27 ms·
They were balancing it against what they saw in Italy: allowing the virus to get out of hand and overwhelm the hospital system and your death rate from covid ju
by monocasa 6y ago
They were balancing it against what they saw in Italy: allowing the virus to get out of hand and overwhelm the hospital system and your death rate from covid jumps into the double digits. Kids would be pretty depressed being surrounded by a 8 digit body count in the US too.
- donovanian 6y ago> Kids would be pretty depressed being surrounded by a 8 digit body count in the US too. Let’s make sure they’re depressed when their brains are irreversibly stunted from missing the crucial social interactions necessary for development. Also, let’s pile on the misery with a generation of kids with stunted literacy. Good luck teaching reading with a freaking mask on. It’s indefensible.
- sillyconesally 6y agoThe technocratic left hates you and your children. It's that simple. This website shadow bans comments critical of lockdown. The technocrats want to replace you with foreign workers that they can exploit and they want your kids poor and desperately stuck working in the gig economy.
- nradov 6y agoDo you have any proof that that would have increased depression rates in children relative to what we see today? And an 8 digit body count would be impossible in the US for a disease with a >99% survival rate. So quit the hyperbole.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- monocasa 6y agoWhat proof would you believe without empirically letting the death rate get into the double digits to begin with?
- stickfigure 6y agoAt this point we have enough data. The CDC gives an approximate IFR of 0.7% in the US. That would translate to low 7 digits. Also, it's very heavily weighted to the 70+ population. Strictly speaking from a kid's perspective, it would mostly be the experience of losing a grandparent early. It would be sad (as death almost always is) but probably not life-changing.
- monocasa 6y ago> At this point we have enough data. The CDC gives an approximate IFR of 0.7% in the US. That would translate to low 7 digits. Also, it's very heavily weighted to the 70+ population. ..with lockdowns in effect enough to keep hospitalization rates below capacity. > Strictly speaking from a kid's perspective, it would mostly be the experience of losing a grandparent early. It would be sad (as death almost always is) but probably not life-changing. And teachers, and looking at how the breakdown of Italian hospitals meant a huge spike in deaths in the 40+ crowd that would have been just fine if they instead had capacity, a ton of dead parents, aunts and uncles to deal with too.
- umanwizard 6y ago> ..with lockdowns in effect enough to keep hospitalization rates below capacity. “Want to buy this vampire repelling rock?”
- heavyset_go 6y agoThere's about a 3% death rate[1] when hospitals aren't flooded with sick people, and the death rate hits double digits when the healthcare system is DDOS'd by sick patients, as we've seen in Italy. The hospitalization rate is about 10%. If everyone in the US got COVID, and 1% of them died, that would be 3.3 million people dead and over 30 million hospitalized. If the death rate is 3%, 9.85 million would die. I don't think there are 30 million hospital beds in the US, so that figure could reach over 10 million, which is 8 digits. However, while you're busy focusing on digits, you're missing the overall point. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
- usaar333 6y ago3% CFR, not IFR. Even Spain hit only a 1.2% IFR early in the pandemic (https://covid19-projections.com/about/#assumptions https://covid19-projections.com/about/#assumptions) The worst-case realistic number of deaths for the US is around 1.2 million. With hospital collapses, maybe double that. 10 million is not possible.
- olliej 6y agoI'm fairly certain that the "only" 6 digit death rate we've currently had has had a negative impact on the families and friends of the affected. If you have been left untouched by it, then good for you, but you shouldn't be assuming that that applies to everyone. The mortality rate in the US is 1.8%. That is 542k dead out of 29.8 million cases. That's nearly 30 million cases with all the lockdowns, mask rules, etc. Even with that minor amount of 9% infected, LA hospitals ran out of capacity, morgues overflowed, etc. Try to imagine if we didn't try to limit the spread - by among other things closing schools. NZs recent outbreak started from a couple of kids in a school of only 13-1500 students, and with lockdowns that dwarf anything the US did they only just managed to control it, getting to something like 100 positive cases because they didn't want to lock down completely.
