9 ms·
The Antiscience Movement Is Escalating, Going Global and Killing Thousands
- Bancakes 6y agoPaid journals are a type of anti-science movement.
- psychiatrist24 6y agoStopped reading at "a key feature of the political right" - the political left has adopted many anti-scientific ideas, too (if you want an example, take gender ideology and critical race theory, or belief that socialism works). People rightfully reject publications that write nonsense like that. If such a publication calls itself "science something something", or worse, has a longstanding reputation for representing science, it is no wonder if people become wary of science in general. It seems healthy, actually. Maybe it is not science that is in trouble, but fake propaganda science.
- refurb 6y agoIndeed. Only if you ignore anti-vaxxers, healing crystals, “food without chemicals”, essential oils, etc can you say with a straight face anti-science is a problem driven by the right. It’s hard to take an article seriously when it only points the finger in one direction.
- elliekelly 6y agoThe article doesn’t claim that only those who lean right deny science. It claims only the right has embraced science-denial as a major political platform. There are plenty of science-denying democrats. There aren’t many (to my knowledge) science-denying policies, platforms, or official talking points of the democratic party. The same cannot be said of the GOP.
- psychiatrist24 6y agoI read it again and no, it doesn't. It claims that certain things the author happens to believe in are rejected by the GOP. I think anybody who claims to represent "the science" or "scientists" already should be mistrusted. It's an anti-science stance. In my opinion, proper science should constantly look for ways to disprove its theories, not the other way round. So saying one should "believe science" is anti-science. The case for Covid-vaccines simply doesn't seem to be as clear cut as for example the author claims. Here in Germany they just halted vaccinations with Astra Zeneca, and there is a lot of debate about it. I guess the author of the SciAM article would say the German government is anti-science, too. In reality, there are aspects in favour of vaccination and aspects against it. I think the anti-science notions people worry about are more about distrust of official proclamations.
- GavinMcG 6y agoI think you're talking about certain subjects being more prevalent in left- or right-wing communities. That's different from making opposition to science a political priority. Yeah, there's kooks on the left who go for healing crystals–but that's not incorporated into left politics. On the other hand, elected Republicans have actively fought in the political arena against climate issues being taken seriously. This shows up in other areas, too, such as the Dickey Amendment that discouraged CDC research re: guns as a public health matter.
- luckylion 6y ago> Yeah, there's kooks on the left who go for healing crystals–but that's not incorporated into left politics. Mhh, critical race theory, the whole gender studies joke etc seems to be pretty deeply settled in left politics. It's just something that progressives "like" and therefore don't question the absurdity and consider it "science".
- GavinMcG 6y agoDo they consider it science? I haven't seen racial justice movements incorporating that. And if they do, that's evidence of an orientation toward science that the right actively opposes—i.e. an effort to dress up views with a scientific gloss. You're talking about misusing science, or relying on junk science. Those are problems, of course, but they're not the opposition to the scientific project as a whole that this article focuses on.
- luckylion 6y ago> You're talking about misusing science, or relying on junk science. I don't think critical race theory and similar stuff is science. They're not misusing it, they're pretending somebody's ramblings are scientific, funding it at universities and then presenting it as "the science is in". > they're not the opposition to the scientific project as a whole that this article focuses on If you only pick those parts that you like and invent the rest, that's very much in opposition to the idea of the scientific method.
- daemoens 6y agoThe only thing I can really say would be the "food without chemicals" part. The rest of that is pretty apolitical except the anti-vaxx movement.
- refurb 6y agoWhat I listed is not exclusively found on the left side of the spectrum but I’ve never met a right winger who is into healing crystals or essential oil quite like the crunchy hippies of the west coast. Again, there are plenty of examples of anti-science thinking across the political spectrum.
- yasp 6y agoSciAm isn't what it used to be. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-unbearable-whiteness-of-climate-anxiety/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-unbearable-wh...
- Kharvok 6y agoI would add to this list a belief in "blank slate-ism" specifically around individual cognitive ability expressed mostly in ineffective education methods.
