9 ms·
Previous Covid-19 may cut risk of reinfection 84%
- ashtonkem 6y agoNot that surprising, that’s how immune systems work. More surprisingly, it looks like some of the vaccines might provide even better protection than previous infection.
- tedsanders 6y agoIs that surprising? The virus is specifically evolved to avoid immune response. The vaccine is specifically designed to trigger strong and lasting immune responses.
- joedoejr 6y agoBoth statements are wildly inaccurate.
- bxrxdx 6y agoWhy are they inaccurate? Not trying to be snarky, just understand what you mean.
- Izkata 6y agoThe second one, at least, is wrong in two ways: The vaccines development was focused on reducing symptoms, and we don't know the limits of how long vaccine or natural immunity will last, simply because neither has been around that long. Last I remember reading, both are "for as long as it's been studied so far" - 8 months for natural immunity, 3 months for the vaccines. These numbers will increase as we continue keeping track of it to see how much the effect degrades over time.
- tedsanders 6y agoFirstly, we have a lot more than 3 months of data now. This study of the Moderna mRNA vaccine shows that after 209 days "antibody activity remained high in all age groups" and and "nearly all participants had detectable activity in a pseudovirus neutralization assay".[1] Secondly, sure, we don't know how long vaccine immunity will last, but that's a far cry from saying that vaccines were not designed for lasting immune reponses. For example, Pfizer/NTech's phase I/II trials explored over different doses, and they ended up selecting a dose of 30 micrograms rather 10 micrograms or 1 microgram because 30 micrograms elicited greater antibody responses, sustained over their measurement period of 43 days.[2] Thirdly, quoting from the abstract of that same Nature paper: "Two doses of 1–50 μg of BNT162b1 elicited robust CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses and strong antibody responses, with RBD-binding IgG concentrations clearly above those seen in serum from a cohort of individuals who had recovered from COVID-19." [2] Let me state it again, without the jargon: Vaccinated patients had antibody responses clearly above those who had recovered from COVID-19. This, as I understand it, is why the CDC recommends that those who have recovered from COVID-19 still get the vaccine, as it offers extra protection from weaker or faded immune responses. [3] Do you really think my statement that 'the vaccine is specifically designed to trigger strong and lasting immune responses' is wrong? As I shared above, the phase I/II trials of these vaccines measured time series of immune responses to help select the dosing, and they picked a dose that had a strong immune response that lasted over their measurement time series. [1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2103916 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2103916 [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2814-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2814-7 [3] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/downloads/vaccines/toolkits/CBO-FAQs.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/downloads/vaccines...
- bpodgursky 6y ago- The virus is not designed - All viruses evolve to avoid immune responses - The default assumption until we get new evidence should be that COVID-19 behaves like a Coronavirus, where immunity is relatively long-lasting
- chiefalchemist 6y agoPardon the nit-pick but it's more accurate to say: Virus' variants that avoid immune responses persist. That is, effectively, to evolve is reactive, not proactive.
- dhbradshaw 6y agoOne interesting thing here is that this is working against selection bias. That is, if you have had it then you start out susceptible to it. So the cohort studied for this number may differ from that studied for vaccines studies, particularly those performed selectively on people who have not contracted covid. Of course, I'm assuming here that people have different likelyhoods of contracting the virus given similar exposures. That seems reasonable but I don't know how large the effect is.
- raphaelj 6y agoCould go the other way too. Having had COVID with some strong symptoms can make you more prudent as you might fear to get infected a second time.
- JohnCohorn 6y agoPossibly sometimes, but anecdotally that doesn’t seem like the normal direction it goes. Of the folks I know that have had it they’ve become much more likely to take risks on the assumption that they “got it over with” and would probably have resistance afterward.
- vmception 6y ago“I had it six months ago” “I had it at the beginning” My experience matches your experience with other people Of course I haven't run into the other people who are out, have had it, and aren’t leading with that So we wouldn't know Its like the silent vegans that prepare their meals and you just don't notice. They're out there, in theory.
