5 ms·
~15% of the World's trade is dependent on it and this is taking much longer than expected. Why?
by ksec 6y ago
~15% of the World's trade is dependent on it and this is taking much longer than expected. Why?
- ksm1717 6y agoFor real. Why haven’t they just mobilized hacker news?
- albertgoeswoof 6y agoBecause it’s hard
- londons_explore 6y agoJust dig a new canal around the ship? A quarter mile diversion can't take that long to dig. The whole canal is 120 miles, so an extra quarter mile they should be able to dig in a few days I would think?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoLol no
- gizmo385 6y agoThis sounds eerily similar to "Just add the new feature, it can't take that long". Things are complicated.
- spookthesunset 6y agoI mean it is just typing... how hard can it be?
- Hamuko 6y agoSounds easier to just dig through the ship.
- pjc50 6y agoThis man doesn't infrastructure. (If you think it's that easy, pop over and ask if you can have a go on the JCB)
- londons_explore 6y agoI actually spent a few weeks of my life driving a JCB commercially...
- phkahler 6y ago"Just" widen the canal so it can continue pivoting around the most stuck end until its straight again.
- azornathogron 6y ago> The whole canal is 120 miles, so an extra quarter mile they should be able to dig in a few days I would think? Uh, what? Why would the length of the canal as a whole tell you anything about how long digging a quarter-mile section would take? If the canal as a whole was longer or shorter, would that somehow change your estimate?
- gm3dmo 6y agoJust get people who know what they are doing to sort it out.
- londons_explore 6y agoYes it would... I know the suez canal was a once-per-century type infrastructure investment for Egypt. Doing that same investment again probbaly isn't feasible. But doing 0.2% of the work again is starting to sound pretty affordable...
- pjc50 6y ago> suez canal was a once-per-century type infrastructure investment for Egypt. Once-per-century investment for France. It was, like the Eurotunnel, nominally privately funded: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Canal_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Canal_Company but with significant political cover.
- LegitShady 6y ago"Quarter mile" is a linear dimension. What is the width? If you had to estimate the volume of earth in that 'quarter mile', and then estimate the size of an excavator bucket, and the capacity of a dump truck, and the availability of all those things at any given time (even if you ship them in), you'd soon realize that just digging out that earth will take more time. On top of that, there's going to be FLOW in the canal - what will your diversion to for erosion, pressure on the locks, etc. You risk damaging the canal itself to deal with a temporary problem if you think you can just 'dig around it' in 5 days. My bet is you've never seen how long it takes to plan something with this much risk involved. This isn't software, you aren't going to Agile it away if you screw it up.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoVolume is ^3 of the linear size. To get a clear picture of how much it is do this: - launch minecraft in creative mode and make 40x40 pad of steel blocks, 1 block high. You should do it in a few minutes. - now do a 40x40x40 cube. Good luck for the rest of your day.
- ben509 6y agoYou're swapping moving a mostly hollow ship with containers for moving a far larger volume of solid earth.
- dekhn 6y agobecause it's "cheaper" to build a SPOF and then handle the exceptions when they come.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoShip is no longer on the happy path.
- panzagl 6y agoIt's stuck like a couch in a stairwell.
- dkarl 6y agoOh, dear. Time travelers really ought to be more careful.
- phkahler 6y agoYeah, they forgot their towel.
- dr_orpheus 6y agoDo you think getting David Schwimmer to come yell "Pivot!" would help?
- smiley1437 6y agoPivot!
- RantyDave 6y agoExcept it's a couch with a bulbous bow that got buried into the side of the stairwell, which just happens to be made of clay. I assume the stern is stuck, too. And all you have to remove it is a pin. So, this is going to take a while.
- fuzzy2 6y agoBecause it's, you know, stuck. If they accidentally sink it, the cleanup will be even more messy.
- gm3dmo 6y agoSuez canal is 24 meters deep. i count 9 iso containers stacked high on the deck (an iso container is 2.59m high). Smit will be making bank on this.
- RantyDave 6y agoI think it would be very, very difficult to sink. Quite aside from the (hopefully) large number of bulkheads and other such safety measures, the ship will be close to maximum draft for the canal and as such would only be able to sink a metre or two anyway. True, you'd then need to refloat it in situ, which would not be fun ... and it would probably just become more stuck rather than less. I think it's just going to take time and lots of digging.
