public pension, are mandatory.)
- lofi_lory 6y agoIn Europe there is Mietshäuser Syndikat https://www.syndikat.org/en/ https://www.syndikat.org/en/ Their model seems to work well. I think this is the way. Capitalism seems to be oddly unprepared, if you just drop the profit drive in the middle of things. Seems like you can make the system sell itself out.
- paulus_magnus2 6y agobuild more cities. and move jobs there. housing is only expensive where land is expensive - city centres. The Government is able to take long enough view to do this. Any commercial actor will be against this due to rent seeking / market cornering. What is doable in near / short term is to move government agencies out of big cities into smaller ones and start drawing people by creation of stable employment. Right now everyone is more and more forced into the same 1-5 cities per country if you want to have a well paying job. And you have to have one to pay for college / medical insurance. I think my point is clear also not very groundbreaking. It's only that people who could do this are 50+/old and have a conflict of interest - they want to prop up their house value.
- 2ion 6y agoDoesn't fly with zero trust in public policy administration. Which is the mindset I am currently forced to take. Too corruptible, esp. at the local level.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoSimpler solutions are better. Private funding for new housing stock obviates the need for complex government-run bureaucracies that create their own set of problems with rent-seeking behavior like cronyism. So if there were a good way to overcome the political power of homeowners in maintaining regulatory restrictions that prevent the expansion of housing supply, so that the private sector could respond to market forces and expand housing supply, that would be preferrable. According to one analysis, it would only take de-regulating three US cities' housing markets: New York, San Francisco and San Jose, to boost US economic growth on the order of over one third over a span of 45 years: https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/mac.20170388 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/mac.20170388 So here's one potential solution: federalize control over these three cities' zoning rules, in order to remove all of their zoning restrictions on building density, while investing resources into speeding up their permit approval process. This is similar to Japan's housing laws, where the national government decides zoning rules in all cities, including in major economic clusters / key job markets like Tokyo.
- anm89 6y agoThis sounds like a nightmare. Yes, I always wanted to co own my place of residence with a faceless lumbering beaurocracy.