4 ms·
One thing I especially like about The Economist is that they consistantly explain who or what something is. It seems stupid to write: HSBC, a bank... I know it’
by mrweasel 6y ago
One thing I especially like about The Economist is that they consistantly explain who or what something is. It seems stupid to write: HSBC, a bank... I know it’s a bank, but some might not, and in the many cases where I don’t know a person, a company, technology or idea it’s extremely useful.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoThey do the same in their podcasts: https://www.economist.com/podcasts/ https://www.economist.com/podcasts/ Well worth a listen, even it does end up with me muttering curses at the 'radio' sometimes.
- atmosx 6y agoSame here :-)
- gxqoz 6y agoNPR's Code Switch podcast had an episode a few years ago on this, which they call the explanatory comma: https://www.npr.org/2016/12/14/504482252/-hold-up-time-for-an-explanatory-comma https://www.npr.org/2016/12/14/504482252/-hold-up-time-for-a... It gets at what you assume about your audience when you include vs. don't include these. I'm sometimes amused by what gets the explanatory comma in The New Yorker. I recall one issue where they included one for what an MLA citation was. But in the same issue assumed familiarity with someone like Jacques Derrida and their ideas. (This probably wasn't the exact example, but it was close to this.)
- swyx 6y agobut, like, do two words "a bank" really do anything compared to what the reader could google conditional on not knowing what HSBC is? i feel like its just very performative
- mejutoco 6y agoYes. And with acronyms as well. They are always spelled out the first time, before the abbreviation is used.
- ghaff 6y agoNot to criticize but that is, or should be, bog standard in any writing. (Assuming the acronym isn't widely used and the words that it embodies essentially a trivia contest answer).
- ajcp 6y ago> Assuming the acronym isn't widely used I don't care how widely used the acronym for a noun is, first use should always be the full form. Only time I don't think it should be applied is in the case of a standard/protocol, or policy (such as gif or VAT). Then the first use should be the concept explained, not what it stands for. I do like their style-guide definition: acronym: A pronounceable word, formed from the initials of other words, like radar, nimby or NATO. It is not a set of initials, like the BBC or the IMF.
- ghaff 6y agoI don't know. Spelling out the words that make up RADAR or SONAR would seem very pedantic to me. As would, in tech, something like SCSI when that was a common interface. In a general purpose magazine, I'd probably be inclined to given a context for NIMBY, NATO, and the IMF--but maybe not BBC (to a British audience).
- atmosx 6y agoWhat drove me off was the double standards applied by the economist, e.g.: "Yanis Varoufakis, a self-proclaimed erratic Marxist, [...]" vs "Jeroen Dijsselbloem, the President of the Eurogroup, [...]" What about "Varoufakis, a PhD economist who taught economics in three continents, [...]" vs "Jeroen Dijsselbloem, the President of the Eurogroup who accidentally claimed he obtained an MA from University College Cork, [...]" See what I did there? :-) Truth of the matter is that Varoufakis dwarfs the Eurogroup in terms of knowledge much like Keynes dwarfed everyone else at the Bretton Woods. Both of them, came from a position of weakness and for <reasons> failed to deliver. The Economist doesn't like Varoufakis, so Varoufakis must always be always shown in a derogatory light, while complete clowns like JD, and many others (see Krugman's assessment of Schäuble's speech and analysis, laughable at best - comparing a state's economy to a household) as "high ranking, noteworthy authorities". Varoufakis is an example ofc. There are others (e.g. Beppe Grillo, Berlusconi, etc.). The other thing the Economist has (not) going on is that you can tell beforehand what you're going to read... I mean from MILES away, you already know the magazine's stance of everything that matters. China, Russia, Iran (bad)... US (good), UK (okay-ish), EU (almost-good). Consistently pro-war: Supported and pushed (Syria) for all kinds of invasions (Libya, Ukraine, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.). If you take away all that (and it's a lot), the rest is fine :-)
- nindalf 6y ago> Consistently pro-war Whenever the Economist speaks about the Iraq War, they add in parentheses “(which this newspaper supported)”. They don’t need to do that after so many years, but they do it anyway. That level of candour impressed me. This from 2018, 15 years after the war started - “Iraq, in other words, is doing well (see article). Some will argue that this justifies America’s invasion to overthrow Saddam Hussein (which we supported). It does not. Too much blood was shed along the way in Iraq and elsewhere.” (https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/03/28/fifteen-years-after-americas-invasion-iraq-is-doing-well https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/03/28/fifteen-years-a...) This level of self-reflection is rare.
- mardifoufs 6y agoI'm not sure they wouldn't just support the next one and then do a mea culpa after the fact again. Did they change the way they treat US intelligence info? Or address geopolitics differently? I'm not sure. I haven't read the Economist since 2018, but I genuinely don't see how they wouldn't end up cheering for the same exact type of intervention due to the exact same rhetoric.
- euroderf 6y agoQuite useful for Americans. Residents of the infamous North American superpower might be otherwise OTL, lunch being a sometimes-metaphorical meal.