17 ms·
Setting up Starlink
- bserge 6y agoWow, I'm impressed! I thought it would take more than a decade to implement when it was announced, but it's here and it works. Just amazing. 100/16 Mbps is pretty decent I guess, hopefully it doesn't go down as the number of users goes up. The latency is great imo, 40ms using satellites? I don't think anyone has achieved that before. Would a bigger dish work better or not?
- Gwypaas 6y agoAiming for 20 ms later this year. (Elon time) A bigger dish would not lower latency but may increase signal strength leading to better throughput. But it's not a simple parabolic antenna. It is the first consumer oriented phased array antenna tracking the satellites as they move across the sky, so that would increase the antenna cost even more. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phased_array https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phased_array
- Reventlov 6y ago« A bigger dish would not lower latency but may increase signal strength leading to better throughput. » A better signal strength would probably lead to better modulations being used, therefore, less transmission and reception time, and a better latency, or am I wrong ? (at least that's the case for Wi-Fi: the better the signal strength, the lower the transmission time so the better the latency).
- swiley 6y agoIt could also mean less retransmission, depending on how the MAC works. That would lower the average latency.
- labcomputer 6y agoLatency in this case is dominated by time-of-flight to the satellite. At 100 Mbps with a 40 ms latency, there are about 2 megabits in the air between the ground station and CPE.
- Denvercoder9 6y ago> Latency in this case is dominated by time-of-flight to the satellite. Is it though? Starlink orbits at 550 km, time-of-flight from ground to satellite to ground would be only 3.7ms, twice that makes ~20% of the roundtrip latency.
- Robotbeat 6y ago550km is the closest approach. Usually it will be at least sqrt(2) times that (ie at least a slant angle of 45 degrees), maybe 2 times that. Plus the latency from the Gateway to the actual server. And the Gateways can have even greater slant angle to the satellite than the mobile terminals.
- Denvercoder9 6y agoI don't think it'll usually be at a slant angle of at least 45°. The beta requires a field of view of 100° after tilting. I can't find the maximum tilt angle, but SpaceX has authorization to transmit only 25° degrees above the horizon, so the maximum slant angle is 65°.
- Robotbeat 6y agoBut think what that means in terms of SOLID angle, not linear angle.
- Denvercoder9 6y agoOrbital planes are so close together that it doesn't make much difference. However, now that I've actually calculated it, your sqrt(2) factor seems to be about right for the average distance -- there's too few satellites per plane in the current phase. In this phase Starlink uses 72 orbital planes, with 22 satellites per plane, so 1440 satellites in total (they're almost there). It orbits at 550km above Earth's surface, so the orbit has radius 6921km, which gives an orbital length of 43486km. Separation between orbital planes varies depending on your latitude, but assume the worst case, where it is 43486km / 72 / 2 = 302km¹. Thus, the nearest orbital plane is at most 302km / 2 = 151km away from the orbital plane directly overhead. However, since the planes process, on average the nearest orbital plane is only half that, or 76km away from the plane overhead. Satellites within each plane have a separation of 43486km / 22 = 1976km. Thus, there's always a satellite at most 1976km / 2 = 988km away¹ from any point in each orbital plane, and on average there's a satellite half that away, or 494km. Adding all this together, the nearest satellite is on average √(550^2 + 76^2 + 494^2) = 743 km away (at the worst latitude). [EDIT: Actually, that's improper averaging, the correct average is obtained with ∫√(550^2 + x^2 + y^2) dx dy / ∫ dx dy on x=0..151, y=0..988, which yields 777km]. The original plan used 24 planes with 66 satellites, which reduces average distance to 617km. At more favorable latitudes the difference with the current design would be even larger. [EDIT: This should be 635km.] ¹ This is distance on the surface of the orbital sphere, straight-line distance is a bit less. It probably doesn't make much difference.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 6y agoI read that as "future versions of the antenna will be much improved", in price and performance. I know Moore's Law is being repealed, but that's still how new types of electronics work, right?
