15 ms·
To upgrade the SSD in a Mac Pro, you need a second Mac computer
- fortran77 6y agoApple expects all Mac Pro uses to own multiple Mac computers in order to do routine maintenance. Outrageous.
- wmil 6y agoThey could star including a refurb macbook with each purchase. The cost would basically be a rounding error.
- b0tzzzzzzman 6y agoYea, but who would want a second hand Big Mac, when you also got a fresh one? Most would just leave It in the fridge or on the counter and eventually throw it away.
- stockerta 6y agoTo help with the eventual SSD swaping.
- lultimouomo 6y agoA second hand Big Mac sounds indeed disgusting. Just the thought of it would make it hard to eat the fresh one.
- PeterisP 6y agoIt seems quite reasonable to presume that the target audience of Mac Pro users wouldn't treat SDD replacement as "routine maintenance" that would be done by the user, but have it done in a service center. And it's completely reasonable to assume that a Mac service center has other macs on hand. Disks on Macs are not really expected to be a user-serviceable part, if some weird techy wants to do that, they can (with some caveats like this one), but the process is designed with service professionals in mind, not DIY end-users.
- ThothIV 6y agoNo. You have two Mac Pros inside your MacPro. Guys, it has a left hemisphere and a right hemisphere! (Obviously not in shape, but roughly analogous). Yes, it's even got a "collosum" as a little piece of tape, which broke the ability to do battery charging completely when it fell off. (Yes, you need those damnable star-shaped screwdrivers to open the case, just go buy a kit). The tape is pretty obvious to find, and located fairly centrally. You'll notice it. You know, you can "upgrade" your Mac Pro's firmware quite easily by first removing that tape, then taking the USB-c cable and wrapping it around your laptop, connected to both sides (either of the two ports on each side works). Then just play with it a bit and see what changes. ;)
- my123 6y agohttps://github.com/libimobiledevice/idevicerestore https://github.com/libimobiledevice/idevicerestore (Works for restoring T2 Macs too)
- sneak 6y agoThis is great, because the supported method involves Apple Configurator 2, which is only available via the App Store (which requires an Apple ID, which requires a phone number). It will be nice to be able to service macs bought for cash without having to dox oneself to Apple.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoDon't you know that computers are services now? :). (Yes, this sucks.)
- qalmakka 6y agoSo basically if your SSD is faulty, you have to find a new mac to fix the one you already have. Oh well, Apple is being Apple indeed. Arguably you already needed a Mac given how hard it is to download a macOS image without a Mac already.
- jeroenhd 6y agoThere's a whole bunch of scripts available online to create bootable macOS images, they're often used by the hackintosh scene. You do need another computer but it doesn't have to be a Mac. Of course, that's in no way an official,. supported solution, but it'll work.
- m463 6y agoI believe those scripts require a mac to make a full bootable image, unless you want a network boot only image.
- jeroenhd 6y agoI've used them to install High Sierra on my Hackintosh and I don't own any Apple hardware. Apple may have restricted the availability of system images, but as far as I know, you can create fully-functional installer USB drives.
- m463 6y agoI just remember reading the fetch-macos script notes which said: Contributing Back This project can always use your help, time and attention. I am looking for help (pull-requests!) with the following work items: * Create *full* installation (ISO) image without requiring an existing macOS physical/virtual installation. ... hmm... maybe they figured it out?
- throwawayfood 6y agoUntil this free solution is intentionally broken by Apple. Being able to do this for free is a bug, not a feature.
- beervirus 6y agoAnd for a current iMac, it doesn’t matter how many computers you have, you’re not upgrading it.
- deergomoo 6y agoYou can still upgrade the RAM in the 27”...for now
- EricE 6y agoOn the 27" you can upgrade RAM without opening the case. As for hard drives you better call OWC - your insight will be a revelation to them: https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/ssd/owc/imac-27-inch/2013-2019 https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/ssd/owc/imac-27-inch/2013-20...
- beervirus 6y agoHave a closer look at your link. “For iMac 27-Inch (Late 2013 - 2019)” It won’t fly in the 2020.
- mproud 6y agoThis is a little misleading. The T2 firmware needs to be restored after modifying the SSD amount. This upgrade is typically reserved for an Apple Authorized Service Provider, but sure, if you have another Mac, you can do it all alone yourself.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PostThisTooFast 6y agoSo.. it’s not misleading.
