5 ms·
The rail gauge change is tough. While there are several systems for making bogies that can change width, they're not used much on freight cars. Here's a video o
by Animats 6y ago
The rail gauge change is tough. While there are several systems for making bogies that can change width, they're not used much on freight cars. Here's a video of the SUW 2000 gauge changing system for freight cars mentioned in the article.[1] If that can be made to work, the whole process becomes much more efficient. It's been done for passenger trains for decades, mostly at the border between France and Spain, but it's rare for freight. Without that, there has to be an "inland port" at the gauge change points, where containers are unloaded from one train and onto another. China and Europe use the same gauge, but Russia and the former USSR use a wider gauge. All new Belt and Road construction is to China standards, which are similar to US standards.
Single-stack container trains with one car per 40 foot container (2 TEU) seem to be the standard for Belt and Road shipments. That covers most of what needs to be shipped.
China, like the US, uses the AAR coupler on freight cars. The US standardized on that, by an act of Congress, in 1893. Russia uses the SA-3 coupler, which is incompatible but a good automatic coupler. Most of Europe is way behind on freight cars, still using small freight cars with buffers and couplers that require manual attachment. There was an EU plan to standardize railroad coupling across the EU, from 2008, but they gave up.
Not sure what the train length limit is. That's set by the length of sidings.
Those are the physical limits. Paperwork at borders remains a problem.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjiJoAjqVHs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjiJoAjqVHs
- hef19898 6y agoThe gauge also changes between Spain and Italy. Changing containers between trains can be done at the border in roughly one hour for the whole train max, if memory serves well. The actual bottle neck is the number of rail lines crossing the border and not the gauge change. It does add cost and coordination effort, so it would be better without that. Paperwork, for transit at least, doesn't seem to be a big headache along the new silk road. If you use specialist services to handle customs. And that should be the norm nowadays for international shippers and consignees anyway.
- burnte 6y ago> The gauge also changes between Spain and Italy. So it changes in France? Or it changes where Italy and France meet? Or wher eFrance and Spain meet? Because Italy doesn't touch Spain.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe gauge change is on the France/Spain border. Spain and Portugal use a different gauge from the rest of Europe.
- Scoundreller 6y agoHad to look this up, but the high-speed rail network in Portugal/Spain runs on standard gauge, so trips to France weren't a problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_gauge_in_Spain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_gauge_in_Spain
- jcranmer 6y agoAs far as I'm aware, HSR everywhere in the world is 4'8½", even where the local rail gauge isn't (i.e., Spain and Japan). Rail Baltica is similarly planning a 4'8½" line despite local rail being 5'.
- bobthepanda 6y agoVelaro RUS are built to Russian gauge.
- Scoundreller 6y ago> If you use specialist services to handle customs. Sounds like the "better use the guy that knows a guy" system. If you try to do it yourself, suddenly every rule starts to apply.
- hef19898 6y agoAll the rules always apply for everyone. It just a lot faster working with a party that knows all the rules and runs the paper work on a daily basis. There is a reason customs agencies exist. And would always use one of those, and not do customs declarations myself. Unless of course, customs declarations are my business.
- hef19898 6y agoFrance and Spain, obviously. And for freight. As a famous soccer player once put it: Madrid or Mailand doesn't matter as long as it's Italy. The gauge actually changes on the Spanish side at dedicated transit terminals. One line coming down from the north, one meeting it, and running parallel, from the south.
- jcranmer 6y ago> Single-stack container trains with one car per 40 foot container (2 TEU) seem to be the standard for Belt and Road shipments. That covers most of what needs to be shipped. For someone who lives in the US, this seems not-state-of-the-art. Most long-distance train traffic in the US has shifted to double-stack container trains. > Not sure what the train length limit is. That's set by the length of sidings. From what I can tell, Europe tends to prefer far smaller trains than the US does. The typical train length in the US is >100 cars (I want to say 120-ish is the current average, but I don't have firm statistics), but in Europe, it seems to be more like 40 cars.
- Animats 6y agoFrom what I can tell, Europe tends to prefer far smaller trains than the US does. The old-style couplers used in Europe are too weak for longer trains. "The buffers and chain coupling system has a maximum load much less than that of the Janney coupler. They allow around 3,000-4,000 (metric) tonnes total train weight depending on the how they are constructed. The Janney coupler sometimes is built for 32,000 tonnes (31,000 long tons; 35,000 short tons)." The EU attempt to standardize on an automatic freight coupler across the entire EU was a flop. There's a new project under way to test a new generation of freight coupler, one that connects the mechanical, air, and electrical connections.[1] But it's just getting started. [1] https://uic.org/com/enews/article/germany-rail-freight-transport-pilot-project-launched-to-test-automatic-rail https://uic.org/com/enews/article/germany-rail-freight-trans...
- iggldiggl 6y agoWhile the couplings certainly are a factor for heavy (bulk) freight (steel, coal, ore, aggregates, etc.), I'd guess that container trains are often rather length-limited by all the rest of the infrastructure (yard/siding/loop length, signalling) before hitting the actual limits of the old-style screw couplings. Whereas e.g. most of Europe currently has evolved towards a maximum length of around 750 m (which doesn't mean that the infrastructure in terms of loop/sidings length actually allows trains that long everywhere, though!), Denmark allows up to 835 m while still using screw couplings. So for container trains at least, a programme of loops and sidings lengthening would be the more pressing requirement, before actually and absolutely having to upgrade the couplers, but that kind of infrastructure modification doesn't come cheap or necessarily easy, either. Another difference to consider is that in Europe, passenger traffic is much more widespread and common than on North American railways, and also commonly has priority over freight trains. While in principle, longer trains are indeed more efficient than an equivalent larger number of shorter trains, past a certain point they'll eventually become too unwieldy to fit inside the schedule demands of passenger traffic. There's certainly scope for moving beyond the current 750 m maximum, but the multi-kilometre range would probably be pushing things a little too far without completely dedicated infrastructure.
- iggldiggl 6y agoEven where the track gauge itself is the same, differing standards for wheel and flange dimensions (which in turn influence certain crucial dimensions of switches and crossings) still have the potential to throw a spanner in the works and prevent full cross-compatibility. If the differences aren't too large, some sort of compromise wheel set might be possible – if that's not the case, then you'd still need to swap the wheels.