5 ms·
Micropayments are a bad idea that feels like a good idea. They're bad for a fundamental human reason - each decision carries with it emotional and psychological
by arcticbull 6y ago
Micropayments are a bad idea that feels like a good idea. They're bad for a fundamental human reason - each decision carries with it emotional and psychological burden. Make a few in a day and you land in decision fatigue [1]. Weighing the value of a purchase no matter how small over and over again makes the whole experience an utter chore.
There is a paradox in that "people who lack choices seem to want them and often will fight for them", yet at the same time, "people find that making many choices can be [psychologically] aversive." [1]
There's no technical reason why any wallet operator today, like PayPal can't do micropayments except people don't want them. They think they do, but they don't.
Concrete example: For most people, it's always been cheaper to just buy the content you want to watch from iTunes one at a time - and own it forever! But everyone uses Netflix instead. They continue to use Netflix even as it has less and less of what they actually wanted to watch in the first place! In the battle of more expensive vs more decision making, more expensive always wins.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decision_fatigue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decision_fatigue
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- com2kid 6y ago> Concrete example: It's always been cheaper to just buy the content you want to watch from iTunes, but everyone uses Netflix instead. They continue to use Netflix even as it has less and less of what they actually wanted to watch in the first place! In the battle of more expensive vs more decision making, more expensive always wins. No way is that true. A single season of a TV show varies from $10 to $20 on iTunes[1]. Movies are $10-$15 [2]. For anything beyond light viewing, Netflix is a clear win. Watch 2 movies a month on it and you are well over break even! Now if you buy from iTunes, it is only pay once. But for people like me who almost never rewatch a movie, ownership is irrelevant. Streaming is a hands down winner! [1] https://itunes.apple.com/us/tv-season/robot-chicken-season-1/id203874701 https://itunes.apple.com/us/tv-season/robot-chicken-season-1... https://itunes.apple.com/us/tv-season/archer-danger-island-season-9/id1363208365 https://itunes.apple.com/us/tv-season/archer-danger-island-s... https://itunes.apple.com/us/tv-season/the-office-season-3/id192599752 https://itunes.apple.com/us/tv-season/the-office-season-3/id... [2] https://itunes.apple.com/us/movie/back-to-the-future-part-ii/id380040080 https://itunes.apple.com/us/movie/back-to-the-future-part-ii... https://itunes.apple.com/us/movie/the-divergent-series-allegiant/id1090135578 https://itunes.apple.com/us/movie/the-divergent-series-alleg...
- bryanlarsen 6y agoHow much TV do you watch a day? Buying a couple of seasons of TV a month is going to be about the same price as a couple of subscriptions to streaming TV. And theoretically it gets you exactly the TV you want, something which you need 5 subscriptions or so to do right now. I think consumers would be better off with the Season Pass model than having to subscribe to a bunch of services, but what really kills it is that it doesn't have all TV, or anywhere close. Season Pass isn't horrendously expensive if that's all you have, but it does get expensive on top of Netflix and/or cable. As for movies, you can rent them from $1 - $5, so a couple of movies per week can also be cheaper than a couple of streaming services.
- tarboreus 6y agoPeople watch A LOT of TV. Americans watch 4 hours per day, still ahead of the amount of time they spend on smartphones, approximately 3.5. https://www.statista.com/chart/15224/daily-tv-consumption-by-us-adults/ https://www.statista.com/chart/15224/daily-tv-consumption-by...
- jacquesm 6y agoThat's a nice 7.5 hour workday right there.
