8 ms·
> have a strong "US good/China scary & evil" tint The US is imperfect and perhaps worse than (post-colonial) Europe in many respects, but does anyone seriously
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> have a strong "US good/China scary & evil" tint
The US is imperfect and perhaps worse than (post-colonial) Europe in many respects, but does anyone seriously think that a Chinese global hegemony would be better? I understand that this is controversial and I'm not trying to agitate, but I am curious about who holds this position and why?
- vmception 6y agoWell that's part of the point, China is obsessed with territorial unity, not expansionist policies, where the overlap is limited specifically to where we already know: other places that China already calls China. The American perspective is that everyone is secretly trying to expand - like America did. Chinese hegemony could happen in other areas, like how it already has resulted in movies being changed to accommodate Chinese audiences, or having leverage over many private sectors who want access to their market, and with a currency based hegemony that could increase. But the other person's point about books being too "US good/China scary & evil" is exactly about the very limiting false dichotomies that you latched directly on to.
- adventured 6y ago> China is obsessed with territorial unity, not expansionist policies Obviously false. From Tibet to the recent massive South China Sea annexation and Taiwan, all of it is hyper expansionist. It doesn't matter if they lie and claim otherwise, it's plainly a lie. They're seeking territorial expansion. Nobody in their right mind believes the waters off the coast of south Vietnam belongs to China, except China. That's not about territorial unity, it's about hegemony in Asia and expanding their territory through military force. They're in conquering mode. The territy they took when they conquered Tibet is twice the size of France. The South China Sea territory they're attempting to take now - which does not belong to them - is at least the size of Tibet or larger. That's conquering on a scale not seen since immediately after WW2 with the Soviet Union's land grab in Eastern Europe.
- makomk 6y agoThe Chinese propaganda says they're just defending their territory, but as far as I can tell it's just expansionism in disguise. That is to say, they've been taking areas that even China considered to be part of (say) India, rewriting the past so that they're not only part of China but always have been, and sending in troops to claim them. In many ways their claim to the South China Sea is like this too.
- vmception 6y agoyes, I'm watching them to see the incongruence. But primarily, the Chinese constitution calls for upholding territorial unity, and this undermines every other right granted in the constitution, and this is the nature of most of their punishments domestically, demands from foreigners (like when actors and celebrities end up saying boilerplate comments about Chinese sovereignty and unity, and it barely makes any sense to the English audience about why they would say that), and it is also congruent with their actions. Now, is the limitation of my perspective that they can rationalize anything with this? Or that the unanimous People's Congress can update the constitution if any other roadblock is in their way? Sure. I just don't see that predilection. There are plenty of disputed land borders around the edges of China. But I just don't see things beyond that and the South China Sea. I was surprised to see the treatment of their state of Inner Mongolia, and to me this is a separate form of discrimination in favor of Han Chinese (or something more nuanced). My line in the sand - for the expansionist opinion - would be taking pieces of Mongolia. Or way into states of India and bordering nations. Or way past Xinjiang.
- boc 6y agoWhat makes people uncomfortable is that the US is a democracy, and the leaders are chosen by the population. China's military and social power is wielded by a very small group of elites in the CCP, which makes it hard to trust. The nature of US policy has been shaped over the centuries in the open, whereas China's policies and doctrines are sometimes changed overnight.
- wcarss 6y ago> What makes people uncomfortable is that the US is a democracy, and the leaders are chosen by the population. Well, sort of. They're almost always from very wealthy families with very particular educational, social, and occupational histories, on both sides. We get to choose from within the group that makes it to through the candidate vetting processes controlled by the parties. > China's military and social power is wielded by a very small group of elites in the CCP, which makes it hard to trust. Again, it's pretty similar. The rich and their children have time and money to build the connections that can get them into positions of institutional power. > The nature of US policy has been shaped over the centuries in the open, whereas China's policies and doctrines are sometimes changed overnight. Policy changes in China get voted on too. They might seem like an orchestrated rubber stamp to us -- and they might actually be! But similarly in the US, executive orders, agency decisions, and supreme court orders can happen swiftly and have similarly profound impacts on the people and the system. See for example Citizen's United, or the repeal of the Fairness Doctrine by the FCC. Did any normal people vote for those things? They kind of just... happened, and their impacts are huge. I'm not trying to say I would rather live in China or under its system, rather that our perceptions of the differences between the systems are influenced heavily by our context and our naturally western-oriented media diet, and they may in reality be smaller than we feel. To put it very cynically, our system currently works by allowing average people to feel like we have control over it, while China's doesn't use that tool so much. In truth, average people don't have any real control over either system under normal circumstances.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Again, it's pretty similar. I don't see how... Yes, the US has a classist bias and certainly some mild corruption. That still seems a world apart from a single party system that routinely flouts its own constitution. Also, executive orders and legislation are bound by the constitution in theory and practice. While they may result in abrupt changes from time-to-time, they are limited in scope. That seems materially different to me than a single party system that can pass, overturn, or utterly ignore whatever legislation it likes overnight.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI think I'm not quite following--it seems clear to me that China has been interested in expanding its influence for the last 20+ years in much the same way that post-war America was interested in expansion (albeit post-war America had the credible-at-the-time excuse that it was expanding its influence to prevent the spread of communism for the good of the whole world).
