9 ms·
Economically it's much more like gold than a ponzi scheme: Gold: Asset that goes up and down in price according to demand. No central body controlling it. Some
by tim333 6y ago
Economically it's much more like gold than a ponzi scheme:
Gold: Asset that goes up and down in price according to demand. No central body controlling it. Some utility as jewelry though we could get by without that. Massive dollar and environmental cost from mining the stuff.
Ponzi scheme: Fraud where insiders take money from investors and use it to pay other investors. Collapses and the fraudsters run off or go to jail. No mining no utility.
Bitcoin: Asset that goes up and down in price according to demand. No central body controlling it. Some utility as a payments system though we could get by without that. Massive dollar and environmental cost from mining the stuff.
Gold has a certain permanence as the only element in the periodic table that has properties that has made it the #1 jewellery metal for the last few thousand years and probably the next few thousand though while Bitcoin was invented ten years ago and may well get outcompeted by a better invention/currency.
- ABeeSea 6y agoIt’s a decentralized Ponzi scheme. It’s why Bitcoin owners are so aggressive in convincing others to buy Bitcoin.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- herbst 6y agoI honestly never experienced that. Its not like any crypto investor is running around converting others.
- tim333 6y agoThere are people promoting it on youtube - I was watching some last night (What Bitcoin Did https://youtu.be/Pw6tfNh8DAk https://youtu.be/Pw6tfNh8DAk) but most seem to be recommending it sincerely rather than trying to sucker some fools in so they can cash out. It's an interesting time in the history of bitcoin as we are starting to see a move from small speculators (number go up) to institutions buying in (it's sensible to diversify 5% of your portfolio into crypoassets as they have historically high returns and low correlations).
- herbst 6y agoSure i do talk positive about crypto too. But i would never tell anyone where to put their money. Its just wrong to think all people in crypto are evangelising others into their ponzi investments
- ABeeSea 6y agoHow many crypto investors have you been around? I’ve had many, many coworkers trying to convince me to buy Bitcoin over the last decade. This is across different companies, teams etc. And I have definitely witnessed the same thing online. I mean I wish I had listened because BTC was $50 a coin the first time someone tried to convince me to buy in.
- imtringued 6y agoIt was $50 at the time precisely because people failed to convince others. I see lots of people fall into the "If I only had done X back in year Y, then I would be rich." fallacy. No, you wouldn't be rich, because the information available at the time didn't justify such a decision. If that information were available, Bitcoin would have been worth $60k in 2009. Right now nobody can tell you what will happen to Bitcoin, because all available information is already priced in. At this point it might go up but it might go down as well.
- ABeeSea 6y agoThat wasn’t my argument but Ok.
- herbst 6y agoPlenty. However maybe thats a cultural thing but i rarely have people insisting on any kind of investing advice. We might talk about stuff, but both sides know risks are involved. I never experienced evangelism IRL and i even spent some time in ctypto meetups
- dorkwood 6y agoThe entire crypto art movement is a marketing campaign designed to turn artists into crypto evangelists, i.e. convert others.
- herbst 6y agoSource? Couldnt it be that some artists are just super happy they found a way to dsitribute their art lucratively?
- dorkwood 6y agoI’m not saying that all artists are in on it (probably very few of them are). But the truth is that the artists who are getting paid are the ones pushing NFTs as “the future of art” and who have the influence to rope in newcomers. Collectors in the space refer to this as “engaging with the community”. The crypto-famous NFT collector “Silver Surfer”, known for dropping hundreds of thousands of dollars on NFTs [1], tweets “celebrities that fail to get engaged with their communities will continue to have weak secondary [NFT] sales.” [2] That’s weird, I wonder why the money would stop flowing if the artist stopped tweeting about NFTs? Doesn’t their art still have value? The truth is, if you spend enough time around the crypto art community, you realize that there aren’t any “real” art collectors in the space. There are crypto speculators, and there are artists who feel obliged to “engage with the community”. The lack of real money flowing into the space is what leads me to label this as a marketing campaign, as opposed to a completely organic movement. It’s a somewhat decentralized marketing campaign, but it’s a marketing campaign nonetheless. [1] https://twitter.com/makersplaceco/status/1359654252944105473 https://twitter.com/makersplaceco/status/1359654252944105473 [2] https://twitter.com/7Surfer7Silver7/status/1382781884443336706 https://twitter.com/7Surfer7Silver7/status/13827818844433367...
- wslh 6y agoWhile you can be tempted to define Bitcoin in that way, the Ponzi scheme definition doesn't apply [1]. As the parent comment: in Bitcoin no investor has the precise information of when to exit to defraud others. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/ponzischeme.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/ponzischeme.asp
- ABeeSea 6y agoNo one has denied that Bitcoin is an innovator when it comes to new ways to scam and defraud people.
- corty 6y agoI think the Tether people know quite well when to exit, because their implosion will bring Bitcoin down.
