6 ms·
It does not help that Middle Ages cover about 1000 years and very different civilizations. This is a huge span of history. From someone who was alive in 1500, t
by inglor_cz 6y ago
It does not help that Middle Ages cover about 1000 years and very different civilizations. This is a huge span of history. From someone who was alive in 1500, the age of Huns, Avars, Vikings and Pechenegs was more distant than first spaceflight.
But Early Middle Ages were pretty bad in a lot of Europe, there is no way around it. The combination of large scale attacks and primitive agricultural technology was deadly.
Last year I read an article by Czech archeologists who excavated two old burial grounds in Southern Moravia. One was dated approximately to 850-950 AD, the other between 1100-1150 AD. They were just a few miles away from each other. Both were peasants' cemeteries. But the average age of the buried adults grew by 11 years in the meantime. That is a big chunk of extra life, caused by "less war" and "more food".
- heavenlyblue 6y ago> But the average age of the buried adults grew by 11 years in the meantime. Was that progress or luck? It doesn't seem to me many things would chane in peasant's life.
- cygx 6y agoWho knows about this particular burial ground, but large chunks of Europe did go through a 'rough spot' (cities depopulating, total population declining, industries collapsing, ...) in late aniquity/the early middle ages that took centuries to recover from. Sadly, there's this unfortunate tendency to over-correct in the opposite direction when trying to clear up popular misconceptions...
- pjc50 6y ago> less war and more food
- ivanhoe 6y agoLife of peasants greatly improved in Western Europe after the 14th century due to plague killing half of the population, leaving to survivors more land and food and scarcity of work force. And then later in 15th century with the invention of printing the literacy and education became available to common people which again significantly influenced and improved their lives.
- southerntofu 6y agoJust nitpicking here, but I don't think "literacy and education became available to common people" in the 15th century. In fact, for quite some time after Gutenberg's printing press was invented (or reinvented, depending from what cultural angle you look at history) it was common practice for States and catholic Church to legally prevent people from printing stuff: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printing_patent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printing_patent
- ivanhoe 6y agoDepends on the country I guess, the Venetian Republic seems to had more than 150 presses by 1500, the most famous of publishers Aldus Manutius printing 30 thousands of inexpensive “pocket editions” books in just 5 years ("six titles a year for the next five years", at 1000 copies per edition) according to Encyclopedia Britannica https://www.britannica.com/topic/publishing/The-medieval-book https://www.britannica.com/topic/publishing/The-medieval-boo...
- southerntofu 6y agoInteresting! Thanks for sharing. I still would not say 30K books is "available to common people" (most of whom could not read), but i was definitely not aware Venice had such a policy so early in history.
- inglor_cz 6y agoPeace is a huge improvement in a peasant's life. With no more invaders coming across the fields, killing indiscriminately, trampling down wheat and rye, burning villages down and stealing your meagre reserves of food, you and your kids have much better chances to survive. Magyar (proto-Hungarian) raids of the early 10th century were pretty destructive in that corner of the world.
- goto11 6y ago> The combination of large scale attacks and primitive agricultural technology was deadly. The thing is, this depends a lot on which side of the attack you are on! In Scandinavia, the early middle ages (called the Viking Age) was a golden age in terms of political power and influence and also a high point of art and culture. In history there are always many sides, and often they are glossed over in the overarching narrative. For example the fall of Rome was clearly a cultural setback for Italy (which is of course why the narrative of The Renaissance originated there). But was it also a setback for the subjugates areas like France, England which now became independent? Rome continued to prosper centered in Constantinople, but had a large setback when it was plundered by the crusaders and Venice, leading to the balance of power tipping back to the Italian states - hence the "rebirth". Saying early middle ages was "bad" or "good" really depends on how you anchor the narrative. Same with the renaissance(s).
- bluetomcat 6y agoHistory is a bitch in the hands of the current political arrangement. There are indisputable historical facts about things in the past that have happened - wars, civil conflicts, inventions, works of art. Then there are endless possible interpretations and viable (but not provable) causal relations between the facts. Heck, we can't even identify the proper causal relationship for events happening around us right now. Then how about going N centuries back and trying to reason about the involved parties and their intents? We don't know what conversations took place between them, what their internal agenda was, etc.
- kungito 6y agoOne thing is for sure. A big boat was stuck in the Suez Canal recently.
- christophilus 6y agoThat was a deep fake.
- 6y ago
- amelius 6y agoOn the bright side, if history wasn't so damn cruel, we wouldn't have such great athletes.
- pjc50 6y ago? Athleticism is something that's increased dramatically over the 20th century. The cruelty of history physically stunts humans.
- krageon 6y agoAre you seriously implying that before there were marathons, the capability for long-range running didn't exist (or existed much less)? Athleticism as a general activity has increased because it's a leisure activity (as in, something you do when there's not anything really important to do), so it makes sense that there's a dramatic rise in it when we're unquestionably in an abundant time.
- pjc50 6y agoNo? I'm saying that (as is documented by the olympic records!) the peak ability has increased. Things like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mile_run_world_record_progression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mile_run_world_record_progress... It probably was the case that the average person in a world where you had to walk everywhere was fitter than the average person in a world where you don't. Similarly people have gotten taller: https://ourworldindata.org/human-height https://ourworldindata.org/human-height
- r-zip 6y agoI think the commenter's point was that genetically, we were just as capable (if not moreso) before modern times. Of course people's lives and outcomes have improved; that's not in question.
- pjc50 6y ago> genetically, we were just as capable (if not moreso) before modern times They're claiming that, but on what evidence? Comparative measurement is very difficult, but at least with skeletons you can measure height. Which has increased.
- christkv 6y agoThe black death also created a massive redistribution of wealth. Labor wages went up, the power balance between lords and peasants shifted and power institutions were decimated.
- wassenaar10 6y ago> But Early Middle Ages were pretty bad in a lot of Europe, there is no way around it. I recommend anyone who is interested in this topic watch Paul Freedman's "The Early Middle Ages, 284--1000" Yale course lecture videos, which are free online. https://oyc.yale.edu/history/hist-210 https://oyc.yale.edu/history/hist-210 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZC8JcWVRFp8&list=PL77A337915A76F660 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZC8JcWVRFp8&list=PL77A337915...