11 ms·
Facebook had ample warning about privacy problems with “contact import” feature
- throwaway122378 6y agoWe need laws against this carelessness
- darig 6y agoFacebook had years to not exist... yes.
- gherkinnn 6y agoAnother day. Another Facebook fuckup. When will this end?
- 29athrowaway 6y agoWhen consequences get real. Real criminal and civil penalties like jail time, billions of dollars in fines, etc.
- Daho0n 6y agoNever but this will help: https://noyb.eu/en/facebooks-gdpr-bypass-reaches-austrian-supreme-court https://noyb.eu/en/facebooks-gdpr-bypass-reaches-austrian-su...
- StavrosK 6y agoI love the NOYB project. Make sure to support them with a recurring annual donation if you aren't already.
- travisgriggs 6y agoI have an honest question, hope it is not deemed troll bait. I lurk and read quite a bit here on HN. I think I've come to feel pretty versed in the common anti-social-media gripes and stances, and that Facebook is one of the leading villains there. But I also read that there are some really smart and empowered/supported people at Facebook and they make some pretty desirable stuff (things like React, etc). On the one hand I picture a classic clueless business people driven culture driving poor demotivated engineers and so stuff like the latest hack happen. But then, I see this other picture where teams of quite functional teams are doing good engineering. I'm not used to these things coexisting well, especially for extended periods. Am I being too naive about that? Or perhaps my simplistic impressions listed above are too naive? What's the real story? And Facebook insiders here who can add insight? (Edit and disclaimer: I am neither Facebook user or a React programmer)
- nikanj 6y ago” Number of employees 52,535 (June 30, 2020)” Plenty of space for both groups
- travisgriggs 6y agoSo the good and functional engineering teams work on UI toolkits and all the poor programmers shepherded by non technical management work on the ever suspect contact scrapers at another campus or something?
- beagle3 6y agoMore likely it is compartmentalized in such a way that every single person has plausible deniability sufficient to believe that what they are doing is good “I help people find each other!” As Upton Sinclair noted, it is hard to make a person understand something when his salary depends on not understanding it. Doubly so when the salary is FAANG high.
- izacus 6y agoDo you think this also holds true for americans who develop weapons to kill people? American drone pilots dropping bombs on cities? Palantir employees, bank employees, lobbyists, people working on DRM and censorship systems, politically partisan reporters, etc. etc. etc. etc. I find this hand wringing around Facebook employees very wierd when it's so trivially obvious to find people that outright build systems for murdering other people and are even proud of it. If those people exist in hundreds of thousands, why is existence of people that build a webpage that sells advertisements and shows messages from people this wierd? In what way is it worse working for Facebook than working for a news outlet to write fake news that outright attacks LGBT communities? And why can everyone understand existence of those reporters and then wonder why people still work at FB?
- ForHackernews 6y agoI suspect weapons-manufacturers and soldiers are less self-deluded, to be honest. They believe there are bad people in the world who need to be killed to keep America safe. They also believe in the principle of civilian control of the military, and it's not the military's job to second-guess the elected leadership of the country. Who specifically gets killed is above their pay-grade. Contrast this with many FAANG employees who may believe they personally are "making a difference" and continually second-guessing and sniping at their (unelected) corporate leadership because they need to feel that they're On The Right Side of History.
- bamboozled 6y agoNo one really cares about this, in 3 months or less, it will be completely forgotten about and it's business as usual.
- dathinab 6y agoFacebooks "contact import" feature had been running on (in the EU): - it's the user who commits the crime - it's a crime not pursed by the state without anyone suing IMHO it's kinda ridiculous that this "gap in laws/regulations" hasn't been closed years ago.