- ddingus 6y agoI had it near the beginning and it was terrible. Should have been in the hospital. Did not go for a number of reasons, and a big one was capacity and isolation. Early treatment was rough too. My fam ended up with it. Was early enough we just did not do what we needed to do. So we all were down for that month. Outcome? Ended up being ultra conservative about it. Still am. Older people in my life are at risk. And our symptoms were no joke. Mine were the worst of the family. That said, my experience is similar. I see way more people failing to be at least prudent about it. Many just do not want to be bothered, and or feel strong motivation to grab onto any rationale that can keep them active. I don't blame them. The lock down really sucks.
- standardUser 6y agoWith such a tiny number of confirmed re-infections from a virus that has been around for over a year, it seems pretty clear that natural immunity works very well and lasts a lot longer than many people feared. The various vaccine makers have all been very vocal that their vaccines would elicit an even more robust and longer-lasting immune response. I suppose that's what we would expect them to say, but they must have some science behind those predictions.
- microtherion 6y agoThe emergence of a second wave of infections in Manaus, Brazil, despite an estimated 76% of the population having acquired antibodies in the first wave, would seem to pretty conclusively demonstrate that a natural immunity strategy (or an emergence of natural immunity in the absence of a coherent strategy) (a) did not work well for the people and (b) provided an incubator for new, more dangerous strains to evolve. https://www.thelancet.com/article/S0140-6736(21)00183-5/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/article/S0140-6736(21)00183-5/full...
- wk_end 6y agoEvery time this has come up I’ve seen people point out that there were methodological problems with the study that found such high seroprevalence, and that plus the fact that there’s still few actual concrete documented reinfections - even as the P1 variant has spread around the world - or the fact that there’s no evidence P1 escapes any of the vaccines designed for wildtype (of course, the immune system is complicated!), at least points in the direction that there never was a 76% infection rate in Manaus.
- cameldrv 6y agoTake a look at this: https://web.archive.org/web/20210204143915/https://www.novavax.com/sites/default/files/2021-02/20210202-NYAS-Novavax-Final.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20210204143915/https://www.novav... Go to slide 28. This is Novavax's presentation of clinical trial results. As part of their phase 2 trial in South Africa at the end of 2020, they gave everyone antibody tests. In the placebo arm, 30% of that arm was seropositive (had antibodies from a prior infection). Of the seronegative group, 2.9% contracted COVID during the study. Of the seropositive group, 2.9% contracted COVID during the study. At the time, most infections in SA were the B.1.351 variant (referred to in the presentation as 501Y.V2). This variant has many of the same mutations as P.1 and is believed to have a similar ability to evade immunity.
- monkmartinez 6y agoCan I get a card that says I already had it and I am good to go? I even have the time off work to prove it! I am involved in a study that is measuring antibodies and 6 months later my antibodies are still really high.
- snissn 6y agoI’m in your situation but I got the Pfizer vaccine anyway. I think it made me feel good (look up long haul vaccine improvement) even though I didn’t feel like I still had symptoms. Cheers
- krona 6y agoI took a placebo and feel great!
- sa1 6y agoNothing wrong with taking a placebo. It works even when you know you’re taking one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- the_local_host 6y agoIt would be interesting to study whether placebos stop working if you forget to take them.
- camjohnson26 6y agoSchroedinger’s placebo
- bluGill 6y agoThey do. People who take their placebos do better than those who don't .
- divbzero 6y agoIs it appropriate to compare this 84% figure against vaccine efficacy? If so, it’s quite amazing that artificial vaccines can be more effective at providing immunity than infection with the actual pathogen.
- castratikron 6y agoNot unusual, look at tetanus. The tetanus toxin is so potent that the amount that can kill you isn't enough to generate an immune response, so even if you manage to survive there's no guarantee you won't get it again as you'll have no protection. The vaccine on the other hand generates a much stronger response than the real disease.
- ekianjo 6y agoExcept that the COVID19 vaccines don't work at all in the same way at the tetanus vaccines.
- newacct583 6y agoUh... yes it does? Both present an single inactive/non-dangerous molecule to the body against which it can develop an immune response using its own toolkit. Tetanus toxoid is synthesized externally where the covid spike protein is done by the body via introduced mRNA, but the immune system is doing the same job.
