8 ms·
Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles
- nickthegreek 6y agoPBS Spacetime just released a video on this experiment. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4Ko7NW2yQo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4Ko7NW2yQo
- MichaelApproved 6y agoSo did Fermilab ;) https://youtu.be/ZjnK5exNhZ0 https://youtu.be/ZjnK5exNhZ0 Definitely worth checking out the rest of the videos on both those channels. While we’re at it, check out 60 Symbols’ channel for great physics discussions that hardly ever (thanks Brady!) include equations https://youtube.com/user/sixtysymbols https://youtube.com/user/sixtysymbols
- elorant 6y agoWarning. Sixty symbols is a black hole. It will devour all your free time.
- mseepgood 6y agoWhy does it take physicists so long to find the complete foundation of the universe? I want an answer in my lifetime.
- gbpz 6y agoI blame the mathematicians anf the engineers.
- mhh__ 6y agoSo far we're struggling to reverse engineer all the perl it was hacked together with
- collinvandyck76 6y agothe container that runs the simulation is extremely hard to escape from
- MichaelApproved 6y agoI know you’re joking around but does the universe seem hacked together to you? I feel like it’s incredibly elegant. All these low level rules are able to create such complex structures with beautiful order to it. It’s so orderly, we can play things backwards billions of years. We can look back to how things were just a fraction of a second after this version of the universe began. It’s astonishing.
- xxpor 6y agoIt's too bad we'll almost certainly never be able to answer the meta question of how or why we ended up with the rules we did.
- whimsicalism 6y agoThese questions are more metaphysics than science. I, personally, am partial to the idea that the anthropic principle has a pretty big role to play, at least in terms of the fundamental constants.
- xxpor 6y agoThat's why I didn't say metaphysics specifically. I really mean the scientific answer to the question rather than a philosophical one. How did we end up with bosons, gluons, etc as opposed to anything else? Maybe it was totally random. A combo of it being random, the anthropic principle being true, and the possibility that the big bang was actually proceeded by the collapse of $current_universe - 1 due to heat death seems plausible. It could turn out we're actually on universe number 1 trillion and this was the first one where the randomness worked out where it'd support life. Or maybe it's even the second. We'd never be able to figure it out either way.
- 6y ago
- ganzuul 6y agoHilbert's tomb: Wir müssen wissen Wir werden wissen You should not be downvoted. Spare the world a little cruelty where we can.
- vecter 6y agoHe/she is being downvoted for demanding an answer, as if they're entitled to one but all the physicists out there are just too dumb to figure it out or refuse to give them what they are owed. Perhaps that is not how this person actually feels. If so, a little humility and empathy in their communication would go a long way to rectify that.
- ISL 6y agoPhysicist here: 1. One should be rather specific about what 'the complete foundation' might comprise. The depth of questions one can ask is infinite, but some questions are more important than others. The g-2 experiment is asking a specific question: "Does the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon open a door to discoveries that are inaccessible with modern colliders?" It is tempting to regard fundamental physics as a study of "Why are we here?", but it is really a study of "How are we here?" The difference is subtle but substantial. If "Why?" is what you're seeking, you are more likely to find that answer within, rather than within the study of physics. 2. Physicists can do a lot more in these directions with greater institutional support. With great sadness, I recently departed a lab, where colleagues next-door were working on this very experiment, precisely because a collision between funding rules and administrative priorities made further progress within my specialty unsustainable. I was the third postdoc in a row to do the same; not for lack of scientific promise nor ability to attract grants.
- mseepgood 6y ago> It is tempting to regard fundamental physics as a study of "Why are we here?", but it is really a study of "How are we here?" The difference is subtle but substantial. If "Why?" is what you're seeking, you are more likely to find that answer within, rather than within the study of physics. I don't want to know why, I just want to know the complete set of rules at the lowest level.
- ISL 6y agoIt is unlikely that we will ever grasp the complete set of rules at the lowest level. I don't say this to be defeatist, but rather as a statement of pragmatism. To do so would be to have a convincing grasp of Planck-scale physics -- a detailed understanding of physics at and above energy-densities reached in the Big Bang. Some precision experiments and astrophysical measurements do constrain certain Planck-scale models, but a true test of whether or not we understand early-universe physics is likely to necessitate creating a few Big Bangs ourselves. Doing so, with known technology, seems impossible. If it were possible, doing so would seem fraught with actual risk. (N.B. for the non-expert reader: there are cosmic rays that strike the Sun at least once every five minutes (and Earth, at least once a month) with energies 10,000,000 times greater than anything humans have ever achieved. Those collisions, over the last 4,500,000,000 years, have not yet resulted in the disruption of spacetime or the formation of a black hole. You are very, very, very safe from physicists breaking the universe as you know it. :).) Edit to add: You, mseepgood, aren't alone in your desire for knowledge. One Stephen Hawking once stated, “My goal is simple. It is a complete understanding of the universe, why it is as it is and why it exists at all.”
- xxpor 6y ago120 years ago, we had no model of the atom, no quantum theory, no relativity, and only the first hints of figuring out radioactivity. Yet we were able to split the atom in 1942, create the MOSFET in 1959, and started launching the first GPS satellites in 1978. It's hard to express how much progress we've made in such a small amount of time relative to the rest of history. It's a god damn miracle.