- kube-system 6y agoMoore’s law was specific to the way IC manufacturing worked. While it does (/did?) help reduce the price of electronic simply because they relied on ICs, the big price decreases you see in products after their early-adopter phase are likely just general economies of scale. Making small early batches of anything is more expensive per unit than making a ton of them —- regardless of whether it’s cutting edge tech or a plastic chair.
- geerlingguy 6y agoI think in the antenna's case, the primary goal would be to reduce costs for now (while still maintaining reliability), since the things currently cost $1500 per unit to make (SpaceX takes a loss on each new customer initially, for now).
- walrus01 6y agoI have seen as low at 15.85 ms from my starlink terminal to downtown Seattle. On average it's more like 22-23 ms.
- daniellarusso 6y agoSo, could multiple single units be coupled together? I assume that would be less expensive than creating larger circuit boards, shipping and packaging.
- gameswithgo 6y agoThe latency may well be better than landlines in some cases. For instance, data from an edge cache in your city will be faster than starlink. But data from china? Starlink may win. I wonder if it could improve gaming/video conferencing with people far away.
- Denvercoder9 6y agoRight now, that's not really the case though, as the satellite interlinks aren't operational yet. All your traffic goes through a base station relatively close to you, and continues over "regular" fiber around the world.
- tyingq 6y agoThis article and accompanying videos are interesting in that regard: https://www.circleid.com/posts/20191230_starlink_simulation_low_latency_without_intersatellite_laser_links/ https://www.circleid.com/posts/20191230_starlink_simulation_... It suggests they could be lower latency than a great-circle path ground fiber without the satellite interlinks.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- geerlingguy 6y agoI know my Spectrum cable connection gets high 30s range for latency. Starlink is close at low 40s, and as they get more sats up, that latency average may go down.
- zikduruqe 6y ago> 40ms using satellites? Starlink sats are low earth orbiting (about 250 miles away). The really high latency sats that people used to use were geosynchronous sats that are parked about 30,000 miles away, and the round trip delay between earth, bird, earth.
- house9-2 6y ago> 100/16 Mbps is pretty decent I guess Its fantastic, can't wait until this is available where I live. Currently paying $200+ a month for 20Mbps from local wireless company. 2 miles North from here there is AT&T fiber and Comcast available, 5 miles South there is Comcast (150Mbps) but I'm in a small community of homes where only options are satellite or fixed wireless.
- Scoundreller 6y agoMake friends with someone on fibre 2mi away with an old TV tower or at the top of a hill. Set up your own link.
- sillyquiet 6y agoThis seems weirdly specific and not terribly practical advice
- Scoundreller 6y agohow so?
- sillyquiet 6y agoFind an old tower? c'mon
- m4rtink 6y agoYeah, that's how we got most of our Internet access here in Czech Republic, starting ~2005. The monopolistic telecom company was totally incompetent so people banded together, bough some upstream connectivity and the connected themselves to that link via wireless point to point links using commodity WiFi hardware with directional antennas. Since them most of these networks are still in place, now in the 100 mbit/gbit territory. And while most turned into commercial volcanoes over time, there are still some that work as community organizations to this day.
- esaym 6y ago> I thought it would take more than a decade to implement when it was announced, The idea of low orbit satellites for internet has been around at least since the late 1990's [0] [0]:https://tinyurl.com/9frjxbhz https://tinyurl.com/9frjxbhz
- tyingq 6y agoAside: The router design is as impractical as it is futuristic. The thing would fall over if you looked at it sideways, and the solitary LED on the front was hard to see unless in a dark room or looking closely, straight at it. Hopefully a 2nd iteration will be better! Wow, he's right about the shape of the router. It also looks like it forces the ethernet cable in front if you want to be able to see the LED, and the cable itself is pointed downward: https://preview.redd.it/42rc9fkqwnw51.jpg?width=960&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=1666578e2071ccda441afb8a421b482a247801de https://preview.redd.it/42rc9fkqwnw51.jpg?width=960&crop=sma... I suppose that's a minor nit, given what Starlink delivers, though. I'm curious how practical it might be for on-board aircraft wi-fi. That's a space that could use a leap in bandwidth/tech, as FAA certification makes it difficult to keep equipment current. I'm curious if tracking is hard since the satellites and the "ground station" are both moving around...the aircraft on all axis points.