- h2odragon 6y agoscience is still great. "scientific consensus" has taken over in many places where people used to mean "scientific method"; and thats not great but still fits into "believe the science" for the people putting logos on signs. Science doesn't care what we believe.
- taylodl 6y agoThe so-called hard sciences are still great. It's kind of hard to deny that an apple, when released, falls to the ground. Now let's go to the so-called soft sciences which rely upon statistical modeling. Whoa! We necessarily must rely more on "scientific consensus." We should be increasing the public's education in statistics since it's become so important for public discourse of important issues. But of course we haven't.
- wrycoder 6y agoI’m surprised that Sci Am published this. The hyper partisan language immediately caused me to doubt the veracity of the claims the author makes. And that’s an understatement. Sci Am used to be a quality magazine. No more.
- eplanit 6y agoSo we can add scientific American to the pile of things that used to do journalism.
- nerdponx 6y agoThere is plenty of antiscience on the left (chemtrails, 5g, anti-vax). But critical race theory is a deliberately extreme academic model of the world, and it actually turns out to be a useful model. To complain that it is not a falsifiable model misses the point of what literary "theory" is for. Your post smells like a bad faith dogwhistle, rather than an attempt to discuss something.
- psychiatrist24 6y agoIt wasn't my intention to discuss any of those beliefs, just to list examples of anti-science beliefs among leftists. If you believe critical race theory is science, OK - it's not the subject of this thread, I suppose. The only relevant aspect is that we will see articles of how anti-science conservatives supposedly are, because they reject critical race theory. It's actually useful for that - identifying bullshit articles and organisations.
- nerdponx 6y agoFair enough. Just don't conflate "belief in things I don't believe" with "anti-science".
- EamonnMR 6y agoIt's odd that the author only traces the political aspect back to 2015, when climate change denial has been a political issue since the turn of the millennium: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_policy_of_the_George_W._Bush_administration https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_policy_of_the...
- pjmorris 6y agoAnd I'd heard of the anti-vaxx movement in the mid-90's.
- mannykannot 6y agoCertainly, though it was mostly ignored by major political parties in those days. And WRT EamonnMR's point, while the article invokes 'antiscience' as a movement, its author is clearly only interested in medical science. Personally, I'm not convinced that there is a unitary, consolidated anti-science movement, though it might be developing.
- jfengel 6y agoAnti-vax took a weird twist over the past decade. It used to be a hippie-liberal notion, heavily informed by being anti-corporate anti-big-pharma. But it became more mainstream and cross-party when endorsed by celebrities, and then cross-fertilized with the anti-science anti-government Republican party. I'm sure the crunchy-granola antivaxers are still out there, but they were a fringe group and remain a fringe group. But for the GOP it's mainstream. COVID's a little different from general anti-vax, being driven by a hoax narrative from the President combined with the perception of rushing a vaccine through (with the intention of having it be an October surprise for the election). That makes everybody nervous, on all sides of the spectrum.
- djrogers 6y ago> But for the GOP it's mainstream. No, it's really not. It's only mainstream in the GOP if you get your news from the left - if you associate with and listen to people on both sides of the aisle, you realize that it's a fringe element on both sides.
- mdpopescu 6y agoFrom your mouth to God's ears. /grin This religion, despite Asimov, was not successful because it worked. It was successful because - like all other religions - it made it easier for people to stop thinking for themselves, and accept what they are told is the truth. [When it works we call it engineering.]
- threatofrain 6y agohttps://www.axios.com/concern-republican-coronavirus-vaccine-hesitancy-trump-6220b95e-f334-49c4-ad4f-854d5af6b76b.html https://www.axios.com/concern-republican-coronavirus-vaccine...
- DethNinja 6y agoI’ve been pro science all my life but heavy censorship on coronavirus made me change my mind, perhaps blame is on the censorers a bit, no? If it is truly science, why censor the ideas of others?
