15 ms·
It's kind of amusing that the entire premise of this article is undone by the aside: > update: Apparently it is possible to downvote comments, which I never re
by crazygringo 6y ago
It's kind of amusing that the entire premise of this article is undone by the aside:
> update: Apparently it is possible to downvote comments, which I never realized.
But while downvotes seem useful for comments where there's a lot more scope for false information, trolling, etc., I'm not sure what the additional value would be for posts -- they're either popular or not, and you can still flag posts that are actively harmful.
And then this:
> Is it realistic for users to expect to post in an environment where there are no penalties at all, no way for their peers to express disapproval or disagreement with their post?
Huh? Peers express disapproval and disagreement by commenting within the post. As I am doing precisely right now. ;)
Jeff Atwood is a super-smart guy who's done amazing things but this particular piece leaves me quite baffled.
- jokab 6y agoUpvoted :)
- harpiaharpyja 6y agoThe content of the article still stands if you take it about social voting systems in general. I guess you can apply it to like... Twitter or something.
- busymom0 6y agoThe content will soon apply to YouTube too as they are removing the dislike counts. Though YouTube is much different from HN.
- Hiopl 6y agoI'm also baffled by his position. I often think that downvotes on HN serve to reinforce conformism to an accepted set of values and ideas. Which might be okay if, say, you want to "immunize" a community against racism, sexism or fake information, but isn't great if issues (as in politics or even in tech on a social level) are a lot more nuanced and there might be plenty of room to explore ideas off the beaten path (and no, I don't mean inane stuff like "but masks don't work" or "but it's just like the flu"). It's easy to find yourself on the receiving end of endless downvotes for something that isn't offensive but clashes with the accepted HN narrative. It makes me wish downvotes weren't a thing. I'm okay with flagging, since I mostly see comments flagged that clearly break HN's simple rules.
- diob 6y agoI agree, I've seen a lot of downvotes simply on things that aren't pro capitalism. I wish comments were used instead.
- crispyambulance 6y agoI'm not so worried about it. There's certain number of "tar-baby" subjects/opinions that can get someone downvoted on HN really quick... like suggesting Peter Thiel is an asshole, or saying anything negative about crazy libertarians. But HN is ALL about discussion. It's a relatively safe place to float an idea and hear some provocative opinions. The techno-libertarians don't actually bite. Stackoverflow, on the other hand, has higher stakes. People are trying to figure something out at work and running into a brick wall. If they make the mistake of posting an earnest question they make themselves vulnerable and have a good chance of being humiliated and made to feel like shit by some smug prick who's having a bad day. You really need to put on some psychological armor before attempting to question or answer on Stackoverflow. It's an intrinsically toxic environment.
- diob 6y agoCase against it being all about discussion though, my original comment has been voted down for some reason. Please folks, just debate me or post a counterpoint. I think at the very least tie ability to vote down with commenting. In other words, once the user has replied to the original comment, they can vote it down if they desire. You might think this is a safe place, but I've come to just avoid commenting anything like this that might get "hive minded" into oblivion. I'm sure I'm not the only one. In that sense, it's safe place for a certain "kind" of people with a certain "kind" of opinion.
- clairity 6y ago> ‘I've come to just avoid commenting anything like this that might get "hive minded" into oblivion.’ that’s exactly when you should be commenting, otherwise the community is lulled into false conformity. contentious topics require more diversity of thought and more considered words, not less. internet points don’t matter, just the food for thought that comes with broader discussions.
- chc 6y ago> But while downvotes seem useful for comments where there's a lot more scope for false information, trolling, etc., I'm not sure what the additional value would be for posts -- they're either popular or not, and you can still flag posts that are actively harmful. I think this ignores the concept of purpose. If you are optimizing for popularity, then this works. But a lot of forums (including Hacker News, theoretically) intend to optimize for relevance, which is contrary to popularity in many cases. For a really clear-cut example, Kim Kardashian's Instagram posts get far more likes than pretty much any post on Hacker News. Would Hacker News be better if it were replaced with a redirect to Kim Kardashian's Instagram feed? In terms of how popular the content is, this is an unambiguous yes. But that would not be a better Hacker News, it would just be more popular because you've replaced Hacker News with something completely different. That's an extreme example, but the same applies for content that's more relevant than Kim Kardashian's instagram feed. Popularity measures breadth of appeal more than anything else, so if you're trying to appeal to specific interests or cultivate some kind of niche content, popularity can be a negative. Downvotes can function as a way for a site's userbase to say, "Whoa, this is not what this place is supposed to be about, even if it is broadly appealing."
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago> Downvotes can function as a way for a site's userbase to say, "Whoa, this is not what this place is supposed to be about, even if it is broadly appealing." Can be. I'd argue it would appear to me down votes here are overwhelming used for simple disagreement. It's fun to discuss what a thing could be, spherical cow in a vacuum, it's probably more useful to discuss how that thing actually gets used and how each of us weight the value of those uses.
- FalconSensei 6y ago> Peers express disapproval and disagreement by commenting within the post. As I am doing precisely right now. ;) Exactly. And this is actually something that I like about Twitter, and hate about Reddit. Don't like what I post? Reply and say it.
- dheera 6y agoA lot of HN doesn't do that, they just downvote. I think it would make a lot of sense to require a response before you can downvote.
- KMag 6y agoI fear required responses would be similar to checked exceptions. They're great in theory, but in practice, without a lot of discipline and actively maintained culture of quality, they both tend to devolve into low-quality boilerplate.
- ypeterholmes 6y agoDang. I've been on here years looking for a downvote capability. Apparently you need ~500 karma and I have 200. Any upvotes would be greatly appreciated.
- esyir 6y agoYou seem to have missed the point of the up vote requirement for downvotes though. It exists to restrict downvotes to those who are more active, and thus more "invested?". I believe that this was a very deliberately chosen barrier to entry here.
- ypeterholmes 6y agoI definitely did not miss that point. I understand the idea behind a barrier to entry. However I am pretty active. I read HN every day, and I've even written a few submissions, one of which made the front page. So wouldn't you say I'm invested? I just don't comment very often.
- davesque 6y agoI think it's worth wondering whether or not he still holds any of the opinions expressed in the article. It looks like it was written over a decade ago.
- brudgers 6y agoAtwood is smart, but the social sophistication of StackOverflow mostly came from Spolsky. I don't know if they are still available, but Atwood and Spolsky had a regular phone call that went out as a podcast from the earliest days of the StackOverflow project. In terms of the social structure of Spolsky thought "How do I move the Turtle in LOGO" [1] was a good question for the site (he wrote it). Atwood thought it was a bad question. Judging people's character by the questions they ask became standard. And people have an excuse to be rude and abusive on the site. Which is unfortunate. [1]: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1003841/how-do-i-move-the-turtle-in-logo https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1003841/how-do-i-move-th...
- mbauman 6y agoAmusingly Discourse doesn't have downvotes. It's a great piece of software, but the way in which the meta site is run is a little strange.