10 ms·
If I must have ads, I'd prefer not be tracked by hundreds of untrustworthy companies, and I'd also prefer not see irrelevant ads... This therefore seems like
by londons_explore 6y ago
If I must have ads, I'd prefer not be tracked by hundreds of untrustworthy companies, and I'd also prefer not see irrelevant ads... This therefore seems like the best bad option...
- JoshTriplett 6y agoYou don't have to have ads at all. The best option is an adblocker, and a non-Chrome-based browser.
- judge2020 6y agoI'd also like to support websites I visit, though, if I don't have the money to directly donate to them and if I am going to purchase a product anyways (think visiting an amazon product page, leaving it for a day, then clicking an ad for it to give x% to the website). Many websites today wouldn't exist without ads since a lot of their traffic is people who don't go out of their way to donate to websites they find useful. If I can do this without giving up privacy I'll turn off my ad blocker (and I already do for websites I find useful).
- londons_explore 6y agoUsing an adblocker is like stealing candy from the store... They can handle some theft, but if literally everyone stole their candy, the store would close down and nobody can have candy.
- goalieca 6y agoIt’s been said many times, but if the business model is advertising then you’re the product.. not the quality journalism or content. They’ll focus on generating content to increase engagement instead of perfecting what you think it is they are supposed to deliver. Perhaps it is time for an advertising model to die out as the default.
- cortesoft 6y agoOk, then don’t patronize sites supported by ads.
- Nursie 6y agoThis is why I’m more than happy when sites say “adblocker detected, please disable or leave”. I will not render your ads. I’d be happy to put that in the first http request to your site. If that means no site for me, then quite honestly 90% of my browsing is a waste of time anyway.
- simias 6y agoOr they'll move on to a more sustainable business model that doesn't involve selling their user's privacy?
- jshen 6y agoA business model that will exclude the poor.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoLets not pretend that ads help people with less money. Ads are designed to manipulate people into buying things they don't need. They encourage people to believe their self worth is linked to the things they own. That a persons status in society is somehow associated with how much money they have to spend.
- HeckFeck 6y agoPreach. I don't consent to tracking. I don't want my browser helping anyone track me in any way. I don't want to be pressured and manipulated into buying things I don't need. Advertising is not moral and I owe nothing to anyone who tries to manipulate me. Websites can move to more efficient and lighter methods of delivery to cover the absence of advertising revenue. Anyone skilled who works in the advertising industry is freed to offer his skills to better human endeavours. Everyone wins.
- somethingAlex 6y agoWhat do you mean by "more efficient and lighter methods of delivery?"
- HeckFeck 6y agoPlainer HTML and very little Javascript which will reduce development and running costs. As witness, this very website. It supplies all that is necessary and no more. It is very successful. With harmful incentives removed, this would encourage websites to focus on good writing and less on being 'content farms' to drive up engagement for the advertisers. All I want from most sites is the text. Not adverts, trackers and those damnable autoplaying videos that jump out and follow me down the page. I use the reader mode in most cases. Why is it necessary to use reader mode if not to cut the useless cruft? Why can't the web just be like that?
- calvinmorrison 6y agoMost cost is producing content, not hosting.
- throwaway3699 6y ago> Anyone skilled who works in the advertising industry is freed to offer his skills to better human endeavours. I don't want to be rude, but won't they just end up losing their livelihoods? If the advertising industry goes, most programmers will see their salaries drop hugely. Even those not working in advertising will see a drop due to the flood of supply.
- dathinab 6y agoHonestly I have no problems with ad's as long as it doesn't involve any tracking (or lets call it what it is spying). If blog or similar can finance part of their cost with Ad's, why not. Sure on slow internet it's a somewhat different matter. Anyway Ad's okay, but tracking for me is spying and should be treated like that, i.e. it should be illegal. There are ways to have personalized ads without it, like local learning which then selects to get an add for a specific topic, with that a side could still track which ads you got, but it would be much less useful as FLoC, and then you add additional steps to even further decrees any chance of tracking. Companies still get implicit feedback by what adds get selected more then others. People can explicitly blacklist annoying (or offensive) adds making sure they don't see them ever again and if enough do so in turn making that app not seen much more at all etc. etc. But the FLoC cohorts are WAY to small/identifiying to not allow you to be tracked fairly easy with it. Just combine it with other identifying aspects of browsers (there are a lot) and I wouldn't be surprised if it's often allows a 100% unique identification. And given that you likely wont be able to "ad-block" FLoC this makes it way worse then the status quo.
- Ntrails 6y agoIf you could give me a world in which ads were always static images with a link behind them and nothing more. Where they never move, never pop, never animate, never play sounds or video, never run scripts etc etc... Yeah, in that world, ads would be ok with me. Sure they're pointless because I won't click on them - but not really worse than having a blank spot in the page because of an ad blocker.
- tremon 6y agoHonestly I have no problems with ad's While I have no problem with the concept itself of advertising, I do have a problem with modern implementations of ads. Almost invariably, they are loud (vocally and visually), intrusive, obnoxious and almost coercive in their use of language. They are intended to dumb down the target audience, rather than enrich their targets' lives. I do have a problem with everything that attacks my ability to think freely.