- maxehmookau 6y agoSomething about a lie making it half way across the world before the truth can get its boots on. We, as a general population, have proven that completely uncensored speech gives way too much weight to ideas that have no merit.
- luckylion 6y ago> We, as a general population, have proven that completely uncensored speech gives way too much weight to ideas that have no merit. That sounds like it'll get pretty scary once you start following the road.
- brigandish 6y agoQuite the opposite. We proved that the imposition of “acceptable” information and censorship to protect it holds back societies, and can see that those with greater freedoms do better economically and otherwise.
- maxehmookau 6y ago[citation needed] That's a pretty bold statement. I'm pro free speech, but believe it should have limits in a civilized society. I don't know what the answer is, or where the line should be but entirely unrestricted free speech isn't the infalable utopia that the US is conditioned to believe.
- brigandish 6y agoShall we begin with some egregious examples and go from there? How is Nazi Germany doing? Or East Germany? Soviet Russia? Clearly there's an impossible hump of correlation/causation, but that doesn't mean we can't show at least part of the data set to be true - that you are far more likely to fail or be a horrible place to live. > entirely unrestricted free speech isn't the infalable utopia that the US is conditioned to believe It wouldn't be a utopia, it would just be better than the alternative, like most liberties. Utopianism is a vision that is associated with a lack of freedom and collectivism (large scale collectivism necessarily entails curtailed freedom), not with enhanced liberty. > I'm pro free speech, but believe it should have limits in a civilized society To be civilised implies two things, primarily: - greater learning - better manners That you can learn more where information is unrestricted should need no explanation. As to manners, what better sign of good manners and civility can there be when you may say whatever you like without fear of punishment and yet you remain civil? Hence, a more civilised society has less limits on what you can say and imbues its citizens with greater responsibility to practise that speech well.
- z5h 6y agoAny group/person/movement with any agenda other than promoting science and reason must necessarily be against science and reason at points. Any “agendaism” must be prepared to attack science and reason as well as proponents of science and reason. I’m not suggesting other agendas aren’t important. Rather that they can incur a science-debt, and don’t typically have the motivation to pay it off. Edit: I should be clear that I’m speaking about the scientific process: admit you may not have full understandings, devise experiments to test/expand understanding, execute, interpret, repeat.
- vbtemp 6y agoI think you are spot on. I also think much of the "anti-science" right is a reaction to the "anti-science" left, which has lots of ideologies that cannot be defended by pure reason alone, and need to be defended instead by online angry mobs. Whether it's to do with social issues (crime, racial issues, gender issues, abortion, immigration, etc), pop ideas today are defended by a "how dare you" if you are not in the movement. Note also how they leave no room for moderates: Someone with balanced views on abortion, for example, is as bad as a catholic fundamentalist. Someone with mixed views on immigration is a neo nazi. Etc I'm also reminded of the near daily episodes on reddit, which constantly has threads highlighting outrage over police brutality, criminal injustice, etc. Then, when it's someone they don't like getting crushed by the system, it's a party of joyous triumphalism.
- z5h 6y agoMore than a reaction. Any agendaist who opposes science also makes it easier for other agendaists to oppose science. Their methodologies are essentially open source! I get in many arguements with friends and loved ones, not because I disagree with what their agenda represents, but because their methods are problematic. It’s very hard for someone not to take it as an attack of their values.
- vbtemp 6y agoI may misunderstand, but I read it this way: The "pro-science" team is so obviously and transparently hypocritical and self-serving in their use of logic, become extremely defensive to any kind of criticism, and basically resort to name-calling ("they're stupid") anyone out side of the bubble. This basically sets the scene that anyone can make any logic work and no one really needs to really think anything through - it's all just window dressing for the agenda. We act like it's only Trump that does it but he's just goofiest-looking, that's all. I thought it was really funny in the picture accompanying the article, an anti-vaxer waved a sign that said something like "Respect my bodily autonomy" - we know where that kind of logic came from. Also, since that group was clearly anti-abortion, we knew it was just really poking fun at the "window dressing" logic that of pro-choicers that it is really about "autonomy". I believe at the end of the day we've entered the phase of words mean nothing any more, we all just have our agendas, we want what we want, and we'll all just wrap it in whatever bullshit we want.
