11 ms·
Modern farming is not the bucolic system drawn on the food packages in the supermarket. It's an extractive industry little different from mining or oil drillin
by gumby 6y ago
Modern farming is not the bucolic system drawn on the food packages in the supermarket.
It's an extractive industry little different from mining or oil drilling. In fact industrial food is largely eating oil, both in energy intensity itself and the use of oil as feedstock for fertilizers and food additives.
- Spooky23 6y agoExactly. I worked on a farm in my teens in 90s upstate ny that was like the last dying breath of the traditional family farm. It was a property that was intact since a land grant from a Dutch patroon and continuously farmed until around 2000. Today the family still owns it, and boards a few horses to pay the taxes. The farmer was an old-school conservative farmer. He was a local Republican Party leader for awhile, a conservationist and just overall hardworking guy. The modern farm is more like an oil company. I think that 75 years from now, when we lament the fate of the impoverished Midwest Desert and will see the 1970s/1980s as a watershed moment where we flipped our entire governance philosophy to short term P&L, despite then obvious and already learned lessons of the past.
- failrate 6y agoThis is a romanticized view of the small family farm. Our farmibg practices in the US were imported from Europe and were not adapted to our climates. Settlers spread like locusts across land that was so fertile that even if they didn't know what to do, the soil would rescue them. Until it was finally so used up that it couldn't support crops.
- dijit 6y agoThis is a weird take on history, it contradicts directly what I was taught and understood to be true. The dust bowl was pretty bad but as far as I understood it there was very little fertility to much of the land in what we now call the USA, which is why life was difficult for the early European settlers.
- supernovae 6y agoI saw something recently that showed the dustbowl was from loss of native grasses that had deep roots to crops that couldn't contain the soils and hold the bio-mass... Eventually without the root mass of the native grasses, it withered away... The treatment of the soil as if it is infinite and something purely to be extract is exactly like oil and mineral mining no matter the scale... Regardless of the dust bowl and the types of farmers that caused it, the hopes are that we learned how to farm within the ecology of the region(s) we live in and how those regions may vary from one another and we should build adaptive farms that work in harmony...
- failrate 6y agoCan you explain all of the people who were living and farming here prior to the European invasion? The land in the US is fertile. The prairies were incredibly fertile.
- dijit 6y agoThe reason I brought it up was because most farms in Native American USA were largely unproductive, and even agriculturally heavy tribes had to supplement their farms with hunting in winter.
- ljm 6y agoSettlers didn't intuitively know how to farm the land at home, whether that was in the Mediterranean climate of the south of Europe or the temperate one in central Europe, or the colder one further north. And it's certainly not as if the European continent is somehow especially farmable without knowing anything about farming. The wikipedia article on crop rotation[1] explains quite plainly that this has been evolving over eight thousand years, with a recent development pre-WW2 being in the southern US, and the most recent one being a shift to stopping crop rotation and instead switching to chemicals. That last particular update should be setting the alarm bells ringing. The evidence doesn't really support your claim unless you think the entirety of Northern America had no concept of farming until colonialism arrived a few hundred years ago. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crop_rotation#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crop_rotation#History
- failrate 6y agoThe settlers had every opportunity to learn local farming practices from the Native Americans. Instead, they did everything in their power to force their farming practices onto the land where they occupied. Native Americans farmed. They farmed different crops that were actually suited to the local biome.
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> The settlers had every opportunity to learn local farming practices from the Native Americans. > Native Americans farmed. They farmed different crops that were actually suited to the local biome. But many didn't. and those that did were often captured and conquered by those that didn't. The Comanche were the best known ones, but their were others. [0] That omission alone is what allows for many people to romanticize the horrible warfare and slavery that took place amongst the native people's perpetual state of warfare. Also, it's kind of hard to learn from a people who once exposed to European diseases were wiped out in absurd numbers long before the settlers and colonizers would actually arrive. Colonialism happens in waves, and can span long periods; it's worth reminding that the the first wave were people not interested in establishing a homestead lifestyle and a family farm but abject conquest, for that required the more disenfranchised and honestly peasant/pleb classes to be able to get to the 'New World' much later. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nomadic_peoples#Americas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nomadic_peoples#Americ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- titzer 6y agoI think you're being ungenerous to settlers from Europe; my ancestors were some of them. Soil conditions varied a lot! In Indiana, where my ancestors settled, there was largely forest, and great soil for farming, but the plains weren't that way. But regardless, yes, humans have very radically changed not only the soil ecology, but the entire ecology of North America over our entire time. But it's really picked up in the last 50 years. We're way past sustainability now. The practices of 100 or 200 years ago were much more sustainable than what we have now. They had no pesticides or fertilizers, and they couldn't till the soil so thoroughly. Farms were smaller and the increased biodiversity of "pests" was actually better for the soils, if not for yields. What has really tipped the balance is the "amazing" 4x crop yield increase over the last century. It came at the expense of literally every other living thing associated with the land: pests, grasses, trees, animals, birds, you name it. And it required juicing everything up on steroids, genetically modifying and breeding different crop varieties, and carpet-bombing an entire phylum of life with chemical warfare.
