14 ms·
U.S. adds Chinese supercomputing entities to economic blacklist
- 1cvmask 6y agoThere is a strangeness in the reasoning in the article. The claim is that these supercomputers pose a threat to the US but current purchases en route to China are exempted. Normally anything that poses a real threat would not create any exemptions. “The new rules take effect immediately but do not apply to goods from U.S. suppliers already en route.”
- tw04 6y ago>Normally anything that poses a real threat would not create any exemptions. Citation please? Exemptions happen all the time for all sorts of reasons. Off the top of my head: if the goods in-flight were already invoiced and paid, and on the books for a publicly traded company, halting shipment and asking them to take the stock back could have massive ramifications to that company and the stock market as a whole. If the parts shipped so far aren't enough to actually complete the supercomputer build, why on earth would the government force that company to jump through all those hoops? In general, retroactively punishing previously legal behavior is frowned upon by most folks in all but the rarest circumstances.
- hluska 6y agoI’m not the person who you’re replying to but I believe they have made a mistake. There is the US Munitions List, for which export is controlled by the US Department of State. This is a US Commerce blacklist so these items are not on the USML. I vaguely recall a shipment being stopped midway under the USML but I’m having an early 40s moment - I’ll update this if I remember the case and find a decent citation!
- kube-system 6y ago> Normally anything that poses a real threat would not create any exemptions. Define "real threat". Are we talking about an imminent threat, a potential threat, a long-term strategic threat, etc? The immediacy in which someone handles a threat depends on the details. For instance, high cholesterol and a heart attack are both a threat to someone's health. While you'd want to address both of those issues, one of them you might immediately call 911 for, and the other you might schedule an appointment for next week.
- refenestrator 6y agoOwn goal. We lost the chip lead because of outsourcing national-security-critical fab capabilities, and now we're telling China "don't make the same mistake we did -- develop your own capability".
- dtwest 6y agoChina already knows this, and has known this for a long time, they didn't need recent US actions to remind them. But I agree with your sentiment on the first point, what a huge strategic mistake.
- bllguo 6y agochina is not a hive mind, it does not exert the kind of iron grip over their private sector that westerners think. external stimuli like these could potentially have the effect of aligning the government's interests and the private sector's interests more closely
- dtwest 6y agoCreating semiconductor fabs takes billions of dollars in investment and can only be achieved by a few very large companies, most likely with government support and coordination in any country that builds them. While it is true that China has a private sector with its own set of interests, the Chinese government is already working very closely with relevant parties in this particular circumstance.
- bllguo 6y agothat's a good point, though i still think there's something to be said for the motivational effects of both parties now being pushed to do or die
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoWhy do semiconductor fabs cost so much? Billions of dollars seems kind of overkill.
- ENOTTY 6y agoEllen Nakashima of the Washington Post wrote two in-depth articles on this topic over the past couple days: * https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/china-hypersonic-missiles-american-technology/2021/04/07/37a6b9be-96fd-11eb-b28d-bfa7bb5cb2a5_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/china-hyper... * https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/biden-administration-slaps-export-controls-on-chinese-firms-for-aiding-pla-weapons-development/2021/04/07/0c45bf0a-97f6-11eb-b28d-bfa7bb5cb2a5_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/biden-admin... The TL;DR is that one of the sanctioned companies, Phytium, designs chips used in a Chinese supercomputer that the PLA's researchers use to simulate hypersonic weapons. The chips are designed using tools from Cadence and Synopsys (both American companies) and fabricated at TSMC.
- llboston 6y agoThe sad thing is, there is >0% chance that CCP will invade Taiwan one day using the weapon that TSMC help them build.
- zionic 6y agoBut they will pay for said weapon via the net economic extraction some boomer provided paying $300 instead of $400 for his lawn mower
- aparsons 6y agoWhy boomer? Are millennials or any other generation looking forward to paying more to avoid Chinese-made products?
- clpm4j 6y agoAs a millennial, I go to pretty significant lengths to avoid Chinese-made products and gladly pay quite a bit more to do so. I'm personally very aligned with Taiwan independence.
- 6y ago
- throwaway4good 6y agoThe exact same reasoning could be applied to big American manufacturers: Boeing, Intel - all provide products to the US military and have very large business interest in China. Why doesn't China answer back with similar sanctions? It is honestly a bit of mystery to me. The best answer I can come up with is that the Chinese government is actually quite content with the US forcing Chinese companies to fabricate on Chinese soil.
- thefounder 6y ago>> Why doesn't China answer back with similar sanctions? Because it can't, yet.
- throwaway4good 6y agoSure not directly maybe. But they could go after Boeing or Nike or Starbucks. But my sense is that the ccp likes their “Sputnik moment”.
- babesh 6y agoGo look at how plane orders from China are shifting to Airbus.
- dragonelite 6y agoThere are other ways to hit the US in their wallet, like allocating new sales to their EU rival. Let them fight each other. Its a more elegant way of putting diplomacy and economic heft at work. Also COMAC should deliver their first model to (domestic?)customers this year. Then you also have a joint venture with a Russian plane company.
- peytn 6y agoCCP is sensitive to its unemployment problem and needs the jobs for stability.
