8 ms·
This is exactly the way the Stasi used to get new agents. Monitor someone who they wanted to recruit until they could 1) find an accusation for which the targ
by pessimizer 6y ago
This is exactly the way the Stasi used to get new agents.
Monitor someone who they wanted to recruit until they could
1) find an accusation for which the target would have no alibi (although they were clearly innocent)
2) confront the target with the accusation and the penalties for it,
3) say that (as an agent) "I personally think that you are innocent although you have no alibi and would have to be found guilty if reported,
4) "but to prove your loyalty, you could help us just this once in our fight against the criminals we just accused you of working with."
- onetimemanytime 6y agoWith so many Muslims why did they choose him? IMO, the no-fly-list should be challenged (and reserved for people who should be in jail, i.e., should not exist) since not traveling is so burdensome. If you want to blow up airlines you should be in jail or mental hospital. Is this the case of someone guilty getting 25 years in jail for not wanting to snitch?
- 8fGTBjZxBcHq 6y agoWait you think people in jails should just not exist? Do you want to uh elaborate on that a little? EDIT: yes I got it thank you to everyone who explained. I'm not a native english speaker and misunderstood the phrasing.
- elliekelly 6y agoI'm not the person you're replying to but I read their comment as saying the No-Fly List shouldn't exist. As in, if someone is deserving of government restrictions on their movement then they should be in prison, otherwise they should be permitted to move freely.
- haswell 6y agoI believe they were trying to say: "No fly lists should be reserved for people who are in jail ... and therefore the no fly list should not exist (since the people who shouldn't fly can't fly because they're in jail)". But their statement was open to misinterpretation, and it's possible that I might be the misinterpreter.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoNo, I said /meant the No-Fly list should not exist, at least of US persons. If you are too dangerous to fly, you should be either in jail or mental hospital.
- 8fGTBjZxBcHq 6y agoOhhh I see ok. Thanks for explaining that makes a lot more sense.
- abanayev 6y agoDefinitely not the obvious interpretation. Parallel structure of “should ... ie should ...” strongly suggests that the poster meant people in jail should not exist
- jrochkind1 6y agoI do think prisons should not exist, although I'm not sure that's what was being said originally. Here's an audio interview with Ruth Wilson Gilmore elaborating. https://theintercept.com/2020/06/10/ruth-wilson-gilmore-makes-the-case-for-abolition/ https://theintercept.com/2020/06/10/ruth-wilson-gilmore-make...
- cool_dude85 6y ago>Is this the case of someone guilty getting 25 years in jail for not wanting to snitch? Maybe you can let us know about the facts you have at hand to make claims like these.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoCourt case will answer that.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>With so many Muslims why did they choose him? It's their job to pick someone, you can't assume guilt because he was chosen.
- nashashmi 6y agoOften it is a guy who has little time , loved ones, and is both disconnected with the community and weak jurisprudentially IOW doesn’t know how to defend himself.
- mr-wendel 6y agoAdditionally, if you're not not assuming guilt then there is one thing you can assume: leverage. He's got a lot to lose which the article makes painfully clear: - time with family - personal reputation - fulfilling personal/religion goals - ... and a lot more Personally, I think it enlightening to consider the opposite scenario: what about those on the fringe with nothing to lose? The FBI has a life changing program for you! They'll give you a sense of purpose, a feeling like you're part of something, and all the support you need to ... become the star of the next foiled terrorist plot.
- kelnos 6y agoExactly. And in this guy's case, he also has a wife who is not a US citizen, so they can additionally threaten him with messing with her immigration status. Leverage takes many forms, and need not have anything to do with being guilty of a crime.
- danaliv 6y ago> Is this the case of someone guilty getting 25 years in jail for not wanting to snitch? This is an absolutely disgusting suggestion.
- onetimemanytime 6y agowell, it is possible that someone may have different feelings about the USA, despite living here, no?
- danaliv 6y agoDo you really not get how what you're saying is 180° from principles of due process, equal protection, and freedom of speech?
- Judgmentality 6y agoI understand that as a US citizen I have more freedoms than most people throughout history, but the idea that it's really free for everyone is a little idyllic. Obviously this is a hyperbolic example and is a tiny fraction of the populace, but you can't possibly talk about due process and reconcile that with Guantanamo Bay. There are many more examples to fill spaces in the spectrum, that's just meant to be a single point to prove it's not really equal for everyone.
- danaliv 6y agoI'm with you on all of that, but that's not what the person I'm replying to is saying. They're saying that the subject of the article might be a bad guy so he probably deserves what's happening to him.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoNOT at all. I'm just willing to believe that some Russian, Chines, "Muslims" or [insert anything here] are willing to do harm to our system. I am EXTREMELY happy that ACLU took the case so the truth has a chance to come out
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mikesabbagh 6y agoUSA is a beacon of freedom, Liberty and Equality
- temp8964 6y agoSo what happens to people refuse to work for the cops in other countries? "Sorry for bothering you, bye-bye"?