- datavirtue 6y agoWe are not past sustainability.
- titzer 6y agoMaybe in the broadest possible sense that it may yet be possible to live sustainably, but we are currently in overshoot, and it's not even close. https://www.overshootday.org https://www.overshootday.org
- bluGill 6y agoThe practices of 150 years ago destroyed the soil. Farmers had to stop those in the 1930s. Since then plows have gone out of style and reduced soil loss greatly. Farmers who get 4x the yields are actually building soil, they have to because the soil they were left with by the 1980s wouldn't support those yields without doing things to build up the soil. It is years to build up though, if you can add 1mm of soil in a decade that is good. However you can also make what is left better without adding more.
- Spooky23 6y agoNot at all. My respect for my late friend and employer may sound romanticized, but the business was a real and practical thing. I think a farm being a vital business since the 1670s qualifies as adapted to the local climate. In my region of the country, water and topsoil is abundant. But you can’t compete with massive western operations.
- monkeybutton 6y agoThis makes me think of the Grapes of Wrath: >Some of the owner men were kind because they hated what they had to do, and some of them were angry because they hated to be cruel, and some of them were cold because they had long ago found that one could not be an owner unless one were cold. And all of them were caught in something larger than themselves. Some of them hated the mathematics that drove them, and some were afraid, and some worshiped the mathematics because it provided a refuge from thought and from feeling. >You know the land’s getting poorer. You know what cotton does to the land; robs it, sucks all the blood out of it. The squatters nodded—they knew, God knew. If they could only rotate the crops they might pump blood back into the land.
- nuisance-bear 6y agoMaybe we shouldn't burn ethanol in cars. Maybe we shouldn't load up every food product with corn syrup.
- slt2021 6y agoif you think about it, it is ridiculous that we burn food as fuel in our cars and add unhealthy amount of sugar syrup into everything
- bluGill 6y agoFood is fuel, always has been. An internal combustion engine is efficent compared to biological processes of motion.
- AceJohnny2 6y agoCorn in the US is heavily subsidized. It's why corn syrup is so prevalent in US foods, because the subsidies mean it's cheaper than any other sources of sugar. In the US, Iowa is the largest producer of corn [1] (producing nearly 40% more than the next, Illinois,) and thus the greatest beneficiary of those corn subsidies. Could we reduce those corn subsidies? No, it's politically nonviable, in part because Iowa has enshrined in its laws that it must have the first primaries in the US [2][3]. No candidate that has ever said anything against corn subsidies has won a primary. [1] https://www.cropprophet.com/what-state-produces-the-most-corn/ https://www.cropprophet.com/what-state-produces-the-most-cor... [2] https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/why-iowa-and-new-hampshire-go-first https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/why-iowa-and-new-hampshi... [3] https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2004/01/why-the-iowa-caucus-comes-first.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2004/01/why-the-iowa-cau...
- AceJohnny2 6y agoAnd if you believe in a link between obesity, diabetes, and the prevalence of corn products in our food, the chain of causality looks even worse.
- 6y ago
- selimthegrim 6y agoSarah Taber covers this very well on her Twitter (even though she has a particular anti-dairy ax to grind)
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThere is more than one twitter account that comes up when you search for that name. I assume you mean this one (whom I happen to be following already and didn't realize it): https://twitter.com/SarahTaber_bww https://twitter.com/SarahTaber_bww
- selimthegrim 6y agoYes that’s her.
- hinkley 6y agoFrom what I understand we probably all should. Mark Shepard also complains from time to time that dairy supply is outstripping demand to the point where farmers can't make money off of it. That's dumb in it's own right but if you consider the ecological footprint, then we have a problem.
- corty 6y agoMost important is nitrogen-based fertilizer, that can easily be produced from any kind of electricity. Most of the other stuff are minerals that are cheaply mined anywhere and won't run out for the next few thousand years. The most important oil consumption is for driving farm implements, but that can easily be changed to rapeseed oil in the short term and other green energy in the long term. So no cause for panic.