- Iwan-Zotow 6y agoscrewed up half of biosphere as well...
- sto_hristo 6y agoIt's theories galore out there that aim to describe everything. Proving them right/wrong via experiments is the hard part.
- libraryofbabel 6y agoThere have been a bunch of articles near the top of HN on this result, but I found this one from Quanta magazine to be one of the best non-technical explanations. Particularly interesting was the focus on an alternative theoretical calculation for the muon magnetic moment: the “BMW” approach, which uses a numerical lattice model and produces a number much closer to the Fermilab experiment. For an outsider, one of the surprising things here must be just how hard the theoretical calculation actually is, especially as you get deeper into the decimal places and have to include the vacuum effects on the muon of basically all particles in the standard model, including hadrons which means trying to calculate the Strong Force. Back when I studied quantum field theory in college we never got anywhere near actually producing numbers for strong force effects; the equations weren’t soluble with the usual perturbation theory techniques. But it’s interesting to read about how it is possible to get useful numbers with these different cutting-edge theoretical/computational methods - but with some uncertainty about whether they’re actually right! Curious to hear any practicing physicists on HN weigh in on the BMW calculation versus the orthodox theoretical approach that everyone’s comparing the Fermilab result against.
- tobmlt 6y agoCan’t upvote you enough. This is driving me crazy-curious. It must be eating at the HEP folks... unless it isn’t, hah. If this becomes a quagmire nested with the muon quagmire within the new physics quagmire. I will surely have to find a way to renormalize my self energy.
- whatshisface 6y agoThe class of integrals that QCD solutions belong to is known to be NP-hard. It is not known specifically that QCD itself is NP-hard but it is suspected to be by many.
- penteract 6y agoWould this mean that either the strong Church-Turing thesis(any model of computation based on physical reality gives the same class of problems solvable in polynomial time as a Turing machine) is wrong or P=NP?
- DrBazza 6y agoRegardless of whether this is a real result, I always had trouble "trusting" the "Standard Model" when I was at university. There are too many knobs to twiddle, and levers to pull in order to get the results. The mathematics is non-trivial. Just reading the article gives you an idea of how difficult it is to make predictions from the model. Compare it to this comment about General Relativity: "Widely acknowledged as a theory of extraordinary beauty, general relativity has often been described as the most beautiful of all existing physical theories." (via wikipedia - Landau & Lifshitz 1975, p. 228). (ignoring the cosmological constant, of course). Compared to most, or all, other physical theories, the Standard Model feels like there's something much simpler set of equations underneath waiting to be discovered.
- whimsicalism 6y agoIt doesn't seem obvious that the fundamental models of reality would just happen to match up with the mathematical constructs that we humans have come up with.
- idolaspecus 6y agoOn the flip side, it wouldn't be entirely surprising if mathematical constructs that we have thought of are in fact very good models of fundamental reality. We should remember that, after all, nothing exists outside of fundamental reality, and if certain basic patterns can be encoded such that the encoding is both high-fidelity and simple, that won't be shocking. It might be awe-inspiring, but not really surprising.
- pochamago 6y ago>nothing exists outside of fundamental reality A bold assertion.
- CarelessExpert 6y agoThis is a deep philosophical debate: Is mathematics invented or discovered? https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/great-math-mystery/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/great-math-mystery/
- peter303 6y agoThe muon was the first non-standard matter particle and second transient particle discovered in 1937. It lead to much new physics in mid-20th century. And continues to suggest new physics.
- fasteddie31003 6y agoQuestion for physicists: Are the G-2 results more groundbreaking than discovering the Higgs particle to moving physics forward?
- peteradio 6y agoIf physics is climbing a mountain. G-2 result is seeing the next hand hold (hoping its not a mirage). Higgs discovery and its subsequent precision measurement is resting your toe into a hold and flexing your calf upwards.
- Diederich 6y agoI'm not a physicist, I just pay some attention to these things. The Higgs particle was expected, and so finding it within expected ranges was confirmation of the standard model. The G-2 results are showing deviations from the expected ranges from the standard model. In the former case, Higgs, the standard was further, strongly confirmed. In the latter case, G-2, there's a strong indication that the standard model is fundamentally missing something. I think that's pretty exciting!
- quantum_mcts 6y agoPhysicist. Some people in the community are quite excited because it hints at something beyond SM. The problem is that the quoted theoretical prediction for g-2 is not a settled issue and is a subject of a long controversy between various groups of theorists. https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/627852/386 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/627852/386
- podiki 6y agoI would agree with the other commenters. g-2 has been a debate for a long time, but fundamentally points to something new if the result holds. The Higgs was expected, and given the mass and properties we've seen, doesn't point to anything new. "New" meaning not the Standard Model.
- quantum_mcts 6y agoCheck out this phyics.stackexchange answer: https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/627852/386 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/627852/386 I've been involved in one of the light-by-light theory groups a long time ago. The situation with theoretical prediction is not as clear.
- dang 6y agoDiscussed yesterday: Particle mystery: physicists confirm the muon is more magnetic than predicted - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26726269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26726269 - April 2021 (282 comments)
- SMAAART 6y agoThe most exciting news in quite a while!