9 ms·
One of the worst things we could have would be an efficient government. Delay is a feature of government, with a special carve out for emergencies. People ten
by mc32 6y ago
One of the worst things we could have would be an efficient government.
Delay is a feature of government, with a special carve out for emergencies.
People tend to think of and idealize best case scenarios rather than likely scenarios. The likely scenario is China. Mass mobilization and change in policy from one day to the next.
- question000 6y agoWell the life of the average Chinese citizen has improved substantially in the last 30 years, no Western country can really say that.
- echelon 6y agoThat's because the West already made those improvements and there are no longer any low hanging fruit.
- question000 6y agoI'm sorry China has solved many problems the West is still working on. They've had public funded healthcare/education from the medieval era and they haven't been involved in any major wars and yet still dictate policy in the region.
- Semiapies 6y agoDisregarding who actually had access to that healthcare and education (since by similar definitions of who had access, the West had both public services by the classical Greek era)...No major wars? Really? Even ignoring the phrasing that could be read as claiming no major wars since the medieval era, we don't have to go so far back. I mean, sure, the Cultural Revolution killed more Chinese people than WW2 and the Korean war did combined, but that's still eleven million or so Chinese people dead in those conflicts.
- kansface 6y agoChina is responsible for murdering many 10s, possibly 100 million of its own citizens and is actively and purposefully engaged in genocide of its own people right now. I have a very hard time separating the good from the bad here. > they haven't been involved in any major wars and yet still dictate policy in the region. As far as I know, the last major war China fought in was when they invaded Vietnam in 1979 after Vietnam had invaded Cambodia (Chinese ally) to get rid of the Khmer Rouge (the same regime that killed everyone who wore glasses because they may have been reading too much)...
- asdff 6y agoThe west made some of these improvements 70 years ago but follow up maintenance, replacement, and expansion never came. The built environment of the U.S. has changed remarkably little in the past 40 years, and we are paying for this stasis today with our housing crisis from not building enough housing supply, our congested and crumbling roadways, our lack of transit infrastructure investment (NYC subway has been frozen in time for almost a century practically, and all we can celebrate elsewhere are a handful of light rail lines that usually sit in traffic with the cars), we've voted to defund our schools, and have refused to expand our public healthcare system to those younger than 65 as originally planned in order to protect private insurance industries. The only improvement the west has made in the last 40 years was figuring out how to move a greater proportion of its wealth into the hands of the few, and iPhones I guess.
- jjb123 6y agoWe made those same moves 100 years earlier, with liberty intact. If North Korea made this relative progress over the next 30 years (and 70 years after South Korea), this same argument would suggest there’s something we should copy there.
- sudosysgen 6y agoYes, in 160 years, as opposed to 30, and then solved many problems we aren't able to solve. No one is saying that authoritarian governments are good, but opposition to efficient governments just makes life worse for everyone.
- mc32 6y agoAny country in a retrograde economy has the benefit of existing modern technology to adopt as well as the absence of legacy encumbrances, making it easier to play catch-up.
- Semiapies 6y agoIt's similar to the "miracle" of Soviet industrialization. The USSR hired scads of advisors from Western companies to direct their efforts, then chest-thumped about socialism. Or, for that matter, the Nazi economic "miracle". In their case, they started from the wreckage of WW1 and the Weimar Republic, but they used knowledge and corporate organization that predated both to rebuild, while letting their ideology and leadership take credit.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere was no Nazi economic miracle - it was built on debt and was unsustainable, which is why it's discounted. Not because somehow it used existing expertise, of course it did, that's entirely normal. As far as that, I don't see how hiring foreign advisors somehow make your own economic achievements worthless - anyone can do that, and it's stupid to expect everyone to reinvent the wheel.
- zajio1am 6y agoMost western countries that were part of communist bloc can say that.
- echelon 6y agoIf the Internet has been regulated from day one, no way would it have grown to do the things it can do. Stream music? Sell sex? Buy stuff across state lines or internationally? Imagine what we'd be able to do if the megacorps and government didn't start carving it up.