- tertius 6y agoExpansionist as in borders, no, as in marketshare of foreign capital and resources? Undoubtedly.
- yongjik 6y ago> China is obsessed with territorial unity, not expansionist policies ... You say as if it makes China better, but I see strong parallels with Nazi Germany's Lebensraum, or Imperial Japan's "Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere". Nationalist sentiments can paint a surprising amount of aggression as "defending what's naturally ours."
- r00fus 6y ago> Well that's part of the point, China is obsessed with territorial unity, not expansionist policies They are not directly militarily expansionist but are very economically influential by bankrolling the new silk road and lots of developments in Africa. > The American perspective is that everyone is secretly trying to expand A huge & growing society seeks resources - which requires expansion; it would be more surprising if they did not given their capabilities and size.
- aksss 6y ago> China is obsessed with territorial unity, not expansionist policies I don’t think the evidence supports that - they’re literally creating new islands to gain more territorial water, for instance. They contest their borders with India and Japan regularly. Their international economic and development policies serve to expand their global influence.
- dv_dt 6y agoI don't see the comment as thinking it's better, but more that it's a very likely possibility of a shifting balance of power.
- dmos62 6y agoIt's fine that you're asking for insight into some specific point of view, but do you feel that comparing Chinese hegemony to US's pertains to what the person said?
- throwaway894345 6y agoYes, maybe I misinterpreted, but I understood his grievance to be that many books focus too much on preserving US influence relative to Chinese influence. Apologies if I misunderstood.
- dmos62 6y agoI think she was looking for a non-biased overview.
- eunos 6y ago> does anyone seriously think that a Chinese global hegemony would be better I welcome Chinese non judgemental policy especially internal matter.
- dis-sys 6y agoIt is the non-interference in internal affairs policy. China is having it to criticize the US gunboat approach. It is not a policy that will be used forever. See how Haiti was criticized by China for its internal affairs just a few weeks ago.
- dis-sys 6y agoIt would be good for many small developing countries that don't seek for global hegemony. For those developing countries, China's rise proves that there is an alternative route for modernization. Of course, for the west, that itself is THE single biggest threat from China.
- throwaway894345 6y agoWhy should we think that China would be better for small developing countries than the West? Or that the West's interests are in keeping small developing countries poor? Specifically, I would think Western countries with capitalist economies would want wealthy trading partners, and indeed give hundreds of billions of dollars in aid per year (ignoring private investment altogether).
- nathannecro 6y agoSure, happy to provide the contra. Not everything I write below is something I necessarily believe to be true, but it should be generally representative of the beliefs from the opposite position. China as a nation and as a group of people have rarely (if ever) been aggressive outside their own borders. Any time where China exerted force or pressure outside its own country is justified as being purely defensive in nature. Internally, this is seen as largely being a cultural difference between Chinese philosophy/practice and the rest of the world. In contemporary times, this practice of non-aggression translates to China's global policy. "One belt, one road" -- one of the primary globalization initiatives of China -- is built around Chinese support of critical national and trade infrastructure of developing countries. The idea is to build up trade partners and diplomatic allies through cooperation and capital infusions. Examples include building international trade ports, providing billions in medical aid, donating technology infrastructure, building millions of km of roadways, and investing in local enterprises. Fundamentally, China is focusing on countries left by the wayside by Western regimes (Africa, parts of Southeast Asia, South America, parts of the Middle East) but China is a good partner to many European countries. This is a dramatic departure from European colonialism and American exceptionalism where military might and economic threats were the standard negotiating tactics. This, the Chinese allege, is fundamentally why a Chinese global hegemony is better than previous historical attempts. The Chinese do not significantly interfere with other nation's business unless it is as an ally of support or unless it's a defensive reaction to outside aggression. This allows other nations and peoples of the world to live their own lives while taking advantage of the market efficiencies, technology, and capital resources that China can provide.
