12 ms·
Just goes to show you what moral hazards look like. The DOJ (and perhaps similarly in GB?) has repeatedly preferred to prosecute white collar crimes seeking fin
by vlovich123 6y ago
Just goes to show you what moral hazards look like. The DOJ (and perhaps similarly in GB?) has repeatedly preferred to prosecute white collar crimes seeking fines instead of jail time. From their perspective it makes sense. The accused admit their crime, you get a quicker resolution, and the government gets more tax revenue. The problem of course is that everyone bakes it into the “cost of business”. What would the banking industry look like if HSBC executives had been personally indicted for the many money laundering issues they allow to happen? What would it look like if the HSBC’s corporate veil were pierced as a result of their malfeasance?
You don’t need conviction numbers to set examples around unacceptable bad behavior. Add enforcement and regular independent audits by regulators with strong regulatory capture protections, and you’ll have a better run system.
- coryrc 6y ago> corporate veil were pierced This refers only to going after shareholders. Employees can always be held responsible for their actions.
- missedthecue 6y agoI don't think there has ever been a case in modern history where shareholders have been criminally tried for a crime committed by the company.
- doctor_eval 6y agoThat’s the point of limited liability companies. Shareholders are able to invest capital without needing to invest anything else (like time) and without worrying that they will go to jail for something the company does, with or without the consent of the shareholders. This is hugely important to VC funding and to the entire share market. Imagine buying shares on the NYSE and next week you’re in prison!! So that is sensible I think. The flip side is that shareholders don’t get to make any material decisions about running the company; that’s the job of the directors (who might not be shareholders). Directors are, in theory, legally liable for the actions of the company they manage. All this would be fine with me, and directors certainly have gone to jail for crimes committed by their company, but it’s incredibly rare, and in Australia where I live, is generally related to trading insolvent, tax avoidance, or other clear and simple legal issues. But go ahead and let your company illegally blow up irreplaceable ancient cave paintings in the outback, and you’ll be fine. In fact, in Australia at least, the corporate regulator ASIC is so toothless that there is no straightforward way to enforce director’s breaches of company constitutions or other governance agreements other than directly with lawyers. This makes enforcement of the governing documents of a company (the documents that the shareholders sign up to) incredibly expensive and intimidating. Even clear breaches of the Corporations Act, the governing law of business in Australia, must be dealt with through civil law. So if you are a minority shareholder in an Australian Pty Ltd company and the directors decide to break their agreements with you - say an agreement to use green energy or to use ethically sourced labour - you’re screwed unless you sue them. If you’re a small time investor or if a significant portion of your wealth is invested in that company, you’re shit out of luck. The directors can do what they like. That’s messed up, because it means that directors can get away with almost anything, even if the minority shareholders disapprove, and there is zero recourse in the justice system. I presume that, as with many things legal, Australia follows the US in this regard, but I don’t know this for certain.
- gambiting 6y ago>>Imagine buying shares on the NYSE and next week you’re in prison!! So that is sensible I think. If you give your neighbour some money and he goes and buys a gun with it and kills someone, you can be held liable in that scenario(depending on the intent, on how well you knew what he was going to do etc etc etc). If you give a company money(investment) and they go and destroy the Amazon illegaly.....your hands are clean? I mean, obviously I understand what you mean. I own some shares myself. But there has to be some middle ground between "100% responsibily, straight to jail" and "give money to people who do bad things, have 0 responsibility".
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI'm assuming - hoping - that if could be demonstrated that a LLC was open about trying to engage in illegal practices, and the investor knew that before investing, then the investor could be charged with facilitating crime.
- sokoloff 6y agoLots of companies operate in a grey area. PayPal, Uber/Lyft, AirBnB, and others were all open about “disrupting” which is code for breaking regulations that some people don’t agree with. All four of those companies have made my life better and I’m glad someone invested to make them happen.
- iudqnolq 6y agoI'm sure people say the same about drugs
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt was entirely possible to achieve the same disruption without breaking laws, so think instead of the opportunity cost - the damage done to the markets, granting wealth to people who demonstrated sociopathic tendencies and blatant disregard for the law, allowing those people to follow their principles and abuse their workers/"partners" at scale, and erosion of public trust in local governance. All of which could perhaps be avoided if the investors were afraid to be associated with such scummy business practices, and instead pressured aforementioned startups to stay fully above board while realizing their vision.
- neilwilson 6y ago"The accused admit their crime, you get a quicker resolution, and the government gets more tax revenue. " The problem there is that the government has no need of their 'tax revenue' because no such thing exists in sovereign currency areas like the UK and the US. (As explained by Beardsley Ruml decades ago: http://home.hiwaay.net/~becraft/RUMLTAXES.html http://home.hiwaay.net/~becraft/RUMLTAXES.html) If they don't get it from the fraudster, they'll get it from the next person in the spending chain. It all happens anyway. (And if they divert it, then the downstream doesn't happen and they lose 'tax revenue'). For the integrity of the tax system, tax evasion must always involve significant jail time. It's the most valuable thing you can take away from the people who undertake these sorts of frauds.
- astrange 6y agoIt's the public (aka the holders of the currency) who get the benefit of tax enforcement, because it causes demand for the currency and so contributes to it having value in the first place. But there's multiple levels of government and not all of them get to print money; the US federal government does a lot of payments but doesn't give states whatever they want.
- naveen99 6y agoPrinting money is just taking on debt. Anyone can do it in proportion to their assets and future income. just your interest rates are different. Local governments issuing municipal bonds is essentially printing money.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoPrinting money isn't just taking on debt. For fiat currencies, printing money is inflation: a tax on money.