- traceroute66 6y agoI agree very misleading. What is it with HN recently and all this childish Apple bashing ? If I want Apple bashing, I'll head on over to The Register where its a well known fact they hold a long-term grudge against Apple because of some decade's old fight they picked with Apple's PR department. Back to the case in point, this HN post is disgustingly misleading. What the Apple support article is actually saying is that if you have : (1) A spare mac with Apple Configurator 2 installed (2) A USB-C/USB-C cable or USB-C/USB-A cable Then you can do the repair yourself. This is not exactly a significant obstacle ! (1) Apple Configurator is a FREE download from the App Store (2) You can run Apple Configurator on any Apple machine, you DO NOT NEED another Mac Pro! (3) Any self-respecting tech will already have USB cables by the dozen Yes, you need "another mac", but let's face it, if you use a Mac Pro at work or at home, then you most likely have "another mac" of some description around the place. And if you don't, you probably have one or more friends who have one !
- andybak 6y ago> disgustingly misleading That strikes me as rather emotive phrasing for an discussion about SSD upgrades. Anyway - surely the point is that something that used to be simple (upgrading storage in a personal computer) now has a potentially large hurdle in it's way. Does finding that to be a step backwards make one an anti-Apply fanboy?
- reportgunner 6y agoWell yeah you probably have a couple of them laying around anyway since you have to upgrade every 3 years.
- EricE 6y agoI always get 3-5 times the life out of my Mac's than any Windows PC I have owned. You have that flipped a bit...
- reportgunner 6y agoSo you're saying you don't have a Mac laying around ? All thinkpads that I own are still in use to this day. The newer one is over 5 years old and the rest are 10+ years old.
- Toutouxc 6y agoI don't get the outrage. Yes, the firmware thing is something you don't have to do with other computers. But seriously, we expect people to have a second computer around when doing anything involved with their hardware. New computer? Need to create a bootable flash drive with an OS. WiFi not working on Linux? Need to download stuff and move it to your machine. Monitor/ethernet/mouse/GPU/anything not working? Plug it into a different machine. Network settings borked? Ping it from the second machine. We're used to this. And Apple, surprisingly, expects your other machine to be a Mac. Because why wouldn't it be a Mac. They expect you to use a Mac or an iOS device to verify your identity, to contact their support comfortably, AND to restore firmware on your other devices. They expect you to use their ecosystem of devices and software. You may not like it, and that's why you probably don't have a Mac, but it's consistent and it makes sense in the context of their philosophy.
- Phylter 6y agoI have a USB stick that I can use to reload Windows at any time. I downloaded Windows and put it on the USB key using their utility and if I were to replace a drive, my OS eats itself, etc. I just grab that stick. It really should be that easy with macOS too. Most people don't have multiple computers and most people that own a Mac are unlikely to have two of them.
- Fomite 6y ago"Most people don't have multiple computers and most people that own a Mac are unlikely to have two of them." - I would actually be interested on the stats for this for Mac Pro owners.
- Toutouxc 6y agoYou can absolutely do that with macOS, you just have to download the OS and create the macOS-installer USB stick on a Mac. The firmware thing is a separate, unfortunate, issue.
- kalleboo 6y agoHonestly I would assume nearly all people with a Mac Pro also have a laptop of some sort, and they have a Mac Pro it's likely the laptop is also a Mac.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- datapolitical 6y agoAnyone with a Mac Pro has a Mac laptop or a friend with a Mac laptop.
- EricE 6y agoSsshh - don't spoil their faux outrage with logic and common sense :)
- rswail 6y agoI get the outrage, but I also understand where the problem originates in terms of Apple's use of the T2 chip. To maintain the security of the T2, which is tied to the encryption of the SSD, the SSD is bound to the T2 in a non-reversible way. So when you change the SSD, you have to rebind it with the T2. This is not a "field supported" operation of the T2 standalone, so requires the use of a secure path via Apple Configurator, with, I assume, a tunnel back to Apple's RA equivalent. Should they make this a function of the T2 that is available in the field standalone? Absolutely. Why haven't they? I can think of any number of reasons, some nefarious (the "remove right to repair") side of things, but, more likely, you don't muck around with a security chip too often or without a real need.
- PaulHoule 6y agoI just heard Lenovo is locking server chips to the motherbord now which is a similar story: you know that major chips on the board are authentic but when somebody tries to recycle the cpu later it doesn't work.
- api 6y agoIt's really hard to design secure systems that do not harm convenience, serviceability, etc., since someone trying to compromise the system is... "servicing" it.
- Nexxxeh 6y agoNot sure if it's the specific thing you're thinking of, but AMD EPYC chips can be vendor locked and Dell EMC does this. They blow eFuses in the CPU so they'll only work with Dell motherboards with the correct code signature. https://www.servethehome.com/amd-psb-vendor-locks-epyc-cpus-for-enhanced-security-at-a-cost/ https://www.servethehome.com/amd-psb-vendor-locks-epyc-cpus-...
- PaulHoule 6y agoYes it is. Lenovo and Dell both do it.