- silicon2401 6y ago> How much TV do you watch a day? Just a side comment, 'watching TV' today when TVs and monitors are common and cheap is different from 'watching TV' 20-30+ years ago, when TVs were more of a luxury good (I know displays still aren't free but they're much more accessible than they used to be). It's common for people to have netflix on in the background while doing things (e.g. studying, netflix and chill), to have netflix on a secondary monitor while gaming, to fall asleep to, etc. People probably don't 'watch' TV in the sense of sitting down and just staring at the screen like they used to, but they still 'watch' a lot of TV in the sense of having it on. From that perspective, it's easy to imagine someone watching 8+ hours of netflix a day: auto-playing sitcoms in the background during chores or studying, switching to a favorite show to watch during meals, binging multiple episodes or seasons of a new show on weekends, etc. That would rack up the cost quick using your pay-per-show model
- ethbr0 6y agoThat seems like an overgeneralization. People are perfectly happy to buy low price things on Amazon or eBay. IMHO, transaction fatigue swamps the effect of decision fatigue. Where transaction = the energy required to realize a decision, once made. See: PayPal's valuation.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoYou can get the best of both worlds with a plug-in that allocates a fixed amount each month for whatever media you choose. Microbuy to your heart’s content until the amount runs out, then decide if you’ve had enough for the month or top it up. The plug-in would roll your allotment over if you don’t finish it.
- arcticbull 6y agoIMO each time is still a purchasing decision. People are about as weary of deferring the making of the purchasing decision to an app as they are tired of making the decisions.
- charcircuit 6y agoJust reduce the price until it isn't.
- TrevorJ 6y ago0 dollars?
- StavrosK 6y agoYou're describing coil.com and Web Payments, sounds like.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mistersys 6y agoThis seems like a reasonable argument, however I must say that buying content from iTunes is usually not cheaper than an Netflix subscription, unless you don't actually watch TV regularly. With the highest level premium subscription of $17.99 a month you could only watch 4.5 movies a month, or 5 - 6 episodes of a TV show. I don't watch TV regularly, but if an average user watchtime of greater than 2 hours is accurate, as I'm getting from a quick search, that's more like 90 episodes a month.
- tshaddox 6y agoBut how many people actually watch 4.5 new (to them) movies or 5-6 new episodes a month? I suspect that’s pretty rare.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoyou think that's high? I usually binge at least 2-3 seasons of a new-to-me show a month on netflix, prime, hulu, if I'm really busy -- my wife makes up for the time I miss watching new-to-her shows, or the kids watch new-to-them shows or disney launches a new movie... I mean.. Wandavision, Falcon+Winter Soldier, Mandalorian, New Mighty Ducks are top notch and that's just disney... Netflix has the Witcher which I still need to watch, just finished two different ones on figure skating Zero Chill (Hockey+Figure skating) and Spinning out. Both really good shows that weren't on my radar. Recently finished Queen's gambit too--also great and not on radar... Lots of back-burner shows too (waiting for the next season). 7-11pm is usually dinner, tv with family put kids to bed, watch 1-2 shows with wife, then go to bed. Sometimes I watch old movies that are new to me just cause I heard they're good but haven't seen them yet. Grew up in 80's and just recently finished Fast Times at Ridgemont High for example. 120 hours of screen time's easy... weekends are probably a lot more.. maybe 8 hour sessions, definitely enough to watch 1 whole new-to-us series... esp. with lockdowns and covid.
- tshaddox 6y ago> you think that's high? I don't really know. I'm sure plenty of people consume a lot of new stuff, but I just had a gut reaction to seeing "4 movies or 6 new TV episodes a month" mentioned as a low bar. To me that's a very busy month! But of course I have no data and no reason to believe myself and my family/friends/peers to be representative. Families with children are an obvious case that probably pushes up the average. But I also get the impression, based anecdotally on myself and my friends and peers, that there's also plenty of people who routinely find themselves considering whether they should even keep paying. There's definitely a common sentiment like "it seems like I browse around on Netflix for several minutes and see the same couple of dozen things that I've been seeing for months, I swear I remember hearing about some recent must-watch movies and shows, but I sure can't find them right now, and I just end up watching YouTube videos." I personally am definitely way over-subscribed to streaming services, and my YouTube Premium subscription is delivering tons more value than all the others combined.
- Aunche 6y agoThat's a good point. I know a lot of people who buy an unlimited Metrocard even when they don't get their money's worth out of it just so they don't need to think about paying for their subway fare.
