16 ms·
CFTC Orders Coinbase Inc. To Pay $6.5M Penalty
- seibelj 6y agoYou heard it here - with this enforcement action, bitcoin is now safe.
- NaturalPhallacy 6y agoNo currency is safe if you mistake it for an investment.
- londons_explore 6y agoAll these actions and far more are widely done by less scrupulous bitcoin exchanges. Seems a bit unfair on coinbase when pretty much everyone else is doing this stuff deliberately, whereas they are being punished for a seemingly accidental case of the same.
- TylerE 6y ago"According to the order, between January 2015 and September 2018, Coinbase recklessly delivered false, misleading, or inaccurate reports concerning transactions in digital assets, including Bitcoin, on the GDAX electronic trading platform it operated. During this period, Coinbase operated two automated trading programs, Hedger and Replicator, which generated orders that at times matched with one another. The GDAX Trading Rules specifically disclosed that Coinbase was trading on GDAX, but failed to disclose that Coinbase was operating more than one trading program and trading through multiple accounts. In addition, the order finds that while Hedger and Replicator had independent purposes, in practice the programs matched orders with one another in certain trading pairs, resulting in trades between accounts owned by Coinbase." Doesn't sound very accidental.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe worst part is at the bottom: > The order also finds that over a six-week period—August through September 2016—a former Coinbase employee used a manipulative or deceptive device by intentionally placing buy and sell orders in the Litecoin/Bitcoin trading pair on GDAX that matched each other as wash trades. This created the misleading appearance of liquidity and trading interest in Litecoin. We always knew that wash trading activity was rampant in the cryptocurrency space, but I didn't actually expect Coinbase employees to be doing it within Coinbase. If employees of the most regulated exchange in the world were wash trading with some regularity, makes you wonder how bad it must be at some of the more Wild West exchanges.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- NaturalPhallacy 6y ago(Devil's advocate disclaimer) I worked in High Frequency Trading for a TBTF bank alongside the former Automated Trading Desk employees and spoke with their quants a few times. And I literally worked on a Dark Pool Crossing Engine myself at the the time, and here's my take: Having multiple algorithms running at the same time was...unremarkable. And since they're all running different algorithms and all trying to game the market, it wouldn't surprise me if they ended up trading with each other by accident, especially if they had multiple accounts to trade with. What's honestly more surprising is that they only had two running at once. And further, if they both traded through a dark pool, then there's no way they could know they were trading with each other, because that's one of the intended features of a dark pool. So accidental seem plausible, but then again so does malice. Now if it wasn't through a dark pool, and the algos could see each other's accounts, then naughty naughty, and they deserved every cent of the fine.
- Galanwe 6y agoSorry but I have to disagree strongly here. Having two separate algos directly and actively trading in the wild is highly unusual. There are obvious reasons for which you don't want your algos to trade one against the other on the market. First, it's very dangerous as you can end up in the situation described here where you essentially self make the market. But more directly for simple execution costs/fees reasons. I don't know of any single player that has concurrent algos where there is not a "netting" layer between algos and the market, so that concurrent trades are matched internally before reaching the market.
- NaturalPhallacy 6y ago>Having two separate algos directly and actively trading in the wild is highly unusual. No it's not. ATD had like 50. >There are obvious reasons for which you don't want your algos to trade one against the other on the market. Who said they're trading against each other? Just look at GME. Swapping shares back and forth makes trading volume go up. Every imbalance is gameable, and they have armies of people whose job is to find every gameable imbalance and make money off of it. >First, it's very dangerous as you can end up in the situation described here where you essentially self make the market. As we've seen when traders have bankrupted themselves. >I don't know of any single player that has concurrent algos where there is not a "netting" layer between algos and the market, so that concurrent trades are matched internally before reaching the market. Well I know of one that had 15+, and coinbase just got busted with two so...
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Seems a bit unfair on coinbase when pretty much everyone else is doing this stuff deliberately "Everyone else is doing it" was never a valid excuse. This statement suggests that at least one Coinbase employee was acting very deliberately. No accidents here. Why would an exchange need to trade from multiple accounts with multiple uncoordinated bots in the first place?
