27 ms·
>how could regulators and authorities let this happen because they have been asleep at the wheel for almost two decades now, letting tech companies privatize a
by Barrin92 6y ago
>how could regulators and authorities let this happen
because they have been asleep at the wheel for almost two decades now, letting tech companies privatize and eat away at the open nature of the internet, so now we have to live in tech giant fiefdoms where they can determine the very form and content of everything displayed on the web because they're the ones who control every access point and standard.
- georgeecollins 6y agoBut also a few times on this site in the past few years when someone complained about AMP, technical people on HN would also say that Google was doing the right thing to make mobile pages more responsive. Google was saying they were trying to solve a real problem, and it isn't easy (for me at least) to have known their true goals. Now if you read the the Texas anti trust suit -- and I recommend it to anyone who is interested-- it seems pretty clear that their motive for AMP was to improve their ad revenue.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> their motive for AMP was to improve their ad revenue It can be both. AMP legitimately sped up a lot of crappy news sites. That put pressure on non-AMP sites to get their game together. It was probably a net positive at first. But then Google abused their position.
- ethbr0 6y ago> But then Google abused their position Absolute market dominance corrupts absolutely. Even, and in spite of, efforts to the contrary from within the company.
- Angostura 6y agoAll they needed to do, in my opinion was to let it be known that sites that were optimised for mobile accessibility and fast loading would prioritised in mobile search result placement, above slow, inaccessible sites.
- enos_feedler 6y agoAll they needed to do was boil the ocean.
- saagarjha 6y agoClearly they could since they somehow got every site on AMP…
- enos_feedler 6y agoThats the point im making. It took leveraging search to offer premium real estate for AMP pages to force adoption. It was a compelling value prop for top publishers. Enough to boil the ocean. However, simply asking the ecosystem to build faster pages.. isn’t going to work.
- Grimm1 6y agoI am a tech person and I have only maintained AMP is a blight. Anyone of us, with even a smidge of business sense could see what they were doing/going to do for quite some time. The people who argued for its benefits very much lacked perspective (or didn't care) outside of the immediate technical effects of speeding up mobile sites. People in tech are not particularly homogeneous in their opinions on a lot of these things and you probably saw a small slice of the various opinions.
- epistasis 6y agoYeah, I saw those, and I didn't recognize any of the people, but their arguments never made sense to me, and it ended up really damaging my opinion of Google even more. What other bad things has Google done, that other people have defended, that I silently accepted without thinking it all the way through?
- deft 6y agoSome of those technical people singing praises of AMP literally worked on it, helped it ruin the web and once finished left and renounced it: https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2020/12/i-have-resigned-from-the-google-amp-advisory-committee/ https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2020/12/i-have-resigned-from-the-go...
- noja 6y ago> because they have been asleep at the wheel for almost two decades now Lobbying.
- toxik 6y agoIt’s simply very difficult to regulate the internet, laws are an extremely blunt tool and while I agree that more could have been done, I’m also convinced that regulation would have stifled innovation. The AMP mess is not the death knell of the open internet, perhaps the sick idea of a rotting company
- treis 6y agoFor as much as I hate Amp it's way better than what came before it. Especially for ad heavy sites that typically rank high in Google searches for random stuff. The only time for me it's not an improvement is for reddit where it is a huge annoyance.
- Analemma_ 6y agoAnd who, pray tell, serves all those annoying ads and makes those ad-heavy sites rank high in searches, thus controlling the nudges that push people onto AMP? Are you seeing the problem yet?
- treis 6y agoUsually Google ads aren't that bad. It's the 3rd rate ad networks and websites that have the annoying dark patterns and crappy performance.
- pembrook 6y agoGoogle could have simply made page weight a more important factor in the ranking algorithm if that was their goal. The minute these publishers weren't getting as much search/news traffic anymore, they would have capitulated, making their sites run faster immediately, the same way they quickly capitulated to AMP. As proven by AMP, when Google says jump, the entire interest responds by saying "How high?" Can anybody give me a single non-nefarious reason for why AMP was necessary instead of simply enforcing page weight/loading-speed factors via the algorithm?
- treis 6y agoGood in theory but liable to be endlessly gamed. Using something like Amp is easy to implement even if it's not ideal.
- esteth 6y agoAMP allows tech people at non-tech companies to push back against all the "just one tiny little thing it won't effect load speed much" requests. Your marketing department wants another tracking script? no can do. Your exec wants a javascript "click the monkey" promo? not on the AMP site. The UX folks want parallax webGL spinning logos? Sorry AMP doesn't allow it. It puts people who were previously not in a position where they could push back against decisions which effect load speed in a position where they can push back.
- dna_polymerase 6y ago> letting tech companies privatize and eat away at the open nature of the internet, so now we have to live in tech giant fiefdoms where they can determine the very form and content of everything displayed on the web because they're the ones who control every access point and standard. Wooow slow down buddy. Nothing like that is hapening. I can still hook up my computer to the internet and start serving websites right away. Google can't do anything about that. Neither can Facebook, or any GAFAM. However Google did change your behavior is entirely on you. You can live without them just fine. Until that is changed I can't see any need for regulation.
- ethbr0 6y ago"Google just blocked my site as deceptive" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26326528 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26326528
- abraae 6y agoThe site in that article was set up to allow random malware to be uploaded and effectively hosted. So not a good example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shard 6y agoYour answer is technically correct (I know, I know, it's the best kind of correct...) but the typical case is that without using the tech giants to propagate your site (search engines, social media, instant messenger services), your site is effectively banished to the dark recesses of the internet, where only your friends and the people who mistype an URL will visit.
- eclipxe 6y agoI mean, that is pretty much the open nature of the internet. Everything was banished to the dark recesses of the internet and just your friends and family, until we had Yahoo, Altavista, Excite, Lycos, and then Google...An open internet doesn't mean everyone has equal visibility and promotion.
- Lammy 6y agoI’m curious why you assume it’s accident or inaction. If I wanted to surveil Internet traffic with all five of my eyes, what better way would there be then rehosting all the content so people had to connect directly to me?
- milanandreew 6y agoI think I prefer tech giant fiefdoms to a web where governments are the ones who control every access point and standard.