13 ms·
Visa moves to allow payment settlements using cryptocurrency
- UShouldBWorking 6y agoWe. Are. Switching. Only for the top 1% does a fiat government currency work and we are in the tail end of this cycle. The US knows this and it's why they are printing the dollar into oblivion. Get you Bitcoin Cash and Monero while you still can.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Datagenerator 6y agoAre you being downvoted? Bitcoin Cash is the original, period. Longtime Bitcoiner here,transaction fees didn't exist for many years. Envisioned by the creators was money without borders nor barriers to entrance.
- UShouldBWorking 6y agoYes, I find that HN hates two things. The truth and Bitcoin.
- sschueller 6y agoVisa is desperately trying to figure out where they can fit in before they are made irrelevant. Why pay visa fees when you can handle the transaction directly? It won't be bitcoin but another crypto surely will be fast and cheap and usable as easily as a debit card.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xxel 6y agoTrue.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThe Fed recently released an update that they’re ahead of schedule with their Instant Payments implementation (2023 GA vs 2024). The reaper is coming for bloated payments businesses. Why use crypto, Visa/MC, or any traditional payment incumbent when you can move funds instantly for about a nickel per transaction? If a lending component is required, that can be done independent of payment rails. https://www.americanbanker.com/news/fed-more-bullish-on-launch-of-real-time-payments-service https://www.americanbanker.com/news/fed-more-bullish-on-laun...
- anm89 6y agoBecause you see risk in holding your assets in that ecosystem.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoIs that internal to US only?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leereeves 6y agoWhat are the fraud protection and chargeback policies on that? Those might be reasons to continue using credit cards.
- theturtletalks 6y agoTrue, but then businesses will pass the processing fee to the customer if they want chargeback protection. They could even incentivize and say: "pay directly and save 3%". For small purchases, are you really doing a chargeback anyways?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoDebit card fees are only pennies right now, basically free compared to credit cards, yet very few businesses offer a discount for debit cards. The reason is that people are willing to spend more using credit cards such that it more than offsets credit card processing fees. And I assume businesses as big and low margin as Target and Walmart and grocery stores have the expertise to figure that out.
- mamon 6y agoYou do realize that Bitcoin transaction fees are like 100x higher that those charged by Visa? Also, most cryptocurrencies have scalability problems, it won't be easy for them to replace traditional payments, because they cannot handle billions of transactions per day.
- ForHackernews 6y agoAccording to the article, Visa is looking at using "the cryptocurrency USD Coin" (whatever that is) So this has nothing to do with bitcoin (except inasmuch as any news article with the word "crypto" in the headline will trigger a bunch of FOMO buyers and drive up the price)
- exdsq 6y agoIt's a stable coin (it's pegged to the dollar) which runs on Ethereum https://www.circle.com/en/usdc https://www.circle.com/en/usdc
- doomroot 6y agoNot on lightning network
- Spivak 6y agoLightning is a competitor to Visa...
- suikadayo 6y agoThere’s hardly been growth in the value of transactions on Lightning, compared to the 20x growth on various L2 solutions on Ethereum like Loopring, zkSync, etc. Lightning’s UX is poor as well, where both parties need to be online at the same time.
- Spivak 6y agoAnd all the solutions to this are to create a supplementary payment processing network that uses Bitcoin for settlement... ya know like Visa.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Visa is desperately trying to figure out where they can fit in before they are made irrelevant Visa is agnostic to the settlement rails it runs on. Having one more option increases its leverage over its members. > Why pay visa fees when you can handle the transaction directly? You're only thinking of cash-like transactions. Add a lender to the mix, where the merchant can seamlessly accept cash the customer doesn't have, and Visa's value add becomes clearer.
- fny 6y agoDon't forget Visa is in the data mining business too.
- samfisher83 6y agoI think people like have payment protection. Visa was basically created by the banks and ultimately the credit system goes back to the banks. Let's say you buy something through eBay and pay through the Bitcoin what protection do you have?
- Spivak 6y agoAbsolutely none just like cash. This is an anti-feature to most but the raison d'etre for people who like BTC.
