9 ms·
Alibaba slapped with record $2.7B antitrust fine
- Trisell 6y agoAnd this is what it looks like the the CCP needs to take down an overzealous businessman. It’s not a traditional make him disappear in the night. It’s a slow devolving of his assets via fines and state directives. It’s been interesting to watch the CCP dismantle what was it’s arguably biggest capitalist/communist success story. Sends a pretty dire message to anybody thinking they can grow bigger then the CCP.
- tyingq 6y ago"It’s not a traditional make him disappear in the night." Well, they also do that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiao_Jianhua https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiao_Jianhua
- bpodgursky 6y agoIt's pretty wild how small his offense was too. Very subtle veiled criticism of CCP fiscal policy, and now he's being completely dismantled.
- jdc 6y ago"Punish one, teach a hundred" - Mao Tse-Tung
- jhvkjhk 6y agoDon’t address A’s words to B. “Punish one, teach a hundred” is from the Book of Han, long before the born of Chairman Mao.
- jdc 6y agoThanks - I was aware there was a Latin precursor but I didn't know about the Book of Han!
- mannerheim 6y agoI've never heard this saying, although along similar lines there is 'kill the chicken to scare the monkey' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_the_chicken_to_scare_the_monkey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_the_chicken_to_scare_the_...
- emmelaich 6y agoAlso Voltaire in Candide: > ".. in this country it is found good, from time to time, to kill one Admiral to encourage the others.” https://wordhistories.net/2016/10/22/pour-encourager-les-autres/ https://wordhistories.net/2016/10/22/pour-encourager-les-aut...
- SECProto 6y agoHere's [1] Cory Doctorow's take on why this wasn't actually some capricious treatment by the CCP over some minor infraction [1] https://twitter.com/doctorow/status/1324391639628959745 https://twitter.com/doctorow/status/1324391639628959745
- foerbert 6y agoNon-twitter link, in case that would have been useful for anybody else. https://pluralistic.net/2020/11/05/gotta-be-a-pony-under-there/#jack-ma https://pluralistic.net/2020/11/05/gotta-be-a-pony-under-the...
- SECProto 6y agoThanks, I had originally seen it on twitter or else I would've sent the blog post directly. Iirc it's something like 60 tweets so the post is definitely better!
- kortilla 6y agoHow can people stand this kind of writing? It assumes conclusions for all kinds of things that are not agreed on. It’s intellectually lazy even for people who agree with these views (“heavy slant towards finance being optimally a utility”, “Uber/Lyft ‘misclassifying’ workers”, etc). This is Fox News level opining.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoIt is an opinion. And it is interesting precisely, because it is not common and it forces you to reconcile your currently held beliefs and opinions with the authors. Frankly, I read much worse.
- kortilla 6y agoIt’s treated like an accepted fact though, not an opinion. That’s intellectually lazy.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoMaybe it was more than the critism. They might have wanted more competition all along. I don't know enough to debate though. Why do I feel the CCP is happy with the world's view of their system of a few guys with big egos whom pull are the strings. (I purposesly didn't use question marks. I don't want to debate. I'm suprised any system with Communism intrgrated in its name is doing great economically, and on other stages. I will never just assume any polital system that incorporates Communists are destined to fail, and of all nations, China worries me the most.)
- enkid 6y agoChina has a huge workforce to exploit, and its a lot easier to catch up then to lead the way. That's the main reason their doing well economically
- chid 6y agoMy guess based off my readings is that this view is what gives them their place in society not to be questioned. If the economic and social outcomes most people are happy with, faith in the party is maintained. It is an interesting contrast with the political system in the west where it feels like politicians don’t like to take responsibility for actions and blame it on large corporates... who work within the frameworks they have designed
- k_sze 6y agoI think there is a version of the story that the West somehow doesn’t hear a lot about. In Mainland China, the sudden interference of the government is attributed to the discovery of the stake of Jiang Zemin’s faction in Ant Group. It’s not a direct stake, but obfuscated through a chain of ownerships. JZM’s faction is nowadays widely seen in Mainland China as being full of corruption and selfish agenda. Naturally, President Xi doesn’t want to see the influence of JZM’s faction over something as large as Ant Group, so the government decided to halt the IPO before it got too big.
- dkural 6y agoWhy wouldn't the west want to see this? If a former politician the government dislikes owns shares in a company, the government should not simply punish the company - including all the other shareholders, many of whom are small retail investors and pension funds! If a former corrupt politician is the real issue, it needs to prove in an independent court there is corruption; and not punish some third party.
- k_sze 6y ago> If a former politician the government dislikes owns shares in a company, the government should not simply punish the company - including all the other shareholders, many of whom are small retail investors and pension funds! If a former corrupt politician is the real issue, it needs to prove in an independent court there is corruption; and not punish some third party. The only thing I can say is: “That’s just not the way politics works in China.”