- tenanuswhut 6y agoSo they're the same if you overlook the tiny detail of where the antigen is manufactured, either via a totally novel method in the body via instructions encoded in mRNA versus synthetically in a lab somewhere. Yeah totally exactly the same 9.9
- newacct583 6y agoSigh. The question was about why it should or shouldn't be surprising that a vaccine generates a stronger immune response than a real infection. And tetanus was cited as an example. And it was dismissed as being unrelated. And that was WRONG, because the immune mechanism is basically the same and the only difference is where the antigen comes from. To wit: tetanus and covid vaccines both generate stronger immune responses than the virus they are designed to fight, and for very similar reasons. Do you actually disagree with that statement?
- outside1234 6y agoThere was another study that suggested however that previous COVID-19 wasn't as effective against variants and that that was one of the root causes of the current Brazil situation (many reinfections).
- bilbo0s 6y agoThis might sound like a dumb question, but does anyone know if COVID is a bit like the common cold in the sense that you get a different variant every time you contract a cold? So having had a cold before is a near guarantee that you won't get the same cold, but almost no protection against a different cold.
- worker767424 6y agoColds are a bit different because of how many different viruses cause them. SARS-CoV-2 is still a single virus for some definitions of "single" and "different."
- glofish 6y agoNotable commentary: > The findings of the authors suggest that infection and the development of an antibody response provides protection similar to or even better than currently used SARS-CoV-2 vaccines. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)00782-0/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... In case you wanted to know - several hypotheses float around on what provides more protection an actual infection or the vaccine.
- anonymouse008 6y agoMy intuitive and 0-observation question is how in the world can a reduced function protein give you a better immune response than the full-featured, infect anywhere there's an ACE receptor, c19 infection? ('A Request for Submissions' I guess should be the title of this question)
- nashequilibrium 6y agoStill a lot of work to be done, what I do know is, I have a family member who went to a friends party and got infected, he was sick for a few weeks and recovered without hospitalization. A few months later, the genius decided to go to a Casino near Reno NV and got infected a 2nd time and was just as sick.
- spookthesunset 6y agoI look forward to returning to a time when catching a respiratory virus is an act of nature and not a moral failing.
- sparker72678 6y agoAgreed. I also hope that some stigma of knowingly going out into the world while sick persists. Probably won’t, though.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoPre-pandemic I had a habit of chucking visibly sick people out of the classroom. No one needs whatever bug they are spreading, not me, not their classmates. This attitude of presentee-ism needed to die even then. We hope it's dead now.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoDoes anyone have thoughts on why there are so few documented reinfections if the risk is only cut by 84%? For instance this tracker only has 71 cases: https://bnonews.com/index.php/2020/08/covid-19-reinfection-tracker/ https://bnonews.com/index.php/2020/08/covid-19-reinfection-t... If it's that subsequent cases are much less severe then the 84% figure may be significantly understating the protective effect of natural immunity.
- ceejayoz 6y agoPerhaps a localized form of herd immunity? If people are getting it mostly from close contacts, maybe it already ripped through these little populations (families, small workplaces, etc.) pretty well.
- fy20 6y agoIt could be that the body is able to fight off the infection better, so they only have mild symptoms. Maybe they don't even know they have it again. The data in this study was based on health care workers who were tested every 2 to 4 weeks (i.e. not just when they felt really sick).
- betwixthewires 6y agoWell, I mean, can't be re infected unless you've been infected at least once before, so 100% of those reinfected had it before.
- newbie2020 6y agoUmm, duh. Has the whole world suddenly forgotten 9th grade biology these last couple years?
- anoncake 6y agoYes, they did. Remember how the existence of T cells, memory cells and literally the entire immune system aside from antibodies was treated like a new discovery?
- agumonkey 6y agoDo covid test detect past infection too or not ?
- 333c 6y agoThere are specific tests that try to detect past infection, but the general standard tests will only detect current infection.
- johbjo 6y agoAntibody tests are designed to have low false positives, not low false negatives. And blood samples have found that a proportion of samples have t-cell immune responses to sars-cov-2 without antibodies, possibly with no exposure to sars-cov-2 specifically. Specific antibody levels drop after a few months. Therefore, might be impossible to establish if someone was exposed or what level of immunity.