- Hamuko 6y ago>the raison d'etre for people who like BTC Until they lose their money in a scam.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoI buy mostly with a card, but even cash has protection. If my cash money gets stolen, i can call the police. If someone scams me, the chance is pretty big the rl scammer is going to be found and it's not unknown to get a refund of banks off it happens digitally. Crypto currency, as far as I'm aware, is really a magic trick. It's gone and no one can help you. ( Just in case someone mentions bitcoin has transparent transactions. Please lookup bitcoin mixing services first)
- sschueller 6y agoIf someone gives you a fake bill (or possibly even an ATM) and you don't notice for a while you are in the same boat. The police won't be able to help you.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoThat hasn't happened in the 33 years i exist. + Shop owners have markers to see if money is valid. Security cameras would have recorded who tried to scam the shop owner. If something would happen with an atm, I'm sure the banks will refund you. In Belgium, the law says you are only viable to a 150€ loss ( https://www.euromex.be/safety-world/wat-als-ik-het-slachtoffer-word-van-fraude-met-mijn-bankkaart https://www.euromex.be/safety-world/wat-als-ik-het-slachtoff... ) As a contrary POV, i ran an experiment with a magazine online and the most popular article was: "how to recover a bitcoin password" ( not in english though). And guess what, most of them would lose all their funds. That wouldn't be the case with a bank.
- devname 6y agoIf bitcoin replaces the middlemen of transactions, why does Square and Jack Dorsey promote them?
- ryanwhitney 6y agoThey make money when you buy/sell Bitcoin through their app. (Cash app)
- gerry_shaw 6y agoSquare is in the payment business. Credit cards are just one method. E.g., Square supports Interact in Canada for a flat fee of $0.10.
- Robotbeat 6y agoIt doesn’t. Because on-chain transactions are (or will be) too expensive and slow for most people, creating a big business opportunity for middlemen.
- gruez 6y ago>creating a big business opportunity for middlemen ...or decentralized settlement networks like LN.
- suikadayo 6y agoNot really decentralized when people have to rely on third party apps like Strike to open channels for them, or they have to open the channels themselves while both users are online. It’s a mess from a usability standpoint.
- Robotbeat 6y ago...which again provides an opportunity for middlemen.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ArtTimeInvestor 6y agoFunny that the article talks about Bitcoin jumping on the news. While the chain on which this settlement takes place is Ethereum.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoBitcoin will likely stay the dominate singular cryptocurrency for a long while, but Etherum has already surpassed it in terms of network effect, and will likely have more value held on it's blockchain than bitcoin in a matter of years. Bitcoin has shown it is uninterested in being anything but digital gold.
- pkulak 6y agoWhich is exactly what everyone who has it wants it to be. :/
- stcredzero 6y agoIn retrospect, it was pretty much designed to become that!
- arcticbull 6y agoIt was designed to be digital cash. That's the title of the whitepaper. It is very bad at that.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoI hold Bitcoin and the day that I sell the vast majority of it and move to something on the ETH chain grows closer every day.
- stcredzero 6y agoEtherium has already surpassed it in terms of network effect, and will likely have more value held on it's blockchain than bitcoin in a matter of years. Etherium is more oriented towards transactions than Bitcoin. In the longer term, the value of Blockchain will be in facilitating transactions. In this, it's 100% analogous to the Internet. The current crop of blockchain is dot.com, where we're still figuring things out. People will look back on it and think it quaint for analogous reasons. I think Harry Dent has a section in a book about this idea. An even bigger explosion of value will be created with the next wave analogous to "Web 2.0." No more multi-day dead tree transactions for settling checks, equities, real estate transactions, etc...
- electriclove 6y agoSay it with me.. Ethereum
- fareesh 6y agoHow would the gas fee work in this scenario?
- humblebee 6y agoIt looks to be for settlements which are done at the end of the day between banks, not on a per transaction basis between merchant and buyers. There is a thread on /r/CryptoCurrency that lays things out https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/mfqnfn/what_settlement_means_in_the_new_stories_about/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/mfqnfn/what...
- Dolpahimide 6y agoI'm sure VISA owns a buttload of ETH and they will just use their own system to settle everything themselves internally. Then they actually buy/sell ethereum when it fits their needs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baron816 6y agoWhat we really need is for the Fed to enable micro transactions. Make transferring money so easy and cheap that Visa et al can be disrupted. Facebook/Google would also be disrupted—people would be willing to pay $.03 to watch a video or read an article instead of handing over their data.