- jetpackjoe 6y agoThe real reason to do a monthly unlimited is to not have to reload, especially when you are pressed for time. Going forward, in NYC, I'm just going to use OMNY, since it's not in all stations.
- majewsky 6y agoI'm one of these people. I have a BahnCard 100, an unlimited-access pass from the German national railway company that works on about 95% of all public transit across the country (all railway except for some lines that are only tourist attractions; and all subways/trams/busses/ferries in 120 large cities). It costs me around 170€ per month, which is way more than I would spend if I bought just a subscription for my city's public transit plus train tickets as needed. But even if I pay a few bucks more, it's totally worth it because it changes how I approach travel. I can wake up in the morning and decide on a whim to do a day trip to a city 200 kilometers away for no extra charge. I can decide on Thursday evening to take Friday off and visit my parents (who live 500 km away from me) for the weekend. (Side-note: Obviously a lot of this is not possible right now because of the plague, but at some point, all parties involved will be vaccinated and I can resume my travels.)
- boringg 6y agoIt's the same idea round buying a season ski pass vs pay each day. Or owning a car vs renting it for each need. It's not that its more cost effective it's the idea of having to do a mental hurdle every time you want to do something. The sunk cost is an enabler to go do something vs having to pay each time and get value out of that trip. I've had this debate many times with friends. Am I hyper efficient with my spend? No, am I happy about my decision making process and/or less decisions to make? Absolutely. If I see micro transactions for reading articles SMH. Conceptually I see where you are going but it would have really bad ripple effects IMHO.
- whimsicalism 6y agoYour concrete example substantially detracts from your argument because it is just not true.
- arcticbull 6y agoI'll accept that I was projecting my own calculus.
- MithrilTuxedo 6y agoI can see some utility though. I'd love to be paid a penny at a time, and pay for things a penny at a time. I'd love for my income and regular bills to all be made into rates (pennies/second) rather than lump sums on some weekly or monthly schedule. Heck, make them functions, so there's no ongoing communication that needs to happen to represent value transferred between parties, until the function changes or the sending account runs out of money. There's so much I can imagine happening if value transfers could defined as functions instead of individual transactions.
- teawrecks 6y agoThe idea would be that people transact without consciously thinking about it. Ex. I pay per byte stored in my cloud backup, but I don't fret about which individual bytes I'm going to store, it's all captured in a high level strategy of which directories I want backed up. If I start spending more than I want, the solution isn't to individually comb through what files I want to back up, it's to tweak my high level strategy.
- tshaddox 6y agoThat’s a valid point, but you don’t seem to be comparing it to the “fundamental human reasons” that dominant Internet media oligopolies supported almost entirely by advertising might impose emotional and psychological burden. I believe the stuff about decision fatigue, I just don’t think you can immediately conclude “therefore paying for online content is a non-starter because of fundamental human psychology.” I mean, people do still decide to buy things, including online content!
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThe parent comment was railing against micropayments in particular, not buying things online in general.
- charcircuit 6y agoConcrete counterexample: The cloud. You can spin up and down servers whenever and you make micropayments for keeping the servers you have around.