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI will add to this a parahrase from a person I personally dislike: John Bolton. It goes something like this. When presenting their case, communist dictatorships tend blame things on mythical hardliners. Here too we have a scapegoat. The theme is different, but the tone is so familiar. That's not a shot at communist dictatorships. They do it, because as a negotiating tactic it tends to work. It is not unlike telling salesman you need to run something by your wife.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI'm pretty sure it was a convenient way for them to show that no one is above Xi Jinping and his reach, even for a relatively minor infraction in the eyes of the CCP.
- ChildOfChaos 6y agoJack Ma is an absolute moron anyway, they built him up and gave him his 'power' so they can take it away.
- 29athrowaway 6y ago"I think it is a huge blessing that we can work 996." - Jack Ma on 996 working hour system (9 am to 9 pm, 6 days a week = 72 hours per week). I think it's a huge blessing that he does not have a platform to make stupid comments like that anymore.
- bdcravens 6y agoDoesn't the startup world fetishize that kind of schedule?
- 29athrowaway 6y agoStartups fetishize selectively "maximizing the work not done", e.g.: low quality except on the surfaces the customer can see.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIDK what fetishes currently run in the startup community, but simplyfing design is a good thing. A component that has been left out of the system cannot introduce bugs and vulnerabilities into the system. Of course, it only holds up to a point, but "the best part is no part, the best process is no process".
- jhvkjhk 6y agoLeaders in startup world fetishize that kind of schedule. Workers want a normal life. BTW, Alibaba is not a startup.
- A_non_e-moose 6y agohttps://github.com/996icu/996.ICU https://github.com/996icu/996.ICU
- watertom 6y agoThis is hysterical. The Chinese government is their key partner, and is mainly responsible for their actions. They direct the company and then get mad and fine the company.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sshah1983 6y agoFeels like a slap on the wrist in the grand scheme of things. I expect this to be a catalyst for Alibaba’s stock since the cloud of uncertainty over how severe the CCP punishment would be has now been lifted and that’s very much been weighing the stock down the past 5-6 months.
- hodder 6y agoGiven the antitrust investigation was ongoing it was clear something would come out of it and a tiny fine is definitely far better than a ton of possible outcomes. I expect the shares to move up on the news but not too materially. Unfortunately it still doesn’t clear up the Ant IPO issue.
- jpgvm 6y agoI suspect it will actually result in a big move up in the share price, just not explosively so. The reasoning is basically this. Share price was $320 all time high preceding ANT IPO which ANT being valued approximately $300B. ANT IPO cancellation dropped 10% off BABA market cap, followed by a further tumble on news Jack Ma appeared to be missing/lying low and culminating with a single day drop of 13% when the anti-trust probe was announced. All in all we are talking about a drop of ~30%+ and 100B in market cap. If we can assume that BABA no longer relies on Pick One of Two and it's elimination as a practice doesn't materially affect sales (this is consensus) then there is really only 2 major financial impacts associated with this remaining: The reduction in the value of ANT following restructuring and elimination of it's credit products and the fine itself. The fine isn't material, it's less than 10% free cash flow/5% net cash on hand. ANT IPO was revalued recently at about $200B, so it lost 33% of it's value. BABA holds a stake of 30% in ANT so it's investment value went from $100B to $66B, material but not drastic. So material damage is about ~$70B. However that shouldn't be deducted directly from market cap because the company isn't valued on it's net cash - that would be insane for a growth company. Instead it's generally valued using a method called Discounted Cash Flow. Effectively you estimate future cash flows and discount it by cost of cash. If you reduce net cash by $70B and run the numbers conservatively it still shows that BABA should be valued at $300-400 if trading at similar multiple to it's peers that face similar regulatory pressure, potential credit tightness and US trade relationship issues.
- nine_zeros 6y agoAs CCP does more and more of this, rich Chinese will start feeling agitated about their government. If they only revolt and elect their own government where actions of thuggery are not ok, they will finally be free. I know a lot of chinese don't care about the government but such actions of stealing wealth is literally how a lot of revolutionary democracies were formed.
- csomar 6y agoRich Chinese did already see the writing on the wall. They have been aggressively buying real-estate in western cities in the last few years.
- Gustomaximus 6y agoDecades. Also passports. Wealthy Chinese are known to buy significant investor (which is not that significant) citizenship in several countries, not to move there but have an exit option. Also to be fair I think a fair portion of this is not fear of China changing the rules, often if the wealth was gained corruptly this is a way to protect it and move away from repercussion.
- jb775 6y agoDon't most extremely wealthy people around the world already do this? Look at all them who ran and hid in New Zealand within the past year.
- Kenji 6y agoThis is the kind of fine Facebook should get for leaking data of half a billion people, then shrugging it off and not even informing the affected.
- twhb 6y agoRelated: https://www.google.com/search?q=ft+Beijing+forces+elite+Jack+Ma+academy+to+halt+new+enrolments https://www.google.com/search?q=ft+Beijing+forces+elite+Jack..., first result. (Sorry for the indirect link, the page doesn’t load without it.)