- dan-robertson 6y agoWell I agree that the oil argument isn’t very good. But I don’t think the conclusion is “no cause for panic.” I think water loss (especially from aquifers but also just drought and river diversion in California), soil erosion, habitat loss, and homogenisation are big worries. We’ve seen big problems from soil loss before in America where the prairie grass with its deep root systems holding the soil together was replaced by cereal crops with short roots and plowing exposing the soil. The result was the dust bowl.
- markdown 6y agoRapeseed oil isn't green energy. It's just more big-Ag.
- corty 6y agoWith that attitude we can just go back to the caves. Big-anything is what makes our society and level of population work, without Big-Ag we couldn't feed everyone. Without Big-Trans we couldn't distribute the food. Without Big-Trade, you would have to inefficiently buy from 20 small shops selling one item each. Without Big-Industry, your kitchen implements would be a pot and a kettle above the fireplace. Rapeseed oil maybe isn't a perfect solution. But whining about everything that makes headway just because it isn't perfect yet also holds us back.
- markdown 6y agoWhat a strange stance to take in a thread about how big-Ag has destroyed a third of US topsoil. You've been brainwashed.
- snarf21 6y agoI'm not worried about the soil, I'm worried about the water. The Ogallala Aquifer is shrinking. The more it shrinks, the more there will be compaction preventing it from refilling to previous states. We can always grow food in water but getting clean water will be an increasingly difficult task. Look how bad it already is in CA.
- nradov 6y agoWe can grow crops with far less water. Look at farms in Israel. The problem is that water prices don't account for externalities or sustainability, so in the short term farmers have little incentive to conserve.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoHow much of the water that Israel’s farms consume, depends on desalination? So, if it really long-term sustainable?
- dcolkitt 6y agoWhy would desalination be unsustainable? The limiting factor is electricity. And renewables continue to deliver Moore's law like improvements in the price and quantity of electricity, without any environmental externalities.
- gumby 6y ago> Why would desalination be unsustainable? The limiting factor is electricity. Disposal of the extracted salt is a serious issue. You can’t just inject brackish water back into he ocean as it screws up the ecology of the near shore environment (or wherever else you’re willing to squirt it.
- nradov 6y agoMost desalination plants do just inject saline water back into the ocean. There's no where else to put it. In most cases the outflow pipe runs some distance offshore into deeper water to reduce the environmental impact.
- titzer 6y agoI come from a long line of farmers. My father was the last of our family to try to hold onto the farming tradition. He grew up on a farm, along with all my aunts and uncles. His generation was the first go to college. He chose business. He made a ton of money, and hated it. After leaving the business world in the mid 1980s to return to farming, it was not the same, and he soon returned to what was effectively day trading in the early to mid 1990s. The transformation of farming is a direct result of corporatization and globalization, like almost every other sector of the economy. It's just more of the machine eating the world. Small, family farms, the kind that my ancestors toiled on, since unrecorded history, literally centuries, back to central Europe, were chewed up and spit out by the machine. The forests, the land, the local wildlife, now, too, the soil, all chewed up and digested in the pursuit of the one thing that the machine really craves: money. It's the legacy of our entire economic focus on profit, growth, scale. No big conspiracy, no evil bad actors you can hate forever, just the summation of our value system expressed in the invisible hand of the market, jostled or cajoled here and there by policy, or retarded briefly by it, but always pointing in the same direction, eventually to consume all the natural resources, dipping over the threshold of sustainability to the reservoir of resources behind it, extracting and emptying it, until eventually there is nothing left.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tharkun__ 6y agoI'm not sure how much this actually scales and makes enough money but it sure is an awesome tale (saw the movie on Netflix - https://www.netflix.com/ca/title/81031829 https://www.netflix.com/ca/title/81031829): https://www.biggestlittlefarmmovie.com/ https://www.biggestlittlefarmmovie.com/ Your dad might love it, even if just for the nostalgia. That said, I think some of the lessons in there are awesome. Both the ones about biodiversity but also perseverance in the light of 'disaster' striking and staying strong and going on with the biodiversity path instead of just resigning and saying "yep, alright, Big Farmer is right, this doesn't work".
- stefs 6y ago
- hangonhn 6y agoThere's nothing bucolic about farming -- ever. Both my wife and I come from farming families. I lost a great grandfather who effectively worked himself to death in his early 30s and my wife had a great grandfather who died from being attacked by a bull. Farming has always been very hard work. I have friends in tech who grew up in farming families and they are the few people in tech who can easily get up early in the morning because that's also a part of farming life -- get up before the sun is even up. I don't know where the romanticized idea of farming life came from because it was never that great. Historically, it was just a way to provide food for your family and maybe make a profit on the side if you're lucky.