- admax88q 6y ago
- prepend 6y agoI see irrelevant ads anyway. I’d rather block all this and use Brave and/or an ad blocker. A choice of least worst is not necessary.
- tssva 6y agoBrave is a protection racket, crypto scam, privacy violating always with an excuse after company. Why the hell would I trust them?
- chrisco255 6y agoBrave is a free open source product that you don't have to pay for or use. It's a browser with an integrated ad blocker. I opted into Brave, no one forced me to. I asserted my right as a user to run software on my machine how I see fit when I browse the web. The ad model of the web is exploitative, monopolistic, privacy invasive, abusive to everyone, and makes the whole open web ecosystem bow down to the whims of Facebook and Google.
- tssva 6y agoI have opted into using Chrome, no one forced me to. I have asserted my right as a user to run software on my machine how I see fit when I browse the web. The ad model of the web allows me to freely browse the web while providing a source of income to those who work hard to provide the services and information I seek on the web.
- prepend 6y ago> who work hard You have no idea how hard people work. Ad browsing pays the same no matter how hard people are working.
- hackerfromthefu 6y agoSources? That just seems like hyperbole actually, and from a biased opinion or vested interest. Brave seems to handle privacy very well considering the choices available, and has made a number of good privacy decisions from what I can see after watching browsers evolve for 25 years. I have switched to using Brave and installing it for those I support. The crypto thing is 1) easy to turn off, 2) an attempt at a possibly better business model where users aren't just sold with it. Regardless I simply turn the crypto setting off.
- foobiter 6y agothe option to be tracked by one untrustworthy company? oh and they’re also in charge of the “anonymization” algorithm, oh and they also decide who is exempt due to protected status (race, income, etc), did I also mention they make the browser most people use and are one of the world’s largest advertising providers? where is the better part? is it the fact that this makes fingerprinting easier? or that floc makes more data available to advertisers than cookies?
- dathinab 6y agoIt's not because the way it's made it makes it easier for hundreds of untrustworthy companies to track you... It says it's about respecting the privacy of users better but in practice it fails very bad at doing so the only thing it archives is allowing Google to disable cookie based tracking and with that makes it harder for 3rd party trackers to be google independent (it not harder for 3rd party trackers if they use/abuse the FLoC Id and generay there are many ways to track users which are not cookie based so especially when it comes to the very bad offender of invasive tracking it doesn't make a difference or becomes even easier, but some of the smaller google ad (and analytic) alternatives will have it harder).
- Vinnl 6y ago> I'd also prefer not see irrelevant ads. This sounded good when I first heard it, but by now I understand 'relevant' to mean 'tailored to optimally influence my behaviour', eg showing me articles about the futility of voting if my political preferences are likely to lean a particular way.
- matkoniecz 6y agoI strictly prefer irrelevant ads less likely to influence me. I really have enough projects, TODO lists, interesting things to buy to last for lifetime of 250 years. Why I would want ads likely to influence me? There is basically no chance that ad will show me useful, worth using object or service to buy that I would not discover anyway. It would be just another scam more effectively targeting me.
- avree 6y agoThere are plenty of good products that only get discovered because of advertisement. People aren’t constantly searching for every single one of their pain points at once. One day, you may have a need for a product, and someone who previously solved your need can’t afford to make the product anymore because only a small percentage of people realized it was a solved problem.
- petters 6y agoThis has not been true for me. I have discovered interesting things in Facebook ads that I would not have discovered and bought otherwise. (They were obscure Kickstarter projects)
- matkoniecz 6y agoI agree that there is some chance that some products will be genuinely useful. But overall risk of getting persuaded to buy worthless products or scammy "investments" seems to not be worth discovering real gems. Overall I would prefer both scams and genuine offers to be as far as away from my interests as possible. Obviously, I would prefer actually useful offers to be close to my interests and to have no scams/worthless trash/malware/porno in my ads, but it appears to not be an available option.
- rainforest 6y agoMost Kickstarter campaigns I get shown on FB are from third party services that just upload the Kickstarter breach list (my email is in it). Could that have happened to you?
- 6y ago
- throwawayboise 6y agoIf ads are relevant to the content of the current page, no user profiling (even pseudo-anonymously) is necessary. To me that would be the best option.
- lupire 6y agoNot every web page has an associated strong commercial intent. Most sites, quality sites, would lose out to commerical junk sites if only commercial sites could make money from ads.
- TheSmiddy 6y agoCan you think of an example where there isn't an associated industry that would be able to serve ads? A philosophy blog is the first thing that comes to find but even then that can have ads for universities, textbooks, quirky t-shirts, etc.
- jefftk 6y agoWhile you can often come up with relevant tie-ins for websites (a weather site could sell vacation packages, a news site could sell... insurance?) it turns out that for a huge fraction of websites relevant commercial interest is just very low.
- natch 6y agoI prefer irrelevant ads because I learn about new things outside of my bubble. Who knew that ship designers could buy special plugins for CAD environments? Even though I could have guessed it (In fact, I made this example up), it’s still fun and interesting to be surprised.
- berryjerry 6y agoI don't think there is a time in the last decade where I received a "relevant" ad. The most relevant they have been is spamming adverts for products I already purchased.