8 ms·
Article misses the point (perhaps due to their capital investments) that the resurgence in active trading is almost entirely just gambling, but exempted from ca
by lupire 6y ago
Article misses the point (perhaps due to their capital investments) that the resurgence in active trading is almost entirely just gambling, but exempted from casino regulation.
Also, saying "no more" to refer to a blip fad is a ridiculous healdit.
- Scoundreller 6y ago... and with much lower commissions than betting on horse/footballer/dog races.
- gruez 6y agoIs it? Robinhood allows you to trade for free, but that's not the whole story. Bid-ask spreads add an implicit fee to each transaction. This is small for highly liquid stocks, but buying blue chip stocks directly also isn't exactly exciting. If you want the excitement of gambling you'd need to either use margin (borrowing fees) or options (worse spread).
- hogFeast 6y agoIf you bet on a liquid market, you will pay vig of something like 1-2%. Where I am, it is actually cheaper to bet (just think about how unbelievably fucked that is...you can see why VCs want to insert themselves into that) but in the US your trade costs are probably underneath that level all-in.
- nly 6y agoDepends. There are sports betting platforms outside of the US that work like stock exchanges. Betting exchanges can offer good liquidity, tight spreads and commissions as low as 2%
- jdhzzz 6y agoI do 99.9% of my gambling in the stock market because it historically is positive sum. Even with costs (commissions, fees, bid/ask spread). For me to win, you don't have to lose. Straight gambling cannot offer this.
- matwood 6y agoI do wonder if the surge will die down as everything opens back up. When the world closed down and there were no sports, there was nothing to gamble on. When RH was blowing up around GME, stats came out that many of their customers were playing around with relatively small amounts money. The amounts sounded pretty similar to what I hear people talk about throwing on a game. $25-$100 for the excitement.
- freetime2 6y agoRoaring Kitty’s posts that kicked off the GME craze had some very thoughtful analysis. And recently I watched some videos about dividend investing on YouTube that I would consider reasonable investment advice. I agree that there is a lot of gambling and excessive risk taking going on. And I myself stick to a 3 ETF portfolio because I like the simplicity. But to call it almost entirely just gambling I think is missing the point. There is some interesting and good stuff happening now in the intersection of social media and low cost trading, and it makes sense I think for VCs to be investing in that space.
- danlugo92 6y agoWhat 3 ETFs do you invest on?
- freetime2 6y agoSCHB, SCHF, and SCHE. That's a bit of an oversimplification because I do have some other assets I've picked up over the years. But the bulk of my net worth is invested in those 3. If I were to start over again I might even just hold SCHB, which I feel has enough international exposure to make SCHF and SCHE somewhat redundant, while also being more efficient for taxation purposes.
- Scoundreller 6y agoAs a Canadian, I have a similar stance: the US stock market provides enough intl diversification. Canada has a lot of resource companies which largely follow the global economy. Most big corps have less than half of their sales in US. Developed markets still pay with a visa/MasterCard and have iphones. Or the US owns a stake in their local equivalent. Or Amazon is expanding there. Truly emerging markets barely have a stock market, but their citizens probably eye a Coca Cola, have an intel PC and an android phone doing searches on Google.
- tim333 6y agoThere's a potential tax advantage in splitting into different holdings. If you need money you can sell the one that hasn't gone up thus delaying or avoiding capital gains tax.
- baq 6y agoexcept it isn't: if enough gamblers stick to one ticker, they can break the market. options aren't roulette and stocks aren't blackjack. casinos don't have this failure mode. gamestop was the example of what happens in the limit - only the DTCC prevented a global financial crisis as a circuit breaker of last resort.
- kreeben 6y agoIf enough retailers work in concert they start to resemble HF's. >> if enough gamblers stick to one ticker, they can break the market HF's, I assume, has had this power all along and they probably tried more than once to break the market. So, what's the difference then, between internet hive minds and HFs and why should one take more blame than the other when it comes to "breaking things"?
- baq 6y agoMore call options expiring in the money than shares available for example.
- nly 6y agoSports bookmakers will ban your ass if you look to be any kind of sharp, or engage in arbitrage (exploiting their slow pricing). Casinos wont let you put a billion $$$ on red or black just because they have a 1/37 edge on the roulette wheel. That variance is to high. There are failure modes
- baq 6y agoFair points. I had options in mind, casinos don’t have derivative bets afaik...
- cortesoft 6y agoCasinos absolutely have that failure mode (which is why there are table limits) Casinos need to ensure that they have enough liquidity to withstand a large bet hitting. The law of large numbers only works if you can survive the short term swings.
- walleeee 6y agospeculative fever driven in part by intuition that currency is being debased?