- aksss 6y agoReminds me a bit of the old line, “Rome conquered the world in self defense”. The idea that “we acted outside our borders in defense”, is a line as old as empire itself (and in no way unique). One need only look at the changing borders of China over time to see that their interests extend exactly as far as the geography and external kinetic force allow it to. Another line of thinking they’ll teach you in China is that the people of Tibet were enslaved by a ruling class, and their annexation was actually a liberation for the good of the local population. Maybe they’re right, and maybe five people in Tibet agreed before they started shoving families of Han Chinese into the region en masse, but justification of expansionist policies is a different discussion than whether their policies are or are not expansionist.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoHow about no hegemony? Are we allowed that as an option. USA seems only to be fighting China, so it can replace/keep itself in place as bully of the World meddling and causing untold harm for very perverse ends. We need actual democracy, if we can make it work, proportional representation seems a bare minimum to work towards if we want to seek greater global cooperation (which we must to combat global climate change). Instead we have opposition of other countries only so the powerful of our own countries can step in and reap the benefit, rather than to actually take moral high-ground, or seek better outcomes for our respective countries. Take Brexit, how can purposeful interruption of trade and restriction of movement possibly bring QoL improvements to the populous, it can't, it was all a cynical plan to benefit the elite. Maybe it will act as a wake up call.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> How about no hegemony? Are we allowed that as an option. You can have two or more somewhat balanced powers jockeying for supremacy by way of cold or real wars, but this seems strictly worse for nearly everyone than a single imperfect, democratic superpower. I don't think there's a world in which nations don't compete for influence, at least not in the next century. > USA seems only to be fighting China, so it can replace/keep itself in place as bully of the World meddling and causing untold harm for very perverse ends. I don't see how anyone can look on 20th century history and conclude that a US hegemony is as bad as it gets. > We need actual democracy, if we can make it work, proportional representation seems a bare minimum to work towards if we want to seek greater global cooperation (which we must to combat global climate change). I don't see a global democracy coming to fruition in the next 100 years. It's an interesting idea, however.
- pbhjpbhj 6y ago>look on 20th century history and conclude that a US hegemony is as bad as it gets. // A USA hegemony under Sanders would be very interesting, under Trump's ilk ... USA's power relies on threat of violence, can we really not do better than 'the best murderers win'? I'm guessing you're from USA; when you say the best thing for everyone is a USA hegemony?
- fatjokes 6y agoI'll try to make a good-faith response. > does anyone seriously think that a Chinese global hegemony would be better False equivalency; no one is arguing that. However, a multi-polar world is appealing. The US is certainly not always a good actor here either: the US has 50+ years of foreign interventions to point to that span the globe, particularly the middle east, latin america, and southeast asia. Less extreme: its ability to unilaterally cause pain for even allies (EU, Canada) through trade tariffs wasn't exactly welcomed. It would be in Europe (and other regions') interest to be able to defend their own interests on equal footing with the US. Currently, they cannot do that (military and economic dependence). Having China offers leverage. I.e., the US will be incentivized to behave better if other countries can say "well if you push us too far, we'll work with China." This is just my armchair analysis. I'm not invested enough to back this up with citations or anything so if that's what you're looking for feel free to ignore and argue with someone else who cares more.
- ethbr0 6y agoMultipolar (4+) power balances tend to be the least stable (see: WWI & WWII), due to temporarily alliances believing they possess superior force and making a first strike. Afaik, tripolar tends to be the most stable, with a default-neutral third party, who may choose to side with either other major. Bipolar comes in second.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "However, a multi-polar world is appealing." A multi-polar world is one where a bunch of nation-states have a realistic shot at becoming the new global hegemon. The likely situation is something like what occurred in the 19th and early 20th century where all of the major powers were locked into a blisteringly expensive military and arms race. And when you have a military that stands on an equal footing with others, the temptation is there to use it to advance national interests and, as the old quote goes, "of course you realize this means war!"; the list of wars that occurred in the 19th century is surprisingly long. Absolutely nothing about that scenario is appealing.
- xNeil 6y ago