6 ms·
There is an incredibly important part of this that I feel everyone is missing. The grass eaten by the cows would produce exactly as much methane if it was just
by gambiting 6y ago
There is an incredibly important part of this that I feel everyone is missing.
The grass eaten by the cows would produce exactly as much methane if it was just left to rot. It's not as if cows somehow produce methane out of grass that would otherwise just....turn into dust?
None of those studies take this into account, they all just measure what comes into a cow and what comes out, but no one takes into account the amount of methane produced from the same feed even without cows involved.
https://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks/mar-2-2019-the-goodness-paradox-secrets-in-poop-converting-carbon-to-coal-and-more-1.5037008/do-cows-produce-more-methane-than-rotting-grass-1.5037019 https://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks/mar-2-2019-the-goodness-para...
- jstimpfle 6y agoIf there is no difference there (I don't know anything about this), doesn't agriculture at least lead to higher rate / volume of grass growth?
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoOnly grass decomposed in an anaerobic environment would produce methane. Grass decomposed aerobically would produce CO2 instead.
- gambiting 6y agoBut methane decomposes into CO2 on a relatively short timescale(12 years?) so surely....it's a wash?
- ufo 6y agoThose couple of years where the carbon is in the form of methane instead of CO2 have a big impact because methane is a much stronger greenhouse gas.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoNot a wash. Methane has 85x the impact per unit as co2 which has a half life of 27 years.
- augustocallejas 6y agoWouldn’t they make less grass then if it wasn’t used to feed cows as much?
- PZ81JUXJE7uJ 6y agoThe problem is, most weed is produced exclusively for cows, so your argument does not work.
- BlackCherry 6y agoBut the cows eat the grass a lot faster than it would be rotting right? So wouldn't the speed of the methane entering the atmosphere be faster?
- gruez 6y ago>But the cows eat the grass a lot faster than it would be rotting right? Not really? Otherwise grass fields would piled up with grass several feet high.
- InitialLastName 6y agoWould there be perhaps less feed grown if cows were supplemented with other feed? If 20% less of the cows' calories come from methane-producing sources, 20% less land/duty cycle is needed for cattle grazing/growing feed, so other things can be grown or don't get cropped as quickly.
- smcl 6y agoI've got a question that may be stupid. So if you cut the same amount of grass a cow would eat every day and let it rot, then over the course of (say) a year both would release the same amount of methane overall. Do we know if this is the same as if we did nothing to that grass - just let it grow and sit there, without repeatedly cutting it back? Because to me this seems to be what you'd want to compare against.
- stevespang 6y agoNot only that - - - but the effect of the red seaweed wears off over time as gut microbiota adjust to the methane depressant . . . .
- m000 6y ago> None of those studies take this into account, they all just measure what comes into a cow and what comes out, but no one takes into account the amount of methane produced from the same feed even without cows involved. Nobody's missing anything. That feed wouldn't have been planted in the first place if it weren't for feeding the cows. And that would translate to less deforestation [1]. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-53438680 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-53438680
- tengbretson 6y agoThen just buy American beef, which is produced without any deforestation.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoIt's not that simple. Not all American beef is raised on native grasses.
- lazide 6y agoWhy is native or not native important from a carbon balance perspective? Alfalfa still pulls carbon from the air when it grows.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoWhat I should say is, not all American beef is fed from naturally occurring pasture land. In fact, a good deal of it is not.
- lazide 6y agoAt this point, nearly all agricultural land was converted a century ago. The trend now is more towards decreasing total agricultural acreage if anything? No one in America has slash and burned a forest to feed cattle for a very long time.
- 6y ago
- matteuan 6y agoInteresting, but still I don't think your comment is very relevant to this. Without cows we could have a forest instead of grass, instead of leaving it to rot. So if the number of cows remains constant you benefit from reducing methane emissions.
- gambiting 6y agoBut that's an issue with where we feed the cows, isn't it? For instance - cows are raised on many parts of moorlands in the UK, where they eat only the grass growing there. But if you removed the cows, the moors would be exactly as they are now - they cannot support forests or any other kind of vegetation, because they are basically solid rock with an inch of soil on top. I understand that on the "intensive farming" lots where cows are fed corn/hay specifically grown for them that doesn't really apply - but farmers do absolutely raise cows in such places where it makes no difference - even in the absence of cows or sheep you aren't going to have a forest there. I understand this isn't potentially isn't helpful, but the problem is very nuanced - some cows are fed in such a way that their methane emissions are a net positive. But I'm also sure there are some where the emissions aren't positive at all, yet it's all bundled into the same "meat causes climate destruction" bandwagon.
