4 ms·
America should use the "we need to spend spend spend to revitalize the economy" to domesticate more industry.
by Waterluvian 6y ago
America should use the "we need to spend spend spend to revitalize the economy" to domesticate more industry.
- paxys 6y agoI think a national security argument will highlight the importance and urgency a lot better.
- r3trohack3r 6y agoI think National Security might have something to do with manufacturing of electronics moving outside the US. The war on crypto called for manufactures to either provide two versions of their product, or move manufacturing to a place they could export a single product: https://www.eff.org/pages/decrypting-puzzle-palace https://www.eff.org/pages/decrypting-puzzle-palace
- kingaillas 6y agoSo? Don't most manufacturers already have to provide multiple product versions if they sell internationally, to handle different electricity/plug differences around the world (among many other things)? Maybe there is an effect, but it isn't as if products sold worldwide come in one version that works everywhere. Corporations love excuses to differentiate (read: charge more, especially for local captive customers) for products. Big Pharma uses all sorts of US government programs to run interference for them - patents, import/export restrictions, legal buying requirements, etc - all to charge more for the US version of products they sell dirt cheap elsewhere. Whatever "National Security" effect was present causing manufacturing to move overseas was dominated by maximizing profits: wringing savings out of the supply chain and lower labor costs. The result was predictable. I see Intel's complaint about this a way to drum up or steer business their way, hobble their competitors that rely on Asian chip manufacturing, seek future government intervention to help them - or accomplish all of the above.
- rtkwe 6y agoThe electrical differences are isolated from the chip level manufacturers no processor that would have been affected by crypto export bans would be taking raw wall voltage.
- vel0city 6y agoMost of the electrical power supplies I have these days accept voltages anywhere from 100-250VAC. Its just a matter of having the right prongs on the end for the target market.
- dathinab 6y agoIMHO (ok not very humble) any ware on crypto, weather it's in the past or modern approaches to it is stupid af and I want to give a metaphorical kick to anyone pushing it. What many people which push it don't seem to realize is that such approaches undermine national and personal security and any benefits gained for it are likely outstripped by the long term drawbacks. Drawbacks like making it easier for foreign actors to enact industry espionage or find ways to influence or blackmail people. The idea of a government accessible backdoor which can't be accessed by foreign powers is just ridiculous. Especially if the access doesn't require physical access to the devices in question.
- m463 6y agoI wonder if environmental regulation makes it harder to manufacture in the US, more specifically california.
- stefan_ 6y agoThere is a lot of national security silicon in the US, it just tends to be the obscure processes for various defense gadgets..
- dd36 6y agoThey’re already doing that in the infrastructure package.
- vkou 6y agoAs a taxpayer, I'm not particularly keen in seeing my money subsidize privately owned firms. Spend-spend-spend should either be done through secured loans, or by the government receiving equity.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoSometimes the govt needs to intervene and provide resources when you want to get things done properly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_Press_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_Press_Program
- InitialLastName 6y agoYes, but some of the ROI of that intervention should be able to be captured by the US (as a representative of the people) in the form of equity or secured loans. Insisting on stimulus of private industry without equity or interest is a great way to socialize losses and privatize gains, as they say.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoAgreed. According to the article Alcoa operated them as a contractor starting in 1956 but but later bought it outright from the govt in 1982.
- lumost 6y agoa great way to do this is to create a joint venture which the government owns but the private company operates/develops. The government can later sell the stake to a private party to balance out the books.
- vkou 6y agoGreat, and it can do that in exchange for equity.
- imtringued 6y agoI never understood the existence of bailout programs without equity. If the banks, car and semiconductor companies mess up and you keep them alive then you deserve to have a say in their business and owning their shares is the easiest way to achieve that control.
- Zenst 6y ago> "we need to spend spend spend to revitalize the economy" Yeah, I'm showing my age but I'm reminded of a comparative ethos regarding developers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vhh_GeBPOhs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vhh_GeBPOhs
- FpUser 6y agoDid not see this one for a long time. What a lucky guy, for a few seconds I thought it would end up in him having a stroke.
- tootie 6y agoImport substitution is usually a loser policy for developing nations. Also subsidies can frequently run afoul of trade agreements because they're basically the same as a tariff in terms of disadvantaging exporters. National security is not really a valid concern but could maybe be used to justify divestment from China. But that just means diversification of import partners. We could be building fabs in Mexico like we do with the auto industry. Or, as he's actually suggesting, europe.
- Guthur 6y agoRather than aimlessly spending public money it might be better to encourage better corporation across the various companies. I've been reading quite a bit of Dr Deming's thoughts recently and he had the view point that there should be corporation through out the supply chain, not just trying to squeeze every last penny. He felt it would be better for market and society as a whole.
- kleton 6y agoOld-fashioned tariffs used to be one way to do that.
- supernova87a 6y agoWhat is the point of "spend spend spend" without a strategy and top-down direction to it? All we seem to care about in the US is "jobs". Generic jobs. Working class low wage jobs. Whatever jobs gets the public off a politician's back. Not a lot of focus on whether those are useful jobs in long run, or strategically important jobs. Or we seem to end up after "spend spend spend" with some new financial derivative products, people employed to buy/sell them to each other (paid handsomely), and people who are left on the sidelines who didn't get to participate mostly. At least other countries (I'm looking at Asia), less free and dictatorial they may be, decide what industries to make a strategic national priority and go after it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]