- neilwilson 6y agoAll money is debt. Government always spends by "printing money". That's how bank payment and clearing works. So if it caused inflation then we'd have loads of it, and we don't. Whether a bank ends up holding reserves, or holding a government bond is just a difference between a floating rate debt receiving the base rate, or a fixed rate debt receiving the bond rate. Just an interest rate and term difference - nothing else. The last year has completely debunked any question that 'creating money' is inflationary. Believing otherwise is up there with anti-vax thinking.
- neolog 6y ago> strong regulatory capture protections What are some examples of this or where can I read about how to do that?
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI think white collar criminals should be punished with prison time, but in the end how would it look - I guess the criminal sentences would have about the same deterrent effect as harder sentencing has on violent crime, drugs, burglary or whatever else. People would commit the crimes hoping not to get caught.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"The accused admit their crime..." Many times the settlements allow them to avoid making any admissions of wrongdoing.
- FDSGSG 6y ago> What would the banking industry look like if HSBC executives had been personally indicted for the many money laundering issues they allow to happen? It would look the same, we already know that harsher sentences do not provide effective deterrence.
- KSteffensen 6y agoThat is true for friday night stabbing type of crime, pretty much anything drug related (excepting the higher-up El Chapo types), and anything driven by poverty. Do it also hold for white collar greedy banker type crime?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe real problem is that the whole concept of laws against money laundering is operating at the wrong layer of abstraction. You have these criminals. Drug cartels. They sell their drugs and send the profits back to Colombia where they own the government and are immune from prosecution. The theory is supposed to be that you prevent them from getting the money or using it to pay their operatives in the US, since you can't actually put them in jail. The problem is that it can't make their business unprofitable. It can't because the demand is relatively inelastic. Heroin addicts gonna buy heroin. You make it less convenient, the price goes up, the drug cartels make more money and use the money to bribe whoever they need to or buy submarines etc. And all the AML rules can ever do is make it more inconvenient to launder their money. Can't ever actually win that way. It even makes it worse, because higher barriers to entry induce market consolidation. You get bigger, more violent cartels. Because AML drives some producers out of the market, but the others figure out how to evade AML and keep the higher margins from the reduction in competition, and increase their production to satisfy the demand left by the exit of the weaker producers. It puts more money into the hands of the cartels. It's a dumpster fire and should be utterly dismantled. The answer is to solve the underlying problem. Do the opposite on the supply side; increase competition so much that nobody is making any money at all. Decriminalization. And then address the problem on the demand side through regulation and treatment programs etc. rather than prohibition.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alexgmcm 6y ago>You get bigger, more violent cartels. Are bigger cartels actually more violent? I thought a lot of the history of the Mexican cartels was the Government almost collaborating with some of them because having one dominant cartel resulted in a lot less violence than multiple smaller ones.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIf the price is higher there is more financial incentive to fight over territory (violence). In theory that doesn't happen if there is an actual monopoly, but that only works for Mexico, not the US. Because even if there is only one cartel in Mexico and one in Colombia, that's still at least two cartels operating in the US and fighting over territory. On top of that, the merge to monopoly plan has the further disadvantage that then the monopolist drug cartel will be long-term stable. So their operation remains profitable and they never get shut down, which means their power grows over time as they use money to buy more power ad infinitum. You end up as a narco state. Very bad.
- fighterpilot 6y agoThis is also an executive vs shareholder agency conflict-of-interest problem, which is a consequence of limited liability in this context. The executives have an attractive call option. Get caught = limited downside (being fired, no jail time), and the fine is paid fully by the shareholder. Don't get caught = unlimited upside (bonus).
- theaeolist 6y agoThis. Having the company (aka shareholders) pay for the crimes of the executives is a hugely skewed incentive.
- api 6y agoNow they'll scapegoat cryptocurrency even though its use for ML amounts to a tiny percentage of the massive global ML industry. The vast majority of ML is via real estate, all manner of fake businesses and fake equity deals, the "aaaaaaht" market, creative use of things like penny stocks, etc. This is sort of like how they go after street dealers and small time drug "kingpins" while the real leaders of the industry (and there's a heavy overlap there with the major players in ML) aren't prosecuted. The real drug kingpins generally don't touch the product.
- deepstack 6y ago> The DOJ (and perhaps similarly in GB?) has repeatedly preferred to prosecute white collar crimes seeking fines instead of jail time The fine just became a cost of doing business for the banks and corps, and a funding the gov budget, truly a vicious cycle.
- TomK32 6y agoIn Germany if your tax fraud exceeds a million Euros it's prison for you, though it can be on probation.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoseverity of the sentence in Germany depends on who. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uli_Hoene%C3%9F#Tax_evasion_and_imprisonment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uli_Hoene%C3%9F#Tax_evasion_an... a brown person and refugee who gets convicted with a few gram of weed AND for not having a registered address with the police (as is law in Germany) often spends more time behind bars than somebody like the above. Bavaria (CDU/CSU) is especially notorious for being tough on immigrants or foreigners.
- an_opabinia 6y agoI don’t know. Incarceration is an old idea with surprisingly scant evidence, despite it long predating our ability to analyze it dispassionately. Besides, many white collar crimes, like money laundering, lack a proper victim. So you’re missing both the quantitative and qualitative justification to send executives to jail. Your outrage shouldn’t be focused on this. Instead demand that all justice for all crimes be evidence based, especially for crimes committed by normal people.