- telchar 6y agoI think you're underselling moorlands here. Trees can be planted on moors, and other even more carbon-sinking activity too: "It’s worth remembering that the peatlands of the UK store more carbon than the woodlands of the UK, France and Germany combined!" [0] [0] https://www.moorsforthefuture.org.uk/our-purpose/habitats-for-wildlife/a-mosaic-of-moorland-habitats https://www.moorsforthefuture.org.uk/our-purpose/habitats-fo...
- goda90 6y agoI'd like to see an actual study on this. Yeah decomposing grass releases methane, but in the wild does it release as much methane as it would being digested by a cow? Lets say the carbon in the grass goes into the cow and X% goes through the cow's metabolism and is exhaled as CO2 or becomes part of the cow itself. Y% becomes a part of the cow's manure. Z% is released as methane into the air. The carbon of grass decomposing on the ground will turn some parts as methane into the air, but also some parts into the food chain of smaller creatures, some parts as CO2 into the air, and some parts into the soil itself. Cows and decomposing grass releasing the same amount of methane seems unlikely to me. That's not to say I think we should eliminate cattle. Well managed grazing actually does amazing things for the health of soil, and can even fight desertification.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- helen___keller 6y agoI'm not sure how much this point matters, because the alternative isn't a field of rotting grass. If the land is undeveloped, the alternative is likely some kind of forest. If the land is developed, the alternative is probably cropland. Also to be clear, we're not just talking grass, there's also a massive amount of industrially farmed grains to fatten the them up, which wouldn't have been industrially farmed if it wasn't demanded for feeding cattle. So there's no real equivalence here.
- eigenket 6y agoThis point relies on the assumption that the cattle are out eating grass (or other plants) which would naturally be growing and rotting without human intervention. This is kinda not true. Grazing systems supply about 9 percent of the world's production of beef [1]. 80% of the global soybean crop is used to feed livestock [2]. A lot of these soybeans are grown on land that used to be rainforest. Your comparison shouldn't be cow vs grassland - it should be rainforest vs (cow + soybean + transport + processing). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cattle_feeding#Types_of_cattle_feeds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cattle_feeding#Types_of_cattle... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soybean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soybean
- tengbretson 6y agoSurely its clear that if the soybeans aren't growing in the field that something else that grows, dies and decomposes would be.
- eigenket 6y agoYeah, and we even have a word for the "something else" that you're describing - its a rainforest.
- mattnewton 6y agoSomething like a forest with large trees that lock up carbon for many years, and a lack of commercial fertilizer (which uses natural gas).
- tw04 6y agoI don't think they're missing that at all. The cattle in question are eating feed (mainly corn) not grass. Furthermore the grass in question likely wouldn't "decompose" like what I believe that's describing. It probably depends on where you're physically located, but in the north - grass grows for the duration of the season, until it eventually dries out in the fall to go dormant over the winter. I guess I haven't personally tracked that process but I would be very surprised if it's releasing methane in the same way that freshly cut grass left to decompose (via bacteria) would.
- jessermeyer 6y agoWhy is this incredibly important? Is there some huge proportion of unused, rotting feed in the world?
- colechristensen 6y agoHonestly, I don’t trust the source. What an animal science professor says off the cuff in an interview is something that should be verified with real data. The question relies on how much carbon ends up in CO2, CH4, and fixed in the soil between use of what would become cattle feed. Carbon is conserved without a doubt, but how much ends up as gas and which gas is important. Carbon dioxide doesn’t matter because every bit which ends up in the air had to be taken from the air a short time before to build plant matter. Methane matters because it is a much more potent greenhouse gas and how much gets as methane instead of carbon dioxide makes a difference.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xphilter 6y agoThat simply can’t be true in the wild. If that much carbon was released from plants in the wild, we’d never have coal or oil, right? Composting the grass might be the same as cows, but that process doesn’t happen everywhere there’s grass. In the wild, the grass would be trampled and new grass would sprout up to cover it, layers of soil would be generated. But honestly I’m just guessing, but your claim seems so far off the mark.
- jhayward 6y agoCoal and oil come from carbon captured during the Carboniferous period, before the evolution of species of bacteria and fungi that could digest the lignin in plants. Coal and oil formation is not being fed by plant life today. The carbon in plants is recycled rather quickly in to the ecosphere.
- xphilter 6y agoFair. So then I would augment my comment to focus just on soil production in the wild. Not all of the plant debris is being composted. It gets buried too.
- PeterisP 6y agoIMHO any plant debris that gets buried in the soil is - in the long term - also composted, only its breakdown is slower.
- unchocked 6y agoI’m really glad you asked that! The reason we have coal and oil today is that earlier in Earth’s history microorganisms lacked the enzyme to metabolize cellulose (the most abundant bioorganic material). So until then, it was buried and accumulated as fossil fuels. Today’s ecosystem can metabolize cellulose, so no more fossil fuel production. Quite literally an unsustainable fuel!
- xphilter 6y ago