- twhb 6y agoWould people downvoting please leave a comment saying why? I thought this was helpful.
- julee04 6y agowhat about tencent?
- howtofly 6y agoDon't understand why such a good question is downvoted. Tencent is essentially doing the same thing as Alibaba in Chinese market.
- jpgvm 6y agoSAMR already fined Tencent, Baidu, etc along with Alibaba for monpolistic investment practices. i.e basically unapproved M&A. I think it's most likely other anti-monopoly fines will follow for the other megacap techs in China.
- hindsightbias 6y agoPeak Xi. Anyone with any get up and go will get up and leave.
- asquabventured 6y agoBut if you are high profile enough they will just apply pressure on you indirectly by applying pressure on your family members who remain.
- kolbe 6y agoThen come to the US where we allow patent trolls to rip you apart. Where we allow frivolous shareholder lawsuits every time the stock falls 5%. Where we humiliate you in front of congress at every opportunity. Where we allow innumerable types of lawsuits for all sorts of reasons that conflict with innovation. Europe is even worse. I think this fine, in the grand scheme of things, is relatively modest compared to the crap that other countries make you put up with.
- elefanten 6y agoNone of the three things you mentioned matter that much? Don’t hear of serious companies dying because of those scenarios much. The Alibaba fine also comes with an iron fist playing puppeteer.
- kolbe 6y agoIn the same vein, a $2.7b fine doesn’t matter much either. But I’d take a 0.3% of market cap fine every ten years over the BS the US doles out to its corporate giants.
- xwdv 6y agoNow is the time to buy stock in Alibaba if you’ve been waiting on the sidelines. Haters will downvote this.
- dang 6y agoPlease stop posting like this and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26689206 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26689206. Also, please stop posting unsubstantive comments generally, and please follow the site guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), including the second-last one.
- perlpimp 6y agoWhat I have really read from crumbs collected is that Jack Ma is in Hu Jin Tao camp which is apparently is an "opposition" to Xi camp - hence the brash speech at the forum that got him disappeared a bit and now this.
- justicezyx 6y agoAlibaba had practiced outrageous anticipation ploy like "pick one from two", ie if anyone want to sell on Alibaba, they can ONLY sell on alibaba, not another platform. This hurts a lot of small and individual businesses who are very much depend on diversity of channels to boost sales, because they don't have much sales and marketing skills or capital for that. [1] https://amp.scmp.com/tech/enterprises/article/3115300/alibaba-antitrust-investigation-what-picking-one-two-practice https://amp.scmp.com/tech/enterprises/article/3115300/alibab...
- eunos 6y agoIs it similarly forbidden in the US? i.e. Is it legal for Amazon to practice similarly?
- justicezyx 6y agoWhile it's normal to cry that US cannot touch a bit on the big corps, when CCP successfully delivered concrete blows to monopoly, everyone is crying that it was politic driven... Sigh
- Leary 6y agoFunny people think entrepreneurs in China will no longer create companies because of this when in fact startups all hate Alibaba. Can't wait for a similar fine on Tencent.
- justicezyx 6y agoYes, everyone hates the big boys in China. Alibaba tencent are the worst bully one can imagine worldwide in the corporate worlds. They were enjoying great monoply from bullying competitors and supply chain. For instance, Tecent had 94% winning rate in its local court, while only around 50% in Beijing. [1] (unfortunately that's in Chinese) Tencent is also well known for copying small competitors products. In fact, almost all major products from tencent are copies. And a lot of the original firms that pioneered those products were forced out of the market because of Tencent's strong hold through Qq and we chat [2] [1] https://finance.sina.cn/2021-02-23/detail-ikftssap8206412.d.html?from=wap https://finance.sina.cn/2021-02-23/detail-ikftssap8206412.d.... [2] https://www.bilibili.com/read/mobile/1181581 https://www.bilibili.com/read/mobile/1181581
- melomal 6y agoSounds like this is a world wide problem and the idea of a company that does 'good' is nothing more than a CSR/PR play. Everything you have described can also be said for Google, Facebook and Amazon.
- luckylion 6y agoDepends on the incentives, doesn't it? Most companies are for-profit, they don't have any incentive to do good beyond what PR requires. If you set a company up as a cooperative, you'd likely see different results. It's pretty common for housing in Germany, I'm a member of one and am living in one of their apartments. I pay below market rate, they take great care of the project, are super responsive to issues and they usually pay 4% dividend to all members. I don't know of many cooperatives that do "normal" business, but I don't see a reason why e.g. a cellular provider couldn't run on the same model, being perfectly aligned with their customers' interests, because the customers are also the owners. Mondragon Corporation in Spain comes to mind, but I have no idea whether they're friendly to smaller competitors.
- cybert00th 6y agoGood! Now also make them pay it!