- woodruffw 6y ago> If the Internet has been regulated from day one, no way would it have grown to do the things it can do. Maybe it's just me, but most of the things that the Internet can currently do don't feel all that great. My interaction with the Internet is primarily an adversarial one: I have to make a positive (and normally unsuccessful) effort to avoid the hellscape of targeted advertising and rent seeking that all of the dominant platforms currently depend on for income. But at least I can buy junk online (and damage my local economy in the process); is that worth it? And, for what it's worth, the Internet had protocol-level streaming well before it was fully commercialized[1]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mbone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mbone
- II2II 6y agoIt's not just you. The existence of everything from ad blockers to alternatives for the web are the product of people who want to escape from this commercial dystopia. Will it reshape the Internet? Undoubtedly not, but at least there are places to escape to even if it is for fleeting moments in time.
- api 6y agoA related observation I've come to: government is among the class of things that should be boring. Interesting government was a major cause of death in the first half of the 20th century.
- sudosysgen 6y agoInteresting government in the 20th century killed less people than boring deaths that were prevented by some "interesting" governments. Beyond that, the most major cause of death after poverty was war, specifically the attempted invasion of the USSR by Germany, which was really just a matter of realpolitik at the time (thus why the USSR proposed a defensive alliance with France and the UK before the Third Reich). Just to take the Chinese example again - less people died due to Mao's atrocities in China than due to regular old poverty in India, despite them starting at the same spot. We just have normalcy bias by the absolutely staggering amount of death that comes with poverty, whereas a comparatively smaller amount of death brought by a government that fixed the former is much more interesting.
- datavirtue 6y agoBoth were government inflicted.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matkoniecz 6y ago> less people died due to Mao's atrocities in China than due to regular old poverty in India, despite them starting at the same spot What is the source of that? Note also that China had deaths both from poverty and Mao dictatorship.
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt is trickery with timescales. It is like saying for instance "Malaria killed more Jews than Adolf Hitler did!" ignoring that one has existed for millenia and the other didn't make it to 57.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoAs a point of order, I think people want an efficiently run government, but your point about delay being valuable still stands.
- mc32 6y agoI understand that it comes from a place where we don’t want waste (in taxes, resources, time, etc), but what delivers that efficiency also delivers other undesired efficiencies (fine everyone who is contrarian, imprison the opposition, what have you).
- bobthepanda 6y agoInefficient states are most of the states doing this though (say, Egypt is no paragon of efficiency.) The inertia of the bureaucracy can be a hindrance but at the end of the day any bureaucrat will move mountains if a tyrant is breathing down their neck with knife in hand.
- mc32 6y agoOk, but imagine them being efficient at what they do. Imagine efficient suppression or efficient indoctrination policies, etc.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoGotcha, I was coming at this from a different angle. Mostly a local-government perspective for things like city services. That's the kind of government I want streamlined and efficiently run.
- PeterisP 6y agoThe problem is that if the elected government is weak, ineffective and isn't fulfilling its core roles, then other people and organizations would take on these roles and the associated power and decisionmaking - and those emergent de facto replacement "governments" are likely to be even more illiberal, oppressive mini-dictatorships that are not elected or accountable to the general society. That's how you get the origins of Cosa Nostra, or the cartel-governed zones in Mexico, or de-facto rule by corporations in the fictional cyberpunk dystopias.
- dv_dt 6y agoSlow government is sort of only a feature of you don't think government should act. Really we should want deliberate and democratic/cooperative to decide but fast to act on settled matters.
- mc32 6y agoThat presumes a democratic polity always settles on good matters.
- dv_dt 6y agoIn general, to have a government at all, it should act by the processes by which it is validated by it's citizens - democratically ideally. But to have a government and pretend you don't want one to actually act seems silly. If you're worried about it acting in the wrong way, then focus on strengthening the democracy, transparency, and collaboration aspect of it. An ineffective government is a long term path to instability often leading to a risk of non-democratic rule.
- mc32 6y agoYou’re fundamentally betting on both people AND government to make the “good” decision even in trying times. That’s just not the case. Under duress both people, even in a healthy democracy, can reach for the easy solution to a threat which might not be the good of right solution. Time delay usually blunts that initial urge.