- acjohnson55 6y agoWhy? There are other stablecoins, with better reputation. Could people just switch to them?
- corty 6y agoTether mediates a lot of the BTC/USD-exchanges. At the same time there are rumours that tether has insufficient USD backing, so if there is ever a bank run, exchanges will be unable to pay. At that point it will be too late for a tether alternative. And after the "big tether crash", regulation will be a lot harsher on exchanges and possibly all crypto currencies, which will continue to depress courses. And I really don't know if the alternatives are any better.
- acjohnson55 6y agoYeah, I totally get the concerns about Tether's solvency. I guess what I don't get is why Tether remains popular, as a product that isn't unique. Is it just that it's too dangerous for everyone to admit that the emperor has no clothes, because it would crash the whole system? Is it not a liquid market? If I were sitting on a bunch of USDT, but I wanted to be holding USD stablecoins, just generally speaking, why not swap them into a different stablecoin? Maybe another question I should be asking is what proportion of Tether is being used to collateralize leveraged long positions in other crypto assets? Maybe that's why this is a tinder box? Sorry for all of the questions, but legitimately trying to understand what people are talking about.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoWhat investment is not a Ponzi scheme? Real estate and stocks rely on a greater fool that was later to the party to come buy them at a later date. Stocks have appreciated in value so far past what they are worth for a dividend that we have had to give up that charade long ago. From the wiki for Ponzi scheme- > The scheme leads victims to believe that profits are coming from legitimate business activity (e.g. product sales and/or successful investments), and they remain unaware that other investors are the source of funds. TSLA has a P/E of 1,181 right now. Peloton is 1,660. Amazon is even 80. How is it any different right now?
- walleeee 6y agoYes, and it's not only stock market misvaluation. Perpetual growth economics itself functions like a Ponzi scheme insofar as it renders the planet more challenging for future humans to live on.
- Retric 6y agoStocks have dividends, loans have interest, land has either rents or utility from using it. It’s that income stream beyond the initial capital that turns something into an investment. Bitcoin lacks that, it only has money from new investors and it loses money from mining. Which means without new investment it’s value must crash which creates incentives for people that own Bitcoin to convince others to buy Bitcoin. The only way to argue Bitcoin has long term value is it must provide inherent utility like land. Increasing the number of transactions per second would be one way to demonstrate that value, but talking about future value doesn’t.
- cblconfederate 6y agoGold mining through the centuries has probably caused much more environmental pollution than bitcoin, and bitcoin ~~mining~~ minting is programmed to end. Bitcoin can be transferred around the world easily, The way gold achieves permanence is partially by being extremely hard to move around and store. Gold can be outcompeted too, aluminum used to be more expensive than gold.
- rini17 6y agoBitcoin mining is not programmed to end. It has two functions: issuing of new coins and safeguarding transactions. From these two only mining of new coins will eventually end but it still is likely to stay profitable for many decades. Safeguarding transactions, with reward from transaction fees, is programmed to go on indefinitely.
- m00dy 6y agoI second this comment. Glad to see someone knows the actual protocol rather than speculating.
- pyrale 6y agoGold is stable in isolation. If you bury gold in your backyard, and dig it up 20 years later, you will still have the exact same amount of gold. The exchange rate between gold and other things won't change that. On the other hand, for btc to keep value, you need people to mine it from to the moment you buy it to the moment you sell it. This has a cost, which is currently paid by newcomers. But if btc becomes stable (i.e. there are no new entrants willing to pay a premium to get in), current holders have to accept depreciation to pay for mining costs. Since btc is not backed by any kind of real world asset, there is no other source of profit. An investment that is only worthwile as long as it attracts newcomers is in essence a ponzi scheme.
- iambateman 6y agoDo you have a sense of what that depreciation factor is? If it’s nearly equivalent to overall population growth, it may not matter. (For what it’s worth, I’m with you for the most part. Just curious. I’ve been short-term wrong on BTC since $102 and I’m trying to figure out if I’m long-term wrong as well.)
- naravara 6y ago> For what it’s worth, I’m with you for the most part. Just curious. I’ve been short-term wrong on BTC since $102 and I’m trying to figure out if I’m long-term wrong as well.) It has managed to outdistance both the dotcom bubble and the housing bubble at this point. Although the tulip bubble went from the 1590s to the 1630s, so there is some precedent for these boondoggles to run for a surprisingly long time before gravity catches up.
- pyrale 6y agoSomeone else quoted $10B worth of electricity yearly, at current price. Given that number, and knowing that it evolves with market cap, that's about 1% depreciation/year.
- bob33212 6y agoGood point. The problem is that some people think it is a currency instead of an investment. Other people think it is an investment instead of a currency. It can't be both. Currencies have to be less valuable over time, otherwise no one would ever spend the currency. Investments have cost more overtime otherwise no would would invest. But both groups are buying and driving up the price. Also, there is a 3rd group that thinks it is a hedge. With hedges you don't really care if the price is going up or down. You want it to give you options. For example, you may buy a stockpile of food or toilet paper, not because you are hoping to turn a profit, but to give you an option to avoid going to the grocery store during another panic buying situation.