- dboreham 6y agoPeople paid $$$ to politicians to not have that happen.
- telotortium 6y ago> people would be willing to pay $.03 to watch a video or read an article Nope. Maybe for 1% of the price I'd be willing to do microtransactions.
- stcredzero 6y agoThis has been said before. Everyone who is invested in the advertisement model will then start to hate on the idea, for obvious reasons. In particular, media, including journalists who cover these ideas. However, the advertisement model truly sucks. It severely dilutes the interest of the actual consumer and actual fans, in favor of big companies who buy the advertisements. EDIT: As I mention below, this isn't theory. This debate happened between Penny Arcade and Scott McCloud nearly two decades ago.
- gruez 6y ago>In particular, media, including journalists who cover these ideas. Why would they care? They still get paid in the end.
- RIMR 6y agoThey sometimes get more than just payment. If a publication promises to show an ad for a specific company, before a visitor can read a specific article, that company try to help drive visitors to that article to drive more ad views. This is why (using Twitter as an example) you sometimes see news articles for seemingly unrelated content show up as promoted Tweets straight from the journalist with "Sponsored by T-Mobile" at the bottom. Chances are, clicking through to the article will also lead to a T-Mobile advertisement.
- anonymoushn 6y agoSo do I pay like $30 tx fees to buy a coffee with it?
- nyxtom 6y agoExactly, the gas prices on ETH make any transaction at all on it cost prohibitive.
- christopherwxyz 6y agoI think the hope is that Visa would process these transactions in bulk, not individually.
- exabrial 6y agoThis is precisely what the Stellar Foundation is trying to do: instant, no/low fees, no mining needed.
- howmayiannoyyou 6y agoParticularly since - per a Clubhouse call I lurked on - it appears ETH is heavily sequestered by a small number of whales, it appears to be increasingly inflationary, and if the call's participants are to be believed there are several difficult technical problems many, many months from being resolved. I lack the expertise to know how much of this is true, but I did think to myself after listening that XLM has none of these issues.
- ur-whale 6y ago> ETH is heavily sequestered by a small number of whales And Stellar isn't? Not a judgement, just a plain old question - it was my understanding that Stellar was an airdrop with large chunks to the founders, but my recollections are TBH vague.
- doomslice 6y agoThe Stellar Development Foundation holds about half of the unallocated XLM. They claim they'll use it in the following: https://www.stellar.org/foundation/mandate?locale=en https://www.stellar.org/foundation/mandate?locale=en (and they are a nonprofit so I assume they can't just sell it all).
- tpmx 6y agoThe actual press release has more information: https://usa.visa.com/about-visa/newsroom/press-releases.releaseId.17821.html https://usa.visa.com/about-visa/newsroom/press-releases.rele... It links to a blog post: https://usa.visa.com/visa-everywhere/blog/bdp/2021/03/26/digital-currency-comes-1616782388876.html https://usa.visa.com/visa-everywhere/blog/bdp/2021/03/26/dig... Insanely wordy and very non-specific, but hopefully getting it straight from the horse's mouth is less confusing than reading someone else's misunderstandings. "Visa is piloting the capability with Crypto.com, a Visa partner and one of the world’s largest crypto platforms, and plans to offer the USDC settlement capability to additional partners later this year." The way I read this: They plan to later this year allow some Visa customers (via some bank partners to Visa) to pay their credit card bills using the USDC stablecoin, presumably via crypto.com. Am I really understanding this correctly?
- firloop 6y agoNo, this wouldn't let consumers pay their bills in USDC, but rather allow banks and merchants to be paid in USDC. Settlement is the process in which an acquirer "settles" up with Visa, which happens after a transaction is authorized[0]. The acquirer sends Visa a list of transactions and monetary amounts, Visa accepts this and forwards along money for the transactions to the acquiring bank. Visa is saying that they are now sending USDC (over the blockchain? unclear.) instead of fiat currency over traditional banking rails. Later this year, Visa will expand these capabilities to more acquirers/merchants. [0]: This page explains more. https://financetrain.com/how-credit-card-transaction-processing-works/ https://financetrain.com/how-credit-card-transaction-process...
