5 ms·
"Comments", free-floating on the bottom of news articles, end up being pretty much the opposite of a community. They're a venue for long running partisan fights
by pjc50 6y ago
"Comments", free-floating on the bottom of news articles, end up being pretty much the opposite of a community. They're a venue for long running partisan fights. People running pages have realized that they're the equivalent of putting up a sign saying "please tell me I suck" in public - everyone with any kind of complaint is all over them.
It's increasingly clear that if you want to have a community on the internet, rather than just host a warzone on your lawn, it has to have defense mechanisms in place. This post from Doreen the other day resonated with me: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26639182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26639182
- amelius 6y agoYeah, comments should be private between the original poster and the poster of the comment.
- SilasX 6y agoIt already works that way for stuff you add to "your story". (A feature whose purpose I can never understand except to imitate newer social networks.)
- anthropodie 6y agoFor user: the story feature is kinda like blog. They can share their thoughts, images, videos, stuff they are interested in with few clicks. General public never owned anything like blogs because it is not easy to set up as sharing stories. Also, stories actually engages followers/contacts with the content. I think that is why it's popular among users. For companies: Best place to put ads is between stories. You get 100% views for the ads and hence more engagement. That is why every company is running after it.
- SilasX 6y agoYeah but it appears to be a bit more specialized and narrowly focused than a blog because a) it's apparently deleted after a few minutes or really hard to find after a short interval, and b) responses and reactions are shown only to that person and not the others who view ie. Also I don't know what makes this more true for the story than the feed: "stories actually engages followers/contacts with the content."
- bobthepanda 6y agoI am pretty sure they just hide/downrank the ones you‘ve seen and totally hide after 24h of being active.
- loceng 6y agoInteresting idea. It'd likely kill off trolling or low quality comments as there wouldn't be the eyeballs for engagement for dopamine hits to reinforce that level of behaviour.
- amelius 6y agoA similar approach could work in "hierarchical/threaded" forums: comments are private between parent and child, unless the parent says the child comment can be public.
- loceng 6y agoYes, that's a nice moderation approach - allowing OP to be curator. It also allows OP the opportunity to comment before the thread starts to become public - giving a chance for a response to clarify, rebut, or other.
- AaronM 6y agoThink about how that would work in reverse. Lets say you post something fake, like 5G causes covid. And any response that calls out your post as being fake, you just hide.
- loceng 6y agoWhich is why you need a "God" level of moderation (or really just parenting, parents watching the child in the playground as we all try to understand and master consciousness) for every platform - where they have the ability to add a warning tag/comment - or moderate that person off of platform either as a timeout or permanently; and then having many platforms that are privately owned deciding how they govern is how we de-risk government tyrannical control mechanisms being in place that then apply to all platforms. And then users decide/"vote" with what platform or network they align with based on if they use it or not; the issue of allowing users and their networks to being easily mobile/data and network operability is important then to reduce the friction of this being possible. And then the layers of infrastructure are additional layers of decentralized control mechanisms, e.g. Amazon/AWS kicking off Parler, Parler then needing to eventually find infrastructure that was supportive of their lack of moderation against calls for violence, etc. At least then lines are drawn and we can see who's allying with who, and people can respond or behave accordingly.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI enjoy this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xzxt1sJ3RzI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xzxt1sJ3RzI
- austincheney 6y ago> They're a venue for long running partisan fights. Worse, they tend to be completely uninformed emotional ramblings. I often wonder just how many of those comments and votes are from bots that only exist to provoke gullible people.
- minikites 6y agoIn my experience, people who use "emotional" in a derogatory way are often the most emotional themselves because they're blind to their own feelings. Being emotional is not bad.
- austincheney 6y agoI didn't use emotional in a derogatory way, but I did use it to create a loaded statement. The implication of the word emotional in that statement is meaningless unless somebody reading the hypothetical comment is emotionally activated.
- minikites 6y ago>emotionally activated Do you really think acting like an emotionless robot is a good way to communicate with others?
- hnlmorg 6y agoNo. It's just used that way by people who are getting fed up with reading: 1. made up facts from organisations trying to incite emotional responses rather than conveying accurate information, 2. comments from people who are ignorant on specific topics but still feel strongly enough about said topic to voice their opinion. Clearly we are never going to remove emotion from content. That's as unrealistic as asking the news to be unbiased. But wouldn't it be nice if there was a little less emotive bullshit being argued as factual information.... Unfortunately turning off comments on select posts isn't going to fix the rot.
- nashashmi 6y agoJust read this yesterday from Fred Wilson talking about Tumblr founder resisting the idea of comments. Only thumbs up and reposts were allowed. The founder said it was a wasteland for negativity. https://avc.com/2019/08/tumblr-2/ https://avc.com/2019/08/tumblr-2/
- bobthepanda 6y agoI don‘t think Tumblr reblogs made much of a difference in that regard.
- rchaud 6y agoHe was ultimately correct. Angry internet people created r/tumblrinaction because they couldn't do their outrage pile-on on the platform itself.
- sharken 6y agoI find hope in the fact that a positive community seems to exist over at Reddit, here is an example. Up/down votes and moderation seem to be key. https://www.reddit.com/r/somethingimade/ https://www.reddit.com/r/somethingimade/
- elliekelly 6y agoHave there been any studies about the "optimal" size of a community? It feels like there's a critical mass so long as the size of a community remains less than n people it remains civil and people can forge actual relationships (even behind "anonymous" usernames). Reddit and Discord come to mind. The smaller subs and servers are great while the huge subs and servers tend to be toxic internet wastelands.
- HDMI_Cable 6y agoI think a good way to measure this effect is Discord. You have servers of varying sizes and can compare relative “toxicity” between them. IMO things seem to get pretty bad after 100-150 people.
- type0 6y ago> IMO things seem to get pretty bad after 100-150 people. Once it exceeds Dunbar's number you are getting different tribes fighting each other, that's just the human nature.
- u801e 6y agoPersonally, I've always preferred moderation controlled by the client (i.e., a killfile in a NNTP client) rather than relying on moderators. That way, I can decide what I see. Theoretically, bad actors would end up in everyone else's killfile, but in reality, it never really happened. Some clients at least allowed hiding a subthread so that you wouldn't see messages that were essentially a dispute between two people. But one way to slow down the flame wars would be to rate limit the number of comments that can be posted. If you require people to wait 10 minutes to post a subsequent comment, that would definitely slow down the discussion and probably would lead to them moving on to something else.