- ncallaway 6y ago> I'm curious how practical it might be for on-board aircraft wi-fi I suspect it'll work well for this scenario. My understanding is that the cruising speed of a plane is relatively slow compared to all the other motion involved (LEO satellites move fast!). The US Air Force is reportedly working with SpaceX to test Starlink in various conditions including in flight https://www.avweb.com/aviation-news/air-force-testing-starlink-internet-on-aircraft https://www.avweb.com/aviation-news/air-force-testing-starli....
- mensetmanusman 6y agoI use the command interlocking strips for all my devices that I want standing up: https://www.command.com/3M/en_US/command/products/~/Command-Large-Picture-Hanging-Strips/?N=5924736+3294529207+3294737318&rt=rud https://www.command.com/3M/en_US/command/products/~/Command-... E.g. putting echo dots near a ceiling, or little lamps in a spot to prevent tipping by children, for routers to stand, etc. I like the satisfyingly ‘click’ when things are in place :)
- tw04 6y ago>Wow, he's right about the shape of the router. It also looks like it forces the ethernet cable in front if you want to be able to see the LED, and the cable itself is pointed downward: https://cdn.hackaday.io/images/8430831598574092393.jpg https://cdn.hackaday.io/images/8430831598574092393.jpg I'm not sure the image you link is a fair representation of the router. The one he actually shows is SIGNFICANTLY shorter/smaller/wider and honestly while it's similar it's a different shape. https://i.imgur.com/Pdw4cAf.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/Pdw4cAf.jpeg
- person_of_color 6y agoThe prices aren’t competitive for metros.. what am I missing?
- ncallaway 6y agoThat it's not trying to compete in the metros, and that lots of humans live outside the metros?
- eyesee 6y agoMetro areas aren’t the target. There is a large, underserved market that doesn’t have access to broadband internet, and for those customers this is a breakthrough.
- wolfram74 6y agoAlso while we aren't really used to this being the case with ISP's, lots of products get cheaper from when they are first offered. I think they're pricing a bit higher to start off with to just make sure they don't join the giant heap of bankrupt satellite internet companies.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoIt’s sad that it is even necessary in the US. Telcos were given massive amounts of money by the government with promises they would do this and then they simply didn’t and said cell phone service was good enough. I would posit that a populace educated on cell phone internet is largely responsible for the rise in intense anti-science stupidity and lack of fact checking we are experiencing. People on phones are too easy to manipulate and sway, the ad giants have mastered it.
- postingawayonhn 6y ago> It’s sad that it is even necessary in the US. Isn't it fantastic? The system of (mostly) free enterprise has created an affordable high speed service product that can be accessed anywhere on the planet.
- 6y ago
- nevi-me 6y agoThe cell grouping is interesting. A colleague likes the outdoors, so he's preordered one for his Suzuki Jimny, to mount on it. I wonder if Starlink are considering this use case. I haven't been able to preorder mine, because we're planning on moving out from the city to a small village next year, but the Starlink website requires a street address. Our villages are quite primitive, no street names (I think it's cos nobody's thought of it). So, the nearest town where there's street names, is quite far. I was feeling uneasy about using it as an address, this article sort of cements that concern. I have 50/50Mbps fiber, but reckon we could still be served by 20 down if needed. Exciting!
- mikepurvis 6y agoI imagine they'll eventually have more expensive plans available for mobile/roaming applications, but obviously you want a well spread base load to avoid saturating any one area. It sounds from some of the other posts like they also do a bunch of active assignment/handoff stuff as the satellites pass, and that gets a lot more complicated once you're also accounting for moving ground stations.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TheWoolRug 6y agoYou can put a google plus code (like coordinates) into the starlink address finder for places without street addresses.
- andrepd 6y agoWhy not just coordinates? Talk about overcomplicating.