- fuzzy2 6y agoYes, it probably wouldn’t irreparably sink or something like that. Still, specialized recovery work would take even more time. Not to mention the possibility of containers falling down. Best to take it slow and steady.
- blhack 6y agoOne of the largest ships in the world has run aground. How long did you expect it would take to salvage it?
- dcolkitt 6y agoMy question, for those who know more about this domain than me, is this a problem that enough money could fix? If the governments of the world wrote a $1 trillion blank check, would that be enough to get the ship out in the next 24 hours? Or is this a problem that money alone can't solve?
- kergonath 6y agoAt some point no amount of money is enough to overcome Physics.
- cricalix 6y agoWe're discussing a ship that is 400 metres long, 59 metres wide, and has a draft of 16 metres[0]. It's carrying somewhere over 18,000 containers, each of which could weight up to 27,000 kg[1]. It's unlikely that all of them weigh that much, but still, they can be heavy. The load has been very carefully placed on the ship to ensure maximum stability. So the heavy loads are probably deeper in the hull and the lighter loads are higher up. When ships get unloaded in port, it's unlikely that all the containers are for that port, so an intricate dance starts - offloading some containers, moving other ones to maintain the balance, and loading new ones. At all times, you have to keep the load within tolerances so that your ship doesn't go "I'm out!" and roll over. So yeah, money alone can't solve this in 24 hours. They've got to calculate the load changes when they offload containers, so that you don't accidentally cause the ship to roll over in the canal. You're not going to stop that happening with a few bits of rope tied to some concrete pillars in the ground.. [0] https://www.vesselfinder.com/vessels/EVER-GIVEN-IMO-9811000-MMSI-353136000 https://www.vesselfinder.com/vessels/EVER-GIVEN-IMO-9811000-... [1] https://www.dsv.com/en/our-solutions/modes-of-transport/sea-freight/shipping-container-dimensions/dry-container https://www.dsv.com/en/our-solutions/modes-of-transport/sea-...
- cricalix 6y agoAnd as a bit more context, the cranes that are used at ports are capable of moving 60+ tonnes[0] - physics becomes a bit of a problem when your crane is a lever.. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Container_crane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Container_crane
- Denvercoder9 6y agoNine women can't make a baby in a month. Some things just take time, regardless of how much resources you throw at it.
- Black101 6y agoSomebody just have to come up with a good idea.... IE: blow up a boat load of C4 on the side of it...
- munk-a 6y agoI'm pretty certain if you nuked the container ship you'd solve the first problem - it'd be messy and expensive but if you could explosively throw chunks out of the canal you could probably resume service. And just imagine how badass the canal would look if we glassed the banks and lined them with some LEDs! (please don't do this)
- azornathogron 6y agoI think you might inadvertently create a few new problems if you did this.
- munk-a 6y agoI was thinking the same thing - that glassed canal would probably be so scenic that you'd cause several future traffic jams from private vessels and romantic cruises charting a path through the already near-capacity canal.
- krisoft 6y agoJust in case you are not joking, what do you think blowing up C4 at the side of the ship would achieve?
- Black101 6y agoYeah joking, but if the ship could survive the blast, maybe it could move the boat or move the dirt that is keeping it still
- yuliyp 6y agoSo yes it affects a lot of trade. But it can be worked around. Ships can sail around Africa or goods can be shipped across the Pacific and across the Panama Canal or via rail across America. Obviously those are more expensive, but the goods will still be transported.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arnaudsm 6y agoExtrapolating from the 2014 extensions, building a 2nd backup canal would cost >$8B. Considering it earns $10B/year to Egypt, I don't know if this short downtime will justify the cost to them.
- kergonath 6y agoIt is costing much more than that to shipping companies and the broader industry. If that is an option, I am sure they’ll find the money. That probably would take much longer than un-sticking the ship, assuming this is possible.
- nabla9 6y ago~30% of World container traffic goes trough it. Many bulk carriers exceed Suezmax limits and can't go trough.
- vkou 6y agoBecause your expectations were far too high.
- madeofpalk 6y agoIs this taking longer than expected?
- zokier 6y agoMuch longer than expected by whom? Have you seen some scenario planning documentation by canal authorities or others for this sort of situation? Or what are you basing you claim on?