- ancorevard 6y agoThe irony here is that this article is published by Scientific American, who themselves have abandoned science on topics that relate to ideological issues.
- w4rh4wk5 6y agoHow about we just take away their phones. Without science there wouldn't be any anyway.
- mdpopescu 6y agoName three scientific papers (that you have studied) that contributed to mobile phones.
- w4rh4wk5 6y agoWhat I was getting at is that the whole field of electronics would not even exist without science. No computers, no phones, maybe a tiny bit of electricity... Pretty much our whole standard of living exists due to advances in science. If people don't recognize and respect this, they should not enjoy their current living standards --- i.e. not having phones. I suspect/hope they'd reconsider their thoughts.
- keenreed 6y agoLysenko was scientist with stellar credibility, he was wrong, but that happens in science. Main problem was not "anti science", but turning science into religion. Unproven theories were implemented too fast, without enough tests and verifications.
- aww_dang 6y agoHis theories fit with the prevailing political ideology, therefore he was "right".
- sremani 6y agoOne of true skills of 21st century is to discern Science from Scientism. As a rule of thumb, 'respect my authoritah' is not a scientific argument. Relying on blunt tools of persuasion alienates people irrespective of scientific substance.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoYou mean like holding up signs trying to persuade people vaccines are bad?
- alexgmcm 6y agoThe antivax movement is ridiculous and hopefully the necessity of covid vaccinations will destroy it as should have happened years ago. Similarly, the evidence for climate change is pretty much undeniable now and I can only assume that those pretending it doesn't exist are not honest actors. But the lockdown scepticism I can kind of understand as it is more of a political issue - the cost/benefit of lockdown and depending on the type of lockdown, if it will even be effective. It seems the usual rational decisions over medical intervention based on quality-adjusted life years etc. has been abandoned in favour of emotional arguments. China showed us lockdowns can work, but these "lockdowns" we have now just seem to be political theatre with little effect on transmission. The politicians want to give the impression of doing something because actually effective measures like closing workplaces and schools would be too expensive/difficult.
- matz1 6y agoHow is china shows lockdown can work ? They may simply reacting and just try to do 'something'. By that logic sweeden, florida, south dakota, shows lockdown doesn't make significant difference.
- alexgmcm 6y agoBecause they went from the disaster in Wuhan to zero cases, with no vaccines.
- mdpopescu 6y ago> Similarly, the evidence for climate change is pretty much undeniable now and I can only assume that those pretending it doesn't exist are not honest actors. That's exactly my position, except the opposite. Anyone who claims that "the world is ending, give us money" is anything but a scam, shamelessly copied from the Catholic Church, is not an honest actor.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoSo do you have a rational explanation for all the permafrost sinkholes opening in Siberia? Or the ice shelfs melting? Or half of antartica disappearing? Or Australia, and Western United States constantly on fire? Do you know what a feedback loop is? Heat rises, permafrost melts, methane is released causing heat to rise more, more permafrost/ice is melted causing higher temps. Do you know what happens if we lose bees and other polinators, and how close we are to losing them because of pesticides? There's plenty of people pushing climate change and not demanding a cent. Those pushing the hardest AGAINST climate change are the ones demanding we "look the other way" because of their corporate greed - re: Oil / Plastics industries.