- dannyw 6y agoBecause literally every prop trading firm in the world runs more than one algorithm??? The same way you have more than one unit test file?
- 3np 6y agoMost of those unscrupulous exchanges are not in the US. I’m personally a bit surprised there hasn’t been more heat on Poloniex, though.
- peteretep 6y ago> Seems a bit unfair on coinbase Nah, the opposite. It’s a small financial slap on the wrist, and in exchange they get to be absolved of their past sins and be declared squeaky clean. New competitors will need to be perfect from the get-go.
- TylerE 6y agoHardly. This only covers activity through summer of 2018.
- peteretep 6y agoThis fine does, but presumably this has come about as part of a wider audit
- ac29 6y agoThe point is law enforcement and regulatory agencies move really, really slowly - they generally like to take time building strong cases, even when misconduct is fairly evident. This activity dates back 3-5 years, and is only being publicly announced now. What's happened since then?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoThis is a mosquito bite. They are a 50+ billion dollar company. When a company this big breaks the law it would be crazy to not enforce it on them.
- tehlike 6y agoIf you know who that employee is, and how litecoin got to get listed on coinbase, the story will make more sense to you. Coinbase is playing by the rules, that's why they are not shut down but got a small fine. All other exchanges will probably shut down and their operators might even get jail time.
- freeAgent 6y agoIt’s easy to imagine that this anonymous employee may be Charlie Lee, creator of Litecoin.
- tehlike 6y agoShhh.
- wmf 6y agoThe timeline for people who aren't familiar with this story: Oct 2011: Charlie Lee created Litecoin Jul 2013: Charlie Lee went to work for Coinbase Aug 2016: GDAX (now known as Coinbase Pro) added support for Litecoin Aug-Sep 2016: An unnamed Coinbase employee manipulated Litecoin trading volume on GDAX May 2017: Coinbase retail added support for Litecoin, which doubled in price immediately Jun 2017: Charlie Lee left Coinbase (presumably having accomplished his goal of getting Litecoin listed) Dec 2017: Charlie Lee sold all his Litecoin near the all-time high
- hntrader 6y agoNo, everyone else isn't doing it. Haven't seen evidence of the big ones doing it - Bitmex, Binance, etc. FTX has good analysis on this.
- tehlike 6y agoNever believe an analysis in crypto unless you are knowledgeable enough to replicate it yourself.
- hntrader 6y agoI am, and it's easy to check yourself. Queue a single lot in the queue and observe that your fill is exactly when you expect. If they were generating fake trades it would be obvious since there would be trades that don't lead to you getting filled when you should be getting filled. If instead they were actually wash trading on the real market (not just generating fake trades, which is the most common approach), that would be much harder to detect with any kind of forensic analysis of the data, you'd need some whistle-blower. However, doing this would be impossible in a liquid asset like BTCUSD or LTCUSD.
- koolba 6y ago> The order also finds that over a six-week period—August through September 2016—a former Coinbase employee used a manipulative or deceptive device by intentionally placing buy and sell orders in the Litecoin/Bitcoin trading pair on GDAX that matched each other as wash trades. This created the misleading appearance of liquidity and trading interest in Litecoin. Coinbase is therefore found to be vicariously liable as a principal for this employee’s conduct. If I’m reading this right, the employee had a program interfering with GDAX generating dummy orders filled by itself. To other customers, would look like real liquidity on the platform but it was astroturfing. Was this “fake it till you make it” or something more manipulative? Or perhaps just a lone employee trying to pump Litecoin for their own profit?
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe statement sounds as though the employee was deliberately generating the appearance of liquidity and demand by placing wash trades. It's mind boggling that this would happen at one of the most regulated exchanges in the world. Cryptocurrency is like the wild west of finance, but I expected at least Coinbase was playing fair. Apparently not.
- koolba 6y agoNote that this is 2016 Coinbase. Not 2021, getting ready for IPO, Coinbase.
- loeg 6y agoExplicitly, 2015 through 2018.
- throwaway4good 6y agoYeah. Now there is more money in this ipo thing ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- peteretep 6y ago
- sn_master 6y agoCoinBase is one of the last exchanges which still allow sending and receiving crypto. Others like RobinHood only allow trading, while LocalBitcoins and Kraken disabled sending/receiving for NY and WA this year. I really hope they survive. I don't know what's the future for crypto if we can no longer send or receive actual coins anymore. It becomes meaningless to just buy and sell without ever being able to "own" the coins.