- paranoidrobot 6y agoProbably because a plus code is harder for someone to screw up. Find the place on Google Maps, copy the plus code. Rather than entering lat/lon coords... except did you get the sign right, or maybe you flipped lat/lon, or got a significant digit out.
- poisonborz 6y ago> It's powered through PoE++ (using around 100W of power continuously) Not familiar with Sat gear, but this number seems extremely high to me for just powering an antenna (and some motors occasionally)
- paranoidrobot 6y agoIt's not just an antenna. It's actually a whole satellite terminal as well as all the electronics for controlling the phased array. It can operate entirely without the router they give you - plug in a computer, or another router (into the white port on the POE injector), and off you go. e: If you're interested in watching a Teardown of Dishy, you can see one here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOmdQnIlnRo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOmdQnIlnRo
- akamhy 6y agoJust for comparison satellite dish (Satellite television dish) uses approximately 30 watts https://joteo.net/en-us/electricity-usage-calculator/electricity-usage-of-a-satellite-dish https://joteo.net/en-us/electricity-usage-calculator/electri...
- portillo 6y agoA satellite dish does not transmit any information to the satellite. Satellite TV is a pure broadcast system in the forward direction. Moreover, comparing a parabolic receiver with a phased array is quite unfair. The amount and complexity of the electronics and processing power required is several orders of magnitude different.
- banana_giraffe 6y agoA better comparison might be HughesNet. Not perfect since it's different classes of satellites, but their modem is spec'd at drawing up to 60 watts on their latest gen. Though, in practice, it tends to draw around 15-25 watts, at least according to comments I can find online.
- parsimo2010 6y agoOther users have measured power consumption around 100W constant in operation. https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/l22f1u/power_consumption/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/l22f1u/power_cons... Power consumption could probably be a bit lower, but there are limits. Keep in mind that this is a phased array maintaining a relatively high bandwidth and high SNR link with the satellite. This is complicated microwave electronics design, a whole different ball game than old grandpas bragging about how they made a contact with someone across the ocean with 5W on their homebuilt HF radio. Starlink may have also made a conscious decision to make the user terminals "overpowered" so they can use a less sensitive receiver on the satellite, saving SpaceX weight, power usage, construction costs, and launch costs. The cost of more power usage is paid for by the user with an extra penny per month in their electric bill.
- rocqua 6y agoIs this cell limitation a billing thing, or is it maybe more fundamental? Perhaps the unit needs to be pre-programmed on where to look for satellites in a way that changes when the unit is moved?
- paranoidrobot 6y agoThey've said it's a requirement for the beta. They're limited the number of customers per cell. If they didn't lock you to a location, folks would say they were going to use it out in the boondocks, and then acutally use it somewhere it's already at the capacity limit they've set.
- wyager 6y agoI read something that made it sound like this was about FCC rules on roaming vs stationary ground stations.
- snurfer 6y agoOur Starlink connection (backup WAN) recently switched from a New York ip to one near Chicago. I think we've switched to a downlink station that is geographically closer and we're getting better pings and, possibly, better throughout (needs more testing). The service is expensive, but it's been a fun way to "participate" with all the exciting stuff SpaceX is working on.
- walrus01 6y agofor a very brief period of time my starlink connection was exiting the cgnat to the internet in chicago (the first hop that was a public IP was 1-2ms from various ISPs' looking glasses in chicago), and the latency matched for return trip to LEO/back, down to earth station in the pacific northwest, and then transport circuit to chicago and back. Then after a couple of days it went back to Seattle.
- snurfer 6y agoIs your impression that the service is improving? [We are South of the 45th parallel, by the way.] I think service is improving for us; we don't get the regular 5-10 second disconnects that were occurring every 10 or 15 minutes. According to fast.com, our loaded and unloaded latency has improved. Most media consumption (web pages, video, etc) compares favorably to a terrestrial service. However, Xbox Live (the limit of our online gaming) is still inconsistent. We get disconnected from game servers and from Live itself pretty regularly.