- dilap 6y agoThis conflates "official positions of authorities" with "science". It's like a modern religion, with three tenets: (1) science made everything around us (iPhones and airplanes!) (2) we speak for science (3) therefore you must believe our conclusions. But in fact, that's the opposite of a proper scientific attitude, which always admits doubt, and believes experiment over authority. As for why authorities are increasingly losing trust, I think it's because they've been rather unreliable recently. To use just one glaring example, the official advice on masks went overnight from, "they're useless!" to "you're killing people if you don't use them!". Both positions were condescendingly presented as "the science". A lot of people will start to lose trust when you so glaringly contradict yourself in such a rapid amount of time. In general, the approach seems to be when crafting public advice to not worry about presenting an accurate picture of our current knowledge, but just pick a position, pretend we are certain it is true, and hand it down as the infallible words of Science. (See also: our ever changing dietary recommendations.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 6y agoThe mask thing was a Noble Lie to prevent PPE shortages: https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/yes-experts-will-lie-to-you-sometimes https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/yes-experts-will-lie-to-yo... I agree that that erodes trust, but it was for "a reason".
- dqpb 6y agoI’ve found it very hard to find the original news sources saying not to wear masks, despite remembering how prevalent that messaging was.
- acdha 6y agoHere’s reasonably old document repeating the N95 & exposure concerns. It definitely happened but I think there’s some selective memory feeding a lot of the criticism. https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/04/dont-panic-the-comprehensive-ars-technica-guide-to-the-coronavirus/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/04/dont-panic-the-compr...
- ohiovr 6y agoSome science, it seems, is better than others https://www.discovermagazine.com/health/the-public-health-legacy-of-the-1976-swine-flu-outbreak https://www.discovermagazine.com/health/the-public-health-le...
- bronzeage 6y agoWhen science is weaponized by politicians and when the media is lying about everything intentionally, and being concentrated by very few conglomerates, it isn't anti-science as much as it is anti-media. Just because the media screams "science" doesn't make them the voice of science.
- endisneigh 6y agothere's a fine line between appealing to "experts" and religion. I'd argue though, that there's a monetary incentive to keep people dumb and susceptible to things like advertising - so I don't see this trend reversing soon, if ever. I intentionally don't mention the word "science", because "science" isn't really the issue here - moreso this idea that certain organizations or individuals somehow know the truth we and should just believe them.
- Thursday032521 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism
- prvc 6y agoWe have all learned that science as a method of obtaining knowledge is superior to and fundamentally at odds with the blind acceptance of authority. This includes would-be authorities among us. When the authorities then simply claim the mantle of "science" as their own exclusive domain, who is left to oppose them?
- djrogers 6y agoArticles like this one accelerate the politicization of conspiracies like anti-vax, rather than help address the underlying problem. To attempt to make this a 'right wing extremist' problem, one has to ignore the fact that one of the historically least vaccinated counties in the US is also one of the most progressive (Marin CO in the Bay Area). This is a 'nut jobs on Facebook' problem, not a right or left problem. -- edited to clarify that I'm not referring specifically to the COVID vax
- jfengel 6y agoThis is a case where "nut jobs on Facebook" are being endorsed by prominent political figures from one party, and not the other. Every party has its nut jobs, but there's a real asymmetry here, where explicit anti-science attitudes are a political platform of just one side. Fighting "nut jobs on Facebook" is a good thing to do, though it's really hard. "Hard" becomes "impossible" when prominent political figures endorse it.
- eric_b 6y agoEh, the political left is just as guilty of abusing "science" for its own agenda. If you look at what peer reviewed articles in medical journals say about COVID, and then you look at the "pro-science" left-leaning-media coverage - you'll see two entirely different things. The political left picks and chooses the findings it likes to fit the narrative, and exaggerates them for effect. In the United States, if you live in a democrat controlled area the only way your kids were going to school in-person during COVID was private education. We had a wealth of data by September of last year showing that it was possible, and worth the risk, to open schools for younger children. And yet it was politics that kept our children out of school, under the guise of "science". The same is true of masks. The outcomes in places with and without mask mandates are roughly similar in terms of spread and mortality. But god forbid you suggest that wearing a mask while working out is counterproductive at best. The whole talking point bugs me. There's no such thing as "science says". On most topics you'll find a wealth of "science" that is contradictory. It's through assimilation and reconciliation of various conflicts through further experimentation that we arrive at "the truth." Calling an entire group "Anti-science" is just another way to shut down conversation and dialog. Just like calling an entire group lazy, racist, criminals, etc.