- kolbe 6y agoWhat good is Coinbase other than as a way to exchange crypto for dollars? If crypto is to ever have any meaning, then it shouldn't need to interface with the financial system that it aims to upend.
- sn_master 6y agoHow else would you obtain crypto if it wasn't by exchanging it with other fiat currency? Mining hasn't been realistic for many years now. It costs the same as a single BTC in electricity cost to mine one, assuming you have the mining hardware. Buying and selling 'assets' on the Darkweb and amongst people you know in other countries with restricted foreign money transfer is one main use case of CoinBase. In fact, I doubt BTC would have thrived as much as it did if it wasn't for SilkRoad/DarkMarket/EmpireMarket/WhiteHouseMarket etc. Not to mention the hundreds of millions that went into worse endeavors like ransomeware and funding terror organizations. BTC didn't become what it is without the billions of dollars in demand for those very real use cases. Each drug dealer exchanges tens and hundreds of thousands of USD in crypt, much more than the average regular crypto enthusiast. BTC investors are investing in blood money, like it or not. It's not just a magic computer token thingy, and it hasn't been for a decade now since the SilkRoad inception.
- louloulou 6y ago> It costs the same as a single BTC in electricity cost to mine one, assuming you have the mining hardware. You just described how to buy bitcoin privately with electricity. Why is it unrealistic?
- spoonjim 6y agoAnd Coinbase is worth $75 billion. Unless executives start going to actual prison, the smart move is going to be to break the law.
- dannyw 6y agoIt should like the actual misbehaviour was that coinbase was running multiple trading algorithms, one to hedge and one to arbitrate between exchanges, and they sometimes incidentally traded against each other. Running multiple algorithms is as common as writing multiple unit tests. That is standard operating practice. What is also a common practice is adding a netting layer so that your algorithms internally settle before sending out trades to the market. This is generally done to save trading fees, but it didn't apply to Coinbase because they are also the exchange. So, overall it sounds like inexperience, not malice.
- tehlike 6y agoYou need to find out who is the employee in question.
- onion2k 6y agoYou can't pay fines out of market cap.
- keiferski 6y agoNot a finance guy, so apologies if this is a stupid question: What about percentage-based fines? I.e. 1% of market cap.
- rocqua 6y agoThe point is that the 'market capitalization' isn't the bank account. It's nothing more than 'share price * number of shares'. You can try to pay a fine by selling more stock. Or by getting convertible bonds. But there are no guarantees.
- throwaway732578 6y agoThis happens soooo much, and is offered my most exchanges as “liquidity”. But in reality it’s washtrading. Fake volume which creates demand from the public. It’s what all (early) stakeholders want. Crypto trading in general is such a scam, with the exception of a few of the top ones.
- jl2718 6y ago> "liquidity" It is cheating the numbers, but it could be moderately beneficial or terrible. If it's actually entered onto the books as liquidity for some time before being consumed, then I guess it could help eliminate slippage, although I think more likely it is matched in the way that puts the desired slippage into customer trades only. > with the exception of a few of the top ones like Coinbase?
- anonymoushn 6y agoI don't usually have big net positions but I have no trotunle getting filled for a million dollars of some shitcoin at the same price
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- redm 6y ago“This enforcement action sends the message that the Commission will act to safeguard the integrity and transparency of such information.” At a paltry 6.5m, the message it sends is “you got away with it.”
- jkhdigital 6y agoI think the size of the penalty is an indication that the scale of the illegal activity relative to the total trading volume on Coinbase was probably minimal. Considering the description of how this happened (two independent trading bots that sometimes matched one another) it sounds more like a lack of controls rather than any malicious intention to deceive markets. And, at least for now, intent matters in our legal system.
- ffggvv 6y agoit sounds like there was two things that happened: 1. What you said. Two bots that lacked controls and interacted with eachother. which may have been accidental 2. A rogue employee intentionally using those bots to fake volume on a specific currency pair. This is actually malicious.