- dv_dt 6y agoThat's why I say "we should want deliberate and democratic/cooperative to decide"...
- paulmd 6y agoInertia is only that - inertia. It doesn't affect the overall trend, by definition no democratic system can withstand a popular-but-harmful idea that remains popular over a sustained period of time (Brexit might be an example). If a system doesn't manifest that public opinion then it is no longer democratic. In other words what you're arguing against here isn't rapid change, it's democracy as a whole. You can't prevent people from having stupid ideas, and on a long enough timescale any democratic system will eventually implement those ideas. The idea of gridlock as a design objective is very harmful. The "inability to form a government" is considered a failure states in most government systems, having a government that is actually able to enact policy is a good thing. In practice however, this gridlock does not produce any incentive to pass "things everyone really agrees on" at all, as you can see by various topics that have 90% public support (eg cannabis legalization) that have been ignored for decades. It just produces gridlock and nothing gets done at all, not even the stuff that "everyone" agrees on. This, too, is a form of un-democracy. A lot of the "gridlock = good" comes back to people blindly falling back on the fetishism they were taught about the US constitution in grade schools - checks and balances are a good thing, who could be against checks and balances? But if there are too many checks and balances that drags the whole system to a halt - again, having a government that is able to actually enact policy without a supermajority control of all branches of government is a good thing. They only work when everyone has a "gentleman's agreement" to play nice and actually do the things that help constituents - when everyone starts playing hardball to the maximal extent permitted by law, the systems drags to a halt and stops working. And once that becomes a matter of routine as opposed to a last resort due to extremity, the systems begins to fail. That's a design flaw, that gets brushed under the rug because we're all taught "checks and balances are automatically good!" as children. Having some checks and balances is good, but too many can also be bad. With inertia taken to an extreme you get the Polish Sejm and the liberum veto - where any single member could object and veto not just the current legislation but every bit of legislation that had been passed in that session. That certainly "slowed government down", and eventually led to the collapse of the polish government. So there clearly exists some configurations where there can be too much inertia and it leads to an inability of the state to respond to a changing world and eventual collapse. Where does the US fall? Compared to most other countries, far far on the side of too much inertia, and we are also failing to a much greater extent then most other states at the moment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberum_veto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberum_veto In particular I think the election of the US president separately from the legislature is very harmful. The executive and legislative agenda largely should be aligned, the cases where it's adversarial have been largely periods of "failed government" where nothing really gets passed. Of course that is also tied up with representative-level gerrymandering and state-size mismatches in the senate. The fixed 2-4-6 year cycles of the US government is also harmful compared to the (potentially) more frequent election cycles in other countries, as those countries can respond to losses in public confidence much more quickly. As such - the best solution to an unpopular president/legislature is likely a variable election cycle to get them back out quicker once they lose a mandate. I am completely willing to trade the other party being able to accomplish more of their agenda while they're in office, for me being able to accomplish more of my agenda while I'm in office. Elections should result in a mandate to enact policy, that is a good thing. It is better to have frequent elections that result in a mandate to lead, with changes in control when the party no longer reflects the will of the people, than to have nobody able to do anything all of the time.
- tehWeeb 6y agoThis is a context sensitive point. We’ve seen government be far more efficient and successful at “the fundamentals” than privatization. Postal service, Medicare/caid, Social Security all financially stable, and logistically competent until meddled with politically to benefit a minority closest to the politicians. I don’t want efficient government when it comes to species stability. I want reliable and resilient. Let man-children speculate about reality without politically contrived economic uncertainty foisted upon everyone. I wasn’t a party to signing a contract that says I have to believe Musk and the rest are that much more worthwhile to humanity as decided by politically contrived fiscal economics. If you all want to be kowtowed like teen girls at a Beatles concert, have at it. The majority just want to live their lives.
- asdff 6y agoWhat you describe is not delay, but consideration of options. You aren't delaying if you are thinking, you are doing. To delay is to do nothing for no good reason, to delay is to kick your feet up, allow time to pass and not do any thinking of options, which is what happens all too often in a world where public works are worked upon by private contractors who are financially incentivized to stretch out projects as long as possible.