- pjc50 6y ago> possible, and worth the risk, to open schools for younger children Could you elaborate on this? It seems to be clear that while children themselves are relatively unscathed, they spread the virus among themselves and to their family members quite effectively.
- eric_b 6y agoI mean, Google will tell you everything you need to know: https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-briefs/transmission_k_12_schools.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-br... > Based on the data available, in-person learning in schools has not been associated with substantial community transmission. Although national COVID-19 case incidence rates among children and adolescents have risen over time, this trend parallels trends observed among adults.17 Increases in case incidence among school-aged children and school reopenings do not appear to pre-date increases in community transmission We knew all of this back in September because Europe had taken the lead on keeping schools open in many places. Only now in the United States is it politically palatable to talk about.
- al_chemist 6y agoScience is modern religion.
- patwolf 6y ago"Antiscience is the rejection of mainstream scientific views and methods or their replacement with unproven or deliberately misleading theories, often for nefarious and political gains." The problem with that definition is "mainstream" science is also full of unproven theories, often for nefarious and political gains. The only real difference between what they consider science vs antiscience is how mainstream the views are. That seems like a poor way to determine scientific credibility.
- joshspankit 6y agoFight me if you must, but I firmly believe that the scientific institutions are the reason that “antiscience” and “scientism” have been able to gain ground. Faking data, using “appeal to experts” and intellectualism to pretend that what they say must be true simply by virtue of the fact they said it, stifling opposing voices, leaning in to sensationalism with misleading conclusions, laying down at the feet of funding sources, propping up the image of “scientists” even in the face of impossible-to-reproduce experiments and predatory journals with overwhelmingly clear agendas... I could go on and on. Human ego and the need for money are challenging hurdles for experts on the unpopular fringes to be sure, but if everyone stuck to (or stood up now and reaffirmed) the basic tenets of science: - Change a single variable and record the results in an unbiased way - The scale of knowing is from “Absolutely no clue” to “fairly sure we’re not wrong”, and there is certainly never a “we’re absolutely sure we’re right” I think it could go a long way towards rebuilding the public trust in the data from scientific studies, or at the very least give people the space to say “Yes the previous data was flawed, but we redid the experiments from scratch and the results are even more concerning.” without getting booed off the stage.
- dathinab 6y agoWhat has me most worried is that in Germany the anti-since movement is undermined, used, pushed, financed?? by more or less all problematic/extremist right wing movements (ultra conservatives, Neo-Nazis, Reichsbürger, all not the same but often with a lot of overlap). Worse may people getting swept up in the movement due to mistrust in the government and health system often don't realize this, starting to repeat right wing propaganda while position themself as everything but right wing. Noticeable is also that as far as I can tell there are organized people spreading this misinformation using expertise about how to best manipulate people. For example thy intentionally take easy to misunderstand since "results" related to Covid and twist them using "broken" (i.e. outright wrong) statistics which for a person not knowing anything about statistics "seem ok/valid". While there are some cases which might have been mistakes many clearly are not. Furthermore the way "fake news" pop up indicates (for me, I didn't to to deep research) that this people do understand exactly what they do. I.e. they look for the best ways to disproof they content and then pre-empty create "fake news" to discredit the sources which would be used for this arguments. Or at least this is how I perceive it. At the same time the established media does a horrible job, instead of properly factual reporting about this problems they put the people tricked in the same pot as the people tricking them and the people taking advantage of the situation. By discrediting all the involved people as extremist right wing and similar they denounce and discredit many people which just have been tricked pushing them further into it and loosing more trust. Especially there is a large amount of "moderate" people which have/had reasonable alternative ideas about how to approaches to handling Covid (like actually reasonable, potentially better then what the government did, especially around fall last year). But this people are repeatedly tricked in some but not all of there arguments by "fake news" and now, the press they already don't trust much discredit all they say because supposedly they are Nazis. (They are not, but they let themself be manipulated by them.) Through in every case I looked into the press was noticeable more honest then alternative sources. But more honest sadly doesn't mean fully honest. The fact that especially some of the state payed (but supposedly independent) press has a record of not fully honest (and sometimes outright deceptive) reporting doesn't help. Similar is true for the non state payed press but in other ways (e.g. their involvement in the copyright reform which offended many young people). For example one of the first larger demo against the covid measurements taken in berlin consisted of the demo moving through the city followed by an announcement. The press reported the lowest estimate of people involved by the moving demo but made it look like it is the number of all of it and also didn't say they took the lower estimated. But on the demo announcement probably twice to thrice of the amount of people had been involved. So not very honest. But the people behind of the demo where worse as they overestimated the amount of people by a factor of 10 or more and used the reasoning "that the press numbers are clearly wrong" to trick people into believing it. Then they took certain events related to the police out of order and represented a moderate reasonable action of the police as something completely different, using this to further undermine the credibility of the government.