- reggieband 6y agoI think you are wrong and you are confusing your opinion with "absolute truth". It is a limited form of is/ought fallacy. Just because things are one way today doesn't mean they ought to be that way. I recall reading a16z blog post "Outgrowing Advertising: Multimodal Business Models as a Product Strategy" [1] and they mention many innovative business models coming out of China. For example, from the "Books" section of that blog post: > Books are also sold as bite-sized snacks. Readers pay per 1,000 words, for often-serialized works. Below is a screenshot of one of the most popular books from 2014, 一世倾城. It has over 10,000 chapters and is still being updated — now more than 46 times the length of the entire Harry Potter series. Because authors can publish chapters piecemeal, they are also able to incorporate reader feedback to quickly change plots or even kill off characters. > Some authors offer free books and illustrations, gain a loyal user base, and then collect money through tips. At the end of each chapter, an overlay button for tipping authors allows readers to tip from $0.15 and up. This kind of thing is built into WeChat and WeChat has significant penetration in the Chinese market. Twitch is also experimenting with a form of micropayments called "bits" [2] Right now in the West we don't have an equivalent of WeChat so we don't see the same things happening. Twitch is a very limited scope (live streams and mostly focused on gaming content). However, just because it isn't happening widely in the West yet doesn't mean that emerging economies aren't going to jump on this. And it also doesn't mean it won't make it's way here eventually. Our systems are preventing us from experimenting with these new business models. If we completely remove the friction that currently exists - let's see if clever entrepreneurs can make it work. The alternative is to fall behind the experimentation that is currently happening outside of our bubble. 1. https://a16z.com/2018/12/07/when-advertising-isnt-enough-multimodal-business-models-product-strategy/ https://a16z.com/2018/12/07/when-advertising-isnt-enough-mul... 2. https://www.twitch.tv/bits https://www.twitch.tv/bits
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed, it's almost certainly my own opinion. The fundamental technology or platform to implement a micropayments system very much exists though, it's something PayPal could implement in a heartbeat.
- dalbasal 6y agoWhile I take your point that "micropayments" are that thing people are have been consistently wrong about for 25 years now... I'd be careful leaning to heavily on psychology in making prediction. There definitely needs to be a breakthrough UI, cultural shift or something... but people have the ability to background stuff given the right circumstances.
- matkoniecz 6y ago> buy the content you want to watch from iTunes one at a time - and own it forever! Can I actually download it? Or is it "as long as it is not removed from iTunes and you can log in"?
- max_ 6y agoThe mere fact that their people demanding these things means that they are wanted.
- z3t4 6y agoMicro transactions would open up new business opportunities. And I don't find it very taxing when for example going to the grocery store where you make a lot of small purchase decisions. One concern though is book-keeping and tax rules if you run an international small business - but I guess that can be automated too ... So that the state automatically get their VAT from every transaction and in turn provides a payment system completely free from transfer fees.
- amelius 6y ago> They're bad for a fundamental human reason - each decision carries with it emotional and psychological burden. Make a few in a day and you land in decision fatigue So, introduce a "content-plan" which is just like the data-plan of your smartphone. I.e. a quota on the total payments per month for content. By the way each advertisement also carries with it an emotional and psychological burden.
- risho 6y agoI tried switching ting as my mobile service provider a few years ago when it was something along the lines of 10 dollars per gigabyte and every time I wanted to watch a youtube video I had to ask myself "is it really worth 4 dollars to watch this?" "would I really spend 2 dollars to download this podcast when I could just download it for free at home?" . I eventually wound up switching to another provider that actually wound up costing me more money per month but a flat cost and a flat allotment of bandwidth. Even though the flat rate service was more expensive it was still preferable to me because I didn't need to spend mental energy justifying the cost of every action I made.
- airhead969 6y agoThere's two issues to deconflate: 1. Reducing fees associated with smaller payments - it would be nice to be able to buy a candy bar or give a street performer a tip without costing anyone an arm and a leg to put a transaction through. 2. More choices - too many choices are bad, unless you're framing a poster. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice
- noxer 6y agoThere is no need to decide you start watching the money starts streaming you stop the money stops. If you only watched a few seconds its only fractions of a cent it doesn't matter. If at all it makes people less likely to watch crap and more likely to stop if it isn't what they hoped it to be. And BTW the standard already exists https://interledger.org/rfcs/0029-stream/ https://interledger.org/rfcs/0029-stream/
- godelski 6y agoIt should also be noted that placing prices on things changes peoples decision processes dramatically. There's the famous experiment where a school tried to combat parents picking up children late (which caused teachers to stay late) by charging them a small fee. That caused the number of late parents to increase because it shifted the issue from guilt to capital. Zach Star used this example in a recent video along with others[0]. These types of decisions are extremely complicated because we're changing the entire incentive structure in a non-obvious way. This often creates "contradictory" results because we have bad priors in our model. What is "obvious" usually isn't (which is often why problems haven't been solved). [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGuwXSe6tAw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGuwXSe6tAw