- Proven 6y ago> Gold: Asset that goes up and down in price according to demand. No central body controlling it. Some utility as jewelry though we could get by without that. Massive dollar and environmental cost from mining the stuff. Wrong. Cost of everything is included in the marginal cost of gold. And gold is still fairly inexpensive.
- sonthonax 6y agoGold has a lot more intrinsic value than bitcoin will ever have. It’s quite reasonable to explain a large part of gold’s price as speculation on continued demand for jewellery. There’s a 5000 year history of gold. But only a few grams per person in this world; and a great number of people feel some sort of pressure to buy a few grams for their spouses. Obviously what I’m saying is an oversimplification. But if we imagined a world where gold did not have its lustrous history, it might still be sold at the same price. In this world, gold would still cost around 800 dollars an ounce to mine; but the only difference would be the market cap for gold would be very small and would serve its niche applications (comparable to the market for terbium or platinum). Gold might be overpriced a little bit. But the debate about bitcoin is if it’s worth anything at all. Disclosure: I work for a bitcoin trading firm.
- Icedcool 6y agoI’d contend that money(any fiat), like Bitcoin, like gold has no intrinsic value. Historic precedence doesn’t exist... till it does. No one wants to carry around chickens to trade. The value of a monetary asset is in its interoperability, and backers of Bitcoin are working to enable that to a high degree.
- sonthonax 6y agoI think you’ve misunderstood me. Gold has its niche applications where you need a malleable and nonreactive metal (like dentistry). If this was the only use for gold, it would still be at least 800-900USD an ounce, because it that’s what it costs to extract. The market cap for gold would be like 1 billion USD, rather than 11 trillion USD. Ironically in a world where gold wasn’t ‘lusted’ after, it might even be more expensive because the market would be illiquid. And a small oligopoly of suppliers would be able to gouge buyers. This is what happens in the rare earth metals market.
- almost_usual 6y agoIf you couldn’t exchange gold for fiat it would still have value. Bitcoin would plummet in value.
- thkim 6y agoAn investment asset must have a cash flow and/or intrinsic value. Otherwise you do not have a way to recuperate your money, so it is not an investment. They also provide basis for value of the asset. Bitcoin has neither. That is why Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme regardless of all the rosy pictures the believers try to paint. This is very important: Bitcoin has neither cash flow nor intrinsic value. The only way to recuperate money from Bitcoin is for another person to pay for it - the very definition of a Ponzi scheme. Gold does not have a cash flow, but it has an intrinsic value.
- copenocoiner 6y agoHow much does it cost to move 17 tons of gold? What is the risk involved in transfer? I can answer that question for BTC. To transfer the USD value equivalent of 17 tons of gold, it's currently around $27.50[1]. This transaction can be made anywhere you can broadcast a hash string. If you want to get fancy, you can trade wBTC on ethereum for, as of this moment, ~$8[2]. If even that is too high a fee for you, you could bridge over to xDAI and trade for orders of magnitude less than the value of a penny[3]. Again, you can do this anywhere you can broadcast a hash string.] All of this is EXCHANGE, transaction, alone. Zero mention of the amazing utility of the financial instruments that are IMPOSSIBLE with legacy protocols. To go over which is not a comment or a blogpost but a detailed textbook or equivalent of a MOOC. How's that for intrinsic value? [1]https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_fee# https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_f... [2]https://etherscan.io/gastracker https://etherscan.io/gastracker [3]https://jaredstauffer.medium.com/what-is-xdai-how-do-i-use-xdai-a-simple-explanation-7440cbaf1df6#:~:text=The%20cost%20to%20perform%20a,someone)%20is%20about%20%240.000021%20USD https://jaredstauffer.medium.com/what-is-xdai-how-do-i-use-x....
- thkim 6y agoIntrinsic value has nothing to do with cost of transaction.
- copenocoiner 6y agoSo VISA and MasterCard have zero intrinsic value as companies. Does not pass the sniff test.
- wkazatu 6y agoSure we could "get by" without gold jewelry, but it is a _real_ tangible thing. The problem with Bitcoin is that it is "international" in nature. Yet, China holds the largest share of Bitcoins and thus ownership is unbalanced. https://www.investopedia.com/news/bitcoin-wont-win-worldwide-adoption-because-china-controls-it-ripple-ceo/ https://www.investopedia.com/news/bitcoin-wont-win-worldwide... https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2021/03/bitcoins-greatest-feature-is-also-its-existential-threat.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2021/03/bitcoins-gr... I think there is more value in Blockchain at the municipal or federal level of a country to improve transparency and such. Or somehow even the issuance of currency. Given geopolitical unrest and contention, or differing political views (USA vs. China), I can't see how this decentralized coin will continue over a 20 year period.