- xnyan 6y agoIf it’s a government for the people, yes. If it’s a government for someone/something else, then make people do stuff for the other by threat of force.
- Quarrelsome 6y agoyes-ish. No government is immune to corruption but certain forms of government narrow areas of operable corruption whereas others can expand it. It's always there but just harder to exploit.
- temp8964 6y agoI am asking about practice, not theory.
- giantg2 6y ago"make people do stuff for the other by threat of force." That's the basic premise of any state and society.
- pjc50 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_undercover_policing_relationships_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_undercover_policing_relatio... The UK is also proposing a law to give informers and police widespread immunity from prosecution for undercover crimes: https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/spy-cops-law-bill-police-informants-crime-lords-b1785410.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/spy-cops-law-bill-polic...
- 6y ago
- dathinab 6y agoThe also hindered you in all kinds of ways like: - You not getting a job. - You losing a job. - You getting "moved" to small villages (e.g. as a teacher). And if they couldn't affect you they went for your relative. E.g. your children being bared from studying at a university even if they are qualified and so on.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> - You not getting a job. > - You losing a job. These two seem to be getting more popular nowadays.
- WesolyKubeczek 6y agoRemember, it's only a no-no if the government does it. If it's "we the people", it's totally fair and indicative of a very progressive and tolerant society. Or something.
- vetinari 6y agoOh, in socialistic countries it was also the collective of your comrades, it wasn't The Government either. Or so they said.
- ttt0 6y agoIt's only okay when it happens to people I don't like, so whoever is considered a nazi or a communist this week (delete as appropriate). Freedom of speech is not freedom from consequences, paradox of tolerance etc., you know the drill.
- WesolyKubeczek 6y agoThe paradox of tolerance in and of itself is okay. We've seen already what happened if intolerance was tolerated, and way more than once. However, the tightly guarded boundary between "tolerant" and "intolerant", as well as "context thereof" must be defined precisely and not be moved around according to one's mood, or depending on whether someone is losing an argument, or whether someone is in an outgroup or in an ingroup. A good application of the paradox of tolerance requires integrity, which is a threatened species among human traits.
- SeanLuke 6y agoDid the Stasi also permit you to lawyer up with the ACLU and sue them in open court? What these FBI agents did, if true, was reprehensible. But surely we can come up with a better comparison than one of the most evil secret police regimes ever to exist.
- decebalus1 6y agoApples to Oranges. OP was referring to the MO of acquiring collaborators, not the legal environment surrounding it. Which is the same MO used by the secret police in basically all countries behind the iron curtain. Let's not mention people lacking money for a proper legal defense. But now that we're talking about it, you might want to read about FISA Courts. Also stuff like https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/federal-court-sides-aclu-no-fly-list-lawsuit https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/federal-court-sides-aclu... and yet.. Edit: Your boos mean nothing, I've seen what makes you cheer.
- anamexis 6y agoIt seems to me that they were comparing the tactics, not the entire institution, or justice system.
- KorematsuFred 6y ago> But surely we can come up with a better comparison than one of the most evil secret police regimes ever to exist. So we have to be thankful that we are "allowed" to spend our life's saving on fighting a lawsuits against a trillon dollar government ? For every such case there are probably 100 other people who folded. There is no difference between those cases and cases where stasi might have done the same thing. It is 100% same.
- gumby 6y agoThe comparison is certainly valid. Almost all the FBI's "terrorism" convictions over the last 20 years have been people set ip by a CI or agent, including the FBI supplying materiel. The fact that there still exists, to some degree, a mechanism in the USA to challenge this in some cases is indeed something to celebrate, but the quite reasonable comparison is not just legitimate and appropriate but is a tool for trying to fix the injustice, not just retail (one victim at a time) but wholesale (change of law).
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoNo alibi == found guilty? Under the Stasi, probably. In a decent system? No. Presumption of innocence is supposed to fix exactly this.
- noitpmeder 6y agoThe issue is most people don't think this way. They immediately jump to the worst case scenario and are pressured to accept.
- skrtskrt 6y agowithout an alibi it will probably come down to whose lawyer is better
- caffeine 6y agoThere are a lot of gradations between "guilty" and "not guilty" in our system, some of them very unpleasant. For example, the author experienced involuntary exile while technically "not guilty." Many employers will fire an employee who is charged with a crime, without a conviction. A "not guilty" person can be arrested and held in jail until a court date which could get postponed repeatedly. There are plenty of cracks people can fall (or be pushed) into.
- onion2k 6y agoIn a decent system? No. Would you be willing to risk that the system you live in is decent? I live in the UK and I hope I never need to find out, because I have a few doubts.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoSure, in theory. We (America) have lots of folks that accept plea agreements because we put pre-trial folks in jail and treat them like criminals, which can easily ruin lives even if you are found not guilty. Of course, you might not be talking about the US system when you refer to a decent system, so maybe you are correct.
- secondcoming 6y ago"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him." Shafting people has been around for aeons
- ilaksh 6y agoThe reality is that when it really comes down to it, the institutions are fundamentally unethical. And this is no surprise because governments are essentially very official mafias.