- nradov 6y agoYour numbers are incorrect. The case numbers are meaningless because there have been so many infections that were never officially counted as cases. Antibody seroprevalence studies have shown that the true number of cases is 2 or 3 times higher. Schools in Florida have been open for months and they aren't overwhelmed.
- wisty 6y agoCovid barely spreads through children. It spreads through travel and large gathering of adults.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- monocasa 6y agoThere's pretty much no evidence for that. Kids are asymptomatic and the virus is so out of control that it's difficult to track down the graph of infections from kids is all. Additionally teachers and school staff tilt pretty heavily to high risk groups. Watching so many of the adults die in their life would absolutely give kids depression too.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- oceanplexian 6y agoMaybe it's a pet peeve of mine but the onus is not on public health institutions to prove or disprove a negative. Saying "There's not evidence of the virus _not_ spreading in Cohort X" is an almost impossible position. If you have evidence to show it's spreading, then present it, and make public policy decisions based on said evidence. If you don't have evidence, then you should not be making policy.
- monocasa 6y agoHere's direct evidence: school closures are one of the most effective government interventions. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/eabd9338 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6531/eabd9338 What I have an issue with is people stating crazy stuff like "covid barely spreads through children" even though they have no real data on it.
- oceanplexian 6y agoIf you read between the lines the study makes quite a few points consistent with my argument: > Primary schools may be generally less affected than secondary schools (20, 25–28), perhaps partly because children under the age of 12 are less susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 (29). The study also goes on to state, in a profound bit of self-awareness: > Our approach cannot distinguish direct effects on transmission in schools and universities from indirect effects, such as the general population behaving more cautiously after school closures signaled the gravity of the pandemic. Additionally, because school and university closures were implemented on the same day or in close succession in most of the countries we studied, our approach cannot distinguish their individual effects And: > (iii) Our results cannot be used without qualification to predict the effect of lifting NPIs. For example, closing schools and universities in conjunction seems to have greatly reduced transmission, but this does not mean that reopening them will necessarily cause infections to soar. Like stated above, this doesn't prove or disprove a negative. If someone comes out with a direct, causative relationship between re-opening schools and increased infections, and that is reproducible, sure, make policy decisions based on that information. But otherwise, if we are blindly making decisions that can affect the health and development of children, we better have data to back up those decisions.
- reaperducer 6y agoKids would be pretty depressed being surrounded by a 8 digit body count in the US too. Kudos for expressing an unpopular opinion. I'll express another one: I think the whole thing about "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion, largely thanks to pseudo-news web sites trying to grab clicks on the internet. The school district where I live put out a press release lamenting an 18% increase in student suicide in 2020. Reading to the end, you find out that the actual numeric increase was something like 2. Two dead kids isn't good in any way. But when the number of suicides reaches a meaningful fraction of the number of COVID deaths, then I'll take it seriously. Having to stay home for a year is nothing — absolutely nothing — compared with what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals (world wars, and the like).
- testesttest 6y ago> compared with what children had to deal with during previous social upheavals (world wars, and the like). You could say that for all of covid. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_and_anthropogenic_disasters_by_death_toll https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_and_anthropogen...
- XorNot 6y agoIt's also worth pointing out that at sample sizes like that (2), you don't have a sample. You have an anomaly at best.
- monocasa 6y agoYou have a scale for comparing absolute rates, which is the gist of what the parent is talking about, I think.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> I'll express another one: I think the whole thing about "ZOMG! Suicide rates through the roof!!!elevelty!1!" is blown out of proportion, largely thanks to pseudo-news web sites trying to grab clicks on the internet. Certain news sites in my state spent 2020 lamenting about how the lockdown is causing overdose deaths to skyrocket. Well, 2021 rolls around and the 2020 overdose death statistics were calculated, and there were about a dozen more overdose deaths in 2020 than in 2019, a change that is statistically insignificant when comparing it to the tens of thousands of overdoses that occurred in the state each year in 2019 and 2020, or to the tens of thousands of people who died from COVID there in 2020. For whatever reason, the types of people who shared such news in 2020 were not the kind of people who gave two shits about addiction and its effects on others before the pandemic. I say this as a person who has struggled with addiction in the past and has lost numerous people I care about to it. It seems to me that the overdose stats were merely a tool to be used to complain about policy that they disliked.