- 6y ago
- johnchristopher 6y agoApple is putting a lot of efforts into securing its hardware but I don't feel it's reflected in their marketing and I don't feel like people are buying Apple products for their secure hardware (people from HN and elsewhere excluded). So why are they doing so much and not advertising it more ?
- kevincox 6y agoProbably because it allows them to extert control over their hardware even when users hold it in their hands. Given System Integrity Protection this allows them to enforce rules on the client and trust them on the server. For example shipping apps from the app store that can't be pirated and trusting that iMessage clients are actual hardware owners with unmodified clients. It is basically a DRM system.
- josephcsible 6y agoBecause Apple only cares about keeping devices secure from their owners, not about security that benefits the device's owner.
- compiler-guy 6y agoApple’s problems are multitude, and I’m no fanboy, but they do work pretty hard to keep their devices secure from government hacking. https://epic.org/amicus/crypto/apple/ https://epic.org/amicus/crypto/apple/
- hu3 6y agoApple's unwillingness to implement e2e encryption of user iCloud data says otherwise. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusive-idUSKBN1ZK1CT https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...
- EricE 6y agoUnwillingness? That's a big assumption. Not that I'm defending it. And I also expect Apple to do better and not just pay lip service. On the other hand, who is doing as much or more? Again, not saying that to excuse them but just point out there is likely far more going on than them just making an arbitrary decision here. Just saying...
- HerbsMan 6y agoAt least it isn't second MacPro ;- )
- refracture 6y agoI get using the T2 to encrypt the drives, as I understand it makes for very good hardware security, but what I do not get is why the machine cannot either: A. Wipe and then 'claim' an SSD, adding it the T2 by itself without another machine, or B. Give you a big fat warning when reinstalling macOS that your drive will not be encrypted. Maybe Apple figures it's not a big deal to require another Mac simply because these machines are priced such and targeted at professionals and corporations.. having an old Macbook or something around isn't unlikely.. this is the kind of thing that would be a deal breaker for me but that's moot since I don't think anyone like me would ever buy one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kmeisthax 6y agoPart of the problem is that swapping the SSD at all was originally not a thing. T2 drive encryption started off on laptops with soldered-on SSDs where I would imagine Apple had zero intent of supporting any attempt by a user (or, more likely, Louis Rossman) to swap chips out. When they shipped the Mac Pro with socketed SSD modules they needed to hack together a way to actually pair the T2 and new SSDs, so they released Apple Configurator to let that happen. The main problem I could see with a field-pairing mechanism is properly messaging it to the user while the SSD is in an unusable state. Remember: once you change the SSD pairing, the data on the old drive is unreadable by anyone and the new drive will be wiped accordingly. So it absolutely should not be an automatic process - what if someone swaps the SSD modules without knowing about the drive encryption? At the very least, you need to flash a warning up on screen and accept a user acknowledgement, which means you need display drivers, USB, and so on all working in the boot ROM. It's not insurmountable, but it is a technical challenge.
- Kwpolska 6y ago> At the very least, you need to flash a warning up on screen and accept a user acknowledgement, which means you need display drivers, USB, and so on all working in the boot ROM. Pretty sure Apple has some form of this. On Intel Macs, the boot picker [0] supports displaying text and graphics, accepting keyboard and mouse input, and even connecting to Wi-Fi. There’s also the FileVault password screen, which does not live in the firmware, but it’s a full-screen UEFI app resembling macOS’ login UI. It’s also a thing in the PC world these days. The UEFI setup menu on modern machines is a bitmap-graphics GUI with mouse and keyboard support, for example [1] (a random YouTube video). [0]: https://www.ninjastik.com/support/how-to-choose-a-startup-disk-on-your-mac-to-boot-from-usb/ https://www.ninjastik.com/support/how-to-choose-a-startup-di... [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q1NDjD2RuGM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q1NDjD2RuGM
- rotidodol 6y agoThe good thing is I dont use mac
- easton 6y agoNow that the iPad has USB-C, I wonder why they don’t build a version of Apple Configurator for it. Since they’re Apple, they can use whatever private APIs they want to use the USB port, and most people with a Apple Silicon (or T2) Mac may not have an old Mac but probably have an iPad.
- EricE 6y agoIf they were willing to do that then why not just embed the functionality into the firmware of the Mac Pro? I think it's far simpler than that - this is such an infrequent issue it doesn't warrant engineering time beyond what they already support - using Apple Configurator on a second Mac to sign the drive to install it. This is likely a dictionary definition of "edge case" after all. Mac Pro's aren't exactly high volume computers (something that is normally touted with great enthusiasm on this site).
- dolni 6y agoReplacing a hard drive is an "edge case"? Something that has literally taken just a couple of minutes on virtually any consumer desktop (and laptop) for _decades_? What sort of twisted Stockholm Syndrome has afflicted you?