- tpmx 6y agoAh. That makes more sense! Thanks.
- arcticbull 6y agoOk, but. Why.
- tarsinge 6y ago> No, this wouldn't let consumers pay their bills in USDC, but rather allow banks and merchants to be paid in USDC. I’m not sure, from the first link of the parent: > Visa has launched a pilot that allows Crypto.com to send USDC to Visa to settle a portion of its obligations for the Crypto.com Visa card program. Crypto.com is a Visa issuer, so if they can now settle with Visa by sending USDC, it logically means Crypto.com Visa card holder will be able directly use the USDC from their account (without converting them to fiat first).
- tyingq 6y agoI wonder if Visa will enact a wallet blacklist. Edit: Well, perhaps whether that blacklist will become shared across more than Visa.
- ur-whale 6y ago> I wonder if Visa will enact a wallet blacklist. You don't have to wonder: it's a guarantee and it's not like they have a choice. They're centralized and therefore subject to political pressure.
- Datagenerator 6y agoWould lol so hard if they promote Bitcoin Cash the peer to peer electronic cash as settlement layer. The Bitcoin chain would halt because the difficulty can't adjust fast enough.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoThe BCH chain almost halted when the split first happened. They changed the difficulty adjustment algorithm to get through that period. Also currently 1 BCH = 0.00898083 BTC.
- tfang17 6y agoVisa is the Ethereum L2 people have been talking about for years.
- SavantIdiot 6y agoWhy would ANYONE do this? With the volatility of cryptocurrency, it could easily end up costing 2-3x.
- lucasmullens 6y agoStablecoins deal with that pretty well, which might be what they're using here.
- RealityVoid 6y agoThey are using USDC stablecoin for settling it. That is fixed to the value of 1 USD. There are a lot of things happening in the space. SOOO many things that it's practically impossible to keep up.
- SavantIdiot 6y agoDidn't Tether try that and end up having to devalue?
- RealityVoid 6y agoNo. Maybe? Don't know what happened all along history, but Tether still exists and it's still 1 USD. Now it's audited. I see no reason why it could not be pegged as long for every 1 usd recieved, they mint 1 stablecoin and release it to whoever bought it. Things get iffy only in case they start doing reaaal shady stuff. But now USDT is audited(from the latest info I have) and USDC has always been audited.
- blhack 6y agoTo those who continue to think that cryptocurrencies are a waste of time, or stupid, or a fad, or tulips, or whatever: What do you know that visa doesn't know? Like if you could sit down with a decision maker and convince them that this is a bad idea, what would you tell them?
- shados 6y agoThat while it may be a good idea financially for them, the resources poured into cryptocurrency mining operations are an amazing waste. It likely wouldn't convince anyone in that position, but damn is that crap a waste we don't need right now.
- suikadayo 6y agoUSDC is on Ethereum (currently PoW but will be on PoS within this year or so) and other PoS chains. Ethereum PoS will be about 99% more environmentally friendly than Bitcoin.
- mywittyname 6y agoThey might be opening the gates to more onerous reporting requirements per the IRS. People are required to pay capital gains tax on crypto gains, and if people are servicing debts with crypto, then visa will probably need to issue some sort of tax document detailing the price of the currency at time of payment. I'm sure their lawyers and accountants understand this and are fine with such a system. From an investors perspective. There is the risk of extreme fluctuation in prices on exchanges. If people are paying their bills at one rate, but Visa is getting a different, lower exchange rate, then that could potentially cost the company dearly. This is probably something they've also thought about and presumably they are scheming to make additional cash from arbitrage. One could think that cryptcurrencies are foolish, while simultaneously thinking of ways a business could make money off of crypto or their holders.
- wrs 6y agoVisa settling dollar-denominated accounts with member banks seems like it must be very much a solved problem, that furthermore doesn’t need any kind of decentralized ledger or smart contract processing to accomplish. So either that’s exactly why it’s a bad idea, or my understanding of how this works today has huge gaps. (Which wouldn’t surprise me a bit.) Can you clarify what’s in this for Visa?
- canadianfella 6y agoWhy?