- walrus01 6y agoIt is definitely much better since mid January with increasing satellite density. Getting the antenna to a really high position on your roof with no tree obstructions around is important. Right now it's averaging about 0.28% loss to Seattle over the past 3 hours. But there are still some very brief periods of 4-5 second hiccups. Based on the monitoring systems I have running, it's more like 0.00% loss for long extended periods of the time now, and then a minute or two with about 10% loss. I haven't tested it a lot for online gaming but realtime voice/video conference type stuff all appears to work normally. There is presently a very big difference in simultaneous satellite density and lack of gaps at 49N vs 44-45N, however.
- fortran77 6y agoAnd Jeff introduced a new character: Flannel Shirt Jeff! He's the one who does outdoor work.
- freedomben 6y agoI'm using Starlink right now. AMA. I'm in East Idaho. Currently my dish angles itself to the north. It rarely moves itself north/south, and slightly moves east/west throughout the day. I've read that right now it locks onto a single satellite, although they're adding multi-satellite support later. My speeds are inconsistent, and interestingly they start slow (around 60 Mbps) but after a couple seconds they'll get to 150-200 Mbps (which is awesome for downloads). Latency is consistently in the low 30ms. I get some downtime every day, so it really is a "beta" like they say. I have a backup WISP. Setup was literally take dish out of the box, insert into tripod (included), plug in cables, connect to the wireless routers SSID and activate with the starlink app. After that I put the included router into storage and plugged in my Protectli[1] running CentOS. Everything works great. My only complaint is the CGNAT, but given the difficulty associated with procuring IPv4 addresses, it's understandable. [1] I love this thing. Highly recommend: https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B0741F634J/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B0741F634J/ref=ppx_yo_dt...
- 7e 6y agoCan you compare with T-Mobile’s 5G home Internet plan? Similar numbers advertised, $60 a month, no caps.
- ericmay 6y agoI can't compare but I think one of the selling points is going to be the satellite coverage for Starlink versus T-Mobile's cell towers. I do like T-Mobile's offering as an alternative to these crappy cable companies.
- m463 6y agoThinking about it, they may complement each other. t-mobile will probably have cell towers/coverage where people live vs starlink which grants coverage where people do not live.
- freedomben 6y agoI can't because the nearest city to me with 5G is several hours away. The 4G at my house is super spotty. I've used it for Webex calls when my home internet went down and it will mostly handle that, but I would never want to rely on it for my primary connection.
- tester756 6y ago>Unfortunately, since Annie's farm was 60 miles (100 km) away from my house, she seemed to be outside my assigned 'cell' of coverage: It cannot be changed somewhat dynamically? e.g by call to SpaceX? >(she works remotely for Reputation) How's that relevant?
- Robotbeat 6y agoI think the license SpaceX has for the terminals is for fixed locations, although SpaceX is applying for mobile terminals (ie for trucks, RVs, etc).
- geerlingguy 6y agoBecause a lot more people these days are moving out to more remote areas and working remotely where it was just not possible in years past. Starlink would open up a lot more parts of the non-urban world to this possibility.
- tester756 6y agoI meant mentioning company
- 1timewonderacc 6y agoI really hope StarLink completely replaces CenturyLink DSL. CenturyLink DSL 30mbps DOWN and 5mbps UP, real world speed is 2mbps DOWN and 512mbps UP. Never goes above this speed. CenturyLink DSL is a complete rip off. Costs $45 and they charge for the modem $10. $55/month total I would be willing to pay $99/month if it had at least real world speed of 30mbps DOWN and 5mbps UP ^_^
- justinwp 6y agoIn my experience, Starlink isn't suitable for many uses right now without some kind of wan bonding(speedify, speedfusion, etc). I currently have two cellular modems + Starlink bonded with some routing rules forcing connections(streaming) directly to Starlink. Since I installed in early March, it has improved significantly and I will probably switch the default routing rules to use Starlink and only use the bonded connection for ssh and similar. Overall, I am very pleased and looking forward to the continued improvements. More on my setup, charts, etc here: https://jpoehnelt.medium.com/upgrading-to-starlink-bc6d4cd7e32a https://jpoehnelt.medium.com/upgrading-to-starlink-bc6d4cd7e...
- walrus01 6y agoThis depends on your current latitude and obstructions - my starlink terminal above 49N is averaging 0.22% packet loss (1/5th of 1%) to stuff in a telecom facility in downtown Seattle. Its overall packet loss over a multi day period is actually better, and jitter is lower, than on a docsis3 cable connection at the same place. The simultaneous density of satellites and gaps, or lack of gaps at your location will have a big impact on the terminal's availability and packet loss to gateway at the other side of the ground-to-space-to-ground link.
- wyager 6y agoI’ve been using Starlink for a few months now. It’s great for the cost. One annoying thing is their super non-standard and kind of broken network setup if you want to use your own router. They have two subnets with different IP ranges (cgNAT and local) on the same Ethernet link. You have to do some weird manual routes, interface resets, and dhcp client configuration if you want things to work reliably.
- walrus01 6y agoThe issue you're seeing there, using your own router, is that during a network-unavailability outage, the starlink terminal will continue serving as a DHCP server to whatever you plug into it. When the network is up and you plug a router into it that's a dhcp client, it'll get an IP address in cgnat space and periodically renew it. When they're doing network maintenance/beta downtime/terminal firmware updates, your router will fail to get an IP address in the cgnat space, but the terminal itself will give the router a new lease in 192.168.100.x (you can ping the antenna at 192.168.100.1), and your router will be happy because it has successfully received a lease and can keep renewing it). Then when the network unavailability is finished, your router keeps its 192.168.100.whatever address and the terminal doesn't issue it a new cgnat address. This sort of setup is weird and not normal, so once your default-configuration DHCP client WAN port router is stuck, you need to manually tell it to go get a new lease, or set up your dhcp client in such a way that it always rejects IPs and leases in 192.168.100.x. I can see why they do it, because they want the starlink app on peoples' phones to be able to communicate with the grpc endpoint on the terminal during outages. But they'll clearly need to do something different with the terminal's firmware and how it treats BYOD router customers, because people will expect to connect a ordinary DHCP client and have it 'just work', and resume working after an outage has cleared.
- garaetjjte 6y agoSeems weird. I think they could just always assign local address and route all traffic from CGNAT address to it? It would mask real address from connected device, but as it is CGNAT it isn't very useful anyway.
- 6y ago
- eigenschwarz 6y agoI have Starlink and am in a wooded part of New England. I mostly agree with freedomben's points. All I will add is I still use my cell phone hotspot (Verizon -- only carrier that gets a modicum of service where I am) for Zoom calls or similar. Starlink is definitely fast but too many hiccups for video calls. Edit: More musings. There is a push to get broadband in our area within the year. If that happens and Starlink's service remains the same, I will cancel Starlink. For me continuous connectivity is much^3 more important than speed.
- m463 6y agoI suspect the hiccups will gradually disappear as more satellites get deployed. 60 satellites batches, just about every week, pretty amazing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Launches https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Launches
- pugworthy 6y ago"Rural" and East Coast is basically the metropolis some other areas of the world. Not surprising you'll have something better than Starlink sooner or later. Lots of other places? Not gonna happen.
- eigenschwarz 6y agoI never claimed I was in a "rural" area, just a "wooded" one. Indeed, Starlink will be a great option for many places. I personally hope they improve the coverage with more satellites so I can continue using it.
- lquist 6y agoAny way to track how many subscribers Starlink has on anything like a real-time (weekly or monthly would be awesome) basis?
- gonesilent 6y agoIt's been using sequential numbers about 75,000 end user terminals shipped.
- wdb 6y agoAmazing that satellite internet can be faster than internet here in (West) London (W9)
- malux85 6y agoI’m in rural NZ and I can’t wait for Starlink to be available here (it says late 2021 for my area) I have been trying to get the local ISP to install their system for 6 weeks now, their service is just terrible. Installers don’t answer the phone, they make promises they don’t keep, I have the keep hounding them, and the ISP itself has a monopoly position so they are abusive in pricing and customer service because you have no alternative :( There is nothing more frustrating than having money to pay for a service, the desire to have it, and the company who’s selling just being abusive and totally useless. (Example: before I got involved they were selling my elderly parents 8,000$ in unneeded networking equipment they told them was required) Save me Starlink!