- swayvil 6y agoYet Florida is perfectly ok. Obviously this "8 digit body count" concept is a load of that which makes the grass grow green.
- monocasa 6y agoI would use many phrases to describe Florida's covid response, but "perfectly ok" would not be one of them.
- nradov 6y agoA better description of Florida would be "perfectly average". In deaths per capita they are right in the middle of US states. Obviously Florida could have done better, but many other states have done far worse. https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/
- monocasa 6y agoThe ones above Florida are either the dense area of the NY extended metro that got hit early and had trouble getting it back under control, or states ideologically aligned with Florida. Just because they're in the middle doesn't make it a good response.
- whatthesmack 6y agoIt also doesn't necessarily make it a bad response. But when you factor in more than simply one detail (COVID vs COVID+economy+mental health), it starts to look like a good response.
- dehrmann 6y agoThe big, open question is why Florida and California have seen such similar case rates despite radically different approaches.
- 6y ago
- sokoloff 6y agoIt’s not even clear that the hospitalization rate for COVID cases is over 10%, let alone the case-fatality-rate. In fact, it’s pretty clear that it’s not.
- monocasa 6y agoTell that to Italy. Their death rate was in the double digits when hospital capacity was overrun.
- jansan 6y agoTheir hospitals are overrun every second winter, dude. They had as much a medical system problem as they had a COVID-19 problem. Check this article from 2018. https://time.com/5107984/hospitals-handling-burden-flu-patients/ https://time.com/5107984/hospitals-handling-burden-flu-patie...
- monocasa 6y agoThat doesn't affect my point. They're a case study not in the sense of "look how easy it is for hospitals to be overrun", but instead "look what an absolute tragedy it is when hospital are overrun". Of course the country predisposed to hospital overruns hit that issue first.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Their hospitals are overrun every second winter, dude No, they aren't. Your article is talking about the 2017-2018 flu season, which was an anomaly when it came to hospitalizations and deaths. Both hospitalizations and deaths that season were about double what they normally are[1]. About 61k people died in the US during that flu season, where about 20k-35k normally die. There were 810k hospitalizations, while hospitalizations usually fluctuate between 250k-500k. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/past-seasons.html https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/past-seasons.html
- tinus_hn 6y agoWhen compared to people tested positive, when they only had resources to test the people they were pretty sure were infected. Their death rate in April was the same as the peak of the second wave in December.
- umanwizard 6y agoThe death rate from Covid is not double digits in Italy or any other country. Where are your numbers coming from?
- monocasa 6y agoThe death rate in Italy was in the double digits during the period of their hospitals being overrun last spring. Then they initiated heavy lockdowns, and got their death rate back under control.
- umanwizard 6y agoLink sources. Prediction: you are quoting the meaningless CFR number rather than reliable estimates of IFR.
- monocasa 6y agoEarly on, like in March of last year when Italy hit their double digit death rate, CFR was very meaningful. It's only when the breakdown was so bad that they couldn't meaningfully trace anymore that CFR stopped mattering.
- makomk 6y agoItaly stopped having meaningful Covid tracing well before their first detected Covid-related death in February last year. They'd reported zero cases in the weeks leading up to it and there are a whole bunch of reasons to suspect that was a massive, massive underestimate. (I think they also imposed measures like school closures pretty soon after this. It didn't seem to help much.)
- TheButlerian 6y agoFrom where did you get the 8 digits you clown?
- enw 6y agoWhy can’t we optimize the care process of COVID patients so that they don’t become a bottleneck? Surely with so many similar cases the processes could be streamlined?
- oblio 6y agoHow? Should we ask TSMC for 3nm MDs?
- pqs 6y agoWriting from Spain. Schools are open since September, with measures such as masks, isolated groups that don't mix during recreation time, etc. It has been shown that schools are not a major vector of propagation and that kids can safely go to school. Here what has an impact in the propagation of the virus is opening bars and restaurants and allowing people to move between counties (comarca) or regions.