- gitowiec 6y agoI read another article linked inside this article. It is very good: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/12/trofim-lysenko-soviet-union-russia/548786/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/12/trofim-l...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- motohagiography 6y agoThe trouble with appeals to science is that anyone can make empirical observations. Like if you can still smell VOC's through a mask (e.g. farts), that is empirical data to cast some doubt about their efficacy against airborne droplets, and about how much economic harm or social restriction you're going to tolerate based on that. If you make these policies about science instead of authority, it's just another lie with a short half-life, and you're going to lose when it comes out. Trusting science on the mask and lockdown policy issue means rejecting the official policy direction. On mRNA therapies it means examining FDA approval and human trial results. Trusting science on curve flattening means rejecting that Ferguson epidemiological model used to justify lockdowns. So-called science should inform policy, but it is not a sound justification for it. To say that your political policies have the authority of "science," as though they were discovered truths is as sound as saying they were divinely revealed, because it comes down to trusting the people who are telling you that. A scientific policy is also necessarily not a democratic one, or one based in any policymaker accountability, because it is founded in the views of a few unaccountable initiates. When elected representatives forfeit their responsibility to un-elected experts and just do what they are told, they are renouncing their authority and giving it to people who don't get fired (or worse) for being wrong. The conflict is that policymakers have basically asked "what is the exception we can use to suspend all these legal constraints on us so that we can wield power to do what we think is the right thing for humanity?" and they have settled on a medical crisis. If only pandemic policy were based on science, we would be in much better shape, but it's based on leaders avoiding responsibility and blaming "science" for their unwillingness to produce democratic policy that preserves the foundations of their societies, arguably, because their agenda is to destabilize and un-moor them.
- amadeuspagel 6y agoRecently, Macron said that the AstraZeneca vaccine was almost ineffective for people older then 65[1]. Politicians on both the left and the right sometimes find their political interests at odds with mainstream scientific research. That doesn't mean they're on some kind of crusade against science. I also find the obsession with anti-vaxxers strange, when the FDA and many european medical authorities refuse to allow the AstraZeneca vaccine. I guess it's easier to blame everything on internet trolls, rather then medical authorities run by people like you, in your social circles, but the latter are objectively responsible for far more death. [1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-56252028 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-56252028
- tzs 6y ago> I also find the obsession with anti-vaxxers strange, when the FDA and many european medical authorities refuse to allow the AstraZeneca vaccine. AZ has not yet asked the FDA to allow the AZ vaccine. They are still in the clinical trial stage in the US. The FDA emergency use authorization procedure includes FDA scientists plus a panel of outside scientists reviewing all of the submitted trial data and doing their own analysis rather than just relying on the submitted analysis. This is why it takes 2 to 3 weeks between the submission of an application and the approval of the authorization. AZ had enough anomalies in their European trials that they weren't sure they would pass the FDA's more stringent review and so are conducting more trials in the US to get cleaner data. About 3 weeks ago AZ said it expected to have results in a few weeks and would apply then.
- ykevinator 6y agoFox news