- teruakohatu 6y agoIt really is going to be save the government a fortune trying to get last mile internet to rural NZ, so a win win for everyone. The only losers are the rural ISPs who everyone complains about. I am sure there are some great ones but the rest are going to disappear as soon as Starlink launches. If you want to send me an email (address in profile) I would really like to hear how the setup goes when you get it. When the sat-sat routing happens it will also be a good undersea cable backup Internet option.
- Jemm 6y agoSo I can't use Starlink for mobile Internet. Bummer would be great to take around on an RV.
- m463 6y agoI think that would be the killer app. My take is that they're manually scheduling satellite customers/aiming/timeslices and as they get more sophisticated they will allow this. The ultimate would be a self-contained electric rv with fold out panels - solar for the motors, climate and appliances, and satellite for internet connectivity. I think an acceptable middle-ground would be the ability to call-it-in change your address. But then there would be people that would get an address in boise, then set it up in NYC.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 6y agoI was fully expecting some Ansible after looking at the domain.
- geerlingguy 6y agoDon't worry, there will be some soon... https://github.com/geerlingguy/internet-pi https://github.com/geerlingguy/internet-pi
- bogomipz 6y agoIt's interesting that the post and at least one comment has mentioned intermittent outages. I understand that this is a beta product however can anyone speculate what might be the cause? Is it because there's no yet enough satellites in the constellation or is it that the rotation of the constellation is still be tuned or something else?
- geerlingguy 6y agoThe app shows the reasons, typically around 1-2 hours total per day (usually < 1 hour in the four days I've tracked it so far). Most of the time is due to 'obstruction' (when a sat is in field of view of dish, but there's something in the way—in my case a tree covers about 10° of the sky). After that is 'beta downtime', which is typically 10-20 minutes per day. Then 'no satellites' (see https://satellitemap.space https://satellitemap.space), when there's no satellite within broadcast distance—typically 5-10 minutes per day at my latitude. Hopefully the latter two metrics go down as time goes on :)
- ggm 6y agoNot here to disrespect anyone using it or seeking it, just commenting that with many cities worldwide mid way through fiber upgrades I worry this will be used to deprecate in ground investment in optical. I know a lot of people can legit say "fiber is never coming to me" but the NBN debacle in Australia comes to mind as a politicised capital investment failure (they dropped FTTP for a mixture of copper, optical, wifi GEO sat and coax depending. I got fiber. It's great.) The UK is another place where national broadband roll-out could freeze on this if the market bifurcated. Or NL with KPN not yet complete on a national fiber deployment. High Bandwidth and 30ms RTT is awesome. This is stellar tech (sorry) Lots of US metro areas trapped behind the consequences of the ma bell breakups, RBOC, cable TV and local laws forbidding Google fiber deals. Its the politics which ruined optical not cost really. Starlink shouldn't be such a rational choice for a metro area and it says a lot about capital investment that it is. Pacific Islands, rural and remote, city fringes with no viable alternatives, this is mega cool. Cities with infrastructure, It's a signal of some major failure this is going to be so popular. NZ ufb crown holdings, the signal got strong if you were too far away from the big towns it was years off. I can relate to any kiwi wanting this tech. It would suck to be seeing people up the road getting ufb and being off the planning horizon. Same with my oz mates who aren't on NBN fiber. If you're on the optus GEO sat stuff, this is going to rock.
- Taniwha 6y agoA friend here in NZ just installed starlink, has roughly the same experience as others - most of us here have gigabit fibre to the home, he lives just enough out of town that he's replacing marginal VDSL
- brandon272 6y agoIt’s always been my understanding that Starlink will never be able to offer anything close to what it achieves for rural speeds in a areas where they’d have many densely packed customers (I.e. cities)