- z2 6y ago
- TheMagicHorsey 6y agoI'm sympathetic to the view that China is a long term threat to Democracy. Their leadership is authoritarian and most people underestimate the monopoly that the CPC has over China's economy. China's leader is not quite, but very close to an absolute despot. He does not at this time have any credible opposition or balancing centers of power. The only thing constraining Xi Xinping from going the route of Putin or Kim is his own self control. That's not a long term stable situation. Having said all that, half-measures to contain China are pointless. We either should have free trade with China, or almost no trade with China. Our tech controls are highly porous. There is constant interchange in expertise and high tech goods. China is only about 5 to 10 years behind the West on any given technology that is commercially available. The only stuff they lag further behind on is stuff that is completely classified. And that stuff is a very small list of things. Arguably, China is already exceeding America's capabilities in many next generation military technologies like drones and cyberwarfare. The West has to make a decision ... either we go the free trade route and hope domestic competition takes down Xi Xinping ... or we withdraw completely from China and disengage as much as possible ... cold war style.
- mc32 6y agoHmmm and a reversal of roles vis a vis Russia and China. For it to work the EU, US, India and the RF would have to form a block to counteract China like Nixon and successors did with China and the precursor to the EU to counteract the then USSR.
- dzonga 6y agoXi's point is - democracy isn't necessary for success. XiJinPing's thought is literally based on the idea that the future is a huge idealogical battle between socialism (socialism with chinese characteristics) and capitalism (corporatism). personal freedoms be damned till china gains it's previous position in the world. he doesn't want China to end up like the soviet union. once you read his manifesto you'll see the chinese singular goal. by the time, the west decides to disengage with china. china would be self sufficient and be able to engage with other countries.
- 6y ago
- LatteLazy 6y agoLaunch a global plague, clamp down on democracy, abandon the rule of law, try to steal land and sea areas, run a genocide and begin an armed conflict with your nuclear neighbour? OK. Build a super computer? No, no, no!
- dang 6y agoNationalistic flamewar is not welcome here, regardless of which nation you have a problem with. Flamewar in general is not what HN is for, either. You broke the site guidelines egregiously with this comment and have been doing it elsewhere also. We ban accounts that do that (and have had to warn you before). If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and fix this, we'd appreciate it.
- booleanbetrayal 6y agoJust another anticipated symptom of the Long Term Debt Cycle decline for the US - https://www.principles.com/the-changing-world-order https://www.principles.com/the-changing-world-order
- whomst 6y agoCan you be more specific?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Leary 6y agoThe Biden administration shows that America First continues beyond the Trump Age. Long-arm jurisdiction along with a broad definition of National Security means that anyone anywhere in the world can be sanctioned.
- seneca 6y agoWhy would America First not continue with any American president? Any nations' leader not acting first and foremost in the interest of their own country ought to be removed from office.
- knowaveragejoe 6y agoAn obvious answer here is that "America First", as with any isolationist and protectionist policy, is explicitly bad economic policy in our globalized world.
- gh-throw 6y agoIsolationism's probably not a great idea, sure, and there might be room to argue that protectionism is typically bad policy for the US, but the argument that protectionism is bad for all states in the modern economy, or that it's bad for every trade relationship the US maintains, is much harder to support.
- analognoise 6y ago"Globalized world" is bullshit - quarterly profit driven mentality has reduced our manufacturing sector to the point where it's a security concern. Also, the globalized world (re China) was, at one point, looking like they'd liberalize and join the rest of the world - we would all rather trade goods than bullets. That has proven to be a mistake, and we're correcting it by investing in manufacturing and infrastructure here. "But the global economy" - nope. It turns out it matters where the factories are located, and we're trying to right the ship - finally!
- knowaveragejoe 6y ago
- poxwole 6y agoRather hypocritical since the best Supercomputers in the US are often used for military purposes. For example the ones at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
- kube-system 6y agoThe entire point of sanctions is to exert a strategic influence over a rival. > “Supercomputing capabilities are vital for the development of many – perhaps almost all – modern weapons and national security systems, such as nuclear weapons and hypersonic weapons, Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo said in a statement.
- trynumber9 6y agoAnd? The US prohibited the export of all sorts of products to the Soviet Union because of their potential military applications. Why was China be exempt from these restrictions? China is still a one party, communist state. Perhaps they realized this fact again after the Hong Kong and Xinjiang crackdowns.
- mike_d 6y agoI doubt hypocrisy has ever seriously factored into a single geopolitical decision of any country. Interactions between nation-states are always driven by self interest. There is zero benefit in acting any differently.
- king_magic 6y agoI think it'd be a lot more hypocritical if the US was actively locking millions of people up into concentration camps.
- Google4567 6y agoWhat do you call the 3 million in US prisons and slave-wage prison labor?
- mlindner 6y agoI mean there's nothing hypocritical here. What you said is like saying "in a war shooting the opposing side is hypocritical since you aren't shooting your own soldiers". Obviously you only penalize one side.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoHey China, what if we "give" you Siberia? Will that buy us 20 years of peace? Maybe by then you'll deflate https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2014/07/03/where-do-borders-need-to-be-redrawn/why-china-will-reclaim